Demba Faye¹, Idy Diop¹, Nalla Mbaye², Doudou Dione¹, Marius Mintu Diedhiou^2
1Polytechnic School of Dakar, University Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar, Senegal.
²Department of Plant Biology, Faculty of Science and Technology, University Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar, Senegal.
DOI: 10.4236/jcc.2023.119004   PDF    HTML   XML   348 Downloads   1,793 Views   Citations

Abstract

The world’s agricultural production suffers huge losses estimated between 20% and 40% annually. 40% to 50% of such losses are due to pest and diseases which cause significant economic losses every year. Precise assessment of severity is crucial for suitable management of crop diseases. It helps famers to avoid yield losses, reduce production costs, ensure good disease management and so on. This paper is a review of plant diseases severity estimation solutions proposed by researchers the last few years and based on Image Processing Techniques (IPT), classical Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) algorithms. The analysis of these solutions has allowed us to identify their limitations and potential challenges in plant disease severity assessment.

Keywords

Plant, Disease, Severity, Machine Learning, Deep Learning

Share and Cite:

1. Introduction

The world’s agricultural production suffers huge losses estimated between 20% and 40% every year [1] [2] . 40% to 50% of such losses are due to pest and diseases [3] [4] . These losses are both quantitative and qualitative and as a result, they are responsible for significant economic losses annually and affect the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of countries. Plant pest and disease protection has become an important research area, due to its highly correlation with food security, climate change and environmental sustainability. It is an essential tool for precision agriculture.

However, knowledge of the disease severity is an essential factor in crop disease protection and management [4] [5] . Crop disease severity is the ratio of plant units with visible disease symptoms to the total plant unit (e.g. fruit, leaf) [6] . Diagnosis of crop disease and disease severity estimation are closely related. It is therefore essential to identify the disease severity stage as early as possible in order to remedy the yied loss. Traditional methods for disease severity estimatimation mostly rely on manual labor, which is labor-intensive, slow and highly subjective [7] [8] [9] . It requires plant protection experts to visit the field to identify the disease and determine its severity.

In recent years, thanks to advances in computer imaging technology and improved hardware performance, computer vision and artificial intelligence have been widely used in agriculture for plant species classification, disease identification and plant disease severity assessment [10] . Solutions proposed by researchers the last few years for disease severity estimation are based on images processing techniques (IPT), classical Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) algorithms [1] [7] [8] .

This paper is a review of plant disease severity assessment solutions proposed by researchers the last few years. The specific contributions of this paper include:

· Advantages of plant disease severity assessment.

· Analysis of proposed crop diseases severity estimation solutions based on IPT, ML or DL.

· Limitations of proposed solutions and potential challenges.

The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 identifies the advantages of plant disease severity assessment in agriculture, Sections 3 provides a critical analysis of the proposed solutions based on IPT, classical ML and DL algorithms, Section 4 shows the potential challenges in crop disease severity estimation and the last Section concludes the paper.

2. Advantages of Plant Disease Severity Assessment

In a field, a disease can spread rapidly over the entire crop batch and cause a field-wide epidemic, which is undoubtedly devastating. In order to effectively monitor and control such situations, it is important to specify earlier not only the type of disease, but also its severity, which is the ratio between the plant unit showing visible symptoms of the disease and the total plant unit [6] . For example, the ratio of diseased area to leaf area (see Figure 1 and Figure 2). This is why the precise quantification of crop diseases is an absolute necessity in agriculture. Thus, asssessing disease severity enables growers to rationalize disease control, for example by deciding on the right dose of fungicide and type of pesticide, as well as the time of day to spray [8] [11] . A reliable and accurate estimation of disease severity enables farmers to predict epidemics in their fields and yield losses, and to assess disease resistance in crop germplasm [12] [13] [14] . It can also help farmers with pesticide management, disease forecasting, spatio-temporal epidemic modeling and crop loss modeling [7] [15] [16] . Pesticide management plays an important role in protecting the environment by simultaneously reducing crop, soil and water pollution and avoiding pesticide residues in fruits

[8] [19] . Early disease severity estimation is essential in global food security [18] .

