Cottonseed yield and its quality as affected by mineral fertilizers and plant growth retardants ()
1.1. Nitrogen
In cotton culture, nitrogen (N), has a necessity role in production inputs, which controls growth and prevents abscission of squares and bolls, essential for photosynthetic activity [2], and stimulates the mobilization and accumulation of metabolites in newly developed bolls, thus increasing their number and weight. Additionally, with a dynamic crop like cotton, excess N serves to delay maturity, promote vegetative tendencies, and usually results in lower yields [3]. Therefore, errors made in N management that can impact the crop can be through either deficiencies or excesses. Ansari and Mahey [4] evaluate the effects of N level (0, 40, 80, 120 and 160 kg·ha−1) on the yield and found that seed yield increased with increasing N level up to 80 kg·ha−1. Nitrogen is an essential nutrient for the synthesis of fat, which requires both N and carbon skeletons during the course of seed development [5]. On the other hand, nitrogen plays the most important role in building the protein structure [6]. Another beneficial change in fatty acid composition due to N nutrition would be an increase in the linoleic and oleic acid contents, and an increase in the percentage of unsaturated fatty acids and a decrease in saturated fatty acids in the seed oil [7].
1.2. Phosphorus
Phosphorus (P) is the second most limiting nutrient in cotton production after nitrogen. Its deficiency tends to limit the growth of cotton plants, especially when plants are deprived of P at early stages than later stages of growth. Further, P is an essential nutrient and an integral component of several important compounds in plant cells, including the sugar-phosphates involved in respiration, photosynthesis and the phospholipids of plant membranes, the nucleotides used in plant energy metabolism and in molecules of DNA and RNA [8]. Phosphorus deficiency reduces the rate of leaf expansion and photosynthetic rate per unit leaf area [9]. Sasthri et al. [10] found that application of 2% diammonium phosphate to cotton plants increased seed yield. Improvements in cotton yield resulting from P application were reported by Stewart et al. [11]; Singh et al. [12]; Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
1.3. Potassium
The physiological role of potassium (K) during fruit formation and maturation periods is mainly expressed in carbohydrate metabolism and translocation of metabolites from leaves and other vegetative organs to developing bolls. Potassium increases the photosynthetic rates of crop leaves, CO2 assimilation and facilitating carbon movement [15]. The high concentration of K+ is thought to be essential for normal protein synthesis. Potassium deficiency during the reproductive period can limit the accumulation of crop biomass [16], markedly changes the structure of fruit-bearing organs, and decreases yield and quality. Improvements in cotton yield and quality resulting from K input have been reported by the following authors: Gormus [17] applying K rates of 66.4, 132.8 and 199.2 kg·ha−1 K; Aneela et al. [18] increase K levels, the effect being highest at 166 kg·K·ha−1; Pervez et al. [19] using K rates of 62.5, 125 and 250 kg·ha−1; Pettigrew et al. [20] with a K fertilizer rate of 112 kg·ha−1; Sharma and Sundar [21] with a foliar application of K at 4.15 kg·ha−1.
1.4. Zinc
Zinc (Zn) is critical for several key enzymes in the plant. Zinc binds tightly to Zn-containing essential metabolites in vegetative tissues, e.g., Zn-activated enzymes such as carbonic anhydrase [22]. Further, Zn is required in the biosynthesis of tryptophan, a precursor of the auxin—indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), which is the major hormone inhibiting abscission of squares and bolls. Zinc deficiency symptoms include: small leaves, shortened internodes, a stunted appearance, reduced boll set, and small bolls size [23]. Zinc deficiency occurs in cotton on high-pH soils, and where high rates of P are applied [23]. Rathinavel et al. [24] found that application of ZnSO4, to the soil at 50 kg·ha−1 increased 100-seed weight. Li et al. [25] found that when cotton was sprayed with 0.2% zinc sulfate at the seedling stage, the boll number plant−1 increased by 17.3% and the cotton yield increased by 18.5% compared with the untreated control.
1.5. Calcium
Calcium (Ca) is essential in cell nucleus matrix. It activates enzymes, particularly those that are membranebound [26]. It is thought that Ca is important in the formation of cell membranes and lipid structures. Ma and Sun [27], suggested that Ca might be involved in light signal transduction chain for phototropism. Calcium deficiency as one of the causes of abscission and suggested this plus the role of Ca in the middle lamella (Ca pectates) as the possible reason. A likely reason was that Ca deficiency affected translocation of carbohydrates, causing accumulation in the leaves and a decline in stems and roots. It seems probable that young bolls abscised because of starvation. Thus, Ca may inhibit abscission because it is a component of the middle lamella, because it promotes translocation of sugars and auxin, and because it helps prevent senescence. Ochiai [28] notes that Ca2+ can bridge phosphate and carboxylate groups of phospholipids and proteins; that it increases hydrophobicity of membranes; that it generally increases membrane stability and reduces water permeability.
1.6. Plant Growth Regulators Retardants
An objective for using plant growth retardants (PGRs) (mepiquat chloride, “Pix”, chloromequat chloride, “Cycocel”, and daminozide, “Alar”) in cotton is to balance vegetative and reproductive growth as well as to improve yield and its quality [29]. Visual growth-regulating activity of Pix, Cycocel or Alar is similar, being expressed as reduced plant height and width, shortened stem and branch internodes and leaf petioles, influence leaf chlorophyll concentration, structure and CO2 assimilation, and thicker leaves. This indicates that bolls on treated cotton plants have a larger photo synthetically sink for carbohydrates and other metabolites than those on untreated plants. More specific response from using PGRs include alteration of carbon partitioning, greater root/ shoot ratios, enhanced photosynthesis, altered nutrient uptake, and altered crop canopy. In this connection, Wang et al. [30] stated that application of the plant growth retardant Pix to the cotton plants at squaring decreased the partitioning of assimilates to the main stem, the branches and their growing points, and increased partitioning to the reproductive organs and roots. Also, they indicated that, from bloom to boll-setting, Pix application was very effective in restricting the vegetative growth of the cotton canopy and in promoting the partitioning of assimilates into reproductive organs. Kumar et al. [31] evaluated the effects of Chamatkar, 5% Pix, 500, 750 and 1000 ppm, on cotton. These treatments increased the values for photosynthetic rate, transpiration rate, total chlorophyll content, and nitrate reductase activity, number of bolls plant−1, boll weight and yield.
Most previous has focused on studying the effect of nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, foliar application of zinc and calcium, the use of PGRs on cotton yield and fiber quality [32,33]. However, there is limited information about the most suitable management practice for application of N, P, K, Zn, Ca and PGRs in order to optimize the quantity and quality of oil and protein of cottonseed [34]. Due to the economic importance of cottonseed (presently the main source of edible oil and meal for livestock) in Egypt, this study was designed to identify the best combination of these production treatments in order to improve cottonseed, protein and oil yields and oil properties of Egyptian cotton (G. barbadense L.) [1,35-37].
2. METHODS AND MEASUREMENTS
Field experiments were conducted at the Agricultural Research Center, Ministry of Agriculture in Giza (30˚N, 31˚: 28’E and 19 m altitude), Egypt using the cotton cultivars “Giza 75” and “Giza 86” (Gossypium barbadense L.) in the two seasons I and II. Seeds were planted on March, and seed cotton was harvest on October [38]. The soil type was a clay loam. Average textural and chemical properties of soil are reported in Table 1 [38]. Range and mean values of the climatic factors recorded during the growing seasons are presented in Table 2 [38]. No rainfall occurred during the two growing seasons. The experiments were arranged as a randomized complete block design. The plot size was 1.95 × 4 m, including three ridges (beds). Hills were spaced 25 cm apart on one side of the ridge, and seedlings were thinned to two plants hill−1 6 weeks after planting, providing plant density of 123,000 plants·ha−1. Total irrigation amount during the growing season (surface irrigation) was about 6000 m3·ha−1. The first irrigation was applied 3 weeks after sowing, and the second one was 3 weeks later. Thereafter, the plots were irrigated every 2 weeks until the end of the season, thus providing a total of nine irrigations [38].
