Analysis of malaria diagnosis discrepancies between RDTs and microscopy by nested PCR

DOI: 10.4236/jbise.2013.610120   PDF   HTML     4,382 Downloads   6,078 Views   Citations


A total of 415 samples from febrile children exhibiting either concordant (n = 108) or discordant (n = 307) results between microscopy, the gold standard diagnostic test, and two Rapid Diagnostic Tests (RDTs), OptiMAL-IT?(pLDH) and Acon?HRP2, were analysed using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from May to December 2011 in Gabon. The aim of the study was to analyse these discrepancies using poly-merase chain reaction (PCR). Nested PCR targeting the Plasmodium ssrRNA gene was used to distinguish P. falciparum, P. malariae and P. ovale. Plasmodium falciparum was the only malaria species identified. Discrepancies frequently involved samples that were negative by microscopy and positive by Acon?HRP2 (90%) or Optimal-it?(86%). The PCR assay detected submicroscopic infection in almost 23% of the microscopy-negative samples, whereas plasmodial DNA was not found in 77% of the Acon?HRP2 positive-microscopy negative samples. Although results obtained with Optimal-it? were more frequently concordant with those of PCR genotyping, the low specificity of Optimal-iT?for non-falciparum malaria parasite detection resulted in a high proportion of false negative RDTs (90%) and a high frequency of tests with faint line intensity. The present study highlights the specific attributes of the different methods used to identify malaria parasite below the microscopy level of detection. RDT results that were discordant with either microscopy or PCR as the gold standard could represent a challenge for rapid, accurate fever case management in malaria endemic areas. It is necessary to pursue the development of more precise and more sensitive point-of-care diagnostic tools for malaria.

Share and Cite:

Mawili-Mboumba, D. , Bouyou-Akotet, M. , Mbouoronde, C. and Kombila, M. (2013) Analysis of malaria diagnosis discrepancies between RDTs and microscopy by nested PCR. Journal of Biomedical Science and Engineering, 6, 967-972. doi: 10.4236/jbise.2013.610120.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] World Health Organization (2006) Guidelines for treatment of malaria. 2006.
[2] Perkins, M.D. and Bell, D.R. (2008) Working without a blindfold: The critical role of diagnostics in malaria control. Malaria Journal, 7, S5.
[3] D’Acremont, V., Lengeler, C., Mshinda, H., Mtasiwa, D., Tanner, M. and Genton, B. (2009) Time to move from presumptive malaria treatment to laboratory-confirmed diagnosis and treatment in African children with fever. PLOS Medicine, 6, e252.
[4] Drakeley, C. and Reyburn, H. (2009) Out with the old, in with the new: The utility of rapid diagnostic tests for malaria diagnosis in Africa. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 103, 333-337.
[5] Murray, C.K., Gasser, R.A., Magill, A.J. and Miller, R.S. (2008) Update on rapid diagnostic testing for malaria. Clinical Microbiology Reviews, 21, 97-110.
[6] Wongsrichanalai, C., Barcus, M.J., Muth, S., Sutamihardja, A. and Wernsdorfer, W.H. (2007) A review of malaria diagnostic tools: Microscopy and rapid diagnostic test (RDT). The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 77, 119-127.
[7] World Health Organization (2010) Malaria rapid diagnostic test performance; results of WHO product testing of malaria RDTs: Round 2.
[8] Abeku, T.A., Kristan, M., Jones, C., Beard, J., Mueller, D.H., Okia, M., Rapuoda, B., Greenwood, B. and Cox, J. (2008) Determinants of the accuracy of rapid diagnostic tests in malaria case management: Evidence from low and moderate transmission settings in the East African highlands. Malaria Journal, 7, 202-211.
[9] Kyabayinze, D.J., Tibenderana, J.K., Odong, G.W., Rwakimari, J.B. and Counihan, H. (2008) Operational accuracy and comparative persistent antigenicity of HRP2 rapid diagnostic tests for Plamodium falciparum malaria in a hyperendemic region of Uganda. Malaria Journal, 7, 221-231.
[10] Chandler, C.I., Jones, C., Boniface, G., Juma, K., Reyburn, H. and Whitty, C.J. (2008) Guidelines and mindlines: Why do clinical staff over-diagnose malaria in Tanzania? A qualitative study. Malaria Journal, 7, 53-65.
