Health-Related Quality of Life of Experts Who Worked in Air Disasters in São Paulo, Brazil

DOI: 10.4236/jbbs.2018.85014   PDF   HTML   XML   501 Downloads   924 Views  


Aim: To evaluate the influence of identifying victims of air disasters in São Paulo on experts’ quality of life (QoL). Methods: QoL was evaluated using the abbreviated version of the World Health Organization (WHO) quality of life questionnaire (WHOQOL-bref). We assessed 29 forensic experts who worked in air disasters in São Paulo and 29 experts who have not worked. The results were analyzed with Student’s t-tests; we compared the QoL scores of individuals at the time of the accident with their current QoL scores, and the scores of the control group were compared with the current scores of the disaster group. Results: Statistical analyses revealed a significant decrease in forensic expert QoL when they worked at the accident site, and this result was evident in all WHOQOL-bref domains. No significant difference was observed between the experts’ current QoL scores and those of the control group. Conclusions: The identification of air disaster victims in the city of São Paulo significantly decreased expert health-related QoL (HRQoL) with regard to physical and psychological aspects, social relationships and environment domains. This disturbance on the QoL was not persistent over the years.

Share and Cite:

Gianvecchio, V. , Muñoz, D. and Lancellotti, C. (2018) Health-Related Quality of Life of Experts Who Worked in Air Disasters in São Paulo, Brazil. Journal of Behavioral and Brain Science, 8, 207-215. doi: 10.4236/jbbs.2018.85014.

1. Introduction

Air accidents are one of the most feared types of mass disasters [1] . In Brazil, these disasters have been highly publicized in recent years, with the fall of a Fokker 100 in São Paulo in 1996 (99 victims), a mid-air collision between a Boeing 737 - 800 and a Legacy jet in 2006 (154 victims), the fall of an Airbus A320 in São Paulo in 2007 (199 victims), and the fall of an Air France Airbus A330-200 in 2009 (228 victims).

Mass disasters have a major impact on society, and air accidents, in particular, trigger massive social upheaval. The media contributes to this increased tension by repeatedly airing graphic footage from the scene [1] [2] .

Air accidents require emergency measures of integrated teams of firemen, health professionals, and police officers. Victims who perish in large-scale air accidents are often dismembered and burned [3] . In these circumstances, the role of forensic experts is crucial [4] .

These experts have to address the social commotion surrounding the accident, deal with pressure from the media and the authorities, and face difficulties inherent to their area of expertise which are the identification of dismembered and burned bodies of the victims. The workload in these circumstances far exceeds the usual because it is 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, until the situation is resolved [4] [5] . All of these aspects alter the lifestyle and routines of these experts.

The World Health Organization (WHO) defines quality of life (QoL) as “individuals’ perception of their position in life in the context of the culture and value systems in which they live and in relation to their goals, expectations, standards and concerns” [6] .

Few studies have assessed the influence on the QoL of professionals who have worked in mass disasters [2] [7] . Firefighters and police officers are the most studied populations. No reports have been published regarding the effects on forensic experts.

The goal of the current study was to evaluate the influence of identifying victims of air disasters in São Paulo on experts’ quality of life (QoL).

2. Method

2.1. Individuals

A cross-sectional study was performed with forensic experts who worked in the identification of victims of air disasters that occurred in São Paulo city in 1996 and 2007. São Paulo city is the capital of São Paulo State in Brazil; is the sixth most populated city in the world, with approximately 11 million inhabitants, and its metropolitan area is the fourth largest urban agglomeration in the world with over 19 million inhabitants [8] .

A number of 29 forensic experts who have worked on disasters that occurred in São Paulo were contacted and voluntarily participated in this research. These represent almost all experts, but it is impossible to be sure of the number because of the time elapsed between the first accident and the research. The same number of forensic experts (29) who had never identified air accident victims was included as a control group.

2.2. Data Collection and Instrument

The data were collected through interviews, and health-related QoL was assessed with the abbreviated version of the instrument employed by the WHO to measure QoL (WHOQOL-bref), which was previously validated in Brazil [9] . The instrument consists of 26 questions that cover four QoL domains (physical, psychological, social relationships, and environment) that range from 0 (lowest QoL) to 100 points (highest QoL).

Each forensic experts who have worked on disasters answered the WHOQOL-bref twice, one related to the period they worked at the accident (group A1) and the other related to their current QoL (at least five years after the accident―group A2). The control group answered the questionnaire with regard to their current QoL (group C). The scores were calculated according to WHOQOL-bref guidelines.