2.1. Experiments
2.1.1. Effect of N, Zn and PGR’s on Cottonseed, Protein, Oil Yields, and Oil Properties
Materials: A field experiment was conducted, using the cotton cultivar Giza 75. Each experiment included 16 treatments the following combinations: 1) Two N-rtes (107 and 161 of N·ha−1) were applied as ammonium nitrate (33.5% N) in two equal amounts 6 and 8 weeks after sowing; each application (in the form of pinches beside each hill) was followed immediately by irrigation. 2) Three PGR’s, 1, 1-dimethylpiperidinium chloride (mepiquat chloride, or Pix), 2-chloroethyltrimethylammonium chloride (chloromequat chloride, or Cycocel), and succinic acid 2, 2-dimethylhydrazide (daminozide, or Alar) were used. Each was foliar-sprayed once at 288 g active ingredient ha−1, 75 days after planting (during square initiation and boll setting stage) at solution volume of 960 l·ha−1. Water was used as the control treatment. 3) Two chelated Zn rates (0.0 and 48 g of Zn ha−1) were foliar-sprayed twice, 80 and 95 days after planting at solution volume of 960 l·ha−1 [35].
2.1.2. Effect of P, Zn and Ca on Cottonseed, Protein and Oil Yields and Oil Properties
Materials: A field experiment was conducted on the cotton cultivar Giza 75. Each experiment included 16 treatments, using combinations: 1) Two P rates, 44 (farmer’s dose) and 74 kg of P2O5 ha−1 were applied (as a concentrated band close to the seed ridge) as calcium super-phosphate (15% P2O5) before the first irrigation, i.e. 3 weeks after planting (during seedling stage). 2) Two Zn rates at 0.0 and 40 ppm, as chelated form [ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA)] each was foliar sprayed twice, 75 and 90 days after planting (during square initiation and boll setting stage) at solution volume of 960 l·ha−1. 3) Four chelated Ca rates at 0.0, 20, 40 and 60 ppm were each foliar sprayed twice, 80 and 95 days after planting, at solution volume of 960 l·ha−1 [36].
2.1.3. Cottonseed, Protein, Oil Yields, and Oil Properties as Influenced by K, P and Zn
Materials: A field experiment was conducted on the cotton cultivar “Giza 86”. Each experiment included 16 treatment combinations of the following: 1) Two K rates (0.0 and 47.4 kg of K ha−1) were applied as K sulfate (K2SO4, “48% K2O), eight weeks after sowing (as a concentrated band close to the seed ridge) and the application was followed immediately by irrigation. 2) Two Zn rates (0.0 or 57.6 g of Zn ha−1) were applied as chelated form and each was foliar sprayed two times (70 and 85 days after planting, during square initiation and boll
Table 1. Physical and chemical properties of the soil used in I and II seasons.
Table 2. Range and mean values of the weather variables recorded during the growing seasons (April-October).
setting stage). 3) Four phosphorus rates (0.0, 576, 1152 and 1728 g of P ha−1) were applied as calcium super phosphate (15% P2O5) and each was foliar sprayed two times (80 and 95 days after planting). The Zn and P were both applied to the leaves with uniform coverage at a solution volume of 960 l·ha−1, using a knapsack sprayer [1].
2.1.4. Effects N, K and PGR on Oil Content and Quality of Cotton Seed
Materials: A field experiment was conducted, using the cotton cultivar “Giza 86”. The experiment included 16 treatments: 1) soil application of N (95.2 “the ordinary”, and 142.8 kg of N ha−1 as ammonium nitrate), 2) foliar application of K (0, 319, 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 as potassium sulfate) and 3) foliar spray of the PGR (1,1-dimethylpiperidinium chloride (mepiquat chloride “MC” or “Pix”) 75 days after planting at 0 or 48 g a.i. ha−1, and 90 days after planting at 0 or 24 g a.i. ha−1). The solution volume applied was also 960 L·ha−1. Nitrogen fertilizer (NH4NO3, “3.5% N”) was applied half at 6 and the rest at 8 weeks after planting. The fertilizer was placed beside each hill in the form of pinches and followed immediately by irrigation. Potassium (K2SO4, “40% K”) was applied as foliar spray during square initiation and boll development stage, 70 and 95 days after planting, respectively. The solution volume applied was 960 l·ha−1. The K and MC were applied to the leaves uniformly using a knapsack sprayer [37].
2.2. Measurements
At harvest the seed cotton yield plot−1 (handpicking) was determined. Following ginning, the cotton seed yield in kg·ha−1as well as 100-seed weight in g was determined. A composite seed sample was collected from each treatment for chemical analyses. The following chemical analyses were conducted: 1) seed crude protein content according to AOAC standards [39]; 2) seed oil content in which oil was extracted three times with chloroform/methanol (2:1, vol/vol) mixture according to the method outlined by Kates [40]; 3) oil quality traits, i.e., refractive index, acid value, saponification value, unsaponifiable matter, and iodine value were determined according to methods described by AOCS [41]; and 4) identification and determination of oil fatty acids by gasliquid chromatography. The lipid materials were saponified, unsaponifiable matter was removed, and the fatty acids were separated after acidification of the saponifiable materials. The free fatty acids were methylated with diazomethane [42]. The fatty acid methyl esters were analyzed by a Hewlett Packard model 5890 gas chromatograph (Palo Alto, CA) equipped with dual flame-ionization detectors. The separation procedures were similar to those reported by Ashoub et al. [43].
2.3. Statistical Analysis
Data obtained for the cottonseed yield and seed weight were statistically analyzed as a factorial experiment in a RCBD following the procedure outlined by Snedecor and Cochran [44] and the least significant difference (LSD) was used to determine the significance of differences between treatment means. As for the chemical properties considered in the study, the t-test computed in accordance with standard deviation was utilized to verify the significance between treatments means [1].