However, traditionally, disease severity is determined manually by experts by estimating the visual surface area of lesions on plants (e.g. leaf, fruit, etc.). This process is slow, time-consuming, highly subjective and largely dependent on the level of experience of agronomists and farmers for visual scoring [1] [7] [20] [21] . Incorrect assessment of disease severity in plants can lead to erroneous conclusions, resulting in wasteful or inefficient use of pesticides, which can further exacerbate losses [15] [22] [23] [24] .

3. Automatic Disease Severity Assessment

In the literature, several solutions have been proposed for estimating the severity of plant diseases. These solutions can be divided into three types:

· Visual assessment, traditionally used by plant experts,

· Solutions based on hyperspectral imaging (image processing techniques) or ML,

· And more recently, solutions based on DL.

For the purposes of this paper, we worked on 47 articles whose work focused on estimating the severity of plant diseases. The articles were searched on Google Scholar, Springer Link, Web of Science, IEEE Xplore, Scientific Research, Frontiers, etc., using the keywords “disease-severity-assessment-plant”. Figure 3 shows the number of studies carried out on this topic every year, between 2008 and 2023.

These work concerns different crops, different diseases and different approaches for determining disease severity. Among the crops covered by the 47 reviewed articles, tomato and maize are the most treated (8 times). It is followed by tomato (8 times), wheat (5 times) and strawberry (4 times) (see Figure 4).

The definition of the severity grades or lavels is essential in diseases severity estimation. Based on the 47 reviewed articles, we can say there are three categories of severity grades namely qualitative grade, quantitative grade and direct calculation of the percentage of the disease lesions (see Figure 5). For example, [18] used Healthy, Early, Middle and End severity levels which are qualitatives. [25] used healthy (<0.1%), very low (0.1% - 5%), low (5.1% - 10%), high (10.1% - 15%) and very high (>15%) grades which are quantitatives. In [26] , the percentage of the disease lesions is directly calculated. In the following subsections, we take a closer look at solutions based on IPT and ML and DL algorithms.

3.1. Solutions Based on IPT

In agricultural research, IP technology has undergone significant development. Solutions based essentially on IP technology have been proposed by reseachers for assessing plant leaf disease severity. For instance, Wijekoon et al. [27] used multispectral images thresholding operation to calculate the ratio of infected area, lesion color index and severity index of soybean leaf infected by rust disease. Weizhong et al. used the Sobel operator to segment soybean rust disease and to determine the spot edge and disease severity of the plant, which is measured by calculating the quotient of disease spot area and leaf area [28] . In [29] , authors applied simple threshold and triangle thresholding methods to respectively segment the diseased leaf area and lesion region on the leaf. The results show an accuracy of 98.60% for estimating the severity of brown spot on soybean leaves. Thus IP technology to measure crop disease severity is convenient and accurate but the severity of the disease measured is depends upon segmentation of the image. Authors of [30] developed a mobile application based on image processing. This app is able to calculate the severity percentage of six different diseases with typical lesions of varying severity. Palma et al. proposed an approach for automatic quantitative assessment of disease severity based on leaf images, regardless of disease type. The proposed method is based on a highly

efficient, noise-free positive nonlinear dynamic system that recursively transforms the image of the leaf until only the symptomatic patterns of the disease remain [31] .

