Deadly Inertia: A History of Constitutional Challenges to Canada's Criminal Code Sections on Prostitution

John Lowman

School of Criminology, Simon Fraser University.

DOI: 10.4236/blr.2011.22005                

Abstract

This paper examines rhetoric surrounding prostitution law reform in Canada from 1970 to the present. During the 1950s and 1960s, there was very little media or political attention paid to prostitution. It was not until the mid 1970s that perceived problems with prostitution law began to surface, driven by concerns that the criminal code statute prohibiting street prostitution was not enforceable. In 1983 the Liberal government appointed the Special Committee on Pornography and Prostitution to consider options for law and policy reform. However, the Conservative government that received the report in 1985 rejected the sweeping law changes the Special Committee recommended, opting instead to rewrite the street prostitution offence. Since then the murder of somewhere between 200 and 300 street prostitutes has prompted renewed calls for law reform. The debate on law reform culminated in 2006 with a parliamentary review that saw all four federal political parties agreeing that Canada’s prostitution laws are “unacceptable,” but unable to agree about how to change them. The majority report held that consenting adult prostitution should be legal, while the minority report held that it should be prohibited. In 2007 the Standing Committee on the Status of Women recommended that Canada adopt the Nordic model of demand-side prohibition. As the deadlock continues, women in the street sex trade continue to be murdered. Faced with this deadly inertia, two groups of sex workers have challenged several Criminal Code sections relating to prostitution, arguing that they violate several of their Constitutional rights, including their right to “life, liberty and security of the person”. The paper concludes with an update on the progress of the Charter challenges now before the courts.