3. ANALYZED DATA FOR MEASUREMENTS
3.1. Experiments
3.1.1. Effect of N, Zn and PGR’s on Cottonseed, Protein, Oil Yields, and Oil Properties
Seed yield ha−1, was significantly (P ≤ 0.05) increased (8.96%) by raising N rate (Table 3) [35]. Abdel-Malak et al. [45] stated that cotton yield was higher when N was applied at a rate of 190 kg·ha−1 than at the rate of 143 kg·ha−1. Palomo Gil and Chávez González [32] applied N at a rate ranging from 40 to 200 kg·ha−1 to cotton plants and found highest yield was associated with high rates of applied N. Similar results were obtained by Sarwar Cheema et al. [33] Saleem et al. [46] when N was applied at 120 kg·ha−1; Hamed et al. [47] when N was applied up to 178 kg·ha−1. Nitrogen is an important nutrient which control growth and prevents abscission of squares and bolls, essential for photosynthetic activity [2] and stimulate the mobilization and accumulation of metabolites in newly developed bolls and thus their number and weight are increased. All tested PGR (Pix, Cycocel and Alar) significantly increased seed yield ha−1 (7.79% - 12.08%), compared with the untreated control. The most effective was Pix (12.08%), followed by Cycocel (10.57%) [35]. These results may be attributed to the promoting effect of these substances on numerous physiological processes, leading to improvement of all yield components. Pix applications increases CO2 uptake and fixation in cotton plant leaves. In cotton stems, the xylem was expanded with Pix treatment, perhaps increasing the transport ability and accounting for heavier bolls. Alar and Pix also have been associated with increased photosynthesis [48,49] through increased total chlorophyll concentration of plant leaves, increased photosynthesis greatly increased flowering, boll retention and yield. Abdel-Al [50] indicated that cotton yield significantly increased with Pix treatment at a rate 11.90 ml (formulation) ha−1 at the beginning of flowering, and Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14] found that cotton yield significantly increased with Pix application at 1, 2 and 3 cm3 L (formulation) at pinhead square, start of flowering and peak of flowering stage. Pípolo et al. [51] found that spraying cotton plants at an age of 70 d after emergence with Cycocel at rates ranging from 25 to 100 g·ha−1 resulted in yield increases. Sawan et al. [52] stated that application of Cycocel and Alar, at rates ranging from 250 to 700 ppm (105 days after planting) increased cotton seed yield ha−1. Similar results were obtained by Sarwar Cheema et al. [33]. Application of Zn significantly increased seed yield ha−1 (8.44%), as compared with untreated plants [35]. Zeng [53] stated application of Zn to cotton plants on calcareous soil increased yield by 7.8% - 25.7%. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]. Zinc is required in the synthesis of tryptophan, which is a precursor of IAA synthesis which is the hormone that inhibits abscission of squares and bolls. Also, this nutrient has favorable effect on the photosynthetic activity of leaves and plant metabolism [25], which might account for higher accumulation of metabolites in reproductive organs (bolls).
Seed index significantly increased with increasing N rate (Table 3) [35]. This may be partially due to enhanced photosynthetic activity [2]. Similar findings were obtained by Palomo Gil and Chávez González [32];
Table 3. Effect of N rate and foliar application of plant growth retardants and Zn on cottonseed yield, seed index, seed oil, seed protein, oil and protein yields.
Hamed et al. [47]. Application of all PGR significantly increased seed index as compared to untreated control; Pix gave the highest seed index, followed by Cycocel [35]. These agree with previous works of Sawan et al. [52], by applying Cycocel and Alar; Carvalho et al. [54] by applying Pix and Cycocel; Abdel-Al [50], by applying Pix. Zinc significantly increased seed index compared with the untreated control [35]. In this connection Ibrahim et al. [13] noted that seed weight increased due to the application of Zn.
Seed oil content was unchanged with increased as N-rate. Oil yield ha−1 significantly (32.9 kg·ha−1), which is attributed to the increase in seed yield (Table 3) [35]. Pandrangi et al. [55] applied N at a rate of 25 or 50 kg·ha−1 to cotton plants and found that the percentage of seed oil content decreased but oil yield increased with increasing N rate. Application of all growth retardants resulted in an insignificant increase in seed oil content above the control and also significantly increased the oil yield ha−1 over the control (29.3 - 45.2 kg oil ha−1), with the clearest effect from Pix (45.2 kg·ha−1), followed by Cycocel (39.8 kg·ha−1) [35]. Sawan et al. [56] indicated that a slight increase in cottonseed oil content was detected with Pix application at rate ranging 10 - 100 ppm. Pix was sprayed once (90 D) or twice (90 and 110 days after planting). Oil yield also increased due to Pix application compared with the control. Similar results were obtained by Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14]. Sawan et al. [52] observed that application of Cycocel and Alar (250 - 750 ppm, 105 days after planting) increased oil yield ha−1. Application of Zn resulted in an insignificant increase in seed oil content over that of the control. The seed oil yield was also increased (34.7 kg oil ha−1) compared with the untreated control [35]. These results could be attributed to the increase of total photoassimilates (e.g. lipids) and the translocated assimilates to the sink as a result of applying Zn nutrient. Sawan et al. [57] found that oil yield increased by the application of Zn to cotton plants at a rate of 12 g Zn ha−1. Zinc was sprayed three times, i.e., 70, 85, and 100 d after sowing. Prabhuraj et al. [58] found that applying Zn at 5 ppm rate increased seed and oil yields of sunflower. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13] on cotton; Bybordi and Mamedov [59] on canola.
High N rate significantly increased the seed protein content and yield ha−1 (49.6 kg protein ha−1) (Table 3) [35]. According to Sugiyama et al. [60], soluble proteins are increased with better N supply and favorable growth condition. These results suggest that the high N-rate increases the amino acids synthesis in the leaves, and this stimulates the accumulation of protein in the seed rather than oil content. Patil et al. [5] found that N application (50 kg·N·ha−1) increased the seed protein content. Seed protein content and yield ha−1 were increased insignificantly in plants in plants treated with the three growth retardants (35.4 - 55.9 kg protein ha−1) compared with the untreated control. Highest protein content was produced by Pix application, followed by Alar, while the highest seed protein yield was obtained with Pix (55.9 kg·ha−1), and followed by Cycocel (46.7 kg·ha−1) [35]. Hedin et al. [61] found that Cycocel increased protein content by 17% - 50% in leaves and squares harvested 4 wk after the first application. Kar et al. [62] in safflower showed that Cycocel and Alar maintained the level of chlorophyll, protein, and RNA contents. Also, the increase in seed protein content may be caused by the role of Pix in protein synthesis, encouraging the conversion of amino acids into protein [63]. Sawan et al. [56]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14] stated that cottonseed protein content and yield ha−1 increased due to the application of Pix. Kler et al. [64] found that when cotton was sprayed using Cycocel rates of 40, 60, or 80 ppm at the age 63 days after planting, seed protein content increased. Sawan et al. [52] stated that application of Cycocel or Alar increased seed protein content and protein yield ha−1. Application of zinc increased insignificantly the seed protein content and significantly increased protein yield ha−1 (41.6 kg protein ha−1) over the untreated control [35]. In these circumstances Ibrahim et al. [13] found that application of Zn to cotton plants increased seed protein content and protein yield ha−1.
The seed oil refractive index and unsaponifiable matter tended to increase insignificantly, while the oil acid value and saponification value tended to decrease by raising N-rate (Table 4) [35]. The increase in unsaponifiable matter is beneficial as it increases the oil stability. Sawan et al. [57] applied N to cotton plants at rates of 108 and 216 kg·ha−1 and found that oil unsaponifiable matter tended to increase, while saponification value tended to decrease by raising N-rate. Application of all PGR significantly increased the oil refractive index. However, unsaponifiable matter was insignificantly increased, whereas acid value and saponification value tended to decrease insignificantly as compared with the untreated control [35]. Applied Cycocel gave the highest refractive index and the lowest acid value, while Pix gave the highest unsaponifiable matter. Also, applied Alar gave the lowest saponification value. Sawan et al. [32] stated that application of Cycocel and Alar to cotton plants increased oil refractive index and unsaponifiable matter and decreased oil acid value and saponification value. Osman and Abu-Lila [65] found a negligible variation in refractive index of flax oil when the plants were treated with Cycocel at the application rates of 25 - 100 ppm twice; the first one 20 d after sowing and the second spray 2 months later. The oil refractive index and unsaponifiable matter tended to increase insignificantly, while acid value and saponification value decreased insignificantly by applied zinc compared with control [35]. Sawan et al. [57] found that application of Zn to cotton plants exhibited negligible effect upon oil-quality characters, i.e., refractive index, oil acid value, unsaponifiable matter, and saponification value.
The oil saturated fatty acids (capric, myristic, palmitic and stearic) decreased insignificantly, while lauric acid increased insignificantly in response to raising the N-rate
Table 4. Effect of N rate and foliar application of plant growth retardants and Zn on seed oil propertiesa.