3.2. Solutions Based on ML

In the literature, there are very few works based on classical ML algorithms for estimating crop disease severity. ML-based solutions often use IPT. IPT are used to improve the quality of the images used, while ML algorithms are used for image segmentation, feature extraction and image classification. For example, Owomugisha et al. [32] used image processing technics and classical ML algorithms such as linear SVC, KNN and Extra Trees to classify four cassava diseases (mosaic, brown streak, bacterial blight and green mite) and assess their severity on diseased leaves. They used a dataset of 7386 images divided into 5 severity levels ranged from 1 to 5. They obtained accuracy scores of 99%. Authors of [33] utilized ML models to detect and classify downy mildew (DM) disease severity in watermelon in five disease severity stages namely low, medium, high and very high. They used Hyperspectral watermelon leave images collected in laboratory and in the field by a UAV and implemented multilayer perceptron (MLP) and decision tree (DT). Results show that classification accuracy increased when the disease severity increased and the best classification results were obtained from the MLP method in high and very high severity stages (87% - 90%). Jiang et al. [34] used two unsupervised learning algorithms namely K-means clustering and spectral clustering and three supervised learning algorithms including SVM, RF, and KNN to assess the severity of wheat leaf stripe rust disease. They used a dataset of 400 samples splitted into height severity levels namely 1%, 5%, 10%, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, and 100%. RF model obtained the best assessment performance with an overall accuracy of 100%. Table 1 summarizes the above-mentioned works according to the year of publication, the crop concerned, the parts of the crop infected, the diseases treated, the disease severity grades, source of the dataset and the algorithms used.

3.3. Solutions Based on DL

Based on the 47 articles we worked on, the majority of solutions proposed for estimating plant disease severity are based on DL and essentially on Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). DL-based solutions can be divided into two categories: CNN-based solutions and CNN-based segmentation networks. These solutions generally follow the workflow described in Figure 6.

3.3.1. CNN-Based Solutions

During the last decade, several solutions based on CNN have been proposed in the filed of crop diseases diagnosis. The estimation of disease severity, an extension of disease diagnosis, is also an area in which several CNN-based solutions have been proposed in recent years. For instance, automatic disease severity assessement of plant based on CNN was first proposed in 2017 by Wang et al. [18] .

Similarly, several authors have proposed plant disease severity assessment solutions based on well-known CNN such as VGG16, VGG19, ResNet18, ResNet50, ResNet101, Inception-V3, GoogLeNet, AlexNet, SqueezeNet, DenseNet121, MobileNetV2, NASNetMobile [4] [5] [12] [14] [15] [18] [24] . Some authors have proposed their own CNNs, which have given better results than well-known CNNs [11] [21] [23] [35] - [41] . Some solutions are based on the combination of CNN and classical ML algorithms such as Random Forest [19] and SVM [13] . Among these CNN-based solutions, several have used the principle of Multi-task learning [1] [4] [8] [10] [14] [25] [35] [37] [42] . Multi-task learning, as opposed to single-task learning, is a learning principle in which several linked tasks can be learned simultaneously [1] . Plant disease classification and disease severity estimation are two related tasks, which can be learned simultaneously using multitask learning. Multi-task learning is more advantageous than Single-task learning because it can reduce the risk of overfitting and lead to better generalization of a model [43] .

These CNN-based solutions have achieved extraordinary performances ranging from 70% to 99% accuracy.

Table 2 is a summarize of theses above-mentioned works according to the year of publication, type of architecture (single or multi task), crop concerned, parts of the crop infected, diseases treated, the disease severity grades, source of the dataset, models used and results obtained.