Keywords

Prostitution Law Reform, Canada

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	G. Ekberg, “Abolishing Prostitution: The Swedish Solution. An Interview with Gunilla Ekberg,” Rain and Thunder: A Radical Feminist Journal of Discussion and Activism, Vol. 41, 2008. http://action.web.ca/home/catw/attach/R%26T_Interview_with_Gunilla_Ekberg.pdf
[2]	Subcommittee on Solicitation Laws of the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights, “The Challenge of Change: A Study of Canada’s Criminal Prostitu-tion,” Government of Canada, Ottawa, 2006. http://www2.parl.gc.ca/content/hoc/Committee/391/JUST/Reports/RP2599932/justrp06/sslrrp06-e.pdf
[3]	A. Jolin, “On the Backs of Working Prostitutes: Feminist Theory and Prostitution Policy,” Crime and Delinquency, Vol. 40, No. 1, 1994, pp. 69-83. doi:10.1177/0011128794040001005
[4]	J. S. Russell, “The Offence of Keeping a Common Bawdy House in Canadian Criminal Law,” Ottawa Law Review, Vol. 14, No. 2, 1982, pp. 270-313.
[5]	J. McLaren, “Chasing the Social Evil: Moral Fervour and the Evolution of Canada’s Laws, 1867-1917,” Canadian Journal of Law and Society, Vol. 1, 1986, pp. 125-165.
[6]	Committee on Sexual Offences against Children and Youth, “Sexual Offences against Children,” Department of Supply and Services, Ottawa, 1984.
[7]	Special Committee on Pornography and Prostitution (the Fraser Committee), “Pornography and Prostitution: In Canada,” Department of Supply and Services, Ottawa, 1985.
[8]	Federal-Provincial-Territorial Working Group on Prostitution (Working Group 1998), “Report and Recommen-dations in Respect of Legislation, Policy and Practices Con-cerning Prostitution-Related Activities,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1998.
[9]	Standing Committee on the Status of Women, “Turning Outrage into Action to Address Trafficking for the Purpose of Sexual Exploitation in Canada: Report of the Standing Committee on the Status of Women,” Com- munica-tion Canada, Ottawa, 2007, p. 3. http://cmte.parl.gc.ca/content/hoc/committee/391/fewo/reports/rp2738918/feworp12/feworp12-e.pdf
[10]	J. Gray, “Red Lights on the Prairies,” Signet, New York, 1971.
[11]	D. Nilsen, “The ‘Social Evil’: Prostitution in Vancouver, 1900-1920,” In: B. Latham and C. Kess, Eds., In Her Own Right: Selected Essays on Women’s History in B.C., Camosun College, Victoria, 1980, pp. 205-228.
[12]	N. Larsen, “Canadian Prostitution Control between 1914 and 1970: An Exercise in Chauvinist Reason-ing,” Canadian Journal of Law and Society, Vol. 7, No. 2, 1992, pp. 137-156.
[13]	L. Rotenberg, “The Wayward Worker: To-ronto's Prostitute at the Turn of the Century,” In: J. Acton, P. Goldsmith and B. Shepherd, Eds., Women at Work, Ontario 1850-1930, Canadian Women’s Educational Press, Toronto, 1974.
[14]	Vancouver Sun, “Trade Brisk in Call Girls: Sun Reveals Taxis Are Key to Sale of Sex,” Vancouver Sun, 12 January 1959, p. 1.
[15]	M. Layton, “Report on Prostitution in Vancouver: Official and Unofficial Reports,” Unpublished Report to the British Columbia Police Commission, 1975.
[16]	R. Prus and S. Irini, “Hookers, Rounders and Desk Clerks,” Gage Publishing, Toronto, 1980.
[17]	D. R. Brock, “Making Work, Making Trouble: Prostitution as a Social Prob-lem,” University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1998.
[18]	J. Lowman, “Street Prostitution in Vancouver: Notes on the Genesis of a Social Problem,” Canadian Journal of Criminol-ogy, Vol. 28, No. 1, 1986, pp. 1-16.
[19]	D. L. Winterton, “The Dilemma of Our Prostitution Laws,” Canadian Police Chief, Vol. 69, No. 2, 1980.
[20]	K. Doyle, “The Sexual Debate,” Maclean’s, April 15, 1985, p. 1.
[21]	Standing Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs, “Report to the House,” Solicitation for the Purposes of Prostitution, 1983.
[22]	J. Lowman, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Vancouver,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989.
[23]	A. Brannigan, L. Knafla and C. Levy, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Calgary, Regina and Winnipeg,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989.
[24]	R. Gemme, N. Payment and L. Malenfant, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Montreal,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989.
[25]	F. Graves, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Halifax,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989.
[26]	S. Moyer and P. J. Carrington, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Toronto,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989.
[27]	J. Fleischman, “Street Prostitution: Assessing the Impact of the Law, Synthesis Report,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1989, pp. 7-8.
[28]	J. Lowman, “Submission to the Subcommittee on Solicitation Laws,” 21 February 2005. http://mypage.uniserve.ca/~lowman/
[29]	Standing Committee on Justice and the Solicitor General, “Report of the Standing Committee on Justice and the Solicitor General Concerning the Three-Year Review of Section 213 of the Criminal Code,” 1990.
