Long-Term Study of Lake Evaporation and Evaluation of Seven Estimation Methods: Results from Dickie Lake, South-Central Ontario, Canada

Huaxia YAO

.

DOI: 10.4236/jwarp.2009.12010                

Abstract

Establishing satisfactory calculation methods of lake evaporation has been crucial for research and manage-ment of water resources and ecosystems. A 30 year dataset from Dickie Lake, south-central Ontario, Canada added to the limited long-term studies on lake evaporation. Evaporation during ice-free season was calcu-lated separately using seven evaporation methods, based on field meteorology, hydrology and lake water temperature data. Actual evaporation determined during a portion of a year was estimated using a lake en-ergy budget model, and the estimation was used as reference evaporation for evaluation of the seven methods. The deviation of method-induced evaporation from the reference evaporation was compared among the seven methods, and a performance rank was proposed based on the root mean squared deviation and coeffi-cient of efficiency. As for the whole ice-free season (roughly May to November), the water balance was the best method, followed by Makkink, DeBruin-Kejiman, Penman, Priestley-Taylor, Hamon, and Jensen-Haise methods. As for shorter duration (a week to a month), the DeBruin-Kejiman was the best method, followed by Penman, Priestley-Taylor, Makkink, Hamon, Jensen-Haise, and water balance method. Annual and sea-sonal changes of energy budget terms and the compensation function of lake heat storage in evaporation flux were also analyzed.

Keywords

Long-Term Study, Lake Evaporation, Water Balance, Energy Budget, Lake Temperature, Stream Discharge