3.3.2. CNN-Based Segmentation Networks Solutions

CNN-based segmentation is widely used in object detection and localization. CNN-based segmentation networks have also been used to assess the severity of plant diseases and other related agricultural tasks. Of the 47 articles reviewed, seven used a CNN-based segmentation network, such as Unet [10] [12] , Mask R-CNN [49] [50] [51] , Faster R-CNN [8] [42] , SegNet [26] , DeepLav [26] and so on. They are based on segmentation of infected areas (of the leaf, fruit, etc.) to quantify disease severity (see Figure 7). For crop disease severity assessment. Su et al. [49] proposed a solution based on Mask-RCNN for the detection and severity estimation of Fusarium Head Blight (FHB) on wheat spikes. Authors defined fifteen severity grades (from grade 0 to grade 14). The proposed solution achieved accuracies of 77.76% and 98.81%, respectively for FHB detection and severity assessment. Chen et al. [20] developped a Deep Learning algorithm (BLSNet) based on Unet for rice leaf bacterial lesion segmentation and severity estimation. Goncalves et al. [26] used six CNNs namely Unet, SegNet, PSPNet, FPN, DeepLabV3 (Xception) and DeepLabV3 (MobileNetV2) to estimate the severity of Coffee leaf miner, soybean rust and wheat. They used a dataset for each of the three diseases. Results show that average precision values are ranged from 90.4% to 95.6% and recall values are ranged from 89.4% to 94.7%. Hu et al. [8] used Faster R-CNN and VGG16 for detection and severity assessment of tea leaf blight disease, respectively. Detection average precision and the severity grading accuracy improved by more than 6% and 9%, respectively, compared to existing solutions. Pillay et al. [51] applied Mask R-CNN to quantify the severity of common rust disease in maize leaf. The Mask R-CNN performed better than standard image processing algorithms more than 5%. Gerber et al. [51] examined automated tuning of Mask R-CNN parameters which are very numerious and use also a genetic algorithm (GA) in order to enhance performance achieved in their previous work [50] . Pan et al. [42] proposed a two-stage model including object detection by Faster R-CNN and few-shot learning by siamese network to estimate strawberry leaf scorch severity. The proposed two-stage method achieved the highest estimation accuracy of 96.67%. Table 3 is a summarize of theses above-mentioned works according to the year of publication, type of architecture (single or multi task), crop concerned, parts of the crop infected, diseases treated, the disease severity grades, source of the dataset, models used

and results obtained.

4. Limitations of Proposed Solutions and Potential Challenges

Results obtained by solutions based on IPT, classic ML and DL algorithms are very promising in crop disease severity estimation. They help to avoid yield losses, reduce production costs, ensure good disease management and so on.

However, these solutions have limitations that need to be overcome:

· For IPT-based solutions, quality of the images has a strong influence on image segmentation and, consequently, on the determination of the area infected by a disease. To obtain good results in quantifying disease severity, it is essential to use high-quality images (noiseless, without complex backgrounds, etc.).

· Estimating the severity of a crop disease from an image containing several leaves is not addressed in the reviewed works, but it is a situation that can occur in real life.

· The accuracy of severity classification increases with the severity of the crop disease. In other words, for solutions using quantitative severity levels, it is difficult to quantify disease at an early stage.

· For solutions using qualitative or quantitative severity grades, image labeling has a major impact on the classification result, and must therefore be carried out by an expert. A bad image labeling systematically leads to incorrect quantification of disease severity and, consequently, to poor a disease management.

· For solutions using the segmentation of disease lesions (on leaves, fruit, etc.), much of the edge information is lost, impacting the result of disease severity quantification.

· Crop diseases can affect leaves, fruits, flowers, panicles and so on. But until now, researchers have focused on assessing only the severity of leaf diseases.

Estimating plant disease severity on other parts, such as fruits, would also be of great use in crop disease management.

5. Conclusions and Future Works

Diagnosing crop diseases goes hand in hand with assessing their severity. Estimating the severity of diseases is very useful for plant disease management. Several solutions based on IPT, ML or DL have been proposed by researchers to estimate the crop diseases severity. These solutions have achieved very impressive results, but have limitations that need to be taken into account.

