Questioning the Weber Thesis: Capitalist Ethics and the Hebrew Bible?

Sigmund Wagner-Tsukamoto
DOI: 10.4236/sm.2012.21001                

Abstract

Weber’s thesis proposed that it was ascetic Protestantism which supported the emergence of modern capitalism in 17th and 18th century Europe, and that this was a completely new and unique phenomenon in the history of mankind up to that point in time. This paper casts doubt on the Weber thesis by examining findings from an economic reconstruction of the Hebrew Bible, and proposing that modern capitalism the way Weber understood it is already visible in the ancient religious text of the “Hebrew Bible”. By means of institutional economic reconstruction, I show that the Hebrew Bible and particularly the stories involving Jacob and Joseph reveal a conceptual structure that can be compared with ideas of modern constitutional and institutional economics. Through this reconstruction, I find myself in agreement with one of Weber’s early but largely forgotten adversaries, Werner Sombart, who suggested, in a behavioral tradition, that other religions, and more specifically Jewish thought, contributed to the emergence of modern capitalism long before the advent of Protestantism.

Keywords

Weber Thesis; Sombart Thesis; Capitalist Ethics of the Hebrew Bible; Capitalist Ethics of Religion

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Armstrong, K. (1996). In the beginning. A new reading of the book of genesis. London: Harper-Collins.
[2]	Ashtor, E. (1983). The Jews and the Mediterranean economy, 10th-15th Centuries. London: Variorum.
[3]	Axelrod, R. (1984). The evolution of cooperation. New York: Basic Books.
[4]	Barbalet, J. (2006). Max Weber and Judaism: An insight into the methodology of The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. Max Weber Studies, 6, 51-67.
[5]	Baron, Salo W. (1975a). The Muslim Middle Ages. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic history of the Jews (pp. 25-34). Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem.
[6]	Baron, Salo W. (1975b). Medieval Christendom. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic History of the Jews. Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem. pp. 35-47.
[7]	Baron, Salo W. (1975c). The early modern period. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic history of the Jews (pp. 55-78). Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem.
[8]	Baron, Salo W. (1975d). The modern period. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic history of the Jews (pp. 83-104). Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem.
[9]	Beller, S. (1995). Review of Jews in the Hungarian economy, 1760- 1945. Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 25, 715-716. doi:10.2307/205824
[10]	Block, W. (2004) The Jews and capitalism: A love-hate enigma. The Journal of Social, Political, and Economic Studies, 29, 305-326.
[11]	Blom, J. C., & Cahen, J. J. (2002). Jewish Netherlanders, Netherlands Jews, and Jews in the Netherlands, 1870-1914. In J. C. Blom, R. G. Fuks-Mansfeld, & I. Schoeffer (Eds.), The history of the Jews in the Netherlands (pp. 230-295). Oxford: Littman Library.
[12]	Bloom, H. I. (1959). Felix libertate and the Emancipation of Dutch Jewry. In J. L. Blau (Ed.), Essays on Jewish life and thought (pp. 105-122). New York: Columbia University Press.
[13]	Brenner, M. A. (1997). Economic ascent. In M. A. Meyer (Ed.), German-Jewish history in modern times, Vol. 2 (pp. 301-308). New York: Columbia University Press.
[14]	Buchanan, J. M. (1975). The limits of liberty. Between Anarchy and Leviathan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[15]	Carr, P. (2003). Revisiting the protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism: Understanding the relationship between Ethics and Enterprise. Journal of Business Ethics, 47, 7-16. doi:10.1023/A:1026232726129
[16]	Cheung, T. S., & King, Y. A. (2004). Righteousness and profitableness: The moral choices of contemporary Confucian entrepreneurs. Journal of Business Ethics, 54, 245-260. doi:10.1007/s10551-004-6405-6
[17]	Child, J. (1964). Quaker employers and industrial relations. Sociolo- gical Review, 12, 293-313. doi:10.1111/j.1467-954X.1964.tb01260.x
[18]	Davidson, R. (1979). Genesis 12-50. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[19]	Don, Y. (1992). Patterns of Jewish economic behaviour in central Europe in the 20th century. In M. K. Silber (Ed.), Jews in the Hungarian Economy, 1760-1945 (pp. 247-273). Jerusalem: Magnes Press/Hebrew University.
[20]	Fishman, A. (1989). The religious kibbutz: A note on the theories of Marx, Sombart, and Weber on Judaism and economic success. Sociological Analysis, 50, 281-290.
