Journal of Modern Physics

Volume 2, Issue 12 (December 2011)

ISSN Print: 2153-1196   ISSN Online: 2153-120X

Google-based Impact Factor: 0.86  Citations  h5-index & Ranking

Why the Big Bang Model Cannot Describe the Observed Universe Having Pressure and Radiation

HTML  XML Download Download as PDF (Size: 188KB)  PP. 1436-1442  
DOI: 10.4236/jmp.2011.212177    4,827 Downloads   10,735 Views  Citations
Author(s)

Affiliation(s)

.

ABSTRACT

It has been recently shown that, since in general relativity (GR), given one time label t, one can choose any other time label t → t*= f(t), the pressure of a homogeneous and isotropic fluid is intrinsically zero (Mitra, Astrophys. Sp. Sc. 333, 351, 2011). Here we explore the physical reasons for the inevitability of this mathematical result. The essential reason is that the Weyl Postulate assumes that the test particles in a homogeneous and isotropic spacetime undergo pure geodesic motion without any collisions amongst themselves. Such an assumed absence of collisions corresponds to the absence of any intrinsic pressure. Accordingly, the “Big Bang Model” (BBM) which assumes that the cosmic fluid is not only continuous but also homogeneous and isotropic intrinsically corresponds to zero pressure and hence zero temperature. It can be seen that this result also follows from the relevant general relativistic first law of thermodynamics (Mitra, Found. Phys. 41, 1454, 2011). Therefore, the ideal BBM cannot describe the physical universe having pressure, temperature and radiation. Consequently, the physical universe may comprise matter distributed in discrete non-continuous lumpy fashion (as observed) rather than in the form of a homogeneous continuous fluid. The intrinsic absence of pressure in the “Big Bang Model” also rules out the concept of a “Dark Energy”.

Share and Cite:

A. Mitra, "Why the Big Bang Model Cannot Describe the Observed Universe Having Pressure and Radiation," Journal of Modern Physics, Vol. 2 No. 12, 2011, pp. 1436-1442. doi: 10.4236/jmp.2011.212177.

