Consistency of Hydrologic Relationships of a Paired Watershed Approach


Paired watershed studies are used around the world to evaluate and quantify effects of forest and water management practices on hydrology and water quality. The basic concept uses two neighboring watersheds (one as a control and another as a treatment), which are concurrently monitored during calibration (pre-treatment) and post-treatment periods. A statistically significant relationship between the control and treatment watersheds is established during calibration period such that any significant shift detected in the relationship during treatment is attributed to the treatment effects. The approach assumes that there is a consistent, quantifiable, and predictable relationship between watershed response variables. This study tests the hypothesis that the hydrologic relationships between control and treatment watersheds for daily water table elevation (WTE) and daily flow data were similar without any statistically significant difference during two different calibration (1988-1989 and 2007-2008) and treatment periods (1995-1996 and 2009), when the control and treatment watersheds were interchanged. The watersheds are two artificially drained loblolly pine forests (D1: 24.7 haand D2: 23.6 ha) located in coastal North Carolina. Results depicted significantly similar WTE regression relationships during the two calibration periods but significantly different WTE relationships during the two treatment periods with reversed control and treatment watersheds. Calibration and treatment flow relationships, and the mean treatment effects on WTE and flow, before and after treatment reversal were significantly different (α = 0.05). The study also discusses causes of differences in hydrologic relationships and treatment effects for such reversal of treatments during a 21-year span of the study on these two similar and adjacent watersheds. The observed differences in the hydrologic relationships between control and treatment watersheds before and after treatment reversal may be attributed to climate or hydrologic non-stationarity which may affect the reliability of paired watershed approach especially when the calibration periods are short.

Share and Cite:

H. Ssegane, D. Amatya, G. Chescheir, W. Skaggs, E. Tollner and J. Nettles, "Consistency of Hydrologic Relationships of a Paired Watershed Approach," American Journal of Climate Change, Vol. 2 No. 2, 2013, pp. 147-164. doi: 10.4236/ajcc.2013.22015.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] K. J. McGuire and G. E. Likens, “Historical Roots of Forest Hydrology and Biogeochemistry,” Forest Hydrology and Biogeochemistry, Vol. 216, 2011, pp. 3-26. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-1363-5_1
[2] V. Andréassian, “Waters and Forests: From Historical Controversy to Scientific Debate,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 291, No. 1-2, 2004, pp. 1-27. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2003.12.015
[3] R. L. Beschta, “Long-Term Patterns of Sediment Production Following Road Construction and Logging in the Oregon Coast Range,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 14, No. 6, 1978, pp. 1011-1016. doi:10.1029/WR014i006p01011
[4] T. A. Burton, “Effects of Basin-Scale Timber Harvest on Water Yield and Peak Streamflow,” Journal of the American Water Resources Association, Vol. 33, No. 6, 1997, pp. 1187-1196. doi:10.1111/j.1752-1688.1997.tb03545.x
[5] K. Cromack Jr., F. Swanson and C. Grier, “A Comparison of Harvesting Methods and Their Impact on Soils and Environment in the Pacific Northwest,” Proceedings of 5th North American Forest Soils Conference, Colorado State University Press, Fort Collins, 6-9 August 1978, pp. 449-476.
[6] J. D. Hewlett, H. Pos and D. Doss, “Effect of Clear-Cut Silviculture on Dissolved Ion Export,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 20, No. 7, 1984, pp. 1030-1038. doi:10.1029/WR020i007p01030
[7] J. D. Hewlett and L. Pienaar, “Design and Analysis of the Catchment Experiment,” 1973.
[8] J. W. Hornbeck, C. Martin, R. Pierce, F. Bormann, G. Likens and J. Eaton, “Clearcutting Northern Hardwoods: Effects on Hydrologic and Nutrient Ion Budgets,” Forest Science, Vol. 32, No. 3, 1986, pp. 667-686.
[9] C. W. Martin and R. S. Pierce, “Clearcutting Patterns Affect Nitrate and Calcium in Streams of New Hampshire,” Journal of Forestry, Vol. 78, No. 5, 1980, pp. 268-272.
[10] H. Riekerk, “Influence of Silvicultural Practices on the Hydrology,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 25, No. 4, 1989, pp. 713-719. doi:10.1029/WR025i004p00713
[11] W. T. Swank and J. D. Helvey, “Reduction of Streamflow Increases Following Regrowth of Clearcut Hardwood Forests,” 1970, pp. 346-360.
[12] J. C. Clausen and J. Spooner, “Paired Watershed Study Design,” Office of Wetlands, Oceans and Watersheds, Environmental Protection Agency, Washington DC, 1993.
[13] W. E. Jokela and M. D. Casler, “Transport of Phosphorus and Nitrogen in Surface Runoff in a Corn Silage System: Paired Watershed Methodology and Calibration Period Results,” 2011.
