g the Google browser with the following acronyms, keywords and phrases: “CME”, “CPD”, “continuing medical education”, “continuing professional development”, “accreditation”, “Europe” or “name of the country”.
Internet searches were conducted also using keywords in the countries’ native language. Most of the sites viewed had the English version; for those which hadn’t the English version was used Google Translate tool and the data that were found have been checked crossing available sources.
The review was carried out also using PubMed combining the same keywords (“Education, Medical, Continuing”, “accreditation”, “European Union”). We included studies published from January 2008 to present. Articles were selected based on their title and abstract. Articles not in English were excluded. Four articles were included in the main analysis (Christodoulou, 2007; Vlassis, 2010; Pardell, 2013; Costa, 2010).
The Health Acts of each European country was examined and relevant information extracted.
Members of the European Union of General Practioners (UEMO) were contacted to obtain additional information on UK, Denmark, Hungary, Germany, Malta, Czech Republic, France, Slovakia and Poland. In addition, we attempted to obtain information from countries with insufficient information on CME systems by directly contacting key members of the national competent CME authority. Requests were sent via email to representatives from 12 countries including: Denmark, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Estonia, Finland, Greece, Hungary, Latvia, Luxemburg, Malta, Portugal and Sweden.
2.2. Research Targets
The information we searched for each country were:
− the presence or absence of a CME system;
− the type of CME system (compulsory, voluntary);
− the CME requirements (number of credits per year);
− the unit of accreditation;
− the learning activities recognised;
− the end-users of the training;
− the participations in UEMS EACCME system;
− the name and the website of the competent CME authority of the country;
These relevant informations have been collected in tables like Table 1 for each countries.
3. Results and Discussion
Complete information about CME system was obtained from 24 European countries including: Austria (Akademie der arzte, 2010), Belgium (INAMI, 2012), Bulgaria (BLSBG, 2012; BLSBG CME/SDO Department, 2012), Cyprus (Christodoulou, 2007; CyMA, 2012), Czech Republic (ČLK, 2012; ČLK e-learning system, 2012; ČLK Board of Directors, 2012), Denmark (Van Hemelryck, 2009; UEMS. Denmark, 2008b; Lægeforeningen, 2012), Estonia (EAL, 2012), Finland (Finlex Data Bank, 2012; FMA, 2012), France (CNFMC, 2012), Germany (Bundesärztekammer, 2003; Bundesärztekammer, 2004; Bundesärztekammer, 2006; Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; Bundesärztekammer, 2012), Greece (UEMS. Greece, 2007; Vlassis, 2010), Hungary (MOTESZ, 2006; MOTESZ, 2012), Ireland (Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; RCPI, 2011; RCPI, 2012), Italy (Van Hemelryck, 2009; Agenas, 2010; Murgatroyd, 2011; Agenas, 2012), Latvia (Van Hemelryck, 2009; LAB, 2012), Lithuania (Van Hemelryck, 2009; SMM, 2009; VASPVT, 2012), Netherlands (UEMS. Netherlands, 2008a; Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; KNMG, 2012a, b), Poland (Van Hemelryck, 2009; NIL, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; NIL, 2012), Portugal (UEMS. Portugal, 2008d; Van Hemelryck, 2009), Romania (Van Hemelryck, 2009; CMR, 2011; CMR, 2012), Slovakia (SACCME, 2008; Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; SACCME, 2012), Slovenia (Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; ZZS, 2012), Spain (Pardell, 2008; Van Hemelryck, 2009; Costa, 2010; Murgatroyd, 2011; SEAFORMEC, 2012; Agencia estatal, 2012; Pardell, 2013)
Table 1. Example of a table used for collecting information on the CME system of each country.
Sweden (Van Hemelryck, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; IPULS, 2012), and United Kingdom (Van Hemelryck, 2009; RCP, 2011; RCP, 2012). For the three remaining countries (Lithuania, Luxembourg and Malta) partial information were found (UEMS. Luxembourg, 2008c; Van Hemelryck, 2009; SMM, 2009; Murgatroyd, 2011; VASPVT, 2012; Institut FMC, 2012; ALFORMEC, 2012; MAM, 2012).
Table 2 summarises the results of the research according to six fundamental categories: 1) the presence or absence of a CME system, 2) the CME requirements (compulsory, voluntary), 3) the number of credits per year, 4) the unit of accreditation, 5) the recognition of e-learning and 6) the target of CME.
The 27 countries are full members of UEMS and follow the EACCME directive. While there are various types of CME systems in each country, with some systems still in early development, the results suggest the existence of a common European framework (UEMS). The UEMS represents an important attempt to reduce the heterogeneity across the different CME systems.
A CME system is present in 26 EU countries (96%), but some systems do not have a format based on credits system (11%).
More than half of countries (15 countries, 56%) are characterised by a mandatory participation to their CME system. In the remaining countries participation is voluntary and based on the assumption that CME is a civic duty and, in some cases, participation is encouraged by either tax incentives or financial rewards.
There is a reasonable homogeneity in the type of CME system across countries and for most of them (15 countries) it can be divided into two main types:
− CME system with a five years cycle for a total of 200/250 credits (11 countries);
− CME system with a three years cycle for a total of 150 credits (5 countries).
The remaining CME systems are somewhat different including for example, a five years cycle for a total of 100/120 credits, and a system requiring 75 credits in seven years (Slovenia).
However, among the countries that provide CME credits (21 countries), the majority of these (16) requires healthcare operators to acquire 40 to 60 credits per year.
The case of Sweden is unique since the CME system is not based on credits. Details on the CME system were not available for Luxembourg, Malta, Portugal and Spain.
