Dialectic Approaches and Public Policy Interactions for Social, Environmental and Health Problems: Challenges for Health Promotion across Territorial Scales

DOI: 10.4236/health.2014.67079   PDF   HTML     5,061 Downloads   6,486 Views   Citations


A constant reproduction of environmental injustices and health iniquities has demanded the employment of participatory/dialectic approaches to research and to intervene in the reality making possible the involvement of social actors in healthy public policies. On this framework, the aim of this paper is to analyse scientific production with dialectic approaches associated with public policies in the context of social, environmental and health problems, considering territorial scales of intervention and the correspondence with some relevant strategies of health promotion. A systematic bibliographic review was applied on a wide pan-disciplinary scientific data base and 36 papers were analysed and classified by their territorial scales of approach. The amount of papers found and their spread through a variety of journals showed a modest, but increasing production which has been dispersed in terms of knowledge areas. Within the classification of territorial approaches, 14 papers were classified as local, 5 as expanded and 17 as a multi-level. Although the papers classified as local approaches were in a good structure of stakeholders’ participation, they are limited to dealing with the global driving forces that reproduce the environmental injustices. Regarding this limitation, the multilevel approaches were identified as more opportune to jointly deal with social, environmental and health problems by means of allowing interaction through multiple territorial scales, fomenting the strengthening of community action, creating supportive environments, and building healthy public policies.

Share and Cite:

Giatti, L. , Ribeiro, R. and de Toledo, R. (2014) Dialectic Approaches and Public Policy Interactions for Social, Environmental and Health Problems: Challenges for Health Promotion across Territorial Scales. Health, 6, 607-615. doi: 10.4236/health.2014.67079.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] Martinez-Allier, J. (2007) O ecologismo dos pobres. Contexto, São Paulo.
[2] Harvey, D. (2009) Condição Pós-Moderna: Uma pesquisa sobre as origens da mudança cultural. 18a Edition, Loyola, São Paulo.
[3] WHO (1986) Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. WHO, Geneva.
[4] Kickbusch, I. (2003) The Contribution of the World Health Organization to a New Public Health and Health Promotion. American Journal of Public Health, 93, 383-388.
[5] Prado Jr., C. (1973) Teoria marxista do conhecimento e método dialético materialista. In Discurso—Revista do Departamento de Filosofia da Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas da Universidade de São Paulo, 41-78.
[6] Freire, P. (1987) Pedagogia do oprimido. 17th Edition, Paz e Terra, Rio de Janeiro.
[7] Funtowicz, S. and Ravetz, J.R. (1993) Science for the Post-Normal Age. Futures. London, 25, 739-755.
[8] Ravetz, J. (2004) The Post-Normal Science of Precaution. Futures, 36, 347-357.
[9] Lebel, J. (2003) Health: An Ecosystem Approach. International Development Research Centre, Ottawa.
[10] Lewin, K. (1946) Action Research and Minority Problems. Journal of Social Issues, 2, 34-46.
[11] Carr, W. and Kemmis, S. (1986) Becoming Critical: Education, Knowledge and Action Research. The Palmer Press, London.
[12] Cashman, S.B., Adeky, S., Allen III, A.J., Corbum, J., Israel, B.A., Montaño, J., et al. (2008) The Power and the Promise: Working with Communities to Analyse Data, Interpret Findings, and Get to Outcomes. American Journal of Public Health, 98, 1407-1417.
[13] Adelman, C. (1993) Kurt Lewin and the Origins of Action Research. Educational Action Research, 1, 7-24.
[14] Wesselink, A. and Hoppe, R. (2011) If Post-Normal Science Is the Solution, What Is the Problem?: The Politics of Activist Environmental Science. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 36, 389-412.
[15] List, D. (2006) Action Research Cycles for Multiple Futures Perspectives. Futures, 38, 673-684.
[16] Hancock, T. (2011) The Ottawa Charter at 25. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 102, 404-406.
[17] Kickbush, I. (2007) The Move towards a New Public Health. IUHPE—Promotion & Educational Suplement, 2, 9.
[18] Liberati, A., et al. (2009) The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematica Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Healthcare Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration. British Medical Journal, 339, b2700.
[19] Jacso, P. (2005) As We May Search—Comparison of Major Features of the Web of Science, Scopus, and Google Scholar Citation-Based and Citation-Enhanced Databases. Current Science, 89, 1537-1547.
