Neurological Disorders among the Outpatients Living with Human Immuno Deficiency Virus (HIV) Following at the Parakou Hospital in 2014

DOI: 10.4236/nm.2019.103014   PDF   HTML   XML   315 Downloads   589 Views  


Objective: To study the frequency of neurological disorders associated to HIV infection. Methods: This cross-sectional study was carried out from 16th June to 16th September 2014 and included all 289 HIV-outpatients admitted to the Parakou University hospital. All data were recorded, physical examination was performed and the medical sheet of each patient was assessed. The diagnosis of neurological disorder (central and peripheral) was based on clinical features, past medical history, biological test and CT-scan data after multidisciplinary staff. Epi-data and Epi-Info 6.04C were used to perform analysis. Results: They were 73 (25.3%) male with a mean age of 38.0 years +/ 10.1 years. The mean duration of disease was 48.5 months +/ 37.1 months. 150 (51.9%) of them were at Stage 3 of the disease. All patients (99.7%) were infected by HIV1, 188 (76.1%) had CD4 cells at the onset of the follow-up less than 350 cells/mm3 and 260 (90.0%) were on ART. Among the 289 patients, 110 had at least one neurological disorder, the frequency of neurological disorders was 38.1%. The main neurological disorders were peripheral neuropathy (34.3%), isolated headache (5.2%), stroke (0.7%), cerebral toxoplasmosis (0.7%) and one case of dementia (0.7%). The main associated factors were the age of patient and exposure on neurotoxic drug, especially ART. Conclusion: The neurological disorders were more frequent among HIV patients with a high frequency of peripheral neuropathy probably due to ART.

Share and Cite:

Thierry, A. , Mendinatou, A. , Jolianelle, D. , Rhonel, A. , Arsene, K. , Oyéné, K. , Gottfried, A. , Albert, D. and Dismand, H. (2019) Neurological Disorders among the Outpatients Living with Human Immuno Deficiency Virus (HIV) Following at the Parakou Hospital in 2014. Neuroscience and Medicine, 10, 199-206. doi: 10.4236/nm.2019.103014.

1. Introduction

In sub-Saharan Africa, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) prevalence is 4.7% [1] . According to the WHO, from 2000 to 2020, worldwide HIV-related deaths will be estimated at 68 million, including 55 million in Africa [2] . Since the discovery of the first case in 1985 in Benin, HIV/AIDS prevalence has grown exponentially and hovered around 1.1% in 2012 [3] . Neurological damage associated with HIV infection is common. In previous studies neurological disorders accounted for more than 50% [4] . We reported previously 42.4% of the prevalence of distal sensory polyneuropathy among the HIV outpatients in Parakou [5] . In Bobo-Dioulasso at Burkina Faso Millogo and al reported 14% of neurological disorders in HIV patients [6] . They can occur at all stages of HIV infection and can affect the central nervous system, as well as peripheral nervous system and muscle. This study was conducted with main objective to study the frequency and factors associated with neurological complications of HIV infection in people living with HIV followed ambulatory at CHUD-B/A in Parakou in 2014.

2. Methods of Study

Type of study and period of collection: This was a descriptive and analytical cross-sectional study with prospective data collection from 16 June to 16 September 2014.

Population of study is people living with HIV followed in ambulatory basis in consultation on the care site.

We included patient HIV positive, age more than 15 years old who had given their consent.

Criteria of exclusion were pregnant women infected with HIV and subject who was not able to answer questions.

Sampling was exhaustive with a size of 289 inclusive subjects.

The main dependent variable is neurological complication, whatever the type. After a clinical examination doing by the senior neurologist, study of file and after a validation in staff by a colleague of specialists (neurologist, internist, radiologist), a secondary endpoint is the type of neurological complication whose terms are 3 = certain, 2 = probable, 1 = possible, 0 = no neurological complication, 9 = not researched. Table 1 shows the details of those data..

Data were collected with a standardized questionnaire during interview, observation (interrogation and physical examination doing by the senior neurologists) and document review (patient record).

Ethical considerations: authorization from the hospital management and the

Table 1. Diagnostic criteria for different subtypes of neurological complications.

head of medicine department was obtained prior to the study. Free and informed consent of each participant was obtained prior to inclusion. Confidentiality, rules of courtesy and discretion were respected.

Data were analysed with EPI DATA, EPI-INFO and SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) version 17.0. The quantitative variables were expressed in averages (in case of normal distribution) with their standard deviation, and qualitative variables were expressed in proportion with their confidence interval at 95%. The proportions were compared with the test of chi-square (Khi2) or exact test of Fischer and the means were compared by using Students’ T-test. Statistical significance level was 5%.

