Temple as the Site of Struggle: Social Reform, Religious Symbols and the Politics of Nationalism in Kerala

M. R. Manmathan

Department of History, Farook College, Calicut University, Kerala, India.

DOI: 10.4236/ahs.2013.22010                

Abstract

The temple entry movement of the 1920s and ’30s in Kerala, South India, has become a landmark in the history of social reform and nationalist movements for its uniqueness and sweeping success. Popular history has presented the episode as an integral part of the Nationalist Movement and the Gandhian Constructive Programme mainly because the temple-entry issue was endorsed by the Kerala State Congress Committee and the agitation was concluded under its auspices. But this popular and idealist impression of the movement has been challenged from various quarters. It is pointed out that there have been very little attempts at linking the event with the advancing civic rights movement led by the lower caste people for freedom of worship and social equality which was gaining a radical turn by the 20s and 30s; the pressure exerted by the untouchables to achieve civic freedom even at the cost of renouncing Hinduism had created an alarming situation which no caste-Hindu could ignore. Even more surprising is the absence of academic attempts to link the agitation with the Malabar Rebellion of 1921; in fact the Rebellion had challenged the very survival of the Congress organization in Kerala; this factor forced them to retreat from the earlier secular plane to a religious idiom of politics for which the question of temple-entry served their purpose. The Temple entry movement, therefore, has to be studied in the light of the antipathy shown by the Congress towards popular and radical agitations and in the context of its growing tendency to incline towards Hindu symbols in politics as a means to escape addressing vital and burning social issues.

