TITLE:
Hodographs of the Gravitational Two-Body System and Discrepancies between Newtonian Laws of Equivalent Kepler Orbits and General Relativity
AUTHORS:
Caesar P. Viazminsky, Piere K. Vizminiska
KEYWORDS:
Hodographs; LRL Vector; Laws of Equivalent Orbits; Revised Galileo Law of Free Fall; Equivalence Principle
JOURNAL NAME:
Applied Mathematics,
Vol.5 No.1,
January
2,
2014
ABSTRACT:
We show
first that an orbit, which is naturally characterized by its eccentricity and
semi-latus rectum, can equally be characterized by other sets of parameters,
and proceed to determine mass-independent characterizations. The latter is employed to obtain the
laws of equivalent orbits,
which by definition have the same eccentricity and orbit’s parameter [1]. These laws
relate the values of the same physical observables on two equivalent orbits to
the corresponding total mass; they include the laws of velocity, angular
velocity, radial velocity, areal velocity, acceleration, period, energy and
angular momentum. Regardless of the share of the two bodies of a fixed total
mass, the same relative orbit occurs for the same initial conditions. Moreover,
the same orbit can be traced by different total masses but with different
relative velocities. The concept of a gravitational field generated by a set of masses is shown to be
meaningful only when the center of mass is not changed by the test mass. The
associated concept of the “nothing”, which is an infinitesimal mass that allows
for the property just mentioned to be fulfilled, is introduced and its orbits are determined.
The perturbation of the nothing orbits due to its replacement by a finite mass
is determined. It is proved that such a replacement can have a qualitative
effect resulting in a “phase transition” of an orbit from unbound to bound, and
that the nothing’s circular orbits cannot be occupied by any material body. The
Galileo law of free fall, on which the equivalence principle hinges and which
is exact only for “nothing-like” falling objects, is revised to determine the
duration of free fall of a body of an arbitrary mass. The wholeness of Newton’s
laws and the associated concept of force as an interaction are highlighted, and some contradictions between the Newtonian
laws of equivalent Kepler’s orbits and the general relativistic predictions are discussed. It is
demonstrated that Newton’s law of gravitation is not an approximation of
Einstein field Equations even in the case of a static weak field. However, both
theories have a common limit corresponding to the case in which the alien
concept of a field can be incorporated in the Newtonian theory. We also show that the relative velocity’s hodograph [2-4], the
alternative Laplace-Runge-Lenz (LRL) vector derived by Hamilton [4-6], as well
as an infinite set of LRL vectors, result all from one vector. The hodograph is
a proper circular arc for hyperbolic motion, a circle less a point for parabolic motion, and a full circle
for bound motion.