Emergency Caesarean Section in Adolescent Girls at the Referral Health Center in Commune I ()
1. Introduction
Teenage pregnancy is very common around the world. It poses different problems depending on the cultural, ethnic or religious context [1]. It is at risk of cesarean section by mechanical dystocia [2].
Adolescence is the period of the evolution of the individual from puberty to adulthood. The complexity of the definition justifies the variability of the limit age of adolescence which goes from 10 to 19 years for the World Health Organization (WHO) [3].
In Mali, teenage pregnancy is tolerated culturally and religiously by a large part of the population. The adverse outcomes of these pregnancies and childbirths are mainly: premature delivery, neonatal suffering, the birth of a low-weight fetus and the death of the newborn. The prognosis for early pregnancies often depends on the quality of monitoring of the pregnancy and the skill of the staff during childbirth. Only 6% of pregnant women in Mali are followed by doctors and 19% do not perform any prenatal consultation visit [4]. Also, in Mali, the quality of Antenatal Consultation (ANC) and the management of obstetric complications in emergency which are the main pillars of the fight against maternal and neonatal mortality are not, most often, assured in accordance with the standards. We have initiated this study in order to study emergency cesarean delivery in adolescent girls at the Referral Health Center (RHC) in commune I of the District of Bamako.
2. Patients and Methods
It was a prospective descriptive study conducted in the department of gynecology of the referral health center (RHC) of Commune I in Bamako from January 1 to December 31, 2018. Any adolescent girl in whom an emergency Cesarean section was performed was included. According to WHO definition, we have retained adolescent as a girl aged between 10 to 19 years. For each patient, an individual survey sheet was established containing the following variables: the socio-demographic characteristics of the patient; circumstances of admission, medical and surgical history, history of pregnancy, clinical examination; indications for cesarean section; the surgical act; prognostic factors, APGAR; anthropometric measurements, the fate of the newborn. Data collection was done from the prenatal consultation booklet, obstetric records; the registers of operating report, anesthesia, delivery, the partograph, the Reference/Evacuation sheet. The data was entered and analyzed on SPSS 20.3.
3. Results
We have collected 616 cases of teenage deliveries and performed 202 emergency caesareans, with a frequency of 32.8%. The average age of the patients was 17 with the extremes of 13 to 19 years. They were in the early adolescence (10 to 14 years) 11 in number (5.4%) (Table 1).
The patients who were not living in the health area where the study was conducted were forty (40) or 19.8%. Married adolescents were 193 (95.5%), out of whom two were under the age of 14. religious marriage was found out in 125 patients (64.8%). The mode of admission was self-referencing in 129 cases (63.9%). Primigravida were 121 (79.7%). Those out of school were 104 (51.5%). Of 192 patients (95.04%) who did antenatal consultations (ANC), 152 (75.2%) were followed by midwives. The patients who have done four or more prenatal visits were 90 (44.5%) and 10 (5%) had not performed any prenatal consultation (Table 2).
No prenatal check-up was carried out in 32 adolescent girls (15.8%). On admission examination, an abnormality of fetal heart noise was observed in 66 patients (32.7%), resulting in bradycardia in 60 cases (29.7%), tachycardia in 3 cases (1.5%) and the absence of fetal heart noise in 3 cases (1.5%). The breech and transverse fetal presentations accounted for 25 cases (12.4%) and 4 cases (2%) respectively. The water bag was broken in 167 patients (82.7%). The vaginal examination had found a border pelvis in 78 cases (38.6%), narrowed in 24 cases (11.9%). The amniotic fluid was stained in 75 patients (44.9%). During the surgical intervention, 2 cases of bladder wound were provoked and 12 cases (5.94%) of vascular pedicle involvement. The transfused patients were 24 (11.9%) of whom 12 (5.9%) had blood loss greater than 1000 ml during cesarean section. General anesthesia was performed in 116 cases (57.4%). Postoperative complications were observed in 24 patients (11.88%) including 3 cases of parietal suppurations (12.5%). The number of newborns who were born from caesarean sections was 213, stillbirths 3 or 1.3%, an APGAR ≤ 7 was noted in 68 newborns (31.9%). Macrosomia with a birth weight ≥ 4000 g accounted for 16 cases (7.5%).
