Author(s)

Goki Kaya¹, Miyae Yamakawa², Misako Shigeuchi³, Hiroaki Naritomi⁴

¹Division of Rehabilitation, Senri-chuo Hospital, Osaka, Japan.
²Evidence-Based Clinical Nursing, Health Sciences Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka University, Osaka, Japan.
³Department of Nursing, Kyowakai Hospital, Hyogo, Japan.
⁴Department of Neuology, Senri-chuo Hospital, Osaka, Japan.

Background: Patient falls are a serious problem in a rehabilitation unit. Although patient falls have been described in the healthcare literature for more 60 years, and many risk assessment tools have been developed, the rate of falls in hospitals in Japan has remained unchanged for the last 8 years. A previous study reported that about 50% of patients in rehabilitation estimated their fall risk lower than that estimated by their nurses. We believe that patients in rehabilitation tend to overestimate their ability to perform ADLs. Aim: To identify discrepancies between patients’ and nurses’ estimates of patients’ ability to perform activities of daily living (ADL) and clarify any relationship between the discrepancies and patient falls. Methods: Participants comprised 82 patients (42 men) admitted to a rehabilitation unit in Osaka, Japan from July to December of 2017. Patients and their nurses answered the same questionnaire about patients’ ability to perform ADL. The questionnaire was developed based on the Functional Independence Measure (FIM) and administered at admission, at 1 month after admission, and at discharge. Participants were classified into the overestimating group and the accurately estimating/underestimating group, and groups were compared using Wilcoxon rank-sum tests. Results: The mean age of participants was 76.4 years. At admission, approximately 72% of participants estimated their own ability to perform ADL higher than did the nurses. The percentage of overestimating participants dropped to 30% at discharge. Fifteen of the participants experienced a fall; all were in the overestimating group. The ADL Discrepancy and fall-assessment scores for these 15 participants were significantly higher than those of other participants. Conclusions: There are discrepancies between patients’ and nurses’ estimates of patients’ ability to perform ADL and had important significance for assessing their risk of fall. And minimizing the discrepancy may support the prevention of falls.

Accidental Falls, Rehabilitation, Risk Assessment

Kaya, G. , Yamakawa, M. , Shigeuchi, M. and Naritomi, H. (2023) Discrepancy between Patients’ and Nurses’ Estimates of Patients’ Activities of Daily Living for Fall Risk Assessment: A Quantitative Observational Study. Open Journal of Nursing, 13, 196-206. doi: 10.4236/ojn.2023.133012.