[14] K. King, P. Smiley Jr., B. Baker and N. Fausey, “Validation of Paired Watersheds for Assessing Conservation Practices in the Upper Big Walnut Creek Watershed, Ohio,” Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, Vol. 63, No. 6, 2008, pp. 380-395.
[15] A. Lemke, J. Herkert, T. Lindenbaum, M. Herbert, K. Kirkham, T. Tear, et al., “Evaluating Agricultural Best Management Practices in Tile-Drained Subwatersheds of the Mackinaw River, Illinois,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 40, 2011, pp. 1215-1228.
[16] R. Kallenbach, H. E. Garrett and R. P. Udawatta, “Agroforestry Buffers for Nonpoint Source Pollution Reductions from Agricultural Watersheds,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 40, No. 4, 2011, pp. 800-806.
[17] B. R. Paudel, R. P. Udawatta and S. H. Anderson, “Agroforestry and Grass Buffer Effects on Soil Quality Parameters for Grazed Pasture and Row-Crop Systems,” Applied Soil Ecology, Vol. 48, No. 2, 2011, pp. 125-132. doi:10.1016/j.apsoil.2011.04.004
[18] R. P. Udawatta, R. J. Kremer, H. E. Garrett and S. H. Anderson, “Soil Enzyme Activities and Physical Properties in a Watershed Managed under Agroforestry and Row-Crop Systems,” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 131, No. 1-2, 2009, pp. 98-104. doi:10.1016/j.agee.2008.06.001
[19] R. P. Udawatta, J. J. Henderson, G. S. Garrett and E. Harold, “Agroforestry Practices, Runoff, and Nutrient Loss,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 31, No. 4, 2002, p. 1214.
[20] K. S. Veum, K. W. Goyne, P. P. Motavalli and R. P. Udawatta, “Runoff and Dissolved Organic Carbon Loss from a Paired-Watershed Study of Three Adjacent Agricultural Watersheds,” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 130, No. 3-4, 2009, pp. 115-122. doi:10.1016/j.agee.2008.12.006
[21] P. L. Bishop, W. D. Hively, J. R. Stedinger, M. R. Rafferty, J. L. Lojpersberger and J. A. Bloomfield, “Multivariate Analysis of Paired Watershed Data to Evaluate Agricultural Best Management Practice Effects on Stream Water Phosphorus,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 34, No. 3, 2005, pp. 1087-1101.
[22] D. B. Jaynes, D. Dinnes, D. Meek, D. Karlen, C. Cambardella and T. Colvin, “Using the Late Spring Nitrate Test to Reduce Nitrate Loss within a Watershed,” 2004.
[23] K. E. Schilling, “Chemical Transport from Paired Agricultural and Restored Prairie Watersheds,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 31, No. 4, 2002, pp. 11841193.
[24] D. M. Amatya, J. Gilliam, R. Skaggs, M. Lebo and R. Campbell, “Effects of Controlled Drainage on Forest Water Quality,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 27, No. 4, 1998, pp. 923-935 doi:10.2134/jeq1998.00472425002700040029x
[25] D. M. Amatya, J. D. Gregory and R. Skaggs, “Effects of Controlled Drainage on Storm Event Hydrology in a Loblolly Pine Plantation,” Journal of the American Water Resources Association, Vol. 36, No. 1, 2000, pp. 175-190. doi:10.1111/j.1752-1688.2000.tb04258.x
[26] D. M. Amatya, R. Skaggs and J. Gregory, “Effects of Controlled Drainage on the Hydrology of Drained Pine Plantations in the North Carolina Coastal Plain,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 181, No. 1-4, 1996, pp. 211-232. doi:10.1016/0022-1694(95)02905-2
[27] J. Shanley and B. Wemple, “Effects of Mountain Resort Development—A Case Study in Vermont USA,” 2012.
[28] J. C. Loftis, L. H. MacDonald, S. Streett, H. K. Iyer and K. Bunte, “Detecting Cumulative Watershed Effects: The Statistical Power of Pairing,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 251, No. 1-2, 2001, pp. 49-64. doi:10.1016/S0022-1694(01)00431-0
[29] L. S. Prokopy, Z. Asligül Gocmen, J. Gao, S. B. Allred, J. E. Bonnell, K. Genskow, et al., “Incorporating Social Context Variables Into Paired Watershed Designs to Test Nonpoint Source Program Effectiveness1,” Journal of the American Water Resources Association, Vol. 47, No. 1, 2011, pp. 196-202.
[30] E. Mellina and S. G. Hinch, “Overview of Large-Scale Ecological Experimental Designs and Recommendations for the British Columbia Watershed Restoration Program,” Ministry of Environment, Lands and Parks and Ministry of Forestry, Vancouver, 1995.