Table 1. Distribution of patients according to age.
Table 2. Distribution of healthcare providers who have followed pregnancy.
Among the newborns 71 (33.3%) were resuscitated, 99 (46.5%) were evacuated in pediatrics. We have not recorded any maternal death but 8 neonatal deaths were reported (3.8%).
4. Comments and Discussion
The frequency: 616 adolescent girls gave birth during the study period, including 202 by caesarean (32.8%). Childbirth of adolescent girls in Mali is common due to customary marriages which do not take into account the age of the young girls but rather the physical build and menarche. These practices persist despite the Family Act in Mali that sets the age of marriage for girls at 16. The frequency of adolescent cesarean section in our study (32.8%) was lower than that of Sawadogo Y A [5] who found 56.4%. This difference could be accounted for by the fact that in our study adolescent girls with serious pathologies associated with pregnancy were evacuated to hospitals. In Mali, referral health centers are at the second level in the health pyramid, these centers do not have resuscitation services and the treatment of pathologies such as placental abruption, eclampsia is not provided there.
Age: The youngest patient was 13 years old, and ten others were 14 years old. These patients were neither physically nor mentally mature. Early adolescence corresponds to the period of development and maturation of organs including the pelvis. Immaturity of the pelvis can cause serious consequences during childbirth. The lack of education of young teenage mothers is a real obstacle to the fulfilment and development.
Residence: Each health center covers a well-defined geographic area called “the health areas”. Referral health centers have ambulances that only transport patients in emergency situations in a health facility which is part of its health area. 20% of our patients were living outside the health area and had to go to the care facility by their own means of transport. They often arrived in public transport vehicles or on mopeds. This causes not only a delay in joining health centers but also can worsen certain diseases such as placenta previa, retro placental hematoma. The accessibility of health care centers remains an obstacle in the management of obstetric emergencies.
Marital status: Single adolescent girls accounted for only 4.5%, among them 95.5% were married. Dembélé S and Souley I found 79.2% and 77.3% respectively.
The Family Act in Mali sets up 16 the age of marriage for young girls. This legal provision is circumvented by religious and customary marriages. Marrying young girls in adolescence is a way for families to avoid any risk of humiliation. To see a young girl pregnant out of wedlock is a shame for families in Mali.
Occupation: housewives were the most numerous (74.8%). Without financial resources to meet families’ needs, women in general and adolescents in particular are very fragile.
Level of education: the level of education is very low. Only one adolescent girl in five were educated at the beginning of their pregnancy. Adolescents out of school represented 51.5%. In France Faucher [6] observes that 45.2% of pregnant adolescents are not in school, Combes [7], in Réunion, finds 47%. Several studies have underlined the importance of schooling in preventing the phenomenon of early pregnancy. In the United States, adolescent girls in school under the age of 12 are 6 times more likely to become mothers before the age of 18 [8].
Mode of admission: 63.9% of our patients came by themselves, this does not permit insight into the delay in transport since the departure time is not known by the patients. Diallo BS, in his study, found out 85.4% of patients who had come by themselves.
Surgical history: the risk of complications of pregnancy and childbirth is greater in the case of a scar uterus. 16.33% of adolescent girls had a scar uterus, they were at risk for delivery dystocia and hemorrhage from delivery. Among them, 4 patients had performed no prenatal consultation.
Gravidity: 20.30% were pauciparous, 9% had a spontaneous abortion at the first pregnancy. Whatever is the outcome of a pregnancy, a recovery period is necessary to consider another pregnancy.
Parity: in our series 19.8% of adolescent girls were primiparous. Dembélé F found 25% in 2015.
Monitoring of pregnancy: prenatal consultation is a key element for a positive experience of pregnancy. 5% of our patients had not performed any prenatal consultation, this rate is comparable to that of Drabo A [9] 6.8%. Several studies agree that the quality of pregnancy monitoring is significantly lower in adolescent girls. They receive fewer consultations than their elders and the average term of the first ultrasound is delayed [9]. Most authors also observe a poorer follow-up in adolescent girls [10] [11] as well as a later start of medical surveillance of their pregnancy [12]. The younger the adolescent, the later the onset of pregnancy monitoring and the poorer the quality of the monitoring [13]. More specific reasons for adolescent girls, such as the fact that pregnancy is not wanted or that it is hidden from those around them, contribute to poor monitoring of their pregnancies.
