Author(s)

Cui Xu^*, Mingyu Hu^#*

The Law School of Hainan University, Haikou, China.

The current predominant self-review mechanism by policy-making bodies suffers from deficiencies such as insufficient motivations, limited review capabilities, and weak external supervision. Third-party assessment, characterized by independence and specialization, is designed to mitigate these shortcomings. However, the implementation of third-party assessment faces challenges too. This paper intends to improve the third-party assessment system and to realize the legislative purpose of the system. Based on social research, discussions and exchanges with relevant parties, and the existing research results, this paper analyzes the challenges and possible optimization measures for the third-party assessment. The challenges include repulsion from policy-making bodies, insufficient independence of assessment bodies, disparity of assessment quality, and limited application of assessment outcomes. Possible optimization measures include promoting fair competition culture, increasing the acceptance of third-party assessment from policy-making bodies, enhancing the quality of third-party assessment, clarifying the relationship between policy-making bodies and assessment bodies, ensuring the independence of third-party assessments, and promoting the application of assessment results.

Fair Competition Review, Self-Review, Third-Party Assessment, Dilemma, Optimization

Xu, C. and Hu, M. (2024) Dilemmas and Optimization of Third-Party Assessment System in Chinese Fair Competition Review. Open Journal of Applied Sciences, 14, 2039-2049. doi: 10.4236/ojapps.2024.148134.