[11] Reyburn, H., Mbatia, R., Drakeley, C., Carneiro, I., Mwakasungula, E., Mwerinde, O., Saganda, K., Shao, J., Kitua, A., Olomi, R., Greenwood, B.M. and Whitty, C.J. (2004). Overdiagnosis of malaria in patients with severe febrile illness in Tanzania: A prospective study. British Medical Journal, 329, 1212-1217.
[12] Cnops, L., Jacobs, J. and Van Esbroeck, M. (2011) Validation of a four-primer real-time PCR as a diagnostic tool for single and mixed Plasmodium infections. Clinical Microbiology and Infection, 17, 1101-1107.
[13] Mangold, K.A., Manson, R.U., Koay, E.S., Stephens, L., Regner, M., Thomson, R.B. Jr., Peterson, L.R. and Kaul, K.L. (2011). Real-time PCR for detection and identification of Plasmodium spp. Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 43, 2435-2440.
[14] Bashir, I.M., Otsyula, N., Awinda, G., Spring, M., Schneider, P. and Waitumbi, J.N. (2013) Comparison of PfHRP-2/pLDH ELISA, qPCR and microscopy for the detection of plasmodium events and prediction of sick visits during a malaria vaccine study. PLoS One, 8, e56828.
[15] Rakotonirina, H., Barnadas, C., Raherijafy, R., Andrianantenaina, H., Ratsimbasoa, A., Randrianasolo, L., Jahevitra, M., Andriantsoanirina, V. and Ménard, D. (2008) Accuracy and reliability of malaria diagnostic techniques for guiding febrile outpatient treatment in malaria-endemic countries. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 78, 217-221.
[16] Mawili-Mboumba, D.P., Bouyou Akotet, M.K., Ngoungou, E.B. and Kombila, M. (2010) Evaluation of rapid diagnostic tests for malaria case management in Gabon. Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease, 66, 162-168.
[17] Mawili-Mboumba, D.P., Akotet, M.K., Kendjo, E., Nzamba, J., Medang, M.O., Mbina, J.R., Kombila, M. and MCORU team (2013) Increase in malaria prevalence and age of at risk population in different areas of Gabon. Malaria Journal, 12, 3.
[18] Singh, B., Bobogare, A., Cox-Singh, J., Snounou, G., Abdullah, M.S. and Rahman, H.A. (1999) A genusand species—Specific nested polymerase chain reaction malaria detection assay for epidemiologic studies. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 60, 687-692.
[19] Bouyou Akotet, M.K., Mawili-Mboumba, D.P., Madoungou, B. and Kombila, M. (2013) Performances of Malaria P.f/Pan rapid test device Acon® (Pf HRP2/ pan aldolase) and malaria Pf rapid test device Acon® (Pf HRP2) for the diagnosis of malaria in adults and children living in Gabon, Central Africa. Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease, 77, 58-63.
[20] Hopkins, H., Kambale, W., Kamya, M.R., Staedke, S.G., Dorsey, G. and Rosenthal, P.J. (2007) Comparison of HRP2-and pLDH-based rapid diagnostic tests for malaria with longitudinal follow-up in Kampala, Uganda. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 76, 1992-1997.
[21] Rubio, J.M., Buhigas, I., Subirats, M., Baquero, M., Puente, S. and Benito, A. (2001) Limited level of accuracy provided by available rapid diagnosis tests for malaria enhances the need for PCR-based reference laboratories. Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 39, 2736-2737.
[22] Hopkins, H., Bebell, L., Kambale, W., Dokomajilar, C., Rosenthal, P.J. and Dorsey, G. (2008) Rapid diagnostic tests for malaria at sites of varying transmission intensity in Uganda. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 197, 510-518.
[23] Desakom, V., Dondorp, A.M., Silamut, K., Pongtavornpinyo, W., Sahassananda, D., Chotivanich, K., Pitisuttithum, P., Smithyman, A.M., Day, N.P. and White, N.J. (2005). Stage dependent production and release of histidin-rich protein 2 by Plasmodium falciparum. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 99, 517-524.
[24] Endeshaw, T., Graves, P.M., Ayele, B., Mosher, A.W., Gebre, T., Ayalew, F., Genet, A., Mesfin, A., Shargie, E.B., Tadesse, Z., Teferi, T., Melak, B., Richards, F.O. and Emerson, P.M. (2012) Performance of local light microscopy and the ParaScreen Pan/Pf rapid diagnostic test to detect malaria in health centers in Northwest Ethiopia. PLoS One, 7, e33014.