50.5% of adolescent girls in our study had done less than four antenatal consultations, Drabo A in Mali [9] found 40.6%, Prosper KL in the DRC 31.8% [14]. Health providers do not perceive adolescent pregnancy as a high-risk pregnancy. Prenatal adolescent consultations are done at the same rate as safe pregnancies. In Mali, in the documents of standards and procedure policies, the number of antenatal consultations in the absence of proven risk is four.
Nowadays the WHO recommends at least eight contacts with the pregnant woman. This concept must be taught to the health providers especially the midwives who assure the majority of the prenatal consultations. In Mali standards, midwives have to monitor pregnancies without pathologies and refer pregnancies at risk.
In our study 75.2% of pregnancies were followed by midwives. In the literature, we did not find information on the qualification of health providers who monitor adolescent pregnancy. However, pregnant adolescents should be followed by gynecologists to identify indications for cesarean section and better programming in order to avoid the urgency which increases maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality.
Prenatal check-up: adolescent pregnant women who had not performed any prenatal check-up were 15.8%. This is likely to increase comorbidity and delay treatment when facing with certain emergencies.
Pathologies occurring during pregnancy: according to several authors, the young age associated with pregnancy exposes to more complications.
Anemia: In Africa, the effects of malaria, parasitic infections of iron deficiency combine to give anemia in pregnant women. Anemia seems more marked in adolescent girls, probably due to the poor follow-up of pregnancy.
We were unable to establish the anemia rate on the basis of blood count because very few of our patients had it. However, 5.9% of our patients had pale conjunctiva.
Blood pressure: pregnancy-induced hypertension ranges from 3.5% according to Hardy [15] to 21.9% according to Janky. 2.5% of our patients had hypertension whereas many studies find a high frequency of hypertension in adolescent girls. [2]. There is a high prevalence of pregnancy toxemia which we could not analyze correctly because they did not meet the inclusion criteria of our study. Such cases are evacuated to suitable management structures.
Noise of the fetal heart: health facilities in Mali do not have a cardiotocograph for monitoring during labor, listening to noise from the fetal heart is a very important element of fetal well-being. Bradycardia or fetal tachycardia causes fetal distress and forces obstetricians to extract in emergency. We found 1.5% tachycardia and 29.7% fetal bradycardia which have a definite influence on the survival of the newborn. 1.5% of parturients had no fetal heart noise at the time of admission to the delivery room.
Presentation of the fetus: All the patients whose fetus had another presentation other than that of the summit should have received a prophylactic cesarean allowing to reduce the maternal and fetal morbidity related to the emergency context of the cesarean. The breech and transverse presentations represented 12.4% and 2% respectively.
The state of the water bag: the time it takes to open the water bag determines the possibility of maternal and or neonatal infection. In our study, 82.7% of patients were admitted with the broken water bag and 98.2% had a rupture time of less than 6 hours. Drabo A and Hamada H found out 19.1% and 21.1% of rupture of the water bag. These rates, significantly lower than ours (82.7%), are explained by the fact that we were simply interested in the emergency cases whereas Drabo and Hamada have included all emergencies or cold deliveries regardless of the route of delivery.
The aspect of amniotic fluid: we found out 44.9% of patients who had a meconial amniotic fluid against 4.3% in the series of Drabo. Frequent scheduled cesareans in the study of Drabo were not included in our work. In the absence of fetal monitoring, the tinted coloration of the amniotic fluid is an important element that alerts the practitioner.
The obstetric pelvis: in adolescents, the pelvis grows more slowly and gradually until old age [14]. In addition, the acquisition of adult size does not imply equivalent growth of the pelvis because “the pelvis does not definitively finish its configuration until around the 25th year albeit the adult forms are reached around the age of 16” [14].
