Evidence of Atlantic Extension in South-East Togo: Case of Fracturing in the Sandstone Relics of Tohoun ()
1. Introduction
Highly eroded sandstone formations, which have been previously related to the upper sequences (“Continental Terminal”) of the Togo coastal basin, outcrop in the Tohoun-Tado area (South-East Togo). By their isolated position in the Pan-African basement area, these formations appear as relics related to an Atlantic transgression. The works of [1] attribute a hypothetical Cretaceous age to these formations allowing considering them as outliers of transgressive phases that are much older than those that were at the origin of the Neogene “Continental Terminal” deposits.
In the Tohoun sandstones, which should be considered equivalent to those at Adakplame in Benin [2], is expressed a dense network of fractures generally represented by “tectoglyphes” (varied marks visible on the slickenside allowing to specify the sense of fault throw) bearing planes indicating normal fault movement [3]. Here we analyzed striated planes in the framework of the search for Atlantic extension markers in the Gulf of Guinea basin. In fact, the Tohoun-Tado sandstone formations constitute evidence of the primary phases of the Togolese coastal sedimentary basin development. As the upper sequences, these formations bear fracture network very probably linked to the Atlantic dynamic. But, up to now, in the Togolese coastal basin, as in the whole Gulf of Guinea basin, fracture networks studies for paleostress determination have never been tackled. Furthermore, extension models have been proposed without stress evidence [4] [5]. That explains the initiative of this fault planes analysis in the Tohoun sandstone relics. These deposits could have recorded the imprints of early tectonic episodes that have oriented the Atlantic extension especially in the Togolese portion of the Gulf of Guinea basin.
2. Geological Setting
In the West-African sub-region (Figure 1), geological suites belong to:
The West-African Craton (WAC), consisting of Archean to Paleoproterozoic assemblages and stabilized since the end of the Eburnean orogeny (2000 ± 200 Ma; [6] ),
The Neoproterozoic to Paleozoic megasequences of Taoudeni and Volta basins,
The Pan-African belts (600 ± 50 Ma) overlapping the WAC and its cover,
And the Meso-Cenozoic internal (Iullemmeden basin) or coastal (Senegal-Mauritania basin, Ivory Coast basin, Gulf of Guinea basin and Benue trough) basins. The coastal basins history is linked to the Atlantic opening.
The geology of the South Togo consists of a meso-cenozoic sedimentary cover relying unconformably on a Pan-African gneisso-migmatitic basement. The sedimentary cover is the Togolese portion of the regional Gulf of Guinea basin (Figure 1).
2.1. The Pan-African Basement
The Togolese coastal basin basement corresponds to part of the western domain of the so-called “internal zone” of the Pan-African Dahomeyides belt [7]. It consists of gneisso-migmatitic units associated with rare late Pan-African granitic intrusions [8] [9] [10]. These lithostuctural units containing ortho- or para-derived petrographic rocks are considered to be of Eburnean age (2000 ± 200 Ma; [6] ), remobilized during the Pan-African orogeny (600 ± 50 Ma; [11] [12] ). They represent the frontal part of the Benino-Nigerian Shield that collided with the eastern margin of the WAC during the ultimate stage of the Dahomeyides edification [7]. The fracture network in the gneisso-migmatitic units is attributed to the two last Pan-African deformation phases [13] [14] [15]. These major fractures have probably influenced the coastal basin setting up.
Figure 1. Synthetic map, extracted from the geological maps of Togo [10] and Benin [16], showing the lithological organization of the Benino-Togolese costal basin (Gulf of Benin basin) and location of the Tohoun-Tado sandstone formations. 1 = Pan-African basement; 2 = Maastrichtian deposits; 3 = Paleocene deposits; 4 = Paleocene to lower Eocene deposits; 5 = Lower Eocene deposits; 6 = Middle Eocene deposits; 7 = Oligocene—Miocene deposits; 8 = “Continental terminal” deposits; 9 = fluvio-lacustrine and marine deposits; 10 = Major fractures; 11 = synthetic cross-section location.
