A Few Reflections on the Reasons Why Cooperative Firms Have Failed to Gain a Firm Foothold

Bruno Jossa^*

Università “Federico II” of Naples, Naples, Italy.

DOI: 10.4236/ojbm.2015.33027                

Abstract

After the inception of the cooperative movement in the mid-19th century, it was widely held that capitalistic businesses would soon be replaced by a system of worker-controlled firms and a wealth of policy proposals called for a major impulse to cooperation in later years also. But cooperation has not met with the hoped-for success. How do we account for this? To our day, employee management specialists have been unable to provide a satisfactory explanation for the fact that the policy proposal to introduce democratic firm control still carries little consensus despite the collapse of the Soviet model of communism. In this paper, we give some answers to the question and emphasise the idea that progress in the direction of a generalised system of cooperative firms would amount to a considerable improvement over capitalism, but will hardly be made without the effective contribution of intellectuals and political parties.

Keywords

Producer Cooperatives, Socialism, Mode of Production, Democracy, Darwinism

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Oakeshott, R. (1978) The Case for Workers’ Co-ops. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
[2]	Cornforth, C., Thomas, A., Lewis, J. and Spear, R. (1988) Developing Successful Worker Cooperatives. Sage, London.
[3]	Ellerman, D.P. (1990) The Democratic Worker-Owned Firm. Unwin Hyman, Boston.
[4]	Bardhan, P. and Roemer, J.E., Eds. (1993) Market Socialism: The Current Debate. Oxford Economic Press, New York.
[5]	Jossa, B. (2005) La teoria economica delle cooperative di produzione e la possibile fine del capitalismo. Giappichelli, Turin.
[6]	Jossa, B. (2012) Cooperative Firms as a New Production Mode. Review of Political Economy, 24, 399-416. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09538259.2012.701915
[7]	Mill, J.S. (1871) Principi di economia politica. III Edit., Ital. transl. UTET, Turin, 1953.
[8]	Walras, L. (1990) Etudes d’économie social, Oeuvres économique complètes. Vol. IX, Econonica, Paris.
[9]	Gibson-Graham, J.K. (2003) Enabling Ethical Economies: Cooperativism and Class. Critical Sociology, 29, 123-161. http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/156916303769155788
[10]	Nozick, R. (1974) Anarchy, State and Utopia. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
[11]	Jensen, M.C. and Meckling, W.J. (1979) Rights and Production Functions: An Applications to Labor-Managed Firms and Codetermination. The Journal of Business, 52, 469-506. http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/296060
[12]	Williamson, O.E. (1985) The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. Free Press, New York.
[13]	Mandel, E. (1973) The Debate on Workers’ Control. In: Hunnius, G., Garson, G.D. and Case, J., Eds., Workers’ Control, Vintage Books, New York.
[14]	Vanek, J. (1969) Decentralization under Workers’ Management: A Theoretical Appraisal. The American Economic Review, 59, 1006-1014.
[15]	Vanek, J. (1970) The General Theory of Labor-Managed Market Economies. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
[16]	Horvat, B. (1975) On the Theory of the Labor-Managed Firm. Reprinted in: Prychitko, D.L. and Vanek, J., Eds. (1996) Producer Cooperatives and Labor-Managed Systems. E. Elgar, Cheltenham.
[17]	Jossa, B. and Cuomo, G. (1997) The Economic Theory of Socialism and the Labour-managed Firm. E. Elgar, Cheltenham.
[18]	Jossa, B. (2010) A Few Advantages of Cooperative Firms. Studi Economici, 65.
[19]	Jossa, B. (2010) Esiste un’alternativa al capitalismo? Manifestolibri, Rome.
[20]	Cole, G.C.H. (1953) Attempts at General Union. Macmillan, London.
[21]	Hansmann, H. (1996) The Ownership of Enterprise. Belknap Press of the Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