(Table 5) [35]. Palmitic acid was the dominant saturated fatty acid. Low content of saturated fatty acids is desirable for edible uses. Application of the three PGR’s resulted in a decrease in the total saturated fatty acids compared with the untreated control. The decrease was significant with the Cycocel and Alar treatments. Cycocel gave the lowest total saturated fatty acids in oil contents, followed by Alar and also tended to increase insignificantly the saturated fatty acid capric acid compared with the untreated control. Applied Pix gave the highest capric and the lowest stearic acid content, while applied Cycocel gave the lowest lauric acid content. Alar application tended to give the lowest myristic and palmitic acids contents compared with control. Application of Zn resulted in a significant decrease in the total saturated fatty acids (capric, palmitic and stearic) while it resulted in an increase in the lauric and myristic saturated fatty acids, compared with untreated plants [35].
The total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) and the ratio between total unsaturated fatty acids and total saturated fatty acids (TU/TS) increased insignificantly (3.53 and 15.93%, respectively) by raising N-rate (Table 6) [35]. Linoleic acid was the most abundant of the unsaturated fatty acids. Kheir et al. [7] found that the higher N-rate increased the percentage of unsaturated fatty acids and decreased saturated fatty acids of flax oil. All PGR’s increased the total unsaturated fatty acids and TU/TS ratio, compared with the control. The increase was significant by the application of Cycocel and Alar. Applied Cycocel gave the highest linoleic acid content, total unsaturated fatty acids (10.64%), and TU/TS ratio (51.0%), and followed by Alar (10.02 and 47.01%, respectively) [35]. The increase in TU/TS as a result of the application of the three PGR may be attributed to their encouraging effects on enzymes that catalyzed the biosynthesis of the unsaturated fatty acids. Spraying plants with Zn significantly increased the total unsaturated fatty acids (7.4%) and TU/TS ratio (35.04%), compared with untreated control [35]. Sawan et al. [56] reported that applying Pix to cotton plants caused a general decrease in oil saturated fatty acids, associated with an increase in oil unsaturated fatty acids. Sawan et al. [52] stated that application of Cycocel and Alar to cotton increased oil unsaturated fatty acids. Osman and Abu-Lila [65] when applied Cycocel at rates of 25 - 100 ppm to flax plants found that generally the higher concentrations (50 and 100 ppm) caused in the total oil saturated fatty acids, while they increased the unsaturated fatty acids.
3.1.2. Effect of P, Zn and Ca on Cottonseed, Protein and Oil Yields and Oil Properties
Seed yield ha−1 was significantly increased (11.24%) when phosphorus was applied at the highest rate (Table 7) [36]. Phosphorus as a constituent of cell nuclei is essential for cell division and development of meristematic tissue, and hence it should have a stimulating effect on the plants, increasing the number of flowers and bolls per plant. Further, P has a well known impact in photosynthesis as well as synthesis of nucleic acids, proteins, lipids and other essential compounds [66], all of which are major factors affecting boll weight and consequently cottonseed. These results are confirmed by those of Abdel-Malak et al. [45]; Ibrahim et al. [13]; Saleem et al. [67]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [60]. Application of Zn significantly increased cottonseed yield ha−1 (8.61%), as compared with the untreated control [36]. This may be
Table 5. Effect of N rate and foliar application of plant growth retardants and Zn on the relative percentage of saturated fatty acidsa.
Table 6. Effect of N rate and foliar application of plant growth retardants and Zn on the relative percentage of unsaturated fatty acidsa.
Table 7. Effect of P rate and foliar application of Zn and Ca on cottonseed yield, seed index, seed oil, seed protein, oil and protein yields.
due to its favorable effect on photosynthetic activity, which improves mobilization of photosynthates and directly influences of boll weight [68]. Also, Zn enhances the activity of tryptophan synthesis, which is involved in the synthesis of the growth control compound IAA, the major hormone that inhibits abscission of squares and bolls. The application of Zn increased the number of retained bolls plant−1. Similar results were obtained by Zeng [53]; Ibrahim et al. [13] on cotton; Bybordi and Mamedov [59] on canola. Calcium application also significantly increased seed yield (7.06% - 12.16%), as yields resulting from the three concentrations applied exceeded the control. In general, it can be stated that the highest Ca concentration (60 ppm) was more effective than the other two concentrations (20 or 40 ppm) [36]. The role of Ca in increasing seed yield can possibly be ascribed to its involvement in the process of photosynthesis and the translocation of carbohydrates to young bolls. Calcium deficiency depressed the rate of photosynthesis (rate of CO2 fixation). Guinn [66] stated that Ca deficiency would cause carbohydrates to accumulate in leaves and not in young bolls. The results obtained agree with those reported by Shui and Meng [69]; Wright et al. [70].
The application of P at the rate of 74 kg P2O5 ha−1 significantly increased seed index (weight of 100 seed in g) relative to the application at 44 kg P2O5 ha−1 (Table 7) [36]. A possible explanation for increased seed weight due to the application of P at the higher rate is that this nutrient activated biological reactions in the cotton plants, particularly CO2 fixation and the synthesis of sugar, amino acids, protein, lipids and other organic compounds. It also increased the translocation of assimilates from photosynthetic organs to the sink [71]. Similar results were obtained by El-Debaby et al. [72]. Application of Zn significantly increased seed index, compared to the control [36]. This may be due to its favorable effect on photosynthetic activity. Zinc improves mobilization of photosynthates and directly influences boll weight that coincide directly with increased seed index. These results are confirmed by those obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]. Calcium applied at all rates significantly increased seed index over the control [36]. The highest rate of Ca (60 ppm) showed the highest numerical value of seed index. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13].
Raising the phosphorus rate increased seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 (Table 7) [36]. This may be attributed to the fact that P is required for production of high quality seed, since it occurs in coenzymes involved in energy transfer reactions. Energy is tapped in photosynthesis in the form of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADP). This energy is then used in photosynthetic fixation of CO2 and in the synthesis of lipids and other essential organic compounds [8]. These results agree with those obtained by Pandrangi et al. [55]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14]. Spraying plants with zinc resulted in an increase of seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 when compared with the untreated control [36]. This could be attributed to the increase of total photo assimilates (e.g. lipids) and the translocated assimilates to the sink as a result of applying zinc. Similar results were reached by Ibrahim et al. [13]. Application of Ca at all concentration tended to increase the seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 over the control; the best result was from the highest Ca concentration (60 ppm) [36]. These results agreed with those obtained by Bora [73] on rape; Ibrahim et al. [13] on cotton; Bybordi and Mamedov [59] on canola. A possible role of Ca as an activator of the enzyme phospholipase in cabbage leaves has been investigated by Davidson and Long [74].
Applying P at the higher rate slightly increased seed protein content (Table 7) [36]. It also increased the protein yield ha−1, resulting from an improvement in both seed yield and seed protein content. Phosphorus is a component of nucleic acids which are necessary for protein synthesis [66]. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14] in cotton. The application of Zn increased the seed protein content and protein yield ha−1, compared with the untreated control [36]. Shchitaeva [75] found that the synthesis of metabolically active amino acids depends on Zn, which increases the synthesis of asparagine and tryptophan. These results agree with studies reported by Ibrahim et al. [13]. Calcium applied at all rates tended to decrease the seed protein content slightly, but protein yield ha−1 increased compared with the untreated control, which is attributed to the increase in cottonseed yield. The best protein yield was obtained at the highest Ca concentration (60 ppm) [36].
