Evaluation of Heirloom and Commercial Cultivars of Small Grains under Low Input Organic Systems

Tejendra Chapagain, Andrew Riseman

Faculty of Land and Food Systems, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.

DOI: 10.4236/ajps.2012.35080                

Abstract

A cultivar trial, including commercial and heirloom cultivars of major cereals and grain legumes was conducted in Vancouver, BC, under low input organic conditions. We assessed 19 wheat (6 commercial and 13 heirloom), 17 barley (8 commercial and 9 heirloom), 5 pea, 5 favabean, 5 kidneybean, 2 lentil, and 2 soyabean cultivars for plant performance metrics, and their potential in a small grain:legume intercropping system. Heirloom wheat cultivars showed notable response in a number of parameters including late maturity, taller plants, greatest number of spikes per m2, longest spike, highest number of seed per spike, greater seed weight to volume ratio, and resistance to stripe rust compared with commercial cultivars. For the heirloom-type, 6 of 14 wheat cultivars, (i.e., “Reward”, “Glenn”, “Cerebs”, “Red Bobs”, “Sounders” and “Black Bearded”) produced yields comparable to the commercial cultivars (i.e., nearly 5 t/h or higher). Also, heirloom cultivars typically contained higher protein levels most suitable for baking and blending purposes with “Einkorn” displaying the highest level (16.2%). Heirloom and commercial barley cultivars did not differ significantly with respect to plant height, spike length, and seed weight to volume ratio. However, a number of heirloom cultivars (e.g., “Jet”, “Dolma”, “Andie” and “Himalayan”) displayed greater responses on earliness, number of spikes per m2, grain yield, protein content and seed weight to volume ratio. Pea and lentil yielded lower than the national average under trial conditions. However, heirloom peas “Corgi”, “De Grace”, “Snowbird”, and “Golden” were earlier compared to the commercial cultivar “Reward”. All kidney bean cultivars yielded ~3 t/h with the highest yield from “Red Kidney” (3.8 t/h). Fava and soyabean appeared as promising crops as the cultivars produced good growth and yields. Neither lentil (“Crimson” and “Essex”) produced satisfactory responses though they had excellent vegetative growth and flowered. Therefore, significant variation was observed including several heirloom cultivars displayed great potential in terms of yield, protein content, and disease resistance and that specific cultivars were better suited for an intercropping system.

Keywords

Commercial and Heirloom Cultivars; Hulled and Hulless; 2-Row and 6-Row; Intercropping