For future work, we aim to propose a CNN-based solution to assess the severity of four mango fruit diseases namely anthracnose, Alternaria, black mould rot and stem and rot. This solution will be adapted to the reality of Africa in general, and Senegal in particular, since we will use the MangoFruitDDS dataset [52] containing images of the above-mentioned diseases and collected in an orchard located in Senegal.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

References

[1]	Ahmad, A., Saraswat, D. and El Gamal, A. (2023) A Survey on Using Deep Learning Techniques for Plant Disease Diagnosis and Recommendations for Development of Appropriate Tools. Smart Agricultural Technology, 3, 100083. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atech.2022.100083
[2]	Banerjee, D., Kukreja, V., Hariharan, S. and Jain, V. (2023) Enhancing Mango Fruit Disease Severity Assessment with CNN and SVM-Based Classification. 2023 IEEE 8th International Conference for Convergence in Technology (I2CT), Lonavla, 7-9 April 2023, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1109/I2CT57861.2023.10126397
[3]	Faye, D. and Diop, I. (2022) Survey on Crop Disease Detection and Identification Based on Deep Learning. In: Mambo, A.D., Gueye, A. and Bassioni, G., Eds., InterSol 2022: Innovations and Interdisciplinary Solutions for Underserved Areas, Springer, Cham, 210-222. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-23116-2_18
[4]	Fenu, G. and Malloci, F.M. (2021) Using Multioutput Learning to Diagnose Plant Disease and Stress Severity. Complexity, 2021, Article ID: 6663442. https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/6663442
[5]	Haque, M.A., Marwaha, S., Arora, A., Deb, C.K., Misra, T., Nigam, S. and Hooda, K.S. (2022) A Lightweight Convolutional Neural Network for Recognition of Severity Stages of Maydis Leaf Blight Disease of Maize. Frontiers in Plant Science, 13, Article 1077568. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2022.1077568
[6]	Shi, T., Liu, Y., Zheng, X., et al. (2023) Recent Advances in Plant Disease Severity Assessment Using Convolutional Neural Networks. Scientific Reports, 13, Article No. 2336. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-29230-7
[7]	Liu, B.Y., Fan, K.J., Su, W.H. and Peng, Y. (2022) Two-Stage Convolutional Neural Networks for Diagnosing the Severity of Alternaria Leaf Blotch Disease of the Apple Tree. Remote Sensing, 14, Article 2519. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs14112519
[8]	Hu, G.S., Wang, H.Y., Zhang, Y. and Wan, M.Z. (2021) Detection and Severity Analysis of Tea Leaf Blight Based on Deep Learning. Computers & Electrical Engineering, 90, Article ID: 107023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compeleceng.2021.107023
[9]	Bock, C.H., Poole, G.H., Parker, P.E. and Gottwald, T.R. (2010) Plant Disease Severity Estimated Visually, by Digital Photography and Image Analysis, and by Hyperspectral Imaging. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 29, 59-107. https://doi.org/10.1080/07352681003617285
[10]	Liang, Q., Xiang, S., Hu, Y., Coppola, G., Zhang, D. and Sun, W. (2019) PD2SE-Net: Computer-Assisted Plant Disease Diagnosis and Severity Estimation Network. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 157, 518-529. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compag.2019.01.034
[11]	Agarwal, M., Gupta, S. and Biswas, K.K. (2021) A New Conv2D Model with Modified ReLU Activation Function for Identification of Disease Type and Severity in Cucumber Plant. Sustainable Computing: Informatics and Systems, 30, Article ID: 100473. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.suscom.2020.100473
[12]	Rabhakar, M., Purushothaman, R. and Awasthi, D.P. (2020) Deep Learning Based Assessment of Disease Severity for Early Blight in Tomato Crop. Multimedia Tools and Applications, 79, 28773-28784. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11042-020-09461-w