The oil refractive index and unsaponifiable matter tended to increase, while the acid value and saponification value tended to decrease as phosphorus rate was raised (Table 8) [36]. The increase in unsaponifiable matter is known to be beneficial, as it increases oil stability. Spraying plants with Zn resulted in a slight increase in the oil refractive index and unsaponifiable matter and a slight decrease in acid value and saponification value, compared with the untreated control [36]. Similar results were obtained by Sawan et al. [57] concerning the effect of applied Zn on oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter and saponification value. Application of Ca at any concentration tended to decrease the oil acid value and saponification value and to increase the unsaponifiable matter, especially as the applied Ca concentration increased, compared with the untreated control [36]. This became especially apparent as the applied calcium concentration was increased. The effect of Ca concentrations on oil refractive index was very limited and without a defined trend. These results are in agreement with those reported by Sawan et al. [57] concerning the effect of applied Ca on oil refractive index, saponification value and unsaponifiable matter. The studied oil quality characters seemed to be genetically controlled.
The high rate of applied P decreased the oil saturated fatty acids capric, myristic, palmitic and stearic, while it increased lauric acid (Table 9). The total saturated fatty acids also decreased. Palmitic acid was the predominant saturated fatty acid. Low content of saturated fatty acids is desirable for edible uses [36]. The application of Zn decreased the abundant saturated fatty acids palmitic and myristic, while it increased capric, lauric and stearic saturated fatty acids, compared to the control. The total
Table 8. Effect of P rate and foliar application of Zn and Ca on seed oil propertiesa.
Table 9. Effect of P rate and foliar application of Zn and Ca on the relative percentage of saturated fatty acidsa.
saturated fatty acids decreased [36]. Calcium applied at all concentrations decreased in the saturated fatty acids capric, lauric, myristic, palmitic and stearica as well as the saturated fatty acids compared with the untreated control with one exception [36]. Spraying plants with Ca at 60 ppm tended to increase stearic acid, compared with the control. Applied Ca at 40 ppm gave the lowest capric, lauric, palmitic and stearic acids contents, compared with the other two concentrations (20 and 60 ppm). Calcium at 20 ppm gave the lowest myristic acid content, compared with 40 and 60 ppm. The total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) and the ratio between total unsaturated fatty acids and total saturated fatty acids (TU/TS) were increased by raising P rate (Table 10). Linoleic acid was the most abundant unsaturated fatty acid. Gushevilov and Palaveeva [76] studied the changes in sunflower oil contents of linoleic, oleic, stearic and palmitic acids due to application rate of phosphorus and found that oil quality remained high at a high P rate. The application of Zn resulted in an increase in total unsaturated fatty acids and TU/TS ratio, over the control [36]. Calcium applied at all rates increased the total unsaturated fatty acid and TU/TS ratio, compared with untreated control. Calcium at 40 ppm gave the highest increment, total unsaturated fatty acid and TU/TS ratio, followed by 60 ppm concentration. Spraying plants with Ca at 20 ppm produced seed oil characterized by the highest oleic acid content, while spraying with 40 ppm gave the highest linoleic acid content, compared with the other concentrations [36].
3.1.3. Cottonseed, Protein, Oil Yields, and Oil Properties as Influenced by K, P and Zn
Seed yield ha−1 significantly increased when K was applied (by as much as 13.99%) (Table 11) [1]. Potassium would have a favorable impact on yield components, including a number of open bolls plant−1 and boll weight, leading to a higher cotton yield. The role of K suggests that it affects abscission (reduced boll shedding) and it certainly affects yield [53]. Gormus [17]; Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly [77] also found that K application increased yield. Application of Zn significantly increased seed yield ha−1, as compared with the untreated control (by 9.38%) [1]. A possible explanation of such results
Table 10. Effect of P rate and foliar application of Zn and Ca on the relative percentage of unsaturated fatty acidsa.
Table 11. Effect of K rate and foliar application of Zn and foliar, additional P on cottonseed yield, seed index, seed oil, seed protein, oil and protein yields.
might be the improvement of yield components due to the application of Zn. Zinc could have a favorable effect on photosynthetic activity of leaves [22], which improves mobilization of photosynthates and directly influences boll weight. Further, Zn is required in the synthesis of tryptophan, a precursor of indole-3-acetic acid [23], which is the major hormone, inhibits abscission of squares and bolls. Thus the number of retained bolls plant−1 and consequently seed yield ha−1 would be increased [24]. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]. Phosphorus extra foliar application at all the three concentrations (576, 1152 and 1728 g of P ha−1) also significantly increased seed yield ha−1, where the three concentrations applied proved to excel the control (by 9.49% - 17.12%). The best yield was obtained at the highest P concentration tested [1]. Such results reflect the pronounced improvement of yield components due to application of P which is possibly ascribed to its involvement in photosynthesis and translocation of carbohydrates to young bolls [9]. Phosphorus as a constituent of cell nucleus is essential for cell division and the development of meristematic tissue and hence it would have a stimulating effect on increasing the number of flowers and bolls plant−1 [78]. These results agree with that reported by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Saleem et al. [67]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
Seed index significantly increased with applying K (Table 11) [1]. A possible explanation for the increased seed index due to the application of K may be due in part to its favorable effects on photosynthetic activity rate of crop leaves and CO2 assimilation [15], which improves mobilization of photosynthates and directly influences boll weight which in turn directly affects seed weight [79]. The application of Zn significantly increased seed index, as compared to control [1]. The increased seed weight might be due to an increased photosynthesis activity resulting from the application of Zn [22] which improves mobilization of photosynthates and the amount of photosynthate available for reproductive sinks and thereby influences boll weight, factors that coincide with increased in seed weight [24]. The phosphorus applied at all three rates significantly increased seed index over the control. The highest rate of P (1728 g·ha−1) showed the highest numerical value of seed index [1]. This increased seed weight may be due to the fact that P activated the biological reaction in cotton plant, particularly photosynthesis fixation of CO2 and synthesis of sugar, and other organic compounds [22,80]. This indicates that treated cotton bolls had larger photosynthetically supplied sinks for carbohydrates and other metabolites than untreated bolls [1].
The applied K caused significant increase in seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 (55.7 kg oil ha−1), compared with untreated control (Table 11) [1]. This could be attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants. Potassium increases the photosynthetic rates of crop leaves, CO2 assimilation and facilitates carbon movement [15]. The favorable effects of K on seed oil content and oil yield were mentioned by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly [77]. Spraying plants with Zn resulted in an increase in seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 (38.2 kg oil ha−1), compared with the untreated control. Cakmak [81] has speculated that Zn deficiency stress may inhibit some antioxidant enzymes, resulting in extensive oxidative damage to membrane lipids. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]. The foliar application of P at all the three concentrations tended to increase the seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 (34.6 - 64.0 kg oil ha−1), over the control [1]. The effect was the most significant at the highest P concentration (1728 g·ha−1) on oil yield ha−1. These results agree with those obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
The applied K caused a slight increase in seed protein content and significantly increased protein yield ha−1 (57.5 kg protein ha−1), compared with the untreated control (Table 11) [1]. It also increased the protein yield ha−1, resulting in an improvement in both seed yield and seed protein content. This could be attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants. Potassium increases the photosynthetic rates of crop leaves, CO2 assimilation and facilitates carbon movement [15]. Also, K has favorable effects on metabolism of nucleic acids, and proteins [82]. These are manifested in metabolites formed in plant tissues and directly influence the growth and development processes. Similar results were obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly [77]. The application of Zn slightly increased the seed protein content, and increased protein yield ha−1 (39.3 kg protein ha−1) numerically compared with the untreated control. Because Zn is directly involved in both gene expression and protein synthesis. Cakmak [81] has speculated that Zn deficiency stress may inhibit the activities of a number of antioxidant enzymes, resulting in extensive oxidative damage to proteins, chlorophyll and nucleic acids. These results agree with those reported by Ghourab et al. [79]. Phosphorus applied at all rates tended to increase the seed protein content and the protein yield ha−1 (37.9-68.5 kg protein ha−1) compared with the untreated control [1]. The effect was significant on protein yield ha−1 when applied the high P concentration (1728 g·ha−1), resulting from an improvement in both seed yield and seed protein content. Phosphorus is a component of nucleic acids, which are necessary for protein synthesis [8]. Similar results were obtained by Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
The oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter and iodine value significantly increased, while saponification value significantly decreased by applied K, compared with the untreated control (Table 12) [1]. On the other
Table 12. Effect of K rate and foliar application of Zn and foliar, additional P on seed oil propertiesa.