Cited by

[1] If A MACHIAN RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GRAVITONS AND GRAVITINOS EXIST, WHAT DOES SUCH A RELATIONSHIP IMPLY AS TO VACUUM ENERGY, AND ANSWERING IF GRAVITONS HAVE MASS? DIVERGENCE FROM QM IF THEY DO
[2] The Large Scale Universe as a Quasi Quantum White Hole
2021
[3] Flat Space Cosmology with Rotation and Expansion
2021
[4] White Hole Cosmology-One Best Alternative for Standard Cosmology
2021
[5] COMMENTS ON THE USE OF THE FLATNESS THEOREM BY MELIA
2021
[6] Light speed expanding white hole universe having a red shift of [z/(1+ z)]
World Scientific News, 2021
[7] Estimating galactic dark matter and redshift in Flat Space Cosmology
2020
[8] Light speed expansion and rotation of a very dark Machian universe having internal acceleration
2020
[9] Light Speed Expansion and Rotation of a Primordial Black Hole Universe having Internal Acceleration
2020
[10] Applications of current cosmic angular velocity
2020
[11] A Practical Model of Godel–Planck–Hubble–Birch Universe
2019
[12] Unified Two Dimensional Spacetime for the River Model of Gravity and Cosmology
2019
[13] Gamma and Beta Model of Growing and Rotating Planck Ball
2019
[14] An Outline Picture of a Growing and Rotating Planck Universe with Emerging Dark Foam
2019
[15] Problems with the dark matter and dark energy hypotheses, and alternative ideas
2018
[16] On the Eternal Role of Planck Scale in Machian Cosmology
2018
[17] Tests and problems of the standard model in Cosmology
Foundations of Physics, 2017
[18] Limit Treatment of Space-Time Foam Calculations If Non Pathological Big Bang Singularity Is Accessible to Modified Einstein Equations
2017
[19] Asking If the Existence of Vacuum Energy to Keep Computational “Bits” Present at Start of Cosmological Evolution, Even If Spatial Radius Goes to Zero, Not …
2016
[20] Asking If the Existence of Vacuum Energy to Keep Computational “Bits” Present at Start of Cosmological Evolution, Even If Spatial Radius Goes to Zero, Not Planck Length, Is Possible
Journal of High Energy Physics, Gravitation and Cosmology, 2016
[21] Cosmic Initial Singularities in A Single Repeating Universe as Opposed to Their Behavior in A Multiverse
2014
[22] IF INITIAL LENGTH OF SPACE-TIME GOES TO A NON PATHOLOGICAL BIG BANG SINGULARITY INITIALLY, WHAT HAPPENS TO VACCUUM ENERGY EVOLUTION?
A Beckwith - rxiv.org, 2014
[23] INSURING EXISTENCE OF VACUUM ENERGY TO KEEP COMPUTATIONAL “BITS” PRESENT AT START OF COSMOLOGICAL EVOLUTION, EVEN IF INITIAL SPATIAL RADIUS GOES TO ZERO, NOT PLANCK LENGTH
A Beckwith - rxiv.org, 2014
[24] IS QUANTUM MECHANICS INVOLVED AT THE START OF COSMOLOGICAL EVOLUTION? DOES A MACHIAN RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GRAVITONS AND GRAVITINOS ANSWER THIS QUESTION?
A Beckwith - rxiv.org, 2014
[25] LIMIT TREATMENT OF SPACE-TIME FOAM CALCULATIONS IF INITIAL LENGTH OF SPACE-TIME COLLAPSES TO A NON PATHOLOGICAL BIG BANG SINGULARITY ACCESSIBLE TO MODIFIED EINSTEIN EQUATIONS
A Beckwith - rxiv.org, 2014
[26] A cosmological model based on Type Ia supernova discoveries at 0.01 < z ≤ 1.55 and dark energy evolution
2014
[27] Energy of Einstein's static universe and its implications for the? CDM cosmology
Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2013
[28] EINSTEINIAN REVOLUTION’S WRONG TURN: LUMPY INTERACTING COSMOS ASSUMED AS SMOOTH PERFECT FLUID, NO DARK ENERGY, ETERNAL UNIVERSE?
New Results and Actual Problems in Particle & Astroparticle Physics and Cosmology-Proceedings of XXIXth International Workshop on High Energy Physics, 2013
[29] Variation of Vacuum Energy if Scale Factor Becomes Infinitely Small, with Fixed Entropy Due to a Non Pathological Big Bang Singularity Accessible to Modified Einstein Equations
Journal of Modern Physics, 2012
[30] Variation of Vacuum Energy if Scale Factor Becomes Infinitely Small, with Fixed Entropy Due to a Non Pathological Big Bang Singularity Accessible to …
2012
[31] IF INITIAL LENGTH OF SPACE-TIME GOES TO A NON PATHOLOGICAL BIG BANG SINGULARITY INITIALLY, WHAT HAPPENS TO VACCUUM ENERGY …
[32] If A MACHIAN RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GRAVITONS AND GRAVITINOS EXIST, WHAT DOES SUCH A RELATIONSHIP IMPLY AS TO VACUUM ENERGY …
[33] INSURING EXISTENCE OF VACUUM ENERGY TO KEEP COMPUTATIONAL “BITS” PRESENT AT START OF COSMOLOGICAL EVOLUTION, EVEN IF …
[34] VARIATION OF VACUUM ENERGY IF SCALE FACTOR BECOMES INFINITELY SMALL,(WITH FIXED INITIAL ENTANGLEMENT ENTROPY) DUE TO A …
[35] LIMIT TREATMENT OF SPACE-TIME FOAM CALCULATIONS IF INITIAL LENGTH OF SPACE-TIME COLLAPSES TO A NON PATHOLOGICAL BIG BANG …

Copyright © 2024 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.