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	G. Krantzberg, “The Great Lakes, a 35th year anniversary: Time to look forward,” Electronic Green Journal, Vol. 26, pp. 1–4, 2008.
[2]	N. D. Yan, A. M. Paterson, K. M. Somers, and W. A. Scheider, “An introduction to the Dorset special issue: transforming understanding of factors that regulate aquatic ecosystems on the southern Canadian Shield,” Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, Vol. 65, pp. 781–785, 2008.
[3]	J. J. Gibson and W. D. Edwards, “Regional water balance trends and evaporation-transpiration portioning from a stable isotope survey of lakes in northern Canada,” Global Biogeochemical Cycles, Vol. 16, No. 10, pp. 1–14, 2002.
[4]	Minnesota DNR Waters, “Lake-ground water interaction study at White Bear Lake, Minnesota,” Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Report, Minnesota, USA, 1998.
[5]	G. Weyhenmeyer, “Rates of change in physical and chemical lake variables – are they comparable between large and small lakes?” Hydrobiologia, Vol. 599, pp. 105–110, 2008.
[6]	J. D. Lenters, T. K. Kratz, and C. J. Bowser, “Effects of climate variability on lake evaporation: Results from a long-term energy budget study of Sparkling Lake, northern Wisconsin (USA),” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 308, pp. 168–195, 2005.
[7]	J. J. Gibson, R. Reid, and C. Spence, “A six-year isotopic record of lake evaporation at a mine site in the Canadian subarctic: Results and validation,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 12, pp. 1779–1792, 1998.
[8]	Y. Mahrer and S. Assouline, “Evaporation from Lake Kinneret, 2. Estimaton of the horizontal variability using a two-dimensional numerical mesoscale model,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 29, pp. 911–916, 1993.
[9]	W. Abtew, “Evaporation estimation for Lake Okeechobee in South Florida,” Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, Vol. 127, pp. 140–147, 2001.
[10]	R. J. Dos Reis and N. L. Dias, “Multi-season lake evaporation: energy-budget estimates and CRLE model assessment with limited meteorological observations,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 208, pp. 135–147, 1998.
[11]	U.S. Geological Survey, “Estimating Evaporation from Lake Mead,” USGS Scientific Investigations Report, No. 2006-5252, Arizona, USA, 2006.
[12]	J. A. Amayreh, “Lake evaporation: a model study,” in Dissertation Abstracts International 57-03, Section B, Utah State University, pp. 1938, 1995.
[13]	D. O. Rosenberry, D. I. Stannard, T. C. Winter, and M. L. Martinez, “Comparison of 13 equations for determining evapotranspiration from a prairie wetland, Cottonwood Lake Area, North Dakota, USA,” Wetlands, Vol. 24, pp. 483–497, 2004.
[14]	D. O. Rosenberry, T. C. Winter, D. C. Buso, and G. E. Likens, “Comparison of 15 evaporation methods applied to a small mountain lake in the northeastern USA,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 340, pp. 149–166, 2007.
[15]	E. Robertson and P. J. Barry, “The water and energy balances of Perch Lake (1969–1980),” Atmosphere-Ocean, Vol. 23, pp. 238–253, 1985.
[16]	A. H. Rasmussen, M. Hondzo, and H. G. Stefan, “A test of several evaporation equations for water temperature simulations in lakes,” Water Resources Bulletin, Vol. 31, pp. 1023–1028, 1995.
[17]	P. F. Hamblin, H. A. Bootsma, and R. E. Hecky, “Surface meteorological observations over Lake Malawi/Nyasa,” Journal of Great Lakes Research, Vol. 29, pp. 19–23, 2003.
[18]	M. E. Keskin and O. Terzi, “Evaporation estimation models for Lake Egirdir, Turkey,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 20, pp. 2381–2391, 2006.
[19]	E. T. Linacre, “Data-sparse estimation of lake evaporation, using a simplified Penman equation,” Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, Vol. 64, pp. 237–256, 1993.
[20]	W. A. Scheider, R. A. Reid, B. A. Locke, and L. D. Scott, “Studies of lakes and watersheds in Muskoka-Haliburton, Ontario: Methodology (1976–1982),” Data Report DR 83/1 of Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Dorset, Ontario, Canada, 1983.
[21]	W. A. Scheider, C. M. Cox, and L. D. Scott, “Hydrological data for lakes and watersheds in Muskoka-Haliburton study area (1976–1980),” Data Report DR 83/6 of Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Dorset, Ontario, Canada, 1983.
[22]	B. A. Hutchinson, L. D. Scott, M. N. Futter, and A. Morgan, “Hydrology data for lakes and catchments in Muskoka/Haliburton (1980–1992),” Data Report DR 93/2 of Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Dorset, Ontario, Canada, 1994.
[23]	T. C. Winter, D. O. Rosenberry, and A. M. Sturrock, “Evaluation of 11 equations for determining evaporation fro a small lake in the north central United States,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 31, pp. 983–993, 1995.
[24]	M. S. Mosner and B. T. Aulenbach, “Comparison of methods used to estimate lake evaporation for a water budget of Lake Semnole, southwestern Georgia and northwestern Florida,” in Proceedings of the 2003 Georgia Water Resources Conference, Athens, Georgia, USA, 2003.
[25]	C.-Y. Xu and V. P. Singh, “Evaluation and generalization of radiation-based methods for calculating evaporation,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 14, pp. 339–349, 2000.
[26]	V. P. Singh and C.-Y. Xu, “Evaluation and generalization of 13 mass-transfer equations for determining free water evaporation,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 11, pp. 311– 323, 1997.
[27]	F. Delclaux, A. Coudrain, and T. Condom, “Evaporation estimation on Lake Titicaca: a synthesis review and modelling,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 21, pp. 1664–1677, 2007.
[28]	M. F. Sadek, M. M. Shahin, and C. L. Stigter, “Evaporation from the reservoir of the High Aswan Dam, Egypt: A new comparison of relevant methods with limited data,” Theoretical and Applied Climatology, Vol. 56, pp. 57–66, 1997.
[29]	R. A. Reid, R. Girard, and A. C. Nicolls, “Morphometry and catchment areas for the calibrated watersheds,” Data Report DR 87/4 of Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Dorset, Ontario, Canada, 1987.
[30]	V. T. Chow, D. R. Maidment, and L. W. Mays, “Applied hydrology,” McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1988.
[31]	A. L. Buck, “New equations for computing vapour pressure and enhancement factor,” Journal of Applied Meteorology, Vol. 20, pp. 1527–1532, 1981.
[32]	H. Yao and I. F. Creed, “Determining spatially-distributed annual water balances for ungauged locations on Shikoku Island, Japan: a comparison of two interpolators,” Hydrological Sciences Journal, Vol. 50, pp. 245–263, 2005.
[33]	J. Doorenbus and W. O. Pruitt, “Guidelines for predicting crop water requirements”, Irrigation and Drainage Paper No. 24, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy, 1977.
[34]	H. Yao, A. Terakawa, and S. Chen, “Rice water use and response to potential climate changes: calculation and application to Jianghan, China,” in Proceedings of the International Conference on Water Resources and Environment Research , Kyoto, Japan, Vol. 2, pp. 611–618, 1996.
[35]	H. A. R. DeBruin and J. Q. Kejiman, “The Priestley-Taylor evaporation model applied to a large, shallow lake in the Netherlands,” Journal of Allied Meteorology, Vol. 18, pp. 898–903, 1979.
[36]	K. J. Devito and P. Dillon, “Errors in estimating stream discharge in small headwater catchments: influence on interpretation of catchment yields and input – output budget estimates,” Technical Report 1993 of Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Dorset, Ontario, Canada, 1993.
[37]	S. W. Hostetler and P. J. Bartlein, “Simulation of lake evaporation with application to modeling lake level variations of Harney-Malheur Lake, Oregon,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 26, pp. 2603–2612, 1990.
[38]	N. G. Grannemann, R. J. Hunt, J. R. Nicholas, T. E. Reilly, and T. C. Winter, “The importance of ground water in the Great Lakes region,” Water-Resources Investigation Report 00-4008, U. S. Geological Survey, Lansing, Michigan, 2000.
[39]	J. E. Nash and J. V. Sutcliffe, “River flow forecasting through conceptual models: Part I – a discussion of principles,” Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 10, pp. 282–290, 1970.
[40]	E. T. Linacre, “Evaporation trends,” Theoretical and Applied Climatology, Vol. 79, pp. 11–21, 2004.
[41]	R. K. Saxena, “Estimation of lake evaporation from a shallow lake in central Sweden by oxygen-18,” Hydrological Processes, Vol. 10, pp. 1273–1281, 1998.
[42]	R. K. Saxena, C. Jaedicke, and L. C. Lundin, “Comparison mass-balance, bulk aerodynamic and bowen ratio methods,” Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Part B: Hydrology, Oceans and Atmosphere, Vol. 24, pp. 851– 859, 1999.