hand, the acid value was not significantly affected due to the K application. Potassium is an essential nutrient and an integral component of several important compounds in plant cells. This attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants [83]. These may be reflected in distinct changes in seed oil quality. Mekki et al. [84] stated that, foliar application with K (0 or 3.5% K2O) on sunflower at the seed-filling stage resulted in decreased oil acid content. Froment et al. [85], in linseed, found that the iodine value, which indicates the degree of unsaturation in the final oil, was highest in treatments receiving extra K. Spraying plants with Zn resulted in a significant increase in oil refractive index, and a significant decrease in unsaponifiable matter, compared with untreated control. The other oil properties (acid, saponification, and iodine values) were not significantly affected. Zinc activates a large number of enzymes, either due to binding enzymes and substrates, or the effects of Zn on conformation of enzymes or substrate, or both [86,87]. These would have a direct impact through utilization in the growth processes, which are reflected in distinct changes in seed oil quality [1]. The application of P at all concentrations significantly increased iodine value, compared with the untreated control, while the other oil properties (oil refractive index; acid and saponification values, and the unsaponifiable matter) were not significantly affected.
The applied K decreased the oil-saturated fatty acids (capric, lauric, myristic, palmitic, and stearic) (Table 13) [1]. A significant effect was found only on capric, palmitic, and the total saturated fatty acids. The total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) and the ratio between total unsaturated fatty acids and total saturated fatty acids (TU/TS) were increased (by 4.31, and 19.77%, respectively) by applied K (Table 14) [1]. The effect was significant on linoleic acid, the total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic), and TU/TS ratio. The beneficial effect of applied K on TU and TU/TS ratio may be due to the regulated effect of K, which acts as an activator on many enzymatic processes, where some of these enzymes may affect the seed oil content from these organic matters. To our knowledge, no information on the effect of K on the cottonseed oil fatty acids is available in the literatures [1]. Mekki et al. [84] stated that, foliar application with K on sunflower increased the oleic acid fatty acid. Froment et al. [85], in linseed oil, found that the linoleic acid content was greatest in treatment receiving extra K. The application of Zn resulted in a decrease of the saturated fatty acids, i.e. palmitic, capric, myristic, and stearic, and the total, but resulted in an increase in lauric acid, compared to the untreated control [1]. The effect was significant only on palmitic acid, and the total saturated fatty acids in the oil. The application of Zn resulted in an increase in the total unsaturated fatty acids (by 3.49%) and TU/TS ratio (by 15.25%), over the control. The effect was significant on oleic acid, the total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic), and TU/TS ratio. The stimulatory residual effects of the application Zn on TU and TU/TS ratio were probably due to the favorable effects of Zn on fundamental metabolic reactions in plant tissues. Phosphorus applied at all concentrations resulted in a decrease in the total saturated fatty acids compared with the untreated control. Spraying plants with P at 1728 g·ha−1 gave the lowest total saturated fatty acids oil, followed by P at 1152 g·ha−1 concentration, compared with the control [1]. Application the high P concentration (1728 g·ha−1) gave the lowest capric, lauric, palmitic, and stearic acid contents compared with the
Table 13. Effect of K rate and foliar application of Zn and foliar, additional P on the relative percentage of saturated fatty acidsa.
Table 14. Effect of K rate and foliar application of Zn and foliar, additional P on the relative percentage of unsaturated fatty acidsa.
other two concentrations (576 and 1152 g of P ha−1), while applied P at 1152 g·ha−1 gave the lowest myristic acid content compared with the other two concentrations (576 and 1728 g of P ha−1). The effect was significant for the two concentrations1152 and 1728 g of P ha−1 on capric acid and the total saturated fatty acids in the oil, and for all different P concentrations on lauric, myristic, and stearic. Phosphorus applied at all rates increased the total unsaturated fatty acid (by 4.77% - 5.75%) and TU/TS ratio (by 20.91% - 26.03%) compared with the untreated control. Applied P at 1728 g·ha−1 gave the highest increment, followed by the concentration 1152 g of P ha−1 [1]. Spraying plants with P at 1728 g·ha−1 produced seed oil characterized by the highest oleic acid content, while spraying with 576 g of P ha−1 gave the highest linoleic acid content compared with the other concentrations. The effect was significant for the high P concentration (1728 g·ha−1) on oleic, for the two concentrations, i.e., 1152 and 1728 g of P ha−1 on the TU/TS ratio, and for all different concentrations on linoleic, and the total unsaturated fatty acid [1]. The beneficial effect of applied P at different concentrations on TU and TU/TS ratio may be due to the regulated effect of P on many enzymatic processes and the fact that P acts as an activator of some enzymes which may affect the seed oil fatty acids composition. Gushevilov and Palaveeva [76] studied the changes in the contents of linoleic, oleic, stearic, and palmitic acids in sunflower oil due to the P-application rate and found that oil quality remained high at a high P-rate. Khan et al. [88] indicated that oleic acid increased by increasing levels of P added to rapeseed mustard.
3.1.4. Effects N, K and PGR on Oil Content and Quality of Cotton Seed
The seed yield of cotton significantly (P < 0.05) increased (as much as 13.03%) by increasing N-application rate from 95.2 to 142.8 kg·ha−1 (Table 15) [37]. There is an optimal relationship between the nitrogen content in the plant and CO2 assimilation, where decreases in CO2 fixation are well documented for N-deficient plants. Nitrogen deficiency is associated with elevated levels of ethylene (which increase boll shedding), suggesting ethylene production in response to N-deficiency stress [89]. Nitrogen is also an essential nutrient in creating plant dry matter, as well as many energy-rich compounds which regulate photosynthesis and plant production, thus influencing boll development, increasing the number of bolls per plant and boll weight. Similar findings were obtained by McConnell and Mozaffari [90] and Saleem et al. [46] when N fertilizer was applied at 120 kg·ha−1 and Wiatrak et al. [80] when N fertilizer was applied at 67 - 202 kg·ha−1. Also, similar results were obtained by Sarwar Cheema et al. [33]; Hamed et al. [47]. On the other hand Boquet (2005) reported that increasing N from 90 to 157 kg·ha−1 did not result in increased cotton yield in irrigated or rain-fed cotton. Foliar application of K significantly increased seed yield by 10.02% to 16.25% as compared to the control (0 g·K·ha−1) (Table 15) [37]. The differences between the effects of the three concerned K rates were statistically insignificant; with the exception of the 957 g·K·ha−1 concentration that proved to produce significantly higher seed yield ha−1 (5.66%) than the 319 g·K·ha−1 concentration. These increases could be due to the favorable effects of this nutrient on yield components such as number of opened bolls plant−1, boll weight, or both, leading to higher cotton yield. Zeng [53] indicated that, K fertilizer reduced boll shedding. Pettigrew [91] stated that, the elevated carbohydrate concentrations remaining in source tissue, such as leaves, appear to be part of the overall effect of K deficiency in reducing the amount of photosynthate available for reproductive sinks and thereby producing changes in boll weight. Cakmak et al. [92] found that, the K nutrition had pronounced effects on carbohydrate partitioning by affecting either the phloem export of photosynthates (sucrose) or growth rate of sink and/or source organs. Mullins et al. [93] evaluated cotton yield under a long-term soil application of K at 75 - 225 kg K2O ha−1, and found that K application increased yield. Results obtained here confirmed those obtained by Aneela et al. [18] when applying 200 kg K2O ha−1, Pervez et al. [19] under 62.5, 125, 250 kg·K·ha·ha−1, Pettigrew et al. [20] under K
Table 15. Effect of soil application of N and foliar application of K and mepiquat chloride (MC) on the yield, 100-seed weight, oil and protein of the cotton.