2.2. The Meso-Cenozoic Cover
The Meso-Cenozoic cover of the Togolese coastal sedimentary basin is defined as a monoclinal mega-sequence with very low dip to the SE where it approaches 600 m thickness (Figure 2). Both basement and sedimentary cover are compartmentalized by normal faults. Formations outcrop in NE-SW trending parallel bands corresponding to different stages of marine evolution [4]. These outcrops become blurred toward the north of the basin by an erosional limit beyond which occur outliers of the Tohoun-Tado Sandstones (Figure 1).
Figure 2. Synthetic cross-section showing the litho-structural organization of the Togolese coastal sedimentary basin in the SW (see Figure 1) according to [17] Project report slightly modified. 1 = Pan-African basement; 2 = Cretaceous deposits; 3 = Paleocene deposits; 4 = Eocene deposits; 5 = “Continental terminal” deposits; 6 = Fault plane; 7 = supposed fault plane.
According to [4] and [18], the mega-sequence of the Togolese coastal basin consists of three series, namely:
1) The lower series or “Tabligbo Group”, consisting, from base to top, of Campanian-Maastrichtian detrital deposits (sands and sandstones), Paleocene-Eocene limestones and laminated mudstones;
2) The middle series of lower to middle Eocene age, called the “Hahotoe-Kpogame phosphatic Complex” [4], bringing together, from bottom to top, phosphatic marls, phospharenites (phosphate deposits in exploitation) and phosphatic mudstones;
3) The upper series (upper Eocene to Quaternary) representing the “Continental terminal s.l.” and consisting of sandy clay detrital deposits with pebbly horizons. The latter, is separated from the preceding series by an erosion surface (Figure 2).
The genesis and evolution of the Togolese coastal basin, like its West African equivalents, are associated with the process of the opening of the South Atlantic equatorial segment. This opening occurred in the global dynamic of the dislocation of Gondwana that separated the African and South American continents since the Lower Cretaceous [19] - [29]. For [30], these basins have several tectono-sedimentary similarities. They are made of continental (fluvio-lacustrine) pre- to syn-rift valley filling deposits overlain by marine sediments generally transgressive on anterior deposits. Basin filling generally ends with a detrital continental series.
3. Main Lithological Characteristics of Tohoun Sandstones
The Tohoun-Tado sandstones occupy the summits of two elliptical interfluves oriented WNW-ESE over a length of 6 to 8 km (Figure 3). These transboundary outcrops are encountered several kilometers from the northern limit of the coastal basin. Similar relics have been mapped in Benin [2] [16]. In Togo, the Tohoun-Tado Sandstones have been considered as formations of the “Continental terminal” [10] [31]. The works of [1] show that they should rather be
Figure 3. Geological map of the study area showing the lithological components of the Pan-African basement and outcrops of Tohoun-Tado sandstones [10] [16].
attached to the coastal sedimentary basin basal formations. The entire sandy sequence is subdivided into two units separated by an erosional disconformity. The lower unit is called “Tado Sandstones” and the upper unit “Tohoun Sandstones”.
In this work the fracture network data has been analyzed. The data was collected from Tohoun outcrops (Figure 3) where the sequence is more complete and the striated planes clearly expressed and well preserved.
On the architectural plan, the Tohoun Sandstone outcrops are tower-like, with a dark color attributed to a carpet covering of lichens (Figure 4(a)). The lithological characteristics are perturbed by intense erosion, ferruginization and dissolution phenomena at the origin of pseudo-karsts.
Strong oblique and cross-bedding stratifications are clearly visible (Figure 4(b)). Fresh rocks are generally massive and characterized by an intergrowth of veinlets with whitish and sometimes little carbonated siliceous infill (Figure 4(c)). They are pale yellowish-brown, with a brown patina and saccharoidal alteration.
Figure 4. Some characteristic aspects of sandstone outcrops of Tohoun: (a) -Tower-like sandstone outcrops; (b) -Oblique and cross-bedding stratifications; (c) -Highly eroded sandstone outcrop with whitish and siliceous infill veinlets.
The texture is heterogranular, medium to coarse grained or micro-conglomeratic with centimetric quartz pebbles. [1] has described traces of bioturbation in the sandstones.