[22]	Hamilton, D. (1999) Evolutionary Economics: A Study of Change in Economic Thought. Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick.
[23]	Hodgson, G.M. (2003) Darwinism and Institutional Economics. Journal of Economic Issues, 37, 85-97.
[24]	De Gregory, T.R. (2003) Muck and Magic or Change and Progress: Vitalism versus Hamiltonian Matter-of-Fact Knowledge. Journal of Economic Issues, 37, 17-33.
[25]	Veblen, T.B. (1964) What Veblen Thought. August M. Kelley, New York.
[26]	Putterman, L. (1990) Division of Labor and Welfare: An Introduction to Economic Systems. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[27]	Horvat, B. (2000) Social Ownership. 10th Conference of IAFEP, Trient, 6-8 July 2000.
[28]	Hodgson, G.M. (1999) Economics and Utopia. Routledge, London.
[29]	Miller, E.S. (2003) Evolution and Stasis: The Institutional Economics of David Hamilton. Journal of Economic Issues, 37, 51-64.
[30]	Dugger, W.M. (2003) David Hamilton: A Radical’s Institutionalist. Journal of Economic Issues, 37, 65-73.
[31]	Gramsci, A. (1964) Il materialismo storico e la filosofia di Benedetto Croce. Einaudi, Turin.
[32]	Commons, J.R. (1924) Legal Foundations of Capitalism. Macmillan, New York.
[33]	Commons, J.R. (1934) Institutional Economics; Its Place in Political Economy. Macmillan, New York
[34]	Copeland, M.A. (1931) Economic Theory and the Natural Science Point of View. The American Economic Review, 21, 67-79.
[35]	Copeland, M.A. (1936) Common’s Institutionalism in Relation to the Problem of Social Evolution and Economic Planning. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 50, 333-346. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1885027
[36]	Miller, E.S. (2002) Economics in a Public Interest: Remarks upon Receiving the Veblen-Commons Award. Journal of Economic Issues, 36, 251-260.
[37]	Bowles, S. and Gintis, H. (1986) Democracy and Capitalism. Basic Books, New York.
[38]	Vanek, J. (1978) La cooperativa di lavoro al crocevia della storia. Ital. Transl in: Hayek, F.A. (1982) Legge, legisla-zione e libertà. Ital. transl. Milan, Il Saggiatore, 1986.
[39]	Hayek, F.A. (1982) Legge, legislazione e libertà. Ital. transl. Milan, Il Saggiatore, 1986.
[40]	Leube, K.R. (1989) Social Policy: Hayek and Schmoller Compared. International Journal of Social Economics, 16, 106-116.
[41]	Colombatto, E. (2002) Towards a Quasi-Lamarckian Theory of Institutional Change. ICER Working Paper No. 26.
[42]	D’Iorio, P. (2013) Ontologia e genealogia nell’estate del 1881. La svolta costruttivista di Nietzsche. Il Ponte, 69, August-September.
[43]	Hayek, F.A. (1983) The Rediscovery of Liberty; Personal Recollection. In: Hayek, F.A. (1992) The Fortunes and the Ideal of Freedom. Routledge & Kegan, London.
[44]	Moene, K.O. and Wallerstein, I. (1993) Unions versus Cooperatives. In: Bowles, S., Gintis, H. and Gustafsson, B., Eds., Markets and Democracy: Participation, Accountability and Efficiency, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[45]	Kester, G. and Pinaud, H. (1996) Trade Unions and Democratic Participation: a Scenario for the 21 Century. Averbury, Aldershot.
[46]	George, D.A.R. (1997) Self-Management and Ideology. Review of Political Economy, 9, 51-62. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09538259700000019
[47]	Panzieri, R. (1960) Intervento sui temi per il Congresso della CGIL. In: Panzieri, R. (1975) La ripresa del marxismo- leninismo in Italia. Sapere Edizioni, Milan.
[48]	Schumpeter, J.A. (1954) Capitalismo, socialismo e democrazia. Ital. transl. Edizioni di Comunità, Milan, 1964.
[49]	Anderson, P. (1967) The Limits and Possibilities of Trade Union Action. In: Blackburn, R. and Cockburn, A., Eds., The Incompatibles: Trade Unions Militancy and the Consensus, Penguin, London.
[50]	Togliatti, P. (1920) Cooperative o schiavitù. Reprinted in: Togliatti, P. (1967) Opere. Ed. by Ernesto Ragionieri. Editori Riuniti, Rome.
[51]	Tornquist, D. (1973) Workers’ Management: The Intrinsic Issues. In: Hunnius, G., Garson, G.D. and Case, J., Eds., Workers’ Control, Vintage Books, New York.