3. Results

3.1. Sociodemographic Characteristics

The site of managment of person living with HIV of University hospital of Parakou had an active line of 1100 patients at the start of the study. During the three months of the survey, a total of 334 persons living with HIV had consulted and 289 were included with the participation rate of 86.52%. The mean age was 38.0 ± 10.1 years (21 - 74 years). They were 112 patients of 35 to 45 years (38.8%), 73 male (25.3%) and 216 female (74.7%) with sex ratio of 0.3; 194 lived in couple (67.1%) and the majority were traders 111 (38.4%) or craftsmen 58 (20.1%). Nevertheless, we found 8 students (2.8%) among the persons living with HIV. More than one third of the patients were illiterate 109 (37.7%). Among the educated patients, 96 (33.2%) had primary academic level and 12 (4.2%) had higher academic level.

3.2. Clinical Characteristics

According to the WHO stages, twenty six percent of patients were in stage 1 of HIV infection; 15.6% in stage 2; 51.9% in stage 3 and 6.6% in stage 4. The mean duration of HIV infection was 48.51 months ± 37.13 months with a maximum of 197 months. Personal history of alcohol intake (27.3%), tobacco (2.8%), shingles (17.0%), hypertension (4.5%) and diabetes (0.7%) had been noted. One hundred and one patients (37.7%) were taken neurotoxic drugs including 96 under Stavudine, 10 under Isoniazide and 3 under Didanosine. The main reason for consultation was a neurological sign in 6.6% of cases (19 patients); the neurological signs are summarized in Table 2.

Thus 16 patients had a sensory syndrome (5.5%), 10 patients a peripheral neurogenic syndrome (3.5%), 1 patient a dementia (0.3%), 1 patient a meningitis syndrome (0.3%) and 1 patient an intracranial hypertension syndrome (0.3%).

Table 2. Distribution of neurological signs in people living with HIV, Parakou 2014.

Two hundred and eighty eight patients (99.7%) were infected with HIV 1 and only one patient (0.3%) with HIV 2. An initial CD4 count less than 350 cells/mm3 was found in 188 patients (76.1%); 34 patients (13.8%) had an initial CD4 count between 350 and 500 cells/mm3 and 25 patients (10.1%) greater than 500 cells/mm3.

Two hundred and seventy nine (96.5%) of patients were taking bactrim prophylaxis; 260 (90%) were on antiretroviral therapy. The therapeutic regimens are summarized in Table 3.

AZT = Zidovudine, 3TC = Lamivudine, EFV = Efavirenz, NVP = Nevirapine, ABC = Abacavir, TDF = Tenofovir, LPV/r = Lopinavir/Ritonavir.

3.3. Neurological Complications and Factors Associated

The frequency of neurological complication was 38.1% (110 patients). Diagnosis of these complications was probable in 12.2%, possible in 2.8% and certain in 19.4% of cases. They are summarized in Table 4.

The factors associated to the neurological complications were: age with a frequency of complications at 26% in the 25 - 34 years group and 49.3% in the >45 years group (Chi2 = 15.53; p = 0.0014); and neurotoxic treatments (p = 0.018 Chi2 = 5.53). ART (p = 0.5351) and the CD4 cells count (p = 0.76) were not statistically associated with the frequency of neurological complications. Nevertheless, the mean CD4 count in patients with toxoplasmosis was 190 cells/mm3 and 310.5 cells/mm3 in patients with peripheral neuropathy.

Table 3. Distribution of people living with HIV according to ART protocol established, Parakou 2014.

Table 4. Neurological complications in people living with HIV, Parakou 2014.

3.4. Time of Onset of Neurological Complications According to the Duration of HIV Infection and CD4 Cells Count (Figure 1)

Persistent headaches are the first neurological manifestations that appear on average at 42 months after the discovery of HIV infection.

Persistent headaches, dementia and neuropathies are the first neurological manifestations that appear after ARV therapy. Their mean time to onset was 37 months, 41 months and 47 months respectively after ART.

The comparison of average duration of infection, mean duration of ART, mean CD4 count and mean age according to neurological or non-neurological complications is summarized in Table 5. The patients with neurological disorders were elder than those without neurological disorders and had a long duration of the disease.

4. Discussion

Patients were young, as patients living with HIV in sub-Saharan Africa [6] . However, the prevalence of neurological complications increased with age in this study. Average age of patients with neurological complications 40.7 years

Figure 1. Neurological manifestations of HIV according to the duration of the disease and CD4, Parakou 2014.

Table 5. Comparison of average duration of infection, mean duration of ART, mean CD4 count and mean age according to neurological or non-neurological complications, Parakou 2014.