Keywords

Temple-Entry; Constructive Program; Vaikam Satyagraha; 1921 Rebellion; Religious

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Aiya, V. N. (1906). The Travancore State manual, I&II. Trivandrum: Travancore Government Press.
[2]	Cornish, W. R. (1874). The census of India 1871, Madras Vol. I, Report. Madras: Government Press.
[3]	Hitchcock, R. H. (1925). A history of the Malabar rebellion, 1921. Madras: Government Press.
[4]	Innes, C. A. (1908). Madras District gazetteers, Malabar I. Madras: Government Press.
[5]	Logan, M. (1882). Report of the Malabar special commission 1881-2, I. Madras: Government Press.
[6]	Logan, W. (1887). Malabar manual, I. Madras: Government Press.
[7]	McIvery, L. (1883). Census of India, 1881, Madras, Vol. I, Report. Madras: Government Press.
[8]	Menon, C. A. (1911). Cochin State manual. Ernakulam: Government Press.
[9]	Menon, M. Sankara. (1901). Census of India, Vol. 20 (Cochin) Part I (Report). Ernakulam: Government Press.
[10]	Pillai, T. K. V. (1940). Travancore State manual, Vol. I. Trivandrum: Travancore Government Press.
[11]	Proceedings of the Conference held at Mr. Idamturuttil Devan Neelakantan Nambutiripad’s House, Vaikam on 10 March 1925. Correspondence on the Vaikam Satyagraha, Vol IX, English Records, Secretariat, Trivandrum.
[12]	Stuert, H. A. (1893). Census of India, 1891, Madras, Part. I Report. Madras: Government Press.
[13]	Tottenham, G. R. F. (1922). The Mappila rebellion, 1921-22. Madras: Government Press.
[14]	Autobiographies
[15]	Kesavan, C. (1968). Jeevitasamaram. Kottayam: National Book Stall.
[16]	Maulavi, M. (1981). Atmakatha. Kottayam: SPCS/National Book Stall.
[17]	Menon, K. P. K. (1986). Kazhinja Kaalam. Calicut: Mathrubhumi Books.
[18]	Nambutiripad, E. M. S. (2005). Atmakatha (6th ed.). Thiruvananthapuram: Chintha Publishers.
[19]	Books
[20]	Aiyappan, A. (1944). Iravas and culture change. Madras Government Museum Bulletin, 1.
[21]	Aloysius, G. (2010). Nationalism without a nation in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
[22]	Anderson, B. (1983). Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. London: Verso Editions and NLB.
[23]	Ansari, M. T. (2005). Refiguring the fanatic: Malabar, 1836-1922. In S. Mayaram, M. S. S. Pandyan, & A. Skaria (Eds.), Subaltern studies, XII (pp. 36-77). Delhi: Permanent Black and Ravi Dayal.
[24]	Asan, K. (1969). Duravastha (Distress). Trivandrum: Sarada Book Depot (Rpt).
[25]	Brown, J. M. (1972). Gandhi’s rise to power: Indian politics, 1915-1922. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[26]	Chand, T. (1972). History of the freedom movement in India, III. New Delhi: New Delhi Publications Division, Government of India.
[27]	Chandra, B. (1989). India’s struggle for independence 1857-1947. New Delhi: Penguin Books.
[28]	Chatterjee, P. (1989). Caste and subaltern consciousness. In R. Guha (Ed.), Subaltern studies: Writings on South Asian history and society, No. 6 (pp. 169-209). Delhi: Oxford University Press.
[29]	Chatterjee, P. (1995). History and the nationalization of Hinduism. In V. Dalmia, & H. Von Steitencron (Eds.), Representing Hinduism: The contraction of religious tradition and national identity (pp. 103-128). New Delhi: Sage Publications.
[30]	Cooiman, D. (1995). Communities and electorates: A comparative discussion of communalism in colonial India. Amsterdam: V.U. University Press.
[31]	Dale, S. F. (1980). Islamic society on the South Asian frontier: The Mappilas of Malabar, 1498-1922. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
[32]	Day, F. (1863). The land of Perumals or Cochin and its past and its present. Madras: Oantz Brothers at the Adelphi Press.
[33]	Gangadharan, M. (2008). The Malabar rebellion. Kottayam: D.C. Books.
[34]	Hardgrave Jr., R. L. (1969). The Nadars of Tamilnad: The political culture of a community in change. Berkeley: University of California Press.
[35]	Isaac, T. M. T. & Tharakan, P. K. M. (1988). Sree Narayana movement in Travancore. In S. K. Sreevastava & L. Sreevastava (Eds), Social movements for development (pp. 155-177). Allahabad: Chugh Publications.
[36]	Iyer, L. A. K. (1909). The Cochin Tribes and castes. Madras: Higginbotham’s.
[37]	Iyer, L. A. K. (1939). The Travancore Tribes and castes. Trivandrum: Government Press.