[13]	Lamba, S., Kukreja, V., Baliyan, A., Rani, S. and Ahmed, S.H. (2023) A Novel Hybrid Severity Prediction Model for Blast Paddy Disease Using Machine Learning. Sustainability, 15, Article 1502. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15021502
[14]	Ji, M.M., Zhang, K.K., Wu, Q.F. and Deng, Z. (2020) Multi-Label Learning for Crop Leaf Diseases Recognition and Severity Estimation Based on Convolutional Neural Networks. Soft Computing, 24, 15327-15340. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00500-020-04866-z
[15]	Kumar, R., Chug, A. and Singh, A.P. (2023) Plant Leaf Diseases Severity Estimation using Fine-Tuned CNN Models. 2023 6th International Conference on Information Systems and Computer Networks (ISCON), Mathura, 3-7 March 2023, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1109/ISCON57294.2023.10111948
[16]	Ilyas, T., Jin, H., Siddique, M.I., Lee, S.J., Kim, H. and Chua, L. (2022) DIANA: A Deep Learning-Based Paprika Plant Disease and Pest Phenotyping System with Disease Severity Analysis. Frontiers in Plant Science, 13, Article 983625. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2022.983625
[17]	Schneider, S.J., Da Graca, J.V., Skaria, M., Little, C.R., Setamou, M. and Kunta, M. (2013) A Visual Rating Scale for Quantifying the Severity of Greasy Spot Disease on Grapefruit Leaves. International Journal of Fruit Science, 13, 459-465. https://doi.org/10.1080/15538362.2013.789273
[18]	Wang, G., Sun, Y. and Wang, J.X. (2017) Automatic Image-Based Plant Disease Severity Estimation Using Deep Learning. Computational Intelligence and Neuroscience, 2017, Article ID: 2917536. https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/2917536
[19]	Gu, C., Wang, D., Zhang, H., Zhang, J., Zhang, D. and Liang, D. (2021) Fusion of Deep Convolution and Shallow Features to Recognize the Severity of Wheat Fusarium Head Blight. Frontiers in Plant Science, 11, Article 599886. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2020.599886
[20]	Chen, S., Zhang, K., Zhao, Y., Sun, Y., Ban, W., Chen, Y., Zhuang, H., Zhang, X., Liu, J. and Yang, T. (2021) An Approach for Rice Bacterial Leaf Streak Disease Segmentation and Disease Severity Estimation. Agriculture, 11, Article 420. https://doi.org/10.3390/agriculture11050420
[21]	Gao, J.F., Westergaard, J.C., Sundmark, E.H.R., Bagge, M., Liljeroth, E. and Alexandersson, E. (2021) Automatic Late Blight Lesion Recognition and Severity Quantification Based on Field Imagery of Diverse Potato Genotypes by Deep Learning. Knowledge-Based Systems, 214, Article ID: 106723. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.knosys.2020.106723
[22]	Zeng, Q.M., Ma, X.H., Cheng, B.P., Zhou, E. and Pang, W. (2020) GANs-Based Data Augmentation for Citrus Disease Severity Detection Using Deep Learning. IEEE Access, 8, 172882-172891. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3025196
[23]	Hayit, T., Erbay, H., Varçın, F., Hayit, F. AND Akci, N. (2021) Determination of the Severity Level of Yellow Rust Disease in Wheat by Using Convolutional Neural Networks. Journal of Plant Pathology, 103, 923-934. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42161-021-00886-2
[24]	Verma, S., Chug, A. and Singh, A.P. (2020) Impact of Hyperparameter Tuning on Deep Learning Based Estimation of Disease Severity in Grape Plant. In: Ghazali, R., Nawi, N., Deris, M. and Abawajy, J., Eds., SCDM 2020: Recent Advances on Soft Computing and Data Mining, Springer, Cham, 161-171. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-36056-6_16
[25]	Esgario, J.G.M., Krohling, R.A. and Ventura, J.A. (2020) Deep Learning for Classification and Severity Estimation of Coffee Leaf Biotic Stress. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 169, Article ID: 105162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compag.2019.105162