[31] A. L. Vogl and V. L. Lopes, “Evaluating Watershed Experiments through Recursive Residual Analysis,” Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, Vol. 136, No. 5, 2010, pp. 348-353. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)IR.1943-4774.0000203
[32] Y. Alila, P. Kuras, M. Schnorbus and R. Hudson, “Forests and Floods: A New Paradigm Sheds Light on AgeOld Controversies,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 45, No. 8, 2009, Article ID: W08416. doi:10.1029/2008WR007207
[33] P. K. Kuras, Y. Alila and M. Weiler, “Forest Harvesting Effects on the Magnitude and Frequency of Peak Flows Can Increase with Return Period,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 48, No. 1, 2012, Article ID: W01544. doi:10.1029/2011WR010705
[34] N. A. Som, N. P. Zégre, L. M. Ganio and A. E. Skaugset, “Corrected Prediction Intervals for Change Detection in Paired Watershed Studies,” Hydrological Sciences Journal, Vol. 57, No. 1, 2012, pp. 134-143. doi:10.1080/02626667.2011.637494
[35] J. L. Boggs and G. Sun, “Urbanization Alters Watershed Hydrology in the Piedmont of North Carolina,” Ecohydrology, Vol. 4, No. 2, 2011, pp. 256-264.
[36] J. C. Bathurst, “Predicting Impacts of Land Use and Climate Change on Erosion and Sediment Yield in River Basins Using SHETRAN,” Handbook of Erosion Modelling, 2011, pp. 263-288.
[37] Z. Liu, S. Tong, C. Jeganathan, P. Roy, M. Jha, Z. Yang, et al., “Using HSPF to Model the Hydrologic and Water Quality Impacts of Riparian Land-Use Change in a Small Watershed,” Journal of Environmental Informatics, Vol. 17, No. 1, 2011, pp. 1-14. doi:10.3808/jei.201100182
[38] S. Tian, M. A. Youssef, R. W. Skaggs, D. M. Amatya, and G. Chescheir, “DRAINMOD-FOREST: Integrated Modeling of Hydrology, Soil Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics, and Plant Growth for Drained Forests,” Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 41, No. 3, 2012, pp. 764782.
[39] M. Wiley, D. Hyndman, B. Pijanowski, A. Kendall, C. Riseng, E. Rutherford, et al., “A Multi-Modeling Approach to Evaluating Climate and Land Use Change Impacts in a Great Lakes River Basin,” Hydrobiologia, Vol. 657, No. 1, 2010, pp. 243-262. doi:10.1007/s10750-010-0239-2
[40] W. H. McDowell, “Comparative Watershed Studies-Opportunities and Limitations,” ILTER Regional Workshop, Budapest, 2000.
[41] P. Schleppi, “Forested Water Catchments in a Changing Environment,” Forest Management and the Water Cycle, Vol. 212, 2011, pp. 89-110.
[42] C. R. Ford, S. H. Laseter, W. T. Swank and J. M. Vose, “Can Forest Management Be Used to Sustain Water-Based Ecosystem Services in the Face of Climate Change?” Ecological Applications, Vol. 21, 2011, pp. 2049-2067.
[43] D. M. Amatya, R. Skaggs and J. Gilliam, “Hydrology and Water Quality of a Drained Loblolly Pine Plantation in Coastal North Carolina,” American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers, St. Joseph, 2006.
[44] J. W. Hornbeck, M. Adams, E. Corbett, E. Verry and J. Lynch, “Long-Term Impacts of Forest Treatments on Water Yield: A Summary for Northeastern USA,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 150, No. 2-4, 1993, pp. 323-344. doi:10.1016/0022-1694(93)90115-P
[45] J. W. Hornbeck, C. Martin and C. Eagar, “Summary of Water Yield Experiments at Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, New Hampshire,” Canadian Journal of Forest Research, Vol. 27, No. 12, 1997, pp. 2043-2052.
[46] E. McCarthy, R. Skaggs, and P. Farnum, “Experimental Determination of the Hydrologic Components of a Drained Forest Watershed,” Transactions of the ASAE, Vol. 34, No. 5, 1991, pp. 2031-2039.
[47] D. M. Amatya and R. Skaggs, “Long-Term Hydrology and Water Quality of a Drained Pine Plantation in North Carolina,” Transactions of the ASAE, Vol. 54, No. 6, 2011, pp. 2087-2098.
[48] E. F. Brater and H. W. King, “Handbook of Hydraulics: for the Solution of Hydraulic Engineering Problems,” McGraw-Hill, New York, 1996.
[49] D. M. Amatya, R. Skaggs, C. Blanton and J. Gilliam, “Hydrologic and Water Quality Effects of Harvesting and Regeneration of a Drained Pine Forest,” American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers, St. Joseph, 2006.
[50] R. L. Brown, J. Durbin and J. M. Evans, “Techniques for Testing the Constancy of Regression Relationships over Time,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B (Methodological), Vol. 37, No. 2, 1975, pp. 149-192.