4. Analysis of the Fracture Networks
4.1. Methodology
Two faulted sites were studied. The first site (N07˚03'13.7''; E01˚36'39.6'') includes sandstone outcrops attributed to the lower members of the sequence. The planes surveyed bear striations whose geometry indicates normal fault movements (Figure 5(a)) associating a more or less important strike-slip fault displacement (oblique slip fault, Figure 5(b)), or exclusively strike-slip fault (Figure 5(c)). Outcrops at the second site (N07˚02'12.5''; E01˚37'36.5'') belong to the upper member of the sandstone sequence and only show normal fault type striated planes (Figure 5(d)).
Several plane directions make up the fracture networks at the two sites. Based on the intersection criteria and superposition of incompatible striae [32] [33] [34], the planes are attributed to many fracturing episodes. A total of 334 striated planes were recorded. From this fault population, only 163 planes are retained considering conformity with movement criteria [35]. The measurements were first subjected to manual stereographic processing to complete striae characterization.
Figure 5. Some striated planes in the Tohoun sandstones. (a) -NW-SE normal fault plane; (b) -NE-SW oblique slip fault plane; and (c) -NW-SE sinistral strike-slip fault plane on site 1; (d) -NE-SW normal fault plane on site 2.
Data on the striated planes were processed using the numerical calculation software Tectonics FP 1.75 [36]. This software requires as inputs, the geometrical parameters of planes (Dip direction/dip) and striae on planes, as well as fault type and the precision for each plane measurement. Three methods are proposed for the calculation of tensors namely: 1) Direct Inversion [37] [38] [39] [40]; 2) Numerical Dynamical Analysis (NDA; [41], review in [42] ); and the 3) Dihedra calculation [43] [44] [45]. The Direct Inversion methods are used for inherited faults systems [44] [46], while the NDA allows determining the parameters of deformation axes rather than stressing characteristics. Thus we have chosen the third method (Dihedra calculation) which is recommended for conjugated fault systems [43] [47] [48]. After the treatments, the states of the paleostresses obtained for each system or fracturing episode are synthesized in Table 1.
At site 2, the intersection criteria allowed to establish a relative chronology of at least three episodes of development of striated planes (Figure 6). The first episode is represented by the E-W to WNW-ESE (N80 to N100) planes. The second generation expresses itself in the NW-SE to NNW-SSE (N120 to N160) directions and finally, the last generation corresponds to the NE-SW (N40 to N70) planes. The same generations of normal faults were recorded at site 1, but one notes the presence of families of NE-SW dextral and NW-SE sinistral strike slip faults. Each generation of normal faults is considered as a system allowing determination of the responsible theoretical stress tensor. The system of strike slip faults at the site 1 is considered to be a set of fault reactivation planes linked to the last episode. These planes were analyzed separately.
Figure 6. Sandstone outcrop at site 2 showing fracture network corresponding to three episodes of fracturing respectively materialized by E-W (1), N-S to NW-SE (2) and NE-SW (3) plane directions. The planes of precocious generations with siliceous infill are intersected by the last planes. This intersection indicates dextral strike-slip fault displacement which really corresponds to the horizontal lateral throw of normal faulting.
Table 1. Synthesis of striated planes analysis at the two faulted sites of Tohoun sandstones: the table summarizes for each site the geographic coordinates, the type of fault (TF) analyzed (NF = normal fault, SF = strike-slip fault), the directions of family planes (D), the number of striated planes analyzed (Nb), and the direction and dipping of principal stress axis (σ1, σ2 and σ3) obtained.
4.2. Results
Site 1
The striated planes recorded at the site 1 have medium to high dips (40˚ to 80˚) in many directions. The pitch of striae and associated tectoglyphes allow identifying normal, normal strike-slip and strike-slip faults. The network is made up of three major normal fault directions which correspond to three conjugated fault systems associated with different fracturing episodes. The NW-SE planes are more represented than the NE-SW and E-W normal faults. The stress tensors determined for each system are the following:
The system of E-W conjugated normal faults express a subvertical maximum principal stress axis σ1, oriented N036-85 and a minor stress σ3 oriented N177-04 (Figure 7(a));
The second generation system of NW-SE conjugated normal faults corresponds to a paleostress tensor with principal axes σ1 N171-86 and σ3 N044-02 (Figure 7(b));
All the NE-SW normal faults assume a tensor with paleostresses σ1 N253-64 and σ3 N344-00 (Figure 7(c)).