2.3. Statistical Analysis

The results were analyzed using Student’s t-tests, and the current QoL scores of the experts (group A2) were compared with their scores at the period of the accident (group A1), as well as with the scores of the control group (group C). Differences were considered statistically significant when p < 0.05. All statistical analyses were performed with SPSS® software, version 16.0 (SPSS Inc. Chicago, IL, USA).

The study was approved by Human Research Ethics Committee of the Irmandade da Santa Casa de Misericórdia de São Paulo, filed under number 22/2012. Participants consent were obtained, and the anonymity was preserved.

3. Results

Statistical analysis revealed significantly lower QoL scores in all four domains of the WHOQOL-bref at the period that experts worked at the accident sites (group A1) than their current QoL scores (group A2). Table 1 shows the forensic experts’ QoL scores in these two situations.

Table 2 shows the current QoL scores for the expert (group A2) and control group (group C). We did not observe any significant differences between these groups.

Table 1. Statistical analysis of the forensic experts QoL scores in all domains of the WHOQOL-bref, at the period they worked at the accident sites (group A1) compared to the present (group A2).


Table 2. Statistical analysis of the current QoL scores of the forensic experts (group A2) and the forensic experts control group (group C), in all domains of the WHOQOL-bref.

A comparative analysis of the average of every WHOQOL-bref question of the questionnaires answered by the experts (group A1 and group A2) was performed to determine how each facet contained in the WHOQOL-bref had an effect on QoL. Significant changes were observed in question 5 (lack of positive feelings), question 9 (lack of healthy conditions in the physical environment), question 13 (lack of information), question 14 (lack of leisure opportunities), question 16 (lack of sleep), question 21 (dissatisfaction with sexual life), question 22 (dissatisfaction with personal relationships), and question 26 (presence of negative feelings). These results were depicted in Table 3, with the means and standard deviations of responses to these questions.

4. Discussion

In recent years, there has been increased scientific and social interest regarding the consequences that working at mass disasters has on professionals’ health. These workers complete many stressful tasks during the execution of their work, including collecting bodies and body parts and identifying victims [10] [11] .

Conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and chronic fatigue are reported in firefighters and police officers who have worked in disasters [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] . The health damage caused by their professional activities could also influence their QoL.

Slottje et al. [2] evaluated the QoL of firefighters and police officers exposed to a Dutch air disaster that had occurred 8.5 years before and concluded that these emergency responders exhibited decreased QoL, even after many years. Voelker et al. [15] evaluated soldiers who worked in the first Gulf War and found that it persistently negatively impacted their QoL.

Similarly, our results also demonstrated a decrease in the QoL of forensic experts who worked to identify victims of air accidents that occurred in the city of São Paulo. However, unlike other professional groups, the negative influence on QoL was not persistent for forensic experts; their current scores were not significantly different from those of the control group.

Chen et al. [7] verified a decrease in QoL of firefighters in Kaohsiung City, Taiwan and showed that the presence of sleep disorders significantly affected physical and mental aspects of QoL.

Table 3. Comparative analysis of the average of each question of the two WHOQOL-bref questionnaires answered by the forensic experts, one related to the period they worked at the accident (group A1) and other with regard to the present (group A2).


In our research, we individually analyzed each question of the WHOQOL-bref and found that lack of sleep (question 16) had a significant negative influence on the physical domain of QoL, similar to what was observed in Taiwanese firefighters. Other aspects that had a significant negative influence on the experts’ QoL were the lack of positive feelings (question 5); the presence of negative feelings (question 26); dissatisfaction with their sexual life and with their personal relationships (questions 21 and 22); and the lack of healthy conditions in the physical environment, information, and leisure opportunities (questions 9, 13 and 14).

Exposure to violent deaths and dealing with corpses and body parts are associated with mental health problems [4] [14] [16] . Although forensic experts were used to dealing with corpses, massive exposure over several consecutive days may have contributed to the decreased QoL at the period of the accident.

Some limitations must be taken into consideration when interpreting the results of our study. A larger number of individuals would be preferable to increase the confidence interval. Nevertheless, identification of human remains is very specific and only performed by a small number of qualified professionals. In our research, all contacted forensic experts accepted the invitation to participate of the study and answered the questionnaire. The time elapsed between the accident and the research could be considered a bias because of difficulty in remembering previously occurring facts; however, it is not possible to plan a prospective study for these situations. We used a validated QoL instrument that did not have specific questions regarding the air accident, which may minimize this bias.

5. Conclusion

The findings of this study showed that the work of identifying victims of air disasters that occurred in São Paulo caused a significant decrease in HRQoL of forensic experts in physical, psychological, social relationships, and environment domains. This disturbance was not persistent over time. Some measures could be adopted to minimize this influence during the performance of such work, such as performing different activities, taking frequent rest breaks, and ensuring the presence of a team for psychological support and support for sleep quality improvement. Further studies should be conducted to analyze the influence on the QoL of professionals who worked to identify air accident victims but did not deal directly with corpses.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.