[21]	Fuks-Mansfeld, R. G. (2002a). Enlightenment and emancipation, from c.1750 to 1814. In J. C. Blom, G. R. Fuks-Mansfeld, & I. Schoeffer (Eds.), The history of the Jews in the Netherlands (pp. 164-191). Oxford: Littman Library.
[22]	Fuks-Mansfeld, R. G. (2002b). Arduous adaptation, 1814-1870. In J. C. Blom, R. G. Fuks-Mansfeld, & I. Schoeffer (Eds.), The history of the Jews in the Netherlands (pp. 192-229). Oxford: Littman Library.
[23]	Giddens, A. (1976). Introduction. In M. Weber (Ed.), The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (pp. 1-17). London: Allen and Unwin.
[24]	Gordon, B. (1989). The economic problem in biblical and patristic thought. Leiden, New York: Brill.
[25]	Gorski, P. S. (2005). The little divergence. The protestant reformation and economic hegemony in early modern Europe. In W. H. Swatos, & L. Kaelber (Eds.), The Protestant Ethic turns 100. Essays on the centenary of the Weber Thesis (pp. 165-190). London: Paradigm Publishers.
[26]	Graves, R., & Patai, R. (1964). Hebrew myths. The book of genesis. London: Cassell.
[27]	Grundmann, R., & Stehr, N. (2001). Why is Werner Sombart not part of the core of classical sociology?: From fame to (near) oblivion. Journal of Classical Sociology, 1, 257-287. doi:10.1177/14687950122232558
[28]	Hanak, P. (1992). Jews and the modernization of commerce in Hungary, 1760-1848. In M. K. Silber (Ed.), Jews in the Hungarian economy, 1760-1945 (pp. 23-39). Jerusalem: Magnes Press/Hebrew University.
[29]	Johanek, P. (1999). Merchants, markets and towns. In T. Reuter (Ed.), The new Cambridge medieval history, Vol. III, c.900-c.1024 (pp. 64-94). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[30]	Kaelber, L. (2005). Rational capitalism, traditionalism, and adventure capitalism. New research on the Weber Thesis. In W. H. Swatos, & L. Kaelber (Eds.), The protestant ethic turns 100. Essays on the centenary of the Weber Thesis (pp. 139-163). London: Paradigm Publishers.
[31]	Kahan, A. (1986). Essays in Jewish social and economic history. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[32]	Kaplan, L. (1975). Metals and mining. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic history of the Jews (pp. 173-178). Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem.
[33]	Kugel, J. L. (1997). The Bible as it was. London: Belknap/Harvard University Press.
[34]	Landheer, B. (1951). Review of Werner Sombart’s the Jews and Modern Capitalism. American Sociological Review, 16, 587-588.
[35]	Lehmann, H. (1993). The rise of capitalism: Weber versus Sombart. In H. Lehmann, & G. Roth (Eds.), Weber’s protestant ethic: Origins, evidence, contexts (pp. 195-208). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[36]	Lehmann, H. (2005). Friends and foes. The formation and the consolidation of the protestant ethic thesis. In W. H. Swatos, & L. Kaelber (Eds.), The protestant ethic turns 100. Essays on the centenary of the Weber Thesis (pp. 1-22). London: Paradigm Publishers.
[37]	MacKinnon, M. H. (1993). The longevity of the thesis: A critique of the critics. In H. Lehmann, & G. Roth (Eds.), Weber’s protestant ethic: Origins, evidence, contexts (pp. 211-243). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[38]	Marx, K. (1967). On the Jewish question. In K. Marx (Ed.), The writings of young Marx on philosophy and society (pp. 216-248). Garden City: Doubleday.
[39]	Mosse, W. E. (1987). Jews in the German economy. The German- Jewish elite 1820-1935. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
[40]	Nipperdey, T. (1993). Max Weber, Protestantism, and the debate around 1900. In H. Lehmann, & G. Roth (Eds.), Weber’s protestant ethic: Origins, evidence, contexts (pp. 73-81). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[41]	North, D. C., & Thomas, R. P. (1973). The rise of the western world. A new economic history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[42]	North, D. C., & Weingast, B. R. (1989). Constitutions and commitment: The evolution of institutions governing public choice in seventeenth- century England. The Journal of Economic History, 49, 803-832. doi:10.1017/S0022050700009451
[43]	Parsons, T. (1928-1929). “Capitalism” in recent German literature: Sombart and Weber. Journal of Political Economy, 36-37, 641-661. doi:10.1086/253984
[44]	Plaut, W. G. (1981). The Torah. A modern commentary. New York: Union of American Hebrew Congregation..
[45]	Pohl, H. (1975). Sugar trade and industry. In N. Gross (Ed.), Economic history of the Jews (pp. 189-190). Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Jerusalem.
[46]	Pollins, H. (1982). Economic history of the Jews in England. London: Associated University Press.
[47]	Rad von, G. (1963). Genesis. A commentary. London: SCM Press.
[48]	Schmidt, W. H. (1984). Introduction to the Old Testament. London: SCM Press.