[26]	Gonçalves, J.P., Pinto, F.A.C., Queiroz, D.M., Villar, F.M.M., Barbedo, J.G.A. and Del Ponte, E.M. (2021) Deep Learning Architectures for Semantic Segmentation and Automatic Estimation of Severity of Foliar Symptoms Caused by Diseases or Pests. Biosystems Engineering, 210, 129-142. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biosystemseng.2021.08.011
[27]	Wijekoon, C.P., Goodwin, G.H. and Hsiang, T. (2008) Quantifying Fungal Infection of Plant Leaves by Digital Image Analysis Using Scion Image Software. Journal of Microbiological Methods, 74, 94-101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mimet.2008.03.008
[28]	Shen, W.Z., Wu, Y.C., Chen, Z.L. and Wei, H.D. (2008) Grading Method of Leaf Spot Disease Based on Image Processing. 2008 International Conference on Computer Science and Software Engineering, Wuhan, 12-14 December 2008, 491-494. https://doi.org/10.1109/CSSE.2008.1649
[29]	Patil, S.B. and Bodhe, S.K. (2011) Leaf Disease Severity Measurement Using Image Processing. International Journal of Engineering & Technology, 3, 297-301.
[30]	Pethybridge, S.J. and Nelson, S.C. (2015) Leaf Doctor: A Newportable Application for Quantifying Plant Disease Severity. Plant Disease, 99, 1310-1316. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-03-15-0319-RE
[31]	Owomugisha, G. and Mwebaze, E. (2016) Machine Learning for Plant Disease Incidence and Severity Measurements from Leaf Images. 2016 15th IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning and Applications (ICMLA), Anaheim, 18-20 December 2016, 158-163.
[32]	Palma, D., Blanchini, F. and Montessoro, P. (2022) A System-Theoretic Approach for Image-Based Infectious Plant Disease Severity Estimation. PLOS ONE, 17, e0272002. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0272002
[33]	Abdulridha, J., Ampatzidis, Y., Qureshi, J. and Roberts, P. (2022) Identification and Classification of Downy Mildew Severity Stages in Watermelon Utilizing Aerial and Ground Remote Sensing and Machine Learning. Frontiers in Plant Science, 13, Article 791018. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2022.791018
[34]	Jiang, Q., Wang, H. and Wang, H. (2023) Severity Assessment of Wheat Stripe Rust Based on Machine Learning. Frontiers in Plant Science, 14, Article 1150855. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2023.1150855
[35]	Sharma, R., Kukreja, V. and Sakshi (2021) Mustard Downy Mildew Disease Severity Detection Using Deep Learning Model. 2021 International Conference on Decision Aid Sciences and Application (DASA), Sakheer, 7-8 December 2021, 466-470. https://doi.org/10.1109/DASA53625.2021.9682305
[36]	Baliyan, A., Kukreja, V., Salonki, V. and Kaswan, K.S. (2021) Detection of Corn Gray Leaf Spot Severity Levels Using Deep Learning Approach. 2021 9th International Conference on Reliability, Infocom Technologies and Optimization (Trends and Future Directions) (ICRITO), Noida, 3-4 September 2021, 1-5. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICRITO51393.2021.9596540
[37]	Verma, S., Chug, A. and Singh, A.P. (2020) Application of Convolutional Neural Networks for Evaluation of Disease Severity in Tomato Plant. Journal of Discrete Mathematical Sciences and Cryptography, 23, 273-282. https://doi.org/10.1080/09720529.2020.1721890
[38]	Salonki, V., Baliyan, A., Kukreja, V. and Siddiqui, K.M. (2021) Tomato Spotted Wilt Disease Severity Levels Detection: A Deep Learning Methodology. 2021 8th International Conference on Signal Processing and Integrated Networks (SPIN), Noida, 26-27 August 2021, 361-366. https://doi.org/10.1109/SPIN52536.2021.9566053
[39]	Mubarokah, I., Laksono, P., Cepy, Safitri, R. and Idris, I. (2022) Detection of Begomovirus Disease for Identification of Disease Severity Level in Tomato Leaves Using Convolutional Neural Network (CNN). 2022 International Symposium on Electronics and Smart Devices (ISESD), Bandung, I8-9 November 2022, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1109/ISESD56103.2022.9980675