[51] J. S. Galpin and D. M. Hawkins, “The Use of Recursive Residuals in Checking Model Fit in Linear Regression,” The American Statistician, Vol. 38, No. 2, 1984, pp. 94105.
[52] J. P. LeSage and R. K. Pace, “Introduction to Spatial Econometrics,” Chapman & Hall/CRC, London, 2009. doi:10.1201/9781420064254
[53] R. E. Plotnick, “Application of Bootstrap Methods to Reduced Major Axis Line Fitting,” Systematic Biology, Vol. 38, No. 2, 1989, pp. 144-153. doi:10.1093/sysbio/38.2.144
[54] W. Ricker, “Linear Regressions in Fishery Research,” Journal of the Fisheries Board of Canada, Vol. 30, No. 3, 1973, pp. 409-434. doi:10.1139/f73-072
[55] B. McArdle, “The Structural Relationship: Regression in Biology,” Canadian Journal of Zoology, Vol. 66, No. 11, 1988, pp. 2329-2339. doi:10.1139/z88-348
[56] C. Cunnane, “Unbiased Plotting Positions—A Review,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 37, No. 3-4, 1978, pp. 205222. doi:10.1016/0022-1694(78)90017-3
[57] V. Baldwin, “Green and Dry-Weight Equations for Above-Ground Components of Planted Loblolly Pine Trees in the West Gulf Region,” Southern Journal of Applied Forestry, Vol. 11, No. 4, 1987, pp. 212-218.
[58] C. Blanton, R. Skaggs, D. Amatya and G. Chescheir, “Soil Hydraulic Property Variations during Harvest and Regeneration of Drained, Coastal Pine Plantations,” 1998, pp. 12-16.
[59] J. M. Grace, R. W. Skaggs and D. K. Cassel, “Soil Physical Changes Associated with Forest Harvesting Operations on an Organic Soil,” Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 70, No. 2, 2006, pp. 503-509. doi:10.2136/sssaj2005.0154
[60] R. W. Skaggs, D. M. Amatya, G. M. Chescheir, C. D. Blanton and J. W. Gilliam, “Effects of Drainage and Management Practices on Hydrology of Pine Plantation,” Hydrology and Management of Forested Wetlands, St. Joseph, 2006.
[61] Y. J. Xu, J. A. Burger, W. M. Aust, S. C. Patterson, M. Miwa and D. P. Preston, “Changes in Surface Water Table Depth and Soil Physical Properties after Harvest and Establishment of Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda L.) in Atlantic Coastal Plain Wetlands of South Carolina,” Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 63, No. 3-4, 2002, pp. 109-121. doi:10.1016/S0167-1987(01)00226-4
[62] M. A. Rab, “Recovery of Soil Physical Properties from Compaction and Soil Profile Disturbance Caused by Logging of Native Forest in Victorian Central Highlands, Australia,” Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 191, No. 1-3, 2004, pp. 329-340. doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2003.12.010
[63] M. H. Eisenbies, J. A. Burger, W. M. Aust and S. C. Patterson, “Loblolly Pine Response to Wet-Weather Harvesting on Wet Flats after 5 Years,” Water, Air, & Soil Pollution: Focus, Vol. 4, No. 1, 2004, pp. 217-233. doi:10.1023/B:WAFO.0000012817.20157.d3
[64] M. Miwa, W. M. Aust, J. A. Burger, S. C. Patterson and E. A. Carter, “Wet-Weather Timber Harvesting and Site Preparation Effects on Coastal Plain Sites: A Review,” Southern Journal of Applied Forestry, Vol. 28, No. 3, 2004, pp. 137-151.
[65] G. Sun, S. G. McNulty, J. P. Shepard, D. M. Amatya, H. Riekerk, N. B. Comerford, et al., “Effects of Timber Management on the Hydrology of Wetland Forests in the Southern United States,” Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 143, No. 1-3, 2001, pp. 227-236. doi:10.1016/S0378-1127(00)00520-X
[66] G. Sun, H. Riekerk and L. V. Kornhak, “Ground-WaterTable Rise after Forest Harvesting on Cypress-Pine Flatwoods in Florida,” Wetlands, Vol. 20, No. 1, 2000, pp. 101-112. doi:10.1672/0277-5212(2000)020[0101:GWTRAF]2.0.CO;2
[67] C. Bliss and N. Comerford, “Forest Harvesting Influence on Water Table Dynamics in a Florida Flatwoods Landscape,” Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 66, No. 4, 2002, pp. 1344-1349. doi:10.2136/sssaj2002.1344
[68] J. K. Searcy, “Flow-Duration Curves Manual of Hydrology: Part 2. Low-Flow Techniques,” US Department of Interior, Washington, 1959.

Copyright © 2022 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.