[49]	Silber, M. K. (1992). Jews in the Hungarian economy, 1760-1945. Jerusalem: Magnes Press/Hebrew University.
[50]	Sombart, W. (1902). Der moderne Kapitalismus. Ester band: Die genesis des Kapitalismus. Leipzig: Duncker and Humblot.
[51]	Sombart, W. (1911). Die Juden und das Wirtschaftsleben. Leipzig: Duncker and Humblot.
[52]	Sombart, W. (1913). The Jews and modern capitalism. New York: Burt Franklin.
[53]	Sombart, W. (1915). The quintessence of capitalism: A study of the history and psychology of the modern businessman. London: T. F. Unwin.
[54]	Sombart, W. (1922). Der moderne Kapitalismus: Historisch-systematische Darstellung des gesamteurop?ischen Wirtschaftsleben von seinen Anf?ngen bis zur Gegenwart. München, Leipzig: Duncker and Humblot.
[55]	Swatos, W. H., & Kivisto, P. (2005). The contexts of the publication and reception of the protestant ethic. In W. H. Swatos, & Kaelber, L. (Eds.), The protestant ethic turns 100. Essays on the centenary of the Weber Thesis (pp. 111-137). London: Paradigm Publishers.
[56]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2001). Economics of genesis. On the institutional economic deciphering and reconstruction of the legends of genesis. Journal of Interdisciplinary Economics, 12, 249-287.
[57]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2003). Human nature and organization theory. On the economic approach to institutional organization. Cheltenham, New York: Edward Elgar.
[58]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2005). An economic approach to business ethics: Moral agency of the firm and the enabling and constraining effects of economic institutions and interactions in a market economy. Journal of Business Ethics, 60, 75-89. doi:10.1007/s10551-005-5842-1
[59]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2007). An institutional economic reconstruction of scientific management: On the lost theoretical logic of Taylorism. Academy of Management Review, 32, 105-117. doi:10.5465/AMR.2007.23463879
[60]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2008a). An economic reading of the Exodus: On the institutional economic reconstruction of biblical cooperation failures. Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament, 22, 114-134. doi:10.1080/09018320802185150
[61]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2008b). Scientific management revisited: Did Taylorism fail because of a too positive image of human nature? Journal of Management History, 14, 348-372. doi:10.1108/17511340810893108
[62]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2008c). Contrasting the behavioural business ethics approach and the institutional economic approach to business ethics: Insights from the study of Quaker employers. Journal of Business Ethics, 82, 835-850. doi:10.1007/s10551-007-9596-9
[63]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2009a). Is God an economist? An institutional economic reconstruction of the Old Testament. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
[64]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2009b). The paradise story: A constitutional economic reconstruction. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament, 34, 147- 170. doi:10.1177/0309089209356416
[65]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2010). Out of a slave contract: The analysis of pre-Hobbesian anarchists in the Old Testament. Constitutional Political Economy, 21, 288-307. doi:10.1007/s10602-009-9084-6
[66]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2011). After the theft: Natural distribution states and prisoner’s dilemmas in the Paradise story. Conference Paper Presented at the Conference: “Religion and Capitalism, Societa, Forum for Ethics, Arts, and Law & Religion and Transformation in Contemporary European Society”, Vienna: University of Vienna. http://hdl.handle.net/2381/9828
[67]	Wagner-Tsukamoto, S. A. (2012) The tree of life: Banned or not banned? A rational choice interpretation. Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament (forthcoming).
[68]	Weber, M. (1924). Wirtschaftsgeschichte. Leipzig: Duncker and Humblot.
[69]	Weber, M. (1952). Ancient Judaism. London: Allen and Unwin.
[70]	Weber, M. (1965). The sociology of religion. London: Methuen.
[71]	Weber, M. (1968). Economy and society. New York: Bedminster Press.
[72]	Weber, M. (1976). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. London: Allen and Unwin.
[73]	Weber, M. (2001). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. London: Routledge.
[74]	Weber, M. (2002). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism and other writings. New York: Penguin.
[75]	Westermann, C. (1986). Genesis 12-36. A commentary. London: SPCK.
[76]	Williamson, O. (1985). The economic institutions of capitalism. New York: Free Press.