[40]	Lamba, S., Baliyan, A., Kukreja, V. and Tripathy, R. (2023) An Ensemble (CNN-LSTM) Model for Severity Detection of Bacterial Blight Rice Disease. In: Marriwala, N., Tripathi, C., Jain, S. and Kumar, D., Eds., Mobile Radio Communications and 5G Networks, Springer, Singapore, 159-171. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7982-8_14
[41]	Mehta, S., Kukreja, V. and Yadav, R. (2023) Advanced Mango Leaf Disease Detection and Severity Analysis with Federated Learning and CNN. 2023 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Technologies (CONIT), Hubli, 23-25 June 2023, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1109/CONIT59222.2023.10205922
[42]	Pan, J.C., Xia, L.M., Wu, Q.F., Guo, Y.X., Chen, Y.P. and Tian, X.L. (2022) Automatic Strawberry Leaf Scorch Severity Estimation via Faster R-CNN and Few-Shot Learning. Ecological Informatics, 70, Article ID: 101706. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2022.101706
[43]	Zhang, Y. and Yang, Q. (2021) A Survey on Multi-Task Learning. IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering, 34, 5586-5609. https://doi.org/10.1109/TKDE.2021.3070203
[44]	Xiang, S., Liang, Q., Sun, W., Zhang, D. and Wang, Y. (2021) L-CSMS: Novel Lightweight Network for Plant Disease Severity Recognition. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection, 128, 557-569. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41348-020-00423-w
[45]	Bhujel, A., Khan, F., Basak, J.K., Jaihuni, M., Thavisack, S., Moon, B.E., Park, J. and Kim, H.T. (2022) Detection of Gray Mold Disease and Its Severity on Strawberry Using Deep Learning Networks. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection, 129, 579-592. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41348-022-00578-8
[46]	Dhiman, A. and Saroha, V. (2022) Detection of Severity of Disease in Paddy Leaf by Integrating Edge Detection to CNN-Based Model. 2022 9th International Conference on Computing for Sustainable Global Development (INDIACom), New Delhi, 23-25 March 2022, 470-475. https://doi.org/10.23919/INDIACom54597.2022.9763128
[47]	Jindal, V., Nagpal, Y. and Kukreja, V. (2022) CNN Implementation for Severity Levels of Potato Blight Disease. 2022 International Conference on Data Analytics for Business and Industry (ICDABI), Sakhir, 25-26 October 2022, 438-443. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICDABI56818.2022.10041501
[48]	Sreedevi, A. and Manike, C. (2022) A Smart Solution for Tomato Leaf Disease Classification by Modified Recurrent Neural Network with Severity Computation. Cybernetics and Systems. https://doi.org/10.1080/01969722.2022.2122004
[49]	Su, W.H., Zhang, J., Yang, C., Page, R., Szinyei, T., Hirsch, C.D. and Steffenson, B.J. (2021) Automatic Evaluation of Wheat Resistance to Fusarium Head Blight Using Dual Mask-RCNN Deep Learning Frameworks in Computer Vision. Remote Sensing, 13, Article 26. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs13010026
[50]	Pillay, N., Gerber, M., Holan, K., Whitham, S.A. and Berger, D.K. (2021) Quantifying the Severity of Common Rust in Maize Using Mask R-CNN. In: Rutkowski, L., Scherer, R., Korytkowski, M., Pedrycz, W., Tadeusiewicz, R. and Zurada, J.M., Eds., ICAISC 2021: Artificial Intelligence and Soft Computing, Springer, Cham, 202-213. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-87986-0_18
[51]	Gerber, M., Pillay, N., Holan, K., Whitham, S.A. and Berger, D.K. (2021) Automated Hyper-Parameter Tuning of a Mask R-CNN for Quantifying Common Rust Severity in Maize. 2021 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN), Shenzhen, 18-22 July 2021, 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1109/IJCNN52387.2021.9534417
[52]	Faye, D., Diop, I., Mbaye, N., Diedhiou, M.M. and Dione, D. (2023) Mango Fruit DDS. Mendeley Data, V3.