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	CGC (Canada Grains Council), “Online Statistical Handbook,” The Canada Grains Council, Winnipeg, Manitoba, 2003.
[2]	C. A. Campbell, R. P. Zentner, P. Basnyat, R. D. Jong, R. L. Lemke and R. L. Desjardins, “Nitrogen Mineralization under Summer Fallow and Continuous Wheat in the Semiarid Canadian Prairie,” Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 88, No. 5, 2008, pp. 681-696. doi:10.4141/CJSS07115
[3]	B. Oleson, “The Wheat Industry in Canada” 2010. http://www.acopiadores.com/publico/atodotrigo/The Wheat Industry in Canada.pdf
[4]	M. Yussefi, “Development and State of Organic Agriculture Worldwide,” In: H. Willer and M. Yussefi, Eds., The World of Organic Agriculture 2004 Statistics and Emerging Trends, IFOAM Publication, 2004. http://www.soel.de/inhalte/publikationen/s/s_74.pdf
[5]	Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, “Organic Grains and Oilseeds,” Bi-weekly Bulletin, 2000. http://www.agr.gc.ca/mad-dam/e/bulletine/v13e/v13n05e.pdf
[6]	Statistics Canada, “Certified Organic Farming, by Provinces (2001 Census of Agriculture),” 2004. http://www.statcan.ca/english/Pgdb/agricul.htm#farms
[7]	A. Sahota, “Overview of the Global Market for Organic Food and Drink,” In: H. Willer and M. Yussefi, Eds., The World of Organic Agriculture 2004 Statistics and Emerging Trends, IFOAM Publication, 2004. http://www.soel.de/inhalte/publikationen/s/s_74.pdf
[8]	D. Walker and A. Smith, “Evaluation of Spring Wheat, Oat and Hulless Oat and Barley Cultivars under an Organic Production Protocol,” Adaptive Research Reports, Vol. 14, 1992, pp. 257-260.
[9]	M. H. Entz, R. Guilford and R. Gulden, “Crop Yield and Soil Nutrient Status on 14 Organic Farms in the Eastern Portion of the Northern Great Plains,” Canadian Journal of Plant Science, Vol. 81, No. 2, 2001, pp. 351-354. doi:10.4141/P00-089
[10]	J. L. Kitchen, G. K. McDonald, K. W. Shepherd, M. F. Lorimer and R. D. Graham, “Comparing Wheat Grown in South Australian Organic and Conventional Farming Systems. 1. Growth and Grain Yield,” Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, Vol. 54, No. 9, 2003, pp. 889-901. doi:10.1071/AR03039
[11]	M. H. Ryan, J. W. Derrick and P. R. Dann, “Grain Mineral Concentrations and Yield of Wheat Grown under Organic and Conventional Management,” Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, Vol. 84, No. 3, 2004, pp. 207-216. doi:10.1002/jsfa.1634
[12]	H. E. Mason and D. Spaner, “Competitive Ability of Wheat in Conventional and Organic Management Systems: A Review of the Literature,” Canadian Journal of Plant Science, Vol. 86, No. 2, 2006, pp. 333-343. doi:10.4141/P05-051
[13]	P. Barbery, “Weed Management in Organic Agriculture: Are We Addressing the Right Issues?” Weed Research, Vol. 42, No. 3, 2002, pp. 177-193. doi:10.1046/j.1365-3180.2002.00277.x
[14]	R. J. French and J. E. Schultz, “Water Use Efficiency of Wheat in a Mediterranean-Type Environment. I. The Relationship between Yield, Water Used and Climate,” Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, Vol. 35, No. 6, 1984, pp. 743-764. doi:10.1071/AR9840743
[15]	A. A. Bomke, S. Yu and W. D. Temple, “Winter Wheat Growth and Nitrogen Demand in South Coastal British Columbia,” Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 74, No. 4, 1994, pp. 443-451. doi:10.4141/cjss94-058
[16]	A. A. Bomke, W. D. Temple, G. E. Kennedy, L. Cain and M. J. Langlet, “Intensive Winter Cereal Production System for South Coastal British Columbia,” Agri-Food Regional Development Subsidiary Agreement Project #23007, BC Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Victoria, 1991.
[17]	S. Rempel, “Demeter’s Wheats: Growing Local Food and Community with Traditional Wisdom and Heritage Wheat,” Grassroots Solutions, Victoria, 2008.
[18]	R. A. Bertrand, G. A. Hughes-Games and D. C. Nikkel, “Soil Management Handbook for the Lower Fraser Valley,” BC Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Abbotsford, 1991.
[19]	J. C. Zadoks, T. T. Chang and C. F. Konzak, “A Decimal Code for the Growth Stages of Cereals,” Weed Research, Vol. 14, No. 6, 1974, pp. 415-421. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3180.1974.tb01084.x
[20]	D. R. Tottman, “The Decimal Code for the Growth Stages of Cereals, with Illustrations,” Annals of Applied Biology, Vol. 110, No. 2, 1987, pp. 441-454. doi:10.1111/j.1744-7348.1987.tb03275.x
[21]	W. Temple, “Progress Report on Delta Farmers’ Institute & UBC Faculty of Land and Food Systems Eco-Friendly Crop Rotations Project,” Faculty of Land and Food Systems, UBC, 2009.
[22]	E. J. Corbin, J. Brockwell and R. R. Gault, “Nodulation Studies on Chickpea (Cicer arietinum),” Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Animal Husbandry, Vol. 17, No. 84, 1977, pp. 126-134. doi:10.1071/EA9770126
[23]	M. A. Halstead, “Growing Organic Winter Cereals on Vancouver Island,” Faculty of Land and Food Systems, University of British Columbia (UBC), 2007.
[24]	K. K. Kidwell, G. B. Shelton, V. L. DeMacon, X. M. Chen, J. S. Kuehner, B. Baik, D. A. Engle, A. H. Carter and N. A. Bosque-Perez, “Registration of ‘Kelse’ Wheat,” Journal of Plant Registrations, Vol. 3, No. 3, 2009, pp. 269-272. doi:10.3198/jpr2009.01.0007crc
[25]	P. R. Shewry, “Improving the Protein Content and Quality of Temperate Cereals: Wheat, Barley and Rye,” In: R. M. Welch and I. Cakmak, Eds., Impacts of Agriculture on Human Health and Nutrition, Eolss Publishers, Oxford, 2006.
[26]	E. J. Wibberley, “Cereal Husbandry,” Farming Press Books, Ipswich, 1989.
[27]	R. T. Poutala, J. Korva and E. Varis, “Spring Wheat Cultivar Performance in Ecological and Conventional Cropping Systems,” Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, Vol. 3, No. 3-4, 1993, pp. 63-83. doi:10.1300/J064v03n03_05
[28]	W. Starling and M. C. Richards, “Quality of Commercial Samples of Organically Grown Wheat,” Annals of Applied Biology, Vol. 36, 1993, pp. 205-209.
[29]	N. W. Shier, J. Kelman and J. W. Dunson, “A Comparison of Crude Protein, Moisture, Ash and Crop Yield between Organic and Conventionally Grown Wheat,” Nutrition Reports International, Vol. 30, 1984, pp. 71-76.