[38]	Jeffrey, R. (1978a). Travancore: Status, class and the growth of radical politics, 1869-1940—The temple entry movement. In R. Jeffrey, (Ed.), People, princes and paramount power: Society and politics in the Indian princely states (pp. 136-169). Delhi: Oxford University Press.
[39]	Jeffrey, R. (1994). Decline of Nair dominance: Society and politics in Travancore, 1847-1908. New Delhi: Manohar.
[40]	Kawashima, K. (1988). Missionaries and a Hindu state: Travancore 1858-1936. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
[41]	Kunhuraman, C. V. (1936). Izhavarude mathaparivarthana samrambham (Religious conversion enterprise of the Izhavas). Kottayam: Kaumudi Press.
[42]	Kunju, A. P. I. (1989). Mappila Muslims of Kerala. Trivandrum: Sandhya Publishers.
[43]	Lemercinier, G. (1984). Religion and ideology in Kerala. Delhi: D. K. Agencies.
[44]	Manavalan, P. (1990). Kerala samskaravum Kraistava missionarimarum (Kerala culture and Christian missionaries). Kottayam: DC Books.
[45]	Mateer, S. (1871). The land of charity: A descriptive account of Travancore and its people. London: John Snow & Co.
[46]	Mateer, S. (1883). Native life in Travancore. London: W. H. Allen & Co.
[47]	Mathew, G. (1989). Communal road to a secular Kerala. New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company.
[48]	Menon, A. S. (1984). A survey of Kerala history. Madras: S. Viswanathan Pvt Ltd.
[49]	Menon, A. S. (1997). Kerala and the freedom struggle. Kottayam: D.C. Books.
[50]	Menon, D. M. (1994). Caste, nationalism and communism in South India: Malabar, 1900-1948. New Delhi: Cambridge University Press.
[51]	Menon, K. P. K. (1977). Some aspects of the nationalist movement in Malabar. In K. P. S. Menon (Ed.), Kesava Menon (pp. 43-48). Calicut: K. P. Kesava Menon 90th Birthday Celebration Committee.
[52]	Menon, P. K. K. (2001). History of the freedom movement in Kerala, Vol. II. Thiruvananthapuram: Department of Cultural Publications.
[53]	Menon, M. G. (1989). Malabar rebellion, 1921-1922. Allahabad: Vohra Publishers.
[54]	Miller, R. E. (1992). Mappila Muslims of Kerala: A study in Islamic trends. Madras: Orient Longman.
[55]	Misra, A. (2004). Identity and religion: Foundations of anti-Islamism in India. New Delhi: Sage Publishers.
[56]	Nair, G. G. (1923). The Moplah rebellion, 1921. Calicut: Norman Printing Bureau.
[57]	Nair, K. M. (2002). Malabar kalapam (Malabar rebellion). Calicut: Mathrubhumi Books.
[58]	Nambutiripad, E. M. S (1952). The national question in Kerala. Bombay: People’s Publishing House.
[59]	Nambutiripad, M. B. (1965). Khilafat smaranakal (Khilafat reminiscences). Kozhikkode: Navakerala Co-operative Publishing House.
[60]	Narayanan, M. G. S., & Kesavan, V. (1983). A history of the Nambutiri community in Kerala. In F. Stall (Ed.), Agni: The Vedic ritual of the fire altar (pp. 256-278). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidas.
[61]	Onwerkerk, L. (1994). No elephants for the Maharaja: Social and political change in Travancore 1921-47. New Delhi: Manohar Publishers.
[62]	Panikkar, K. N. (1984). Peasant exploitation in Malabar in the nineteenth century. Journal of Kerala Studies, 11, 155-185.
[63]	Panikkar, K. N. (1989). Against lord and state: Religion and peasant uprising in Malabar, 1836-1921. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
[64]	Parekh, B. (1989). Colonialism, tradition and reform: An analysis of Gandhi’s political discourse. New Delhi: Sage Publications.
[65]	Pilla, A. K. (1986). Congressum Keralavum (Congress and Kerala). Trivandrum: Prabhath Book House.
[66]	Rao, M. S. A. (1979). Social movements and social transformation: A study of two backward classes movement in India. Delhi: MacMillan.
[67]	Ravindran, T. K. (1988). Vaikam satyagraha and Gandhi. Trivandrum: Sri Narayana Institute of Social and Cultural Development.
[68]	Sarkar, S. (1990). Modern India, 1885-1947. Madras: Macmillan.
[69]	Sitaramayya, P. (1946). The history of the Indian national congress 1885-1936. Bombay: Padma Publications Ltd.
[70]	Sontheimer, G. D. (1995). The erosion of folk religion in modern India: Some points for deliberation. In V. Dalmia, & H. Von Steitencron, (Eds.), Representing Hinduism: The contraction of religious tradition and national identity (pp. 389-398). New Delhi: Sage Publications.
[71]	Thurston, E. (1909). Castes and tribes of southern India, II. Madras: Government Press.