[52]	Salvemini, G. (1993) Movimento socialista e questione meridionale. Ed. by Arfè G. Feltrinelli, Milan.
[53]	Braverman, H. (1974) Lavoro e capitale monopolistico. Ital. transl. Einaudi, Turin, 1978.
[54]	Adler-Karlsson, G. (1986) Il socialismo “minimale” e il dilemma delle uova. In: AA.VV., Cooperare e competere, Feltrinelli, Milan.
[55]	Dubravcic, D. (1970) Labour as an Entrepreneurial Input: An Essay on the Theory of the Producer Cooperative Economy. Economica, 37, 297-310. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2551976
[56]	Gide, C. (1888) L’avenir de la cooperation. In: Gide, C. (1900) La cooperation: Conferences de propagande. Larousse Forces, Paris.
[57]	Labriola, A. (1970) Scritti politici. Ed. by V. Gerratana. Laterza, Bari.
[58]	Fabbri, F. (1981) La cooperazione: 1945-1956. In: Ilardi, M. and Accornero, A., Eds., Il Partito Comunista Italiano. Struttura e storia dell’organizzazione. 1921/1979, Annali della Fondazione Giangiacomo Feltrinelli, Milan.
[59]	Putterman, L. (1984) On Some Explanations of Why Capital Hires Labor. Economic Inquiry, 22, 171-187. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1465-7295.1984.tb00677.x
[60]	Hodgson, G.M. (1993) Transaction Costs and the Evolution of the Firm. In: Pitelis, C., Ed., Transactions Costs, Markets and Hierarchies, Blackwell, Oxford.
[61]	Gunn, C. (2000) Markets against Economic Democracy. Review of Radical Political Economics, 32, 448-460. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/048661340003200310
[62]	Artur, W.B. (1989) Competing Technologies, Increasing Returns, and Lock-In by Historical Events. Economic Journal, 99, 116-131. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2234208
[63]	North, D. (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[64]	Pagano, U. (1991) Property Rights, Asset Specificity, and the Division of Labour under Alternative Capitalist Relations. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 15, 315-342.
[65]	Pagano, U. (1991) Imprese, tecnologia e diritti di proprietà. In: Artoni, R., Ed. (1981) Teoria economica e analisi delle istituzioni. Il Mulino, Bologna.
[66]	Vanek, J. (1971) Some Fundamental Considerations on Financing and the Form of Ownership under Labor Management. Reprinted in: Vanek, J. (1977) The Labor Managed Economy: Essays. By J. Vanek. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
[67]	Galgano, P. (1974) Le istituzioni dell’economia capitalistica. Zanichelli, Bologna.
[68]	Marx, K. and Engels, F. (1845-1846) L’ideologia tedesca. Ital. transl. Editori Riuniti, Rome, 1969.
[69]	Perotin, V. (2006) Entry, Exit, and the Business Cycle: Are Cooperatives Different? Journal of Comparative Economics, 34, 295-316. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jce.2006.03.002
[70]	Veblen, T.B. (1899) The Theory of the Leisure Class. Reprint August M. Kelley, New York, 1965.
[71]	Ellerman, D.P. (1992) Property and Contract in Economics. Blackwell, Oxford.
[72]	Bowles, S. and Gintis, H. (1993) Post-Walrasian Political Economy. In: Bowles, S., Gintis, H. and Gustafsson B., Eds., Markets and Democracy: Participation, Accountability and Efficiency, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[73]	Panebianco, A. (2004) Il potere, lo stato, la libertà. Il Mulino, Bologna.
[74]	Weingast, B.R. and Marshall, W.J. (1988) The Industrial Organization of Congress; or, Why Legislatures, Like Firms, Are Not Organized as Markets. Journal of Political Economy, 96, 132-163. http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/261528
[75]	Kollock, P. (1998) Transforming Social Dilemmas: Group Identity and Cooperation. In: Danielson, P., Ed., Modelling Rationality, Morality and Evolution, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[76]	Huberman, B.A. and Glance, N.S. (1998) Belief and Cooperation. In: Danielson, P., Ed., Modelling Rationality, Morality and Evolution, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[77]	Battilani, P. and Bertagnoni, G., Eds. (2007) Competizione e valorizzazione del lavoro. La rete cooperativa del Consorzio nazionale dei servizi. Il Mulino, Bologna.