This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] Donker, G.A., Yzermans, C.J., Spreeuwenberg, P. and van der Zee, J. (2002) Symptom Attribution after a Plane Crash: Comparison between Self-Reported Symptoms and GP Records. The British Journal of General Practice, 52, 917-922.
[2] Slottje, P., Twisk, J.W., Smidt, N., Huizink, A.C., Witteveen, A.B., van Mechelen, W. and Smid, T. (2007) Health-Related Quality of Life of Firefighters and Police Officers 8.5 Years after the Air Disaster in Amsterdam. Quality of Life Research, 16, 239-252.
[3] Schmeling, A., Geserick, G. and Wirth, I. (2010) Medicolegal Identification of Victims in Mass Disasters Using the Example of Aircraft Accidents. Archiv für Kriminologie, 226, 24-37.
[4] Ursano, R.J., Fullerton, C.S., Vance, K. and Kao, T.C. (1999) Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Identification in Disaster Workers. American Journal of Psychiatry, 156, 353-359.
[5] Berríos-Torres, S.I., Greenko, J.A., Phillips, M., Miller, J.R., Treadwell, T. and Ikeda, R.M. (2003) World Trade Center Rescue Worker Injury and Illness Surveillance, New York, 2001. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 25, 79-87.
[6] The WHOQOL Group (1995) The World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment (WHOQOL): Position Paper from the World Health Organization. Social Science & Medicine, 41, 1403-1410.
[7] Chen, Y.S., Chen, M.C., Chou, F.H., Sun, F.C., Chen, P.C., Tsai, K.Y. and Chao, S.S. (2007) The Relationship between Quality of Life and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder or Major Depression for Firefighters in Kaohsiung, Taiwan. Quality of Life Research, 16, 1289-1297.
[8] Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE) (2010) Censo 2010—São Paulo.
[9] Fleck, M.P., Louzada, S., Xavier, M., Chachamovich, E., Vieira, G., Santos, L. and Pinzon, V. (2000) Application of the Portuguese Version of the Abbreviated Instrument of Quality Life WHOQOL-bref. Revista de Saúde Pública, 34, 178-183.
[10] Fullerton, C.S., Ursano, R.J. and Wang, L. (2004) Acute Stress Disorder, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, and Depression in Disaster or Rescue Workers. American Journal of Psychiatry, 161, 1370-1376.
[11] Stellman, J.M., Smith, R.P., Katz, C.L., Sharma, V., Charney, D.S., Herbert, R., Moline, J., Luft, B.J., Markowitz, S., Udasin, I., Harrison, D., Baron, S., Landrigan, P.J., Levin, S.M. and Southwick, S. (2008) Enduring Mental Health Morbidity and Social Function Impairment in World Trade Center Rescue, Recovery, and Cleanup Workers: The Psychological Dimension of an Environmental Health Disaster. Environmental Health Perspectives, 116, 1248-1253.
[12] Huizink, A.C., Slottje, P., Witteveen, A.B., Bijlsma, J.A., Twisk, J.W., Smidt, N., Bramsen, I., van Mechelen, W., van der Ploeg, H.M., Bouter, L.M. and Smid, T. (2006) Long Term Health Complaints Following the Amsterdam Air Disaster in Police Officers and Fire-Fighters. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 63, 657-662.
[13] Perrin, M.A., Di Grande, L., Wheeler, K., Thorpe, L., Farfel, M. and Brackbill, R. (2007) Differences in PTSD Prevalence and Associated Risk Factors among World Trade Center Disaster Rescue and Recovery Workers. American Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 1385-1394.
[14] Witteveen, A.B., Bramsen, I., Twisk, J.W., Huizink, A.C., Slottje, P., Smid, T. and Van Der Ploeg, H.M. (2007) Psychological Distress of Rescue Workers Eight and One-Half Years after Professional Involvement in the Amsterdam Air Disaster. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 195, 31-40.
[15] Voelker, M.D., Saag, K.G., Schwartz, D.A., Chrischilles, E., Clarke, W.R., Woolson, R.F. and Doebbeling, B.N. (2002) Health-Related Quality of Life in Gulf War Era Military Personnel. American Journal of Epidemiology, 155, 899-907.
[16] Thormar, S.B., Gersons, B.P., Juen, B., Marschang, A., Djakababa, M.N. and Olff, M. (2010) The Mental Health Impact of Volunteering in a Disaster Setting: A Review. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 198, 529-538.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2020 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.