[72]	Viswanathan, G. (2003). Colonialism and the construction of Hinduism. In G. Flood (Ed.), The Blackwell companion to Hinduism (pp. 23-44). Oxford: Blackwell. doi:10.1002/9780470998694.ch2
[73]	Von Stietencron, H. (1989). Hinduism: On the proper use of a deceptive term. In G. D. Sontheimer, & H. Kulke (Eds.), Hinduism reconsidered. Delhi: Manohar.
[74]	Wood, C. (1987). The Moplah rebellion and its genesis. New Delhi: People’s Publishing House.
[75]	Yesudas, R. N. (1975). A people’s revolt in Travancore: A backward class movement for social freedom. Ernakulam: Kerala Historical Society.
[76]	Young, R. F. (1981). Resistant Hinduism: Sanskrit sources on anti-Christian apologetics in early nineteenth century India. Vienna: De Nobili Research Library.
[77]	Zaynu’d-Din, S. (1942). Tuhfat-al-Mujahidin. Translated by S. M. H. Nainar. Madras: University of Madras.
[78]	Articles
[79]	Basu, R. S. (2008). Pulayas in Kerala: The nineteenth century emancipation question re-explored. The ICFAI University Journal of History and Culture, 2, 47-76.
[80]	Dale, S. F. (1975). The Mappila outbreaks: Ideology and social conflict in nineteenth century Kerala. Journal of Asian Studies, XXXV, 85-97.
[81]	Dale, S. F. (1976). The Mappilas during Mysorean rule: Agrarian conflict in eighteenth-century Malabar. South Asia, 6, 1-13.
[82]	Damodaran, N. P. (1981). Oru sathyagrahathinte katha (The story of a satyagraha). Mathrubhumi Weekly, 22-25.
[83]	Dhanagare, D. N. (1977). Agrarian conflict, religion and politics: The Moplah rebellion in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Past and Present, 74, 112-141. doi:10.1093/past/74.1.112
[84]	Gopalankutty, K. (1981). The Guruvayur satyagraha, 1931-32. Journal of Kerala Studies, 8, 43-55
[85]	Gough, K. (1968-1969). Peasant resistance and revolt in South India. Pacific Affairs, XVI, 526-554. doi:10.2307/2754563
[86]	Hardgrave Jr., R. L. (1968). Breast cloth controversy: Caste consciousness and social change in southern Travancore. Indian Economic and Social History Review, 5, 171-187.
[87]	Hardgrave Jr., R. L. (1977). The Mappilla rebellion, 1921: Peasant revolt in Malabar. Modern Asian Studies, 11, 57-99. doi:10.1017/S0026749X00013226
[88]	Heimsath, C. H. (1978). The functions of Hindu reformers—With special reference to Kerala. The Indian Economic and Social History Review, XV, 21-39. doi:10.1177/001946467801500102
[89]	Heimsath, C. H. (1982). From social reform to social struggle. Man and Development, IV, 29-34.
[90]	Houtart, F., & Lemercinier, G. (1978). Socio-religious reform movements in Kerala: A reaction to the capitalist mode of production. Social Scientist, 6, 25-43. doi:10.2307/3516673
[91]	Jeffrey, R. (1974). The social origins of a caste association, 1875-1905: The founding of the S.N.D.P. Yogam. South Asia, 4, 39-59.
[92]	Jeffrey, R. (1978b). Matriliny, marxism and the birth of the communist party in Kerala, 1930-1940. Journal of Asian Studies, XXXVIII, 77-98.
[93]	Kelappan, K. (1925). Vaikam satyagraham. Matrubhumi Onam Special, 42-45.
[94]	Kelappan, K. (1932a). Mathavum samudayavum: Mathaparivarthana sramam kondulla dosham (Religion and community: The harms caused by religious conversion). Matrubhumi Weekly, 10, 7-8.
[95]	Kelappan, K. (1932b). Mathavum samudayavum: Oru swathantra government cheyyendathenthellam (Religion and community: What should an independent government do). Mathrubhumi Weekly, 10, 4-5.
[96]	Kunhuraman, C. V. (1925). Tiyyarku nallathu buddhamatham thanne (Buddhism is better for the tiyyas). Mitavadi Special, II, 6-24.
[97]	Menon, D. M. (1999). Houses by the sea: State formation experiments in Malabar, 1760-1800. Economic and Political Weekly, 34, 1995-2003.
[98]	Muralidharan, M. (1996). Hindu community formation in Kerala: Processes and structures under colonial modernity. South Indian Studies, 2, 234-259.
[99]	Nambutiripad, E. M. S. (1937). Congress socialist. 7-9.
[100]	Nambutiripad, K. S. (1932). Matha parishkaram (Religious reform). Mathrubhumi Weekly, 10, 7-8.
[101]	Narayanan, M. G. S. (2011). Malayala manorama. Sunday Supplement, IX.
[102]	Pulapilly, C. K. (1976).The izhavas of Kerala and their historic struggle for acceptance in the Hindu society. Journal of Asian and African Studies, XI, 24-46. doi:10.2307/3516673
[103]	Thampan, M. R. V. (1932). Kshetra pravesanam (Temple-entry). Mathrubhumi Weekly, 9, 5-6.