[78]	Jossa, B. (2014) A System of Cooperative Firms as a New Mode of Production. Routledge, London.
[79]	Einaudi, L. (1920) Il significato del controllo operaio. In: Einaudi, L. (1966) Cronache economiche e politiche di un trentennio. Vol. V, 1919-1920, Einaudi, Turin.
[80]	Touraine, A. (2004) La globalizzazione e la fine del sociale. Ital. transl. Il Saggiatore, Milan.
[81]	Ben-Ner, A. (1987) Producer Cooperatives: Why Do They Exist in Market Economies? In: Powel, W., Ed., The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University, New Haven.
[82]	Hart, O. and Moore, J. (1990) Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm. Journal of Political Economy, 98, 1119-1158. http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/261729
[83]	Steinherr, A. and Vanek, J. (1976) Labour-Managed Firms and Imperfect Competition. Economic Journal, 86, 339-341. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2230755
[84]	Bernstein, E. (1899) Socialismo e socialdemocrazia. Ital. transl. Laterza, Bari, 1968.
[85]	Meade, J.E. (1972) The Theory of Labour-Managed Firms and of Profit Sharing. Economic Journal, 82, 402-428. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2229945
[86]	Cornforth, C. (1989) Worker Cooperatives in U.K.: Temporary Phenomenon or Growing Trend? In: Lammers, C.J. and Széll, G., Eds., International Handbook of Participation in Organization, Vol. I, Organizational Democracy: Taking Stock, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[87]	Obradovic, J. and Dunn, W., Eds. (1978) Workers’ Self Management and Organizational Power in Yugoslavia. Centre for International Studies, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.
[88]	Kalecki, M. (1937) The Principle of Increasing Risk. Economica, 3, 440-447. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2626879
[89]	Drèze, J.H. (1989) Labour-Management, Contracts and Capital Markets. A General Equilibrium Approach. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
[90]	Drèze, J.H. (1993) Self-Management and Economic Theory: Efficiency, Funding and Employment. In: Bardhan, P. and Roemer, J.E., Eds., Market Socialism: The Current Debate, Oxford Economic Press, New York.
[91]	Putterman, L., Roemer, J.E. and Silvestre, J. (1998) Does Egalitarianism Have a Future? Journal of Economic Literature, 36, 861-902.
[92]	Pittatore, S. and Turati, G. (2000) A Map of Property Rights in Italy and the Case of Cooperatives: An Empirical Analysis of Hansmann’s Theory. Economic Analysis, 3, 23-48. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13668090050004251
[93]	Webb, S. and Webb, B. (1921) A Constitution for the Socialist Commonwealth of Great Britain. Longmans, London.
[94]	Webb, S. and Webb, B. (1923) The Decay of Capitalistic Civilization. Allen & Unwin, London.
[95]	Ben-Ner, A. (1984) On the Stability of the Cooperative Type of Organization. Journal of Comparative Economics, 8, 247-260. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0147-5967(84)90055-6
[96]	Ben-Ner, A. (1988) The Life Cycle of Worker-Owner Firms in Market Economies: A Theoretical Analysis. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 10, 287-313. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0167-2681(88)90052-2
[97]	Dow, G. (2003) Governing the Firm; Workers’ Control in Theory and Practice. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[98]	Dahl, R.A. (1989) Democracy and Its Critics. Yale University Press, Yale.
[99]	Ramsey, H. (1983) Evolution or Cycle? Worker Participation in the 1970s. In: Crouch, C. and Heller, F., Eds., International Yearbook of Organizational Democracy, Wiley, Chichester.
[100]	Visser, J.C. (1989) Factory Occupation and Industrial Democracy. In: Lammers, C.J. and Széll, G., Eds., International Handbook of Participation in Organization, Vol. 1, Organizational Democracy: Taking Stock, Oxford University Press, Oxford.