The reporting of the influenza pandemic, 1918-1920 in Hamilton, Ontario

John Rankin

Department of History, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, USA.

DOI: 10.4236/health.2012.412193                

Abstract

The paper evaluates the ways in which Hamilton, Ontario’s three daily newspapers covered the influenza epidemic, 1918-1920. In Hamilton, the central aspect of influenza coverage was Dr. Roberts’ decision to close all public meeting places twice during 1918. No other story but those connected to a public meeting ban could sustain interest. Thus, the story for the press was to be the ban: whether to ban, what to ban, to lift or not, to reimpose. The story monopolized influenza coverage to such an extent that traditional threads, such as morbidity and mortality and personal interest stories, received little attention. The ban, because it restricted personal freedoms and involved local politics and commerce, received extensive coverage. In the absence of a ban, the influenza story could fade out of the press even during some of the most virulent periods of the epidemic. The paper finds that influenza was not transformative in Hamilton and in fact, demonstrated the viability of traditional charitable responses to disease. The actions carried out by Hamilton’s Board of Health cannot be considered “modern” as its methods were more akin to the nineteenth century than those of the later bacteriological age.

Keywords

Influenza; 1918; Epidemic; Hamilton; Ontario; Health; Medicine

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Roberts, J. (1992) Dictionary of Hamilton biography vol. III, W.L. Griffen Printers Ltd., Hamilton, 176.
[2]	Rutherford, P.A. (1982) Victorian authority: The daily press in late nineteenth-century Canada, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.
[3]	Rankin, J. (2006-2007) For disease reporting in the Anglo-America press at the turn of the twentieth century see, The Reporting of Mosquito-Vector Disease in Anglo- American Daily Press, Media History Monograph, 9, 1.
[4]	MacDougall, H. (2006) Toronto’s health department in action: Influenza in 1918 and SARS in 2003. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 62, 62.
[5]	(1918) Influenza is reported in West Hamilton. The Spectator, 28 September, 18.
[6]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 5 October.
[7]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 5 October.
[8]	Pettigrew, E. (1983) The silent enemy: Canada and the deadly flu of 1918. Prairie Books, Saskatoon, 13.
[9]	Lux, M. (1997) The bitter flats: The 1918 influenza epidemic in Saskatchewan. Saskatchewan History, 49, 4.
[10]	Bliss, M. (1991) Plague: A story of smallpox in Montreal. HarperCollins, Toronto.
[11]	(1914) Ontario Board of Health Act, Section 56.
[12]	Lux, M. (1997) The bitter flats: The 1918 influenza epidemic in Saskatchewan. Saskatchewan History, 49, 4.
[13]	(1918) Four deaths from “flu” reported Here. The Herald, 5 October.
[14]	McCullough, J.W.S. (1918) Four deaths from “flu” reported here. In: McCullough, J.W.S., Ed., The Control of Influenza in Ontario. Canadian Medical Association, Ottawa, 1084- 1085.
[15]	(1918) Nine more deaths from Spanish “flu”. The Herald, 7 October.
[16]	(1918) Nine more deaths from Spanish “flu.” The Herald, 7 October.
[17]	Rankin, J. (2003) Public health quarantine in the American and British daily press, 1850-1905. Unpublished Manuscript, 10-13.
[18]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 7 October.
[19]	(1918) Week’s toll of influenza five hundred cases. The Spectator, 12 October, 1.
[20]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 16 October.
[21]	(1918) Rigid shut-down is demanded by board. The Spectator, 16 October, 1.
[22]	(1918) Will close all public places next Monday. The Herald, 16 October.
[23]	(1918) Will close all public places next Monday. The Herald, 16 October.
[24]	(1918) Rigid shut-down is demanded by board. The Spectator, 16 October, 1.
[25]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 16 October.
[26]	(1918) Health board will stand by closing order. The Spectator, 16 October, 1.
[27]	Jones, E.W. (2003) Searching for the springs of health: Women and working families in Winnipeg’s 1918-1919 influenza epidemic. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg.
[28]	(1918) Victory loan mass meeting is prohibited. The Spectator, 25 October, 1.
[29]	The victory loan officials attended all board of health meetings from 24 October until the 29 October when the matter of a parade was conclusively settled. Board of Health Minutes for Hamilton 1918, 24 October, 28 October, and 29 October.
[30]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 24 October.
[31]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 24 October.
[32]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 24 October.
[33]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 5.