The patients in our series had an abnormal pelvis in 50.5%. Adolescent girls with immature pelvis with no prenatal visits were 2.9%, followed mostly by midwives 86% and only 10.78% by doctors. Prenatal follow-up of high-risk pregnancies must be done by gynecologists and we classify adolescent pregnancy in this category.
Intraoperative incidents: the urgent context of the caesarean section increases the risk of accident during the surgical intervention. In our study, the cases of bladder wound were 0.99% and of vascular pedicle attack 5.94%. This latest incident is responsible for a significant loss of blood. A blood loss of more than 1000cc during the caesarean is considered a hemorrhage of the delivery.
Blood transfusion: it results from an anemia situation aggravated by pregnancy and childbirth, from a hemorrhagic pathology during pregnancy, labor or in the postpartum period. A blood transfusion can occur after a lesion of the uterine pedicle during the cesarean section. 11.9% of the patients in our series were transfused.
Post-operative complications: in the general population, post-cesarean complication rates in adolescent girls are not different from those in adults, nevertheless, the urgent context of cesarean section can be avoided with appropriate follow-up. 12.5% of the patients in our study had an operating site infection.
The newborn: some authors observe a higher rate of prematurity in teenage pregnancies. Our results do not seem to be in favor of such a risk.
The weight of the newborns in our series was mainly between 2500 g and 3500 g (89.2%). Some studies find a lower average weight of newborn babies for teenage mothers compared to adult mothers. Macrosomia with a birth weight greater than 4000 g was found in 7.5% of our patients. Dembélé F and Drabo A found 1.02% and 0.2% respectively. We did not find a rational accounting for the high macrosomia rate in our work.
The percentage of depressed infants with an APGAR score ≤ 7 at the 5th minute was 31.9%. This rate is higher than that of Prosper K who pointed out 8.2%. This is explained by the difference in methodology between the studies. We have included obstetric emergencies with caesarean section as a delivery route whereas in the study of Prosper the vaginal and high delivery are included with or without emergency.
Evacuation in neonatology: According to Mali standards and procedures policies, any newborn who have undergone resuscitation in the delivery room have to be evacuated to the pediatric service. 46.5% of the newborns in our study have been transferred to pediatric department.
Death: we have not recorded any maternal deaths. However, eight newborns were reported died.
5. Conclusion
Emergency cesarean section in teenage is a source of stress for the patient, parents and medical staff. It did not pose any major problems with regard to its completion and the execution time. Better monitoring of pregnancies can permit to reduce the number of emergency caesarean sections and decrease maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality.
Appendix: Individual Survey Sheet
Theme: Emergency Caesarean section in adolescents: frequency, indications, maternal and perinatal prognosis at the reference health center in commune I of the district of Bamako.
(Q1) DATE: …. / …… / 201….
(Q2) Sheet No. / ____ /
I-Sociodemographic characteristics
(Q3) Last name / ……………………………………… / /
(Q4) First names / …………………………………… /
(Q5) Age / ____ / years
(Q6) Residence / ____ / (1 = Commune I, 2 = Outside Commune I)