* Student’s t-test.

significantly higher than those without neurological complications 36.6 years (p = 0.005). This suggests that aging promotes neurological complications. The frequency of neurological complications is higher compared with another in the subregion and elsewhere; 14.7% in Burkina Faso [6] and 7.94% in Tehran in 2014 [7] . Prevalence of neurological complications in our patients is mainly related to the use of neurotoxic drugs, especially stavudine, which is the most widely used molecule. In our study, stage of HIV is not associated with neurological complications, and the proportion of patients with neurological complications is not statistically different from the proportion of other patients. Polyneuropathy (PN) is due to longer duration of infection, uncontrolled viremia, and exposure to older ARV including d4T, ddI and ddC [8] but new regimens suggest a stability of PN prevalence over time [9] . These are the most frequent neurological complications (34.26%) in our patients. Millogo in Burkina Faso had noted a frequency around 37% [6] and Wateba in Togo 30.7% [10] . These neurological manifestations occur more than 4 years and a half in the course of the disease, and their only imputability to neurotoxicity by stavudine or to HIV remains debatable in lack of electroneuromyographic exploration and nerve biopsy. The frequency of cerebral toxoplasmosis is low in this population, as they were included only in consultation and the majority of our patients were on cotrimoxazol prophylaxis (96.5%). Both HIV infection and ART could potentially increase an individual’s risk of stroke [11] . In France, its incidence is 1.1 per 1000 person-years (Male = 1.4 Female = 0.5) [12] . In this study, stroke occurred more late in the course of the disease (197 months) with a lower freqency 0.7% but justify systematic HIV test in all cases of stroke, especially in developing countries such as ours. Isolated headaches are the second most common complication in our patients; probably because of the side effects of ART mainly AZT used in most patients (67.9%).

5. Conclusion

The frequency of neurological complications in people living with HIV aged 15 years and over followed by outpatient visits in Parakou CHUDB in 2014 is 38.1%. A predominance of peripheral neuropathies was noted. Clinical, electrophysiological and therapeutic cohort studies are needed to better monitor this population in our country.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.


[1] Rozenbaum, W. (2001) Guide de l’infection à VIH. Impact médecine, Paris.
[2] Moulignier, A. (2007) Le complexe démentiel associé au VIH: Aspects particuliers chez les sujets agés. Psychologie et neuropsychiatrie du vieillissement, 5, 193-207.
[3] ONUSIDA (2013) Rapport ONUSIDA sur l’épidémie mondiale de sida.
[4] McArthur, J.C., Brew, B.J. and Nath, A. (2005) Neurological Complications of HIV Infection. The Lancet Neurology, 4, 543-555.
[5] Adoukonou, T.A., Kouna-Ndouongo, P., Kpangon, A., Gnonlonfoun, D., Kpacha, B., Dovonou, A. and Houinato, D. (2017) Distal Sensory Polyneuropathy among HIV-Infected Patients at Parakou University Hospital, Benin, 2011. Médecine et Santé Tropicales, 27, 190-194.
[6] Millogo, A., Ki-Zerbo, G.A., Sawadogo, A.B., Ouedraogo, I., Yameogo, A., Tamini, M.M., et al. (1999) Manifestations neurologiques associées à l’infection par le VIH au Centre hospitalier de Bobo-Dioulasso (Burkina Faso). Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique, 92, 23-26.
[7] Mohraz, M., Bayat, Z., Behtaj, M., Shooka, E., Seyedalinaghi, S., Jabbari, H., et al. (2014) Neurological Manifestations in HIV Positive Patients in Tehran, Iran. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Disease, 4, S481-S485.
[8] Chen, H., Cliffordb, D.B., Deng, L.J., Wu, K.L., Lee, A.J., Bosch, R.J., et al. (2013) Peripheral Neuropathy in ART-Experienced Patients: Prevalence and Risk Factors. Journal of NeuroVirology, 19, 557-564.
[9] Evans, S.R., Ellis, R.J., Chen, H., Yeh, T., Lee, A.J., Schifitto, G., et al. (2011) Peripheral Neuropathy in HIV: Prevalence and Risk Factors. AIDS, 25, 919-928.
[10] Wateba, M.I., Fiogbe, A., Assogba, K. and Tidjani, O. (2013) Prévalence des neuropathies périphériques (NP) et leurs facteurs associés chez les patients sous traitement antirétroviral suivis dans le service des Maladies infectieuses du CHU sylvanus olympio de Lomé. Cames Sante, 1, 24-27.
[11] Benjamin, L.A., Bryer, A., Emsley, H.C.A., Khoo, S., Solomon, T. and Connor, M.D. (2012) HIV Infection and Stroke: Current Perspectives and Future Directions. The Lancet Neurology, 11, 878-890.
[12] De Broucker, T. (2013) Complications neurologiques par le virus de l’immuno-déficience humaine (VIH). Pratique Neurologique—FMC, 4, 213-228.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2020 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.