[20] Kingdon, J. (2003) Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies. 2nd Edition, Addison-Wesley Educational Publishers Inc., New York, 90-208.
[21] Quigley, D., Handy, D., Goble, R., Sanchez, V. and George, P. (2000) Participatory Research Strategies in Nuclear Risk Management for Native Communities. Journal of Health Communication, 5, 305-331.
[22] Lazenbatt, A., Lynch, U. and O’Neill, E. (2001) Revealing the Hidden “Troubles” in Northern Ireland: The Role of Participatory Rapid Appraisal. Health Education Research, 16, 567-578.
[23] Getzner, M. (2008) Uncertainties and the Precautionary Principle in Cost-Benefit Environmental Policies. Journal of Policy Modeling, 30, 1-17.
[24] Raine, K.D., Plotnikoff, R., Nykiforuk, C., Deegan, H., Hemphill, E., Storey, K. and Ohinmaa, A. (2010) Reflections on Community-Based Population Health Intervention and Evaluation for Obesity and Chronic Disease Prevention: The Healthy Alberta Communities Project. International Journal of Public Health, 55, 679-686.
[25] Leventon, J. and Antypas, A. (2012) Multi-Level Governance, Multi-Level Deficits: The Case of Drinking Water Management in Hungary. Environmental Policy and Governance, 22, 253-267.
[26] Plescia, M., Herrick, H. and Chavis, L. (2008) Improving Health Behaviors in an African American Community: The Charlotte Racial and Ethnic Approaches to Community Health Project. American Journal of Public Health, 98, 1678-1684.
[27] Nampanya, S., Suon, S., Rast, L. and Windsor, P.A. (2012) Improvement in Smallholder Farmer Knowledge of Cattle Production, Health and Biosecurity in Southern Cambodia between 2008 and 2010. Transboundary and Emerging Diseases, 59, 117-127.
[28] Schulz, A. and Northridge, M.E. (2004) Social Determinants of Health: Implications for Environmental Health Promotion. Health Education & Behavior, 31, 455-471.
[29] Spiegel, J.M., Gonzalez, M., Cabrera, G.J., Catasus, S., Vidal, C. and Yassi, A. (2008) Promoting Health in Response to Global Tourism Expansion in Cuba. Health Promotion International, 23, 60-69.
[30] Heiskanen, E., Kivisaari, S., Lovio, R. and Mickwitz, P. (2009) Designed to Travel? Transition Management Encounters Environmental and Innovation policy Histories in Finland. Policy Sciences, 42, 409-427.
[31] Gonzalez, P.A., Minkler, M., Garcia, A.P., Gordon, M., Garzon, C., Palaniappan, M. and Beveridge, B. (2011) Community-Based Participatory Research and Policy Advocacy to Reduce Diesel Exposure in West Oakland, California. American Journal of Public Health, 101, S166-S175.
[32] Van den Hove, S. (2007) A Rationale for Science-Policy Interfaces. Futures, 39, 807-826.
[33] Moctezuma, P. (2001) Community-Based Organization and Participatory Planning in South-East Mexico City. Environment and Urbanization, 13, 117-133.
[34] Frenk, J. and Moon, S. (2013) Governance Challenges in Global Health. New England Journal of Medicine, 369, 936-942.
[35] Latowsky, G. (2003) Report: Community-Based, Participatory Research in Lawrence, Massachusetts, Flags Environmental Health Hazards and Fuels Education and Action. Science Communication, 25, 204-208.
[36] Sanchez, L., Perez, D., Cruz, G., Silva, L.C., Boelaert, M. and Van der Stuyft, P. (2004) Community Participation in the Control of Aedes aegypti: Opinions of the Population in One Section of Havana, Cuba. Revista Panamericana de Salud Publica-Pan American Journal of Public Health, 15, 19-25.
[37] Laurian, L. (2005) Public Input in Toxic Site Cleanup Decisions: The Strengths and Limitations of Community Advisory Boards. Environment and Planning B-Planning & Design, 32, 445-467.
[38] Wells, N.M. (2005) Our Housing, Our Selves: A Longitudinal Investigation of Low-Income Women’s Participatory Housing Experiences. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 25, 189-206.