fertilizer (112 kg·ha−1); Gebaly [77]. Application of the PGR mepiquat chloride significantly increased seed yield ha−1 (by 9.72%), as compared with untreated plants. Such increases could be due to the fact that, the application of mepiquat chloride restrict vegetative growth and thus enhance reproductive organs by allowing plants to direct more energy towards the reproductive structure [51]. This means that bolls on treated cotton would have a larger photo synthetically supplied sink of carbohydrates and other metabolites than did those on untreated cotton [30]. Results agreed with those obtained by Prakash et al. [94] when mepiquat chloride was applied at 50 ppm, Mekki [95] when mepiquat chloride was applied at 100 ppm, and Kumar et al. [31]. Also, similar results were obtained by Sarwar Cheema et al. [33]; Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
Seed weight significantly increased by adding the high N-rate (Table 15) [37]. This may be due to increased photosynthetic activity that increases accumulation of metabolites, with direct impact on seed weight. Reddy et al. [2], in a pot experiment under natural environmental conditions, where 20-day old cotton plants received 0, 0.5, 1.5 or 6 mM NO3, found that, net photosynthetic rates, stomatal conductance and transpiration were positively correlated with leaf N concentration. Similar findings were reported by Palomo et al. [96], when N was applied at 40 - 200 kg·ha−1; Ali and El-Sayed [97], when N was applied at 95 to 190 kg·ha−1; Hamed et al. [47] when N was applied up to 178 kg·ha−1. 100-seed weight significantly increased with K application at all the three concentrations as compared to the control [37]. The highest rate of K (957 g·K·ha−1) resulted the highest seed weight. The difference between the high rate and low rate (319 g·K·ha−1) was also significant. Increase in seed weight might be due to the effect of K on mobilization of photosynthates, which would directly influence boll weight and increase seed weight [38,91]. Ibrahim et al. [13] reported that, the application of K fertilizer resulted in an increase in seed weight. The application of mepiquat chloride significantly increased 100-seed weight as compared to the plots that had not received mepiquat chloride, the untreated control [37]. Increased seed weight as a result of mepiquat chloride applications may be due to an increase in photosynthetic activity, which stimulates photosynthetic activity, and dry matter accumulation [31,82], and in turn increases the formation of fully-mature seed and thus increases seed weight. Similar results to the present study were obtained by Ghourab et al. [79]; Lamas [98].
Seed oil content was slightly decreased with an increase in the N rate from 95.2 to 142.8 kg·ha−1, but seed oil yield ha−1 had significantly increased (45.5 kg oil ha−1), which is attributed to the significant increase in seed yield (Table 15) [37]. Similar results were obtained by Froment et al. [85], in linseed; Zubillaga et al. [99] in sunflower. Yield increases in this study were attributed to the fact that N was an important nutrient in controlling new growth, thus influencing boll development, increasing the number of bolls plant−1 and boll weight. Synthesis of fat requires both N and carbon skeletons during the course of seed development [5]. The application of K at all the three concentrations tended to increase seed oil content and yield over the control (37.7 - 64.2 kg oil ha−1), but was statistically significant only for 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 concentrations on the seed oil content, and with K application at all the three concentrations on the oil yield ha−1 [37]. The highest rate of K (957 g·K·ha−1) showed the highest numerical values of seed oil content and oil yield ha−1 compared with the other two concentrations (319 and 638 g·K·ha−1) [37]. This could be attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants. Pettigrew [91] stated that, the elevated carbohydrate concentrations remaining in source tissue, such as leaves, appear to be part of the overall effect of K deficiency in reducing the amount of photosynthate available for reproductive sinks and thereby producing changes in yield and quality found in cotton. Madraimov [100] indicated that, increasing the rates of applied K2O from 0 to 150 kg·ha−1 produced linear increases in cottonseed oil contents. Previously, favorable effects of K on seed oil content and oil yield were mentioned by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly [77]. They reported that, increasing K supply to maternal cotton plants increased crude fat content of seed. The application of mepiquat chloride resulted in an insignificant increase in seed oil content over that of the control [37]. Also significantly increased the seed oil yield ha−1 compared with the untreated control (by 38.3 kg oil ha−1). These results could be attributed to the increase of total photoassimilates (e.g. lipids) and the translocated assimilates to the sink as a result of applying mepiquat chloride [101]. This result agreed with those obtained by Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
High N-rate significantly increased the seed protein content and yields (58.0 kg protein ha−1) (Table 15) [37]. Stitt [102] indicated that, nitrate () induces genes involved in different aspects of carbon metabolism, including the synthesis of organic acids used for amino acid synthesis. These results suggest that the highest N rate of the added N in this study compared with the lowest rate increases the amino acids synthesis in the leaves and this stimulate the accumulation of protein in the seed. The present results confirmed the findings of Patil et al. [34]. Averaged seed protein content tended to increase when applying 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 compared with untreated control (0 g·K·ha−1) [37]. Applied K at all rates also, increased the protein yield numerically (40.2 - 66.4 kg protein ha−1), resulting from an improvement in both seed yield and seed protein content. The increase in protein yield ha−1 was statistically significant when applying the 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 concentrations. Best protein yield was obtained at the high K concentration (957 g·K·ha−1) compared with the other two concentrations (319 and 638 g·K·ha−1) [37]. This could be attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants. Potassium has favorable effects on metabolism of nucleic acids and proteins [82]. These are manifested in metabolites formed in plant tissues, and directly influence the growth and development processes, thereby producing changes in yield and quality of cotton [37]. These results were in agreement with those obtained by Ibrahim et al. [13]; Gebaly [77]. Seed protein content tended to increase numerically, while seed protein yield was significantly increased (42.3 kg protein ha−1) in plants treated with mepiquat chloride as compared with the untreated plants. The increase in seed protein content and yield may be caused by the role of mepiquat chloride in protein synthesis, encouraging the conversion of amino acids into protein [62] along with the favorable and significant effect of mepiquat chloride on cottonseed yield. These results were confirmed by Gebaly and El-Gabiery [14].
The seed oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter and iodine value tended to increase, while the oil saponification and acid values tended to decrease by raising N-rate (Table 16) [37]. Narang et al. [103] indicated that, N application increased the oil-quality index (iodine number) in rape. The application of K at different concentrations tended to increase the seed oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter and iodine value, and to decrease the oil saponification value and acid value, numerically, compared with the untreated control, especially when applied K at the high concentration (957 g·K·ha−1) [37]. The effect was significant for the two concentrations 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 on acid value, and unsaponifiable matter, and for all different concentrations on iodine value. The effect of K concentrations on oil refractive index was very limited. Potassium is an essential nutrient and an integral component of several important compounds in plant cells. This attributed to the role of K in biochemical pathways in plants, where K acts as an activator for several enzymes involved in carbohydrates metabolism [8]. These may be reflected in distinct changes in seed oil quality [37]. Mekki et al. [84] stated that, foliar application with K (0 or 3.5% K2O) on sunflower at the seed-filling stage, decreased oil acid value. Froment et al. [85], when working with linseed found that, the iodine value, which indicates the degree of unsaturation of the final oil, was highest in treatment receiving extra K. The application of mepiquat chloride tended to significantly increase the oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter and iodine value, while it tended to insignificantly decrease the oil acid value and saponification value, compared with the untreated control [37]. The application of plant growth regulators, particularly growth retardants may maintain internal hormonal balance, and efficient sink source relationship. This may be reflected in distinct changes in seed oil quality.