[34]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 5.
[35]	(1918) 100 Volunteer nurses soon ready to help. The Herald, 16 October.
[36]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 5.
[37]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 6.
[38]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 9-10.
[39]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 10.
[40]	(1918) Epidemic passing. The Spectator, 1 November, 1.
[41]	(1918) Epidemic passing. The Spectator, 1 November, 1.
[42]	(1918) Board of Health Minutes, 4 November.
[43]	(1918) Annual Health Report, 31 October, 9-10.
[44]	(1918) Warning from doctors about the epidemic. The Herald, 13 November and (1918) “flu” epidemic is still serious. The Spectator, 13 November, 15.
[45]	(1918) Ban on public gathering is again urged. The Spectator, 14 November, 1.
[46]	(1918) Ban not placed on gatherings. The Spectator, 15 November, 31.
[47]	(1918) Ban not placed on gatherings. The Spectator, 15 November, 31.
[48]	(1918) “Flu” spreading. The Herald, 18 November.
[49]	(1918) Doctors declare war on Hamilton’s board of health. The Herald, 23 November.
[50]	(1918) Doctors demand an apology or resignation of Dr. Roberts. The Times, 23 November.
[51]	(1918) Health board not worrying about medicos. The Spectator, 23 November, 31.
[52]	(1920) Annual Health Report, 47.
[53]	(1918) A warning. The Herald, 27 November.
[54]	(1918) Closing order goes into effect tonight. The Times, 29 November.
[55]	(1918) Closing order goes into effect tonight. The Times, 29 November.
[56]	(1918) Board of health ties up Hamilton during season approaching to Christmas. The Spectator, 29 November, 1.
[57]	(1918) Board of health ties up Hamilton during season approaching to Christmas. The Spectator, 29 November, 1.
[58]	(1918) Merchants say order defeats its purpose. The Herald, 30 November.
[59]	(1918) Four o’clock hour proves a menace instead of a help. The Times, 29 November.
[60]	(1918) Mere mulishness. The Herald, 9 December.
[61]	(1918) Knutty points. The Spectator, 4 December 1918, 12.
[62]	(1918) Catholic priest was fined in court this morning. The Spectator, 4 December, 1.
[63]	(1918) Will prosecute a priest for holding service. The Herald, 4 December 1918.
[64]	(1918) Churches closed by bishop’s order. The Herald, 7 December 1918.
[65]	(1918) Order does not stop meetings at city hall. The Herald, 7 December 1918.
[66]	(1918) Rigid shut-down is demanded by board. The Spectator, 16 October, 1.
[67]	(1918) As to the ban. The Spectator, 7 December, 1.
[68]	(1918) Closing order to be modified. The Herald, 7 December.
[69]	(1918) Fewer Deaths and Fewer Cases of Influenza. The Herald, 16 December.
[70]	(1918) The ban lifted. The Herald, 16 December.
[71]	(1918) The ban lifted. The Herald, 16 December.
[72]	(1918) Board silent about high-handed action. The Spectator, 17 December, 1.
[73]	(1918) Ban on churches and theatres ill advised. The Herald, 20 December.
[74]	(1918) More Flu. 14 February and (1919) flu deaths. The Herald, 4 April.
[75]	(1920) Annual Health Report, 1 November, 47.
[76]	(1919) The Canadian annual review of public affairs. The Canadian Annual Review, 574.
[77]	(1920) The Canadian annual review of public affairs. The Canadian Annual Review.
[78]	Duffy, J. (1993) From humors to medical science, 2nd Edition, University of Illinois Press, Champaign, 5.
[79]	MacDougall, H. (2006) Toronto’s health department in action: Influenza in 1918 and SARS in 2003. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 62, 63.
[80]	Herring, D.A. and Korol, E. (1918) The north-south divide: Social inequality and mortality from the 1918 influenza pandemic in Hamilton, Ontario. In: Fahrni, M. and Jones, E.W. Eds., Epidemic Encounters: Influenza, Society, and Culture in Canada, UBC Press, Vancouver, 102-103.
[81]	Herring, D.A. and Korol, E. (1918) The north-south divide: Social inequality and mortality from the 1918 influenza pandemic in Hamilton, Ontario. In: Fahrni, M. and Jones, E.W. Eds., Epidemic Encounters: Influenza, Society, and Culture in Canada, UBC Press, Vancouver, 98.
[82]	(1918) Death rate in Hamilton under average. The Herald, 9 December, 4.
[83]	McGinnis, J.D. (1981) The impact of epidemic influenza: Canada 1918-1919. In: Shortt, S.E.D. Ed., Medicine in Canadian Society, McGill-Queens University Press, Montreal, 471-472.
[84]	Jones, E.W. (2003) For more information on volunteerism and social relationship. Searching for the springs of health: Women and working families in Winnipeg’s 1918- 1919 influenza epidemic. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, 3.
[85]	Kolata, G. (1999) Flu: The story of the great influenza pandemic of 1918 and the search for the virus that caused it. Simon and Schuster, New York, 7.
[86]	Crosby, A.W. (1990) America’s forgotten pandemic. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990.
[87]	Roberts, J. (1992) Dictionary of Hamilton biography. W. L. Griffen Printers Ltd., Hamilton, 176.