[25] Moody, A. (2002) Rapid diagnostic tests for malaria parasites. Clinical Microbiology, 15, 66-78.
[26] World Health Organisation (2012) Characteristics of evaluation panel used for round 4 of WHO malaria RDT product testing at US CDC.
[27] Maltha, J., Gillet, P., Cnops, L., Bottieau, E., Van Esbroeck, M., Bruggeman, C. and Jacobs, J. (2011) Evaluation of the rapid diagnostic test SDFK40 (Pf-pLDH/pan-pLDH) for the diagnosis of malaria in a non-endemic setting. Malaria Journal, 10, 7.
[28] Wongsrichanalai, C., Arevalo, I., Laoboonchai, A., Yingyuen, K., Miller, R.S., Magill, A.J., Forney, J.R. and Gasser Jr., R.A. (2003) Rapid diagnostic devices for malaria: Field evaluation of a new prototype immunochromatographic assay for the detection of Plasmodium falciparum and non-falciparum Plasmodium. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 69, 26-30.
[29] Eibach, D., Traore, B., Bouchrik, M., Coulibaly, B., Coulibaly, N., Siby, F., Bonnot, G., Bienvenu, A.L. and Picot, S. (2013) Evaluation of the malaria rapid diagnostic test VIKIA malaria Ag Pf/PanTM in endemic and non-endemic settings. Malaria Journal, 12, 188.
[30] Koita, O.A., Doumbo, O.K., Ouattara, A., Tall, L.K., Konaré, A., Diakité, M., Diallo, M., Sagara, I., Masinde, G.L., Doumbo, S.N., Dolo, A., Tounkara, A., Traoré, I. and Krogstad, D.J. (2012) False-negative rapid diagnostic tests for malaria and deletion of the histidine-rich repeat region of the hrp2 gene. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 86, 194-198.
[31] Farcas, G.A., Zhong, K.J., Lovegrove, F.E., Graham, C.M. and Kain, K.C. (2003) Evaluation of the Binax NOW ICT test versus polymerase chain reaction and microscopy for the detection of malaria in returned travelers. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 69, 589-592.
[32] Fernando, S.D., Karunaweera, N.D. and Fernando, W.P. (2004) Evaluation of a rapid whole blood immunochro-matographic assay for the diagnosis of Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax malaria. Ceylon Medical Journal, 49, 7-11.
[33] Gillet P, Mori M, Van Esbroeck M, Van den Ende, J. and Jacobs J. (2009) Assessment of the prozone effect in malaria rapid diagnostic tests. Malaria Journal, 8, 271.
[34] Allen, L.K., Hatfield, J.M., DeVetten, G., Ho, J.C. and Manyama, M. (2011) Reducing malaria misdiagnosis: The importance of correctly interpreting ParaChek Pf “faint test bands” in low transmission area of Tanzania. BMC Infectious Diseases, 11, 308-314.
[35] McMorrow, M.L., Masanja, M.I., Abdulla, S.M., Kahigwa, E. and Kachur, S.P. (2008). Challenges in routine implementation and quality control of rapid diagnostic tests for malaria—Rufiji District, Tanzania. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 79, 385-390.
[36] Coleman, R.E., Sattabongkot, J., Promstaporm, S., Maneechai, N., Tippayachai, B., Kengluecha, A., Rachapaew, N., Zollner, G., Miller, R.S., Vaughan, J.A., Thimasarn, K. and Khuntirat, B. (2006). Comparison of PCR and microscopy for the detection of asymptomatic malaria in a Plasmodium falciparum/vivax endemic area in Thailand. Malaria Journal, 5, 121-127.
[37] Nicastri, E., Bevilacqua, N., Sané Schepisi, M., Paglia, M.G., Meschi, S., Ame, S.M., Mohamed, J.A., Mangi, S., Fumakule, R., Di Caro, A., Capobianchi, M.R., Kitua, A., Molteni, F., Racalbuto, V. and Ippolito, G. (2009) Accuracy of malaria diagnosis by microscopy, rapid diagnostic test, and PCR methods and evidence of antimalarial overprescription in non-severe febrile patients in two Tanzanian hospitals. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 80, 712-717.
[38] Proux, S., Suwanarusk, R., Barends, M., Zwang, J., Price, R.N., Leimanis, M., Kiricharoen, L., Laochan, N., Russell, B., Nosten, F. and Snounou, G. (2011) Considerations on the use of nucleic acid-based amplification for malaria parasite detection. Malaria Journal, 10, 323-330.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2020 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.