[39] Postma, J. (2008) Elucidating Empowerment in El Proyecto Bienestar (the Well-Being Project). Journal of Advanced Nursing, 62, 441-450.
[40] Keirns, C.C. (2009) Asthma Mitigation Strategies: Professional, Charitable, and Community Coalitions. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 37, S244-S250.
[41] Kreuter, M.W., Kegler, M.C., Joseph, K.T., Redwood, Y.A. and Hooker, M. (2012) The Impact of Implementing Selected CBPR Strategies to Address Disparities in Urban Atlanta: A Retrospective Case Study. Health Education Research, 27, 729-741.
[42] Millard, J. (2002) e-Government Strategies: Best Practice Reports from the European Front Line. In: Traumuller, R. and Lenk, K., Eds., Proceedings of the Electronic Government, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer, Berlin, 298-306.
[43] D’Alisa, G., Burgalassi, D., Healy, H. and Walter, M. (2010) Conflict in Campania Waste Emergency or Crisis of Democracy. Ecological Economics, 70, 239-249.
[44] Allen, N.E., Javdani, S., Lehrner, A.L. and Walden, A.L. (2012) “Changing the Text”: Modeling Council Capacity to Produce Institutionalized Change. American Journal of Community Psychology, 49, 317-331.
[45] Montiel, R.P. and Barten, F. (1999) Urban Governance and Health Development in Leon, Nicaragua. Environment and Urbanization, 11, 11-26.
[46] Curtis, A. and Lockwood, M. (2000) Landcare and Catchment Management in Australia: Lessons for State-Sponsored Community Participation. Society & Natural Resources, 13, 61-73.
[47] Hadi, A. (2000) A Participatory Approach to Sanitation: Experience of Bangladeshi NGOs. Health Policy and Planning, 15, 332-337.
[48] Whittington, D., Davis, J., Miarsono, H. and Pollard, R. (2000) Designing a “Neighborhood Deal” for Urban Sewers: A Case Study of Semarang, Indonesia. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 19, 297-308.
[49] Berkes, F., Mathias, J., Kislalioglu, M. and Fast, H. (2001) The Canadian Arctic and the Oceans Act: The Development of Participatory Environmental Research and Management. Ocean & Coastal Management, 44, 451-469.
[50] Schroeder, P.C., Boudreau, P.R., Brehme, C.E.W., Boyce, A.M., Evans, A.J. and Rahmani, A. (2001) The Gulf of Maine Environmental Information Exchange: Participation, Observation, Conversation. Environment and Planning B-Planning & Design, 28, 865-887.
[51] Maantay, J. (2002) Zoning Law, Health, and Environmental Justice: What’s the Connection? Journal of Law Medicine & Ethics, 30, 572-593.
[52] O’Fallon, L.R., Wolfle, G.M., Brown, D., Dearry, A. and Olden, K. (2003) Strategies for Setting a National Research Agenda that Is Responsive to Community Needs. Environmental Health Perspectives, 111, 1855-1860.
[53] Brown, P., Mayer, B., Zavestoski, S., Luebke, T., Mandelbaum, J. and McCormick, S. (2004) Clearing the Air and Breathing Freely: The Health Politics of Air Pollution and Asthma. International Journal of Health Services, 34, 39-63.
[54] Sloane, D., Nascimento, L., Flynn, G., Lewis, L., Guinyard, J.J., Galloway-Gilliam, L. and Yancey, A. (2006) Assessing Resource Environments to Target Prevention Interventions in Community Chronic Disease Control. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 17, 146-158.
[55] Williams, A., Holden, B., Krebs, P., Muhajarine, N., Waygood, K., Randall, J. and Spence, C. (2008) Knowledge Translation Strategies in a Community-University Partnership: Examining Local Quality of Life (QoL). Social Indicators Research, 85, 127-144.
[56] Freitas Setti, A.F. and Bogus, C.M. (2010) Community Participation in an Intervention Program Developed in a Protected Area. Saude e Sociedade, 19, 946-960.
[57] Cheadle, A., Bourcier, E., Krieger, J., Beery, W., Smyser, M., Vinh, D.V. and Alfonsi, L. (2011) The Impact of a Community-Based Chronic Disease Prevention Initiative: Evaluation Findings from Steps to Health King County. Health Education & Behavior, 38, 222-230.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2020 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.