(Q7) Ethnic group / ____ / (1 = Bambara, 2 = Peulh, 3 = Soninké, 4 = Malinké, 5 = Sénoufo, 6 = Minianka, 7 = Bobo, 8 = Khasonké, 9 = Moorish, 10 = Sonrhaï, 11 = Dogon 12 = Moor, 13 = Dafing, 14 = Bozo, 15 = Other)
Q8) Marital status / ____ / (1 = Married, 2 = Single)
Q (8a) If married, type of marriage: / ____ / (1 = Civil marriage, 2 = Religious marriage)
(Q9) Profession / ____ / (1 = Housewife, 2 = Employee, 3 = Trader, 4 = Pupil, 5 = Student, 6 = Other)
(Q10) Level of education / ____ / (1 = Primary, 2 = Secondary, 3 = higher, 4 = Not educated)
(Q11) Nationality / ____ / (1 = Malian, 2 = Burkinabé, 3 = Ivorian, 4 = Nigerian, 5 = Senegalese, 6 = Mauritanian, 7 = other)
II-circumstance of admission:
(Q12) Mode of admission / ____ / (1 = self-appointed, 2 = referred, 3 = evacuated)
(Q13) Addressed by / ____ / (1 = doctor, 2 = midwife, 3 = nurse, 4 = herself)
(Q14) If evacuated / referred, structure of provenance / ____ / (1 = Doctor’s office, 2 = Medical clinic, 3 = Community Association Health Center (CAHC), 4 = Community Health Center (CHC), 5 = Confessional center)
(Q15) Reasons / ____ / (1 = Procidence of the cord, 2 = Breech in primigravida, 3 = Acute Fetal Distress, 4 = Boundary pelvis, 5 = stationary dilation, 6 = Pelvis generally narrow (PGN) in labor, 7 = excessive uterine height, 8 = transverse presentation, 9 = HBP, 10 = Pre-eclampsia, 11 = Eclampsia, 12 = Bleeding on pregnancy, 13 = Placenta Prævia, 14 = Retro-Placental Hematoma, 15 = Painful uterine contractions (PUC), 16 = Vicious presentation, 17 = Scar uterus, 18 = Loss of water, 19 = Twin pregnancy on scar uterus, 20 = PRM on scar uterus, 21 = Twin pregnancy with T1 in breech presentation, 22 = Immature pelvis, 23 = Prolonged expulsive phase, 24 = Failure to engage, 25 = Lack expulsive effort, 26 = Refusal to push, 27 = Refusal to cooperate, 28 = overdue delivery, 29 = Other)
III-History
(Q16) Medical: / ____ / (1 = None, 2 = HBP, 3 = Diabetes, 4 = Asthma, 5 = Sickle cell anemia 6 = Heart disease, 7 = Other)
(Q17) Surgical: (1 = None, 2 = Cesarean section, 3 = Myomectomy with opening of the uterine cavity, 4 = Ruptured uterus, 5 = Other)
(Q18) Obstetric:
-Gravida: (1 = Primigravida, 2 = Paucigravida, 3 = Multigravida, 4 = Large multigravida) -Parity: (1 = Nulliparous, 2 = Primiparous, 3 = Pauciparous, 4 = Multiparous)
(Q19) Inter-reproductive interval / ____ / in years
IV Risk factors:
1-History of pregnancy:
(Q20) Term pregnancy / ____ / (1 = Yes, 2 = No)
(Q21) followed by / ____ / (1 = doctor; 2 = midwife, 3 = other person, 4 = not followed)
(Q22) Where / ____ / (1 = Not followed, 2 = Home, 3 = Doctor’s office, 4 = Confessional center, 5 = Community Association Health Center, 6 = Referral health center, 8 = Medical clinic, 9 = Community health center)
(Q23) Number of PNC / ____ /
(Q24) Prenatal check-up (PCU) / ____ / (1 = Done, 2 = Not done)
2-General clinical examination:
(Q25) Size: / ____ / (in meter)
(Q26) Weight: / ____ / (kg)
(Q27) Conjunctivas / ____ / (1 = colored, 2 = pale)
(Q28) BP / ____ / (mmhg)
(Q29) Temperature / ____ / ° C
3-Obstetric examination:
(Q30) Uterine Height / ____ / (centimeter)
(Q31) Painful uterine contraction (PUC)/ ____ / (1 = Yes, 2 = No)
(Q32) Fetal Heart Beat / ____ / (beats / min)
(Q33) Presentation / ____ / (1 = cephalic, 2 = breech, 3 = transverse)
(Q34) Water bag / ____ / (1 = intact, 2 = broken)
(Q35) if broken, appearance of Amniotic fluid / ____ / (1 = clear, 2 = yellowish, 3 = meconium)
(Q36) Pelvis / ____ / (1 = Normal, 2 = Limit, 3 = Generally narrowed, 4 = Asymmetrical)