Saturated fatty acids in oil, lauric, myristic, palmitic and their total decreased, while capric and stearic increased by raising the N-rate (Table 17) [37]. The effect was significant only on palmitic acid, which was the dominant saturated fatty acid. A low content of saturated fatty acids is desirable for edible. The total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) and the ratio between total unsaturated fatty acids and total saturated fatty acids (TU/TS) were increased (by 2.42, and 10.69%, respectively) by raising N-rate (Table 18) [37]. The effect was significant only on oleic acid. Linoleic acid was the most
Table 16. Effect of N rate and foliar application of K and mepiquat chloride (MC) on seed oil propertiesa.
Table 17. Effect of N rate and foliar application of K and mepiquat chloride (MC) on the relative percentage of saturated fatty acidsa.
Table 18. Effect of N rate and foliar application of K and mepiquat chloride (MC) on the relative percentage of unsaturated fatty acidsa.
abundant unsaturated fatty acid. Holmes and Bennett [104] commented that, the fatty acid composition of rape oil is mainly under genetic control, but can be modified to some extent by N nutrition. Seo et al. [105] found that, when sesame was given 0 to 160 kg N, oleic acid content was highest at the highest N rates and linoleic acid content was highest at the intermediate rates. Khan et al. [88] indicated that, oleic acid increased by increasing levels of N added to rapeseed-mustard. Kheir et al. [7], in flax, found that the higher N-rate increased the percentage of unsaturated fatty acids and decreased saturated fatty acids in the seed oil. Potassium applied at all concentrations resulted in a decrease in the total saturated fatty acids (capric, lauric, myristic, palmitic and stearic) compared with the untreated control (Table 17) [37]. Spraying plants with the high K concentration 957 g·K·ha−1 gave the lowest total saturated fatty acids oil, compared with the other two concentrations (638 and 957 g·K·ha−1). The effect was significant for the two concentrations 638 and 957 g·K·ha−1 on capric, and palmitic, and for all different concentrations on lauric, myristic, stearic, and the total saturated fatty acids. Potassium applied at all rates increased the total unsaturated fatty acid (oleic and linoleic) and TU/TS ratio (by 1.84 - 4.48, and 15.70% - 26.27%, respectively), compared with untreated control (Table 18) [37]. Applied K at 957 g·ha−1 gave the highest increment, followed by 638 g·ha−1 concentration. The effect was significant for all different concentrations on linoleic, the total unsaturated fatty acid and TU/TS ratio [37]. Linoleic acid was the most abundant unsaturated fatty acid. The beneficial effect of applied K on TU and TU/TS ratio suggests that it might be due to the regulated effect of K which acts as an activator on many enzymic processes, where some of these enzymes may affect the seed oil content from these organic matters. Seo et al. [105] found that, when sesame was given 0 to180 kg K2O, oleic acid content was the highest at the highest K rates and linoleic acid content was the highest at the intermediate rates. Salama [106] indicated that, K fertilizer applied to sunflower, favored fatty acid composition (high oleic acid content). Mekki et al. [84] stated that, foliar application with K on sunflower increased the oleic acid fatty acid. Froment et al. [85] found that, linoleic acid content was greatest in linseed oil in treatments receiving extra K. The application of MC resulted in a decrease in the total saturated fatty acids, the abundant saturated fatty acid palmitic, capric, myristic, and stearic, while it resulted in an increase in lauric saturated fatty acid, compared to the untreated control (Table 17) [37]. The effect was significant only on capric, palmitic, stearic and the total. The application of mepiquat chloride resulted in an increase in total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) and TU/TS ratio (by 3.69, and 16.69%, respectively), over the control (Table 18). The effect was significant only on the total unsaturated fatty acid, oleic and TU/TS ratio [37]. The stimulatory residual effects of the application mepiquat chloride on TU and TU/TS ratio was probably due to its favorable effects on fundamental metabolic reactions in plant tissues, and would have direct impact through utilization on growth processes, which are reflected in distinct changes in seed oil quality [37]. Some of these changes may affect the seed oil fatty acids composition, which may attribute to their encouraging effects on enzymes that catalyzed the biosynthesis of unsaturated fatty acids. Mekki and El-Kholy [107] investigated the response of rape oilseed to 0, 200 or 400 ppm mepiquat chloride and found that; palmitic acid was only decreased by using 400 ppm mepiquat chloride as compared with 200-ppm treatment or control plants. A low content of saturated fatty acids is desirable for edible purposes. Also, regarding oil quality, higher levels of linoleic acid and oleic acid are considered good for oil quality [108].
4. CONCLUSIONS
From the findings of this study, it seems rational to recommended application of N at a rate of 161 of kg·ha−1, spraying of cotton plants with plant PGR, and application of Zn in comparison with the ordinary cultural practices adopted by Egyptian cotton producers, it is quite apparent that applications of such PGR, Zn, and increased N fertilization rates could bring about better impact on cottonseed yield, seed protein content, oil and protein yields, oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter, and unsaturated fatty acids. On the other hand, there was a decrease in acid value and saponification value. The increase in seed yield and subsequent increase in oil and meal due to the application of PGR, Zn, and increased N fertilization were sufficient to cover the cost of using those chemicals and further attain an economical profit [35].
It can be concluded that addition of P at 74 kg·ha−1, and foliar application of Zn and Ca at different concentrations (especially Ca concentration of 60 ppm) beneficially affected cottonseed yield, seed index, seed oil content, oil and protein yields ha−1, seed oil unsaponifiable matter, and total unsaturated fatty acids (oleic and linoleic) [36].
The addition of K at 47.4 kg·ha−1, spraying cotton plants with Zn twice (at 57.6 g·ha−1), and also with P twice (especially the P concentration of 1728 g·ha−1) along with the soil fertilization used P at sowing time have been proven beneficial to the quality and yield of cotton plants. These combinations appeared to be the most effective treatments, affecting not only the quantity but also the quality of oil, and to obtain higher oil and protein yields and a better fatty acid profile in the oil of cotton. In comparison with the ordinary cultural practices adopted by Egyptian cotton producers, it is apparent that the applications of such treatments could produce an improvement in cottonseed yield, seed protein content, oil and protein yields, oil refractive index, unsaponifiable matter, iodine value, unsaturated fatty acids and a decrease in oil acid value and saponification value. The increase in seed yield and subsequent increase in oil and meal due to the addition of K, spraying cotton plants with Zn and of P are believed to be sufficient enough to cover the cost of using those chemicals and obtain an economic profit at the same time [1].
Application of N at the rate of 143 kg·ha−1 and two applications of both K (foliar; at the rate of 957 g·K·ha−1) and mepiquat chloride (at a rate of 48 + 24 g a.i. ha−1, respectively) have the most beneficial effects among the treatments examined, affecting not only the seed quantity (to obtain higher oil and protein yields ha−1) but also the oil seed quality (as indicated by better fatty acid profile in the oil of cotton) in comparison with the usual cultural practices adopted by Egyptian cotton procedures [37].
ABBREVIATIONS
Ca: calcium N: nitrogen P: phosphorus PGRs: plant growth retardants K: potassium Zn: zinc