The strike-slip faults are organized in a system of conjugated families with NE-SW (N40 to N70) dextral and NW-SE (N115 to N130) sinistral planes. This system of strike-slip faults seems to correspond to a tensor of paleostresses, with subhorizontal σ1 and σ3 oriented N087-06 and N178-07 respectively (Figure 7(d)).
Site 2
Sandstones belonging to the upper member of the sequence (“Tohoun Sandstones”) bear decimetric to decametric normal fault planes in E-W, NW-SE and NE-SW directions. Thus, in the image of site 1, site 2 shows imprints of the three fracturing episodes. Stress tensor is also determined for each episode.
The primary episode is expressed by the E-W planes generally filled in by a greyish brown to blackish fine grained ferruginous sandstone. Analysis of the system of normal faults indicates a tensor of paleostresses with subvertical σ1 N319-85 and σ3 N188-04 (Figure 7(e)).
Figure 7. Stereograms (lower hemisphere projection) resulting from striated plane analysis using Tectonics FP 1.75 software [36]. The three extension episodes in the Tohoun sandstones correspond successively to the paleostress axes constructed in stereogram (a), (b), (c), (d) at site 1, and (e), (f), (g) at site 2. The principal stress axes are σ1 (red stars with 6 branches), σ2 (yellow stars with 5 branches) and σ3 (blue stars with 4 branches).
The second episode corresponding to several NE-SW striking planes filled with whitish silica, results from a tensor with σ1 N079-76 and σ3 N209-09 (Figure 7(f)).
The last concretization of fault tectonics is defined by a population of planes with NE-SW directions. These planes suggest the principal stress axes σ1 N277-85 and σ3 N153-03 (Figure 7(g)).
5. Synthesis and Discussions
The fracture network in the sandstone formations around Tohoun contains three distinct conjugated normal fault systems. At both faulted sites studied, these systems are defined in the E-W (N80-N100), NW-SE (N120-N160) and NE-SW (N40-N70) directions and are interpreted as successive fracturing episodes. Analysis of fault families of each system allowed identifying the tensors of paleostresses that guided the network development. Thus, the first episode materialized by the E-W normal faults system corresponds to a N-S (σ3 N177 to N188) extension. The second episode represented by the NW-SE conjugated normal faults symbolizes a NE-SW extension with subhorizontal σ3 N44 (site 1) or N209 (site 2). The greatest majority of the NE-SW planes mark the impact of the last fracturing episode in the sandstones. On the two sites, the latter episode results from a NNW-SSE (σ3 N153 and N164) extension. It’s to this episode that one can attribute the strike-slip faults present at site 1 and which are interpreted as fault reactivation of previous planes.
In summary, the entire fracture network present in the Tohoun sandstones results from a distentional tectonics that is decomposed into three episodes during which the σ3 stress seems to have evolved around the N-S axis. From the first to the third episode, the direction of stretching reconstructs successively N-S NE-SW and NNW-SSE. This extension in three episodes can be associated with the early phases of the Togolese coastal basin or more widely the development of the Gulf of Guinea basin. These are the pre- to syn-rift phases of the genesis of Cretaceous big lakes [22] [24]; phases with a dynamic probably hesitant and not uniform from one sector to the other.
In the context of the Togolese coastal basin, the importance of this distensive tectonics had been underscored since the works of [19]. The basin architecture and its paleogeographic evolution denote the essential role of fracturing [4] [10] [18]. The principal directional network components have been defined, but only [3] gives some indications of distension axes. On a regional scale, the extension axes responsible for the fracture network can be integrated into the system of paleostresses of the first phases of continental separation in the Gulf of Guinea. In the South-East of Ghana for example, [13] recorded a few tectoglyphe bearing post-Pan-African normal faults indicating a SE-NW extension probably associated with the precursor tectonics of Jurassic rifting. In the offshore basin in Ghana, the structure established by [49] and the Aptian pull-apart basin extension model of [5] appear to be in conformity with a NE-SW stretch axis. Also, concerning the branch of the Benue graben, [22] has identified a NE-SW syn-rift stretch axis.
In the case, these preliminary results of microtectonics analysis of the Atlantic opening and extension markers in the Tohoun sandstone relics are a first. Thus, for a better interpretation of the reconstructed paleostress axes, a study of the fracture network at the scale of the entire Togolese coastal basin would be necessary.