(Q37) Birthing phase / ____ / (1 = latency, 2 = Active, 3 = Not in labor)
V-Indications for cesarean section:
(Q38) Indication of the caesarean section / ____ / (1 = Acute fetal distress, 2 = Proof of the beating cord, 3 = Feto-pelvic disproportion, 4 = Seat in nulliparous, 5 = Pre-rupture syndrome 6 = PGN in labor, 7 = Sherp grade II RPH, 8 = Placenta previa hemorrhagic, 9 = Irreducible dynamic dystocia, 10 = Posterior face presentation 11 = Face presentation,, 12 = Scar uterus on border pelvis, 13 = Scar uterus on PGN, 14 = Dynamic dystocia on scar uterus, 15 = transverse presentation 16 = presentation of bregma, 17 = preeclampsia, 18 = eclampsia, 19 = twin pregnancy on scar uterus, 20 = PRM on scar uterus, 21 = twin pregnancy T1 in breech presentation, 22 = pelvis immature, 23 = Fetal macrosomia, 24 = Short IIG / Scar uterus)
VI-Intraoperatively:
(Q39) Qualification of the operator / ____ / (1 = Gynecologist, 2 = General practitioner, 3 = Internee)
(Q40) Type of skin incision: / ____ / (1 = pfannenstiel, 2 = IMSO, 3 = Joël Cohen)
(Q41) Type of hysterotomy / ____ / (1 = Segmental, 2 = Corporeal, 3 = Segmento-corporeal)
(Q42) Cutaneous incision and fetal extraction time / ____ / in minutes
(Q43) Gesture associated with cesarean section / ____ / (1 = None, 2 = Intrauterine device per-Cesarean section 3 = Hysterectomy, 4 = Tubal ligation and resection, 5 = Myomectomy, 6 = Cystectomy, 7 = Other)
(Q44) Total duration of the intervention / ____ / in minutes
(Q45) Peroperative incident / ____ / (1 = Bladder break-in, 2 = Intestinal perforation, 3 = Split line, 4 = Attack of vascular pedicle, 5 = Nothing to report)
(Q46) Blood loss / ____ / (in cubic centimeters)
VII-Anesthesia:
(Q47) Qualification of the anesthesiologist: / ____ / (1 = anesthesiologist-resuscitator, 2 = Medical Assistant Nurse Anesthesiologist-Resuscitator)
(Q48) Type of anesthesia: / ____ / (1 = GA, 2 = ALR, 3 = ALR converted to GA)
(Q49) Time between installation on operating table and skin incision: / ____ / in minutes
(Q50) Transfusion / ____ / (1 = Yes, 2 = No)
(Q51) If transfusion why / ____ / (1 = Hemorrhage, 2 = Anemia on pregnancy)
VIII-In post-operative:
(Q52) Complication / ____ / (1 = None, 2 = Hemorrhagic, 3 = Infectious, 4 = Anemia, 5 = Thromboembolic, 6 = Digestive, 7 = Other)
(Q53) Duration of hospitalization / ____ / in day (s)
IX-Newborn:
(Q54) Number / ____ /
(Q55) Sex / ____ / (1 = Male, 2 = Female)
(Q56) Apgar 1st minute / ____ / out of 10
(Q57) Apgar 5th minute / ____ / out of 10
(Q58) Weight of Newborn / ____ / in grams
(Q59) Size / ____ / in centimeter
(Q60) Resuscitated newborn / ____ / (1 = Yes, 2 = No)
(Q61) Newborn evacuated to the neonatal service / ____ / (1 = Yes, 2 = No)
(Q62) If yes, the reason for evacuation / ____ / (1 = Newborn suffering, 2 = Low birth weight, 3 = Macrosomy, 4 = Neonatal infection, 5 = Malformation, 6 = Overdue delivery, 7 = No referred, 8 = Other)
(Q63) Fate of a newborn: / ____ / (1 = Alive, 2 = Died)
(Q64) if death, the cause …………………………………………………………
X-Prognostic factors:
(Q65) Time between the teenager’s departure from the source structure if reference/evacuation and the reception structure / ____ / in minutes
(Q66) Means of locomotion of Reference / Evacuation / ____ / (1 = Ambulance, 2 = taxi, 3 = Motorbike)
(Q67) Time between admission and indication of cesarean / ____ / in minutes
(Q68) Time between indication and start of cesarean / ____ / in minutes
(Q69) Fate of the patient after the cesarean / ____ / (1 = Alive, 2 = Died)
(Q70) If death, the cause ………………………………………………………