[30]	A. Brannigan, “Victimization of Prostitutes in Cal-gary and Winnipeg,” Technical Report No. TR1996-15e, De-partment of Justice, Ottawa, 1996.
[31]	J. Fleischman, “Vio-lence against Street Prostitutes in Halifax,” Technical Report No. TR1996-16e, Department of Justice Canada, Ottawa, 1996.
[32]	La bo?te à qu’on-se-voir, “étude sur les violences envers les prostituées à Montréal,” Technical Report No. TR1996-17e, Department of Justice Canada, Ottawa, 1996.
[33]	J. Lowman and L. Fraser, “Violence against Per-sons Who Prostitute: The Experience in British Columbia,” Technical Report No. TR1996-14e, Department of Justice Canada, Ottawa, 1996. http://24.85.225.7/lowman_prostitution/HTML/violence/Violence_Against_Persons_Who_Prostitute.pdf
[34]	J. Lowman, “Violence and the Outlaw Status of (Street) Prostitution in Canada,” Violence against Women, Vol. 6, No. 9, 2000, pp. 987-1011. doi:10.1177/10778010022182245
[35]	The Fed-eral-Provincial-Territorial Task Force on Prostitution, “Dealing With Prostitution in Canada: A Consultation Paper,” Department of Justice, Ottawa, 1995.
[36]	C. Skelton, “Is Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside really ‘Canada’s poorest postal code?’” Vancouver Sun, 10 February 2010. http://communities.canada.com/vancouversun/blogs/parenting/archive/2010/02/10/downtown-eastside-poorest-postcal-code.aspx
[37]	P. Leidl, “Prosperity and Poverty Make for Uneasy Bedfellows in World’s Most Livable City,” Feature story from the United Nations Population Fund report State of World Population 2007: Unleashing the Potential of Urban Growth, 2007, http://www.unfpa.org/swp/2007/presskit/index.htm
[38]	R. Stall, “Mayor to Propose Skid-Row Reward,” The Province, 25 April 1999, p. A16.
[39]	S. Currie, N. Laliberte, S. Bird, N. Rosa and S. Sprung, “Assessing the Violence against Street-Involved Women in the Downtown Eastside/Strathcona Community. A study funded by the Ministry of Women’s Equality, the Downtown Eastside Youth Activities and Watari. Mimeo, 1995.
[40]	K. Barry, “Female Sexual Slavery,” New York University Press, New York, 1979.
[41]	A. Dworkin, “Prostitution and Male Supremacy,” Address given at the symposium entitled “Prostitution: From Academia to Activism,” sponsored by the Michigan Journal of Gender and Law at the University of Michigan Law School, October 31, 1992. http://www.nostatusquo.com/ACLU/dworkin/MichLawJourI.html
[42]	M. Farley, “Bad for the Body, Bad for the Heart: Prosti- tution Harms Women Even If Legalized or Decriminal-ized,” Violence against Women, Vol. 10, No. 10, 2004, pp. 1087-1125. doi:10.1177/1077801204268607
[43]	J. Raymond, “10 Reasons for Not Legalizing Prostitution,” Coalition against Trafficking in Women International, 2003. http://action.web.ca/home/catw/attach/Ten%20Reasons%20for%20Not%20Legalizing%20Prostitution.pdf
[44]	J. Raymond, “Prostitution on Demand,” Violence against Women, Vol. 10, No. 11, 2004, pp. 1156-1186. doi:10.1177/1077801204268609
[45]	S. Bromberg, “Feminist Issues in Prostitution,” In: J. E. Elias, L. Bullough, V. Elias and G. Brewer, Eds., Prostitution: On Whores, Hustlers and Johns, Prometheus, New York, 1998, pp. 294-321.
[46]	International Center for Criminal Law Reform and Criminal Justice Policy, “An Exploration of Promising Practices in Response to Human Trafficking in Canada,” A Report commissioned by the Government of Manitoba on behalf of the Federal/Provincial/Territorial Forum of Senior Officials responsible for Status of Women, 2010. http://www.gov.mb.ca/msw/publications/human_trafficking.pdf
[47]	F. Shaver, “Prostitution: A Critical Analysis of Three Policy Approaches,” Canadian Public Policy, Vol. 11, No. 3, 1985, pp. 493-503. doi:10.2307/3550504
[48]	Stella and Maggies, “Not Up to the Challenge of Change: An Analysis of the Report of the Subcommittee on Solicitation Laws,” Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, 2007. http://www.aidslaw.ca/publications/publicationsdocEN.php?ref=665.
[49]	United Nations, “Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children,” Supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational and Organized Crime, 2000. http://www.uncjin.org/Documents/Conventions/dcatoc/final_documents_2/convention_%20traff_eng.pdf
[50]	M. Farley, J. Lynne and A. J. Cotton, “Prostitution in Vancouver: Violence and the Colonization of First Nation’s Women,” Transcultural Psychiatry, Vol. 42, No. 2, 2005, pp. 242-271. doi:10.1177/1363461505052667
[51]	M. A. Kennedy, C. Klein, J. T. K. Bristowe, B. S. Cooper and J. C. Yuille, “Routes of Recruitment: Pimp and Other Pathways into Prostitution,” Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment and Trauma, Vol. 15, No. 2, 2007, pp. 1-19. doi:10.1300/J146v15n02_01
[52]	M. A. Kennedy, C. Klein, B. B. Gorzalka and J. C. Yuille, “Attitude Change Following a Diversion Program for Men Who Solicit Sex,” Journal of Offender Rehabili- tation, Vol. 40, No. 1-2, 2004, pp. 41-60.
[53]	R. Poulin, “La Mondialisation des Industries du Sexe,” L’f nterligne, Ottawa, 2004.
[54]	Attorney General of Canada, “Factum of the Respondent, the Attorney General of Canada,” Bedford v. Canada, 2010 ONSC 4264, 2009.