Fairness Is a More Effective Interpersonal Motive than Care for Sustaining Prosocial Behaviour ()
Author(s)
Maurizio Brasini1,2*,
Sasha Del Vecchio3,
Edoardo Gregni4,
Chiara Casali1,
Francesca Mira1,
Nicolina Capuano4,
Valentina Questa1,5,
Mauro Giacomantonio1,6,
Francesco Mancini1,2
Affiliation(s)
1Scuola di Psicoterapia Cognitiva (SPC), Rome, Italy.
2Guglielmo Marconi University, Rome, Italy.
3Università degli Studi de L’Aquila, L’Aquila, Italy.
4Associazione di Psicologia Cognitiva (APC), Rome, Italy.
5Roma Tre University, Rome, Italy.
6Sapienza University, Rome, Italy.
ABSTRACT
The present study stems from three general assumptions about prosocial behaviour: 1) that it has an evolutionary foundation; 2) that it is sensitive to the interpersonal context in which it takes place; and 3) that it can be supported by different values and motives. An experiment based on the Dictator Game (DG) was carried out, in which two groups of participants with different Social Values Orientation (SVO) established how to share either €30 gain and a €30 loss, also considering the varying intentions of the other, which could have been selfish, fair or altruistic. Results confirmed that other’s selfish intentions gave rise to a lesser sharing, while other’s fair/altruistic intentions were reciprocated with a balanced sharing. However, when sharing a loss, Proself participants tended to exploit the altruistic intentions of the other. Moreover, the analysis of the relevant motivations in the decisions showed that only an individual orientation towards fairness predicted a higher resource allocation; more specifically, sharing a loss when the other showed altruistic intentions was found to be a matter of fairness. These results support the evolutionary hypothesis that fairness, as a key feature of peer cooperation, offers an interpersonal motivational framework more conducive to prosocial behaviour than empathy-based altruism, which is a key feature of the caregiving/care-seeking interpersonal motivational framework.
Share and Cite:
Brasini, M. , Vecchio, S. , Gregni, E. , Casali, C. , Mira, F. , Capuano, N. , Questa, V. , Giacomantonio, M. and Mancini, F. (2018) Fairness Is a More Effective Interpersonal Motive than Care for Sustaining Prosocial Behaviour.
Psychology,
9, 1426-1443. doi:
10.4236/psych.2018.96087.
Cited by
No relevant information.