A large homogeneity on the accreditation unit across countries was observed. Specifically, 14 countries award one credit for one hour of activity and 6 countries award one credit for 45 minutes of activity. Information on accreditation unit was not available for the remaining 4 countries with a system based on credits. In addition, if we assume that 45 minutes are equal to an hour of training, all the countries with a system based on credits (21) utilises the same accreditation unit.
The type of activities accepted for credit across all 27 European Union countries includes: 1) internal/external activities, 2) publications and 3) referee duties. Distance learning (E-learning) was recognized for the acquisition of credits in 22 countries (81%) and not recognized in Greece and Estonia. Three countries (Luxembourg, Malta and Portugal) did not provide information on accepted activities for accreditation.
Table 2. Synthesis of information collected by the research about European CME systems.
Most CME systems (17 countries) are targeted to medical doctors (all specialties). Seven countries, Italy included, have a CME system open to other health operators (i.e. nurses, obstetricians, pharmacists and so on). Italy in particular is the only European country in which all health operators are obliged to enrol in a continuing medical education programme.
The results show there is a lack of standardisation between European countries’ CME systems and the development of a protocol of e-learning that could be consistently applied in different countries is warranted.
Most countries have CME systems with similar accreditation systems, recognize distance learning and have mutually recognized credits because they adhere to a common system (UEMS).
A potential limitation is that most CME systems are targeted only to medical doctors. However, global events requiring organized actions (which is the primary focus of the Tell Me Project) may require the involvement of different health operators who would be expected to follow specific training recommendations. Numerous health training activities are now operating in different countries which may need to be incorporated into each accreditation system and taken into account in case of a coordinated European action to rapidly spread information in case of a pandemic situation.
Few studies have reported a complete overview of the CME system in the 27 EU countries and this article may provide a useful update of the existing literature.
This report has been produced as a study of feasibility for an online course for primary care staff in the context of the European Project Tell Me-Transparent communication in Epidemics: Learning Lessons from experience, delivering effective Messages, providing Evidence (http://tellmeproject.eu).
- Agencia estatal (2012). Boletín oficial del estado (BOE) núm. 81. http://www.boe.es/boe/dias/2007/04/04/pdfs/A14765-14800.pdf
- Agenzia nazionale per i servizi sanitari regionali (Agenas), National Agency for Regional Health Services (2010). Criteri per l’assegnazione dei crediti alle attività ECM approvato dalla Commissione nazionale per la formazione continua. http://ape.agenas.it/documenti/2.criteri_per_assegnazione_crediti_e_fsc.pdf
- Agenzia nazionale per i servizi sanitari regionali (Agenas), National Agency for Regional Health Services (2012). http://www.agenas.it
- Akademie der arzte (2010). CPD (Continuing Professional Development) Regulations. http://www.arztakademie.at
- Association Luxembourgeoise pour la Formation Mèdicale Continue (ALFORMEC) Association for Continuing Medical Education of Luxemburg (2012). http://www.alformec.lu
- Bulgarian Medical Association (BLSBG) CME/SDO Department (2012). Mail email@example.com
- Bulgarian Medical Association (BLSBG) (2012). http://www.blsbg.com
- Bundesärztekammer, German federal Medical Association. (2004). Regulations Continuing Medical Education Certificate. http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/downloads/ADFBSatzungEn.pdf
- Bundesärztekammer, German Federal Medical Association (2012). http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de
- Bundesärztekammer, German Medical Association (2003). Social Health Insurance Modernisation Act. http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de
- Bundesärztekammer (2006). Order of 13 July 2006 Approving the Validation Rules CME. http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de
- Česká lékařská komora (ČLK) Czech Medical Chamber (2012). http://www.lkcr.cz
- Christodoulou, N. (2007). Continuing Medical Education and Continuing Professional Development in the Mediterranean Countries. Eura Medicophys, 43, 195-202. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17589412
- Colegiul Medicilor din Romania (CMR), Romanian College of Physicians (2011). National Continuing Medical Education Program. (Colegiul medicilor din romania, departamentul profesional stiintific, programul national de educatie medicala continua). http://www.amf-b.ro
- Colegiul Medicilor din Romania (CMR), Romanian College of Physicians (2012). http://www.cmr.ro
- Conseils Nationaux de la Formation Médicale Continue (CNFMC) (2012). National Councils for Continuing Medical Education. http://www.cnfmc.fr
- Cook, D. A., Levinson, A. J., Garside, S., Dupras, D. M., Erwin, P. J., & Montori, V. M. (2010). Internet-Based Learning in the Health Professions: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association, 300, 1181-1196. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jama.300.10.1181
- Costa, A., Van Hemelryck, F., Aparicio, A., Gatzemeier, W., Leer, J. W., Maillet, B., & Hossfeld, D. K. (2010). Continuing Medical Education in Europe: Towards a Harmonised System. European Journal of Cancer, 46, 2340-2343. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejca.2010.05.029
- Cyprus Medical Association (CyMA) (2012). http://www.cyma.org.cy
- Česká lékařská komora (ČLK), Czech Medical Chamber, E-Learning System (2012) http://www.eclk.cz
- Eesti Arstide Liit (EAL), Estonian Medical Association (2012). http://www.arstideliit.ee
- European Union of Medical Specialists (UEMS) (2012). http://www.uems.net/index.php?id=32
- Finlex Data Bank (2012). http://www.finlex.fi
- Fordis, M., King, J., Ballantyne, C. M. et al. (2005). Comparison of the Instructional Efficacy of Internet-Based CME with Live Interactive CME Workshops. A Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of the American Medical Association, 294, 1043-1051. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16145024 http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jama.294.9.1043
- Institut Luxembourgeois pour la Formation Médicale Continue (Institut FMC) Institute for Continuing Medical Education of Luxembourg (2012). http://www.institutfmc.lu
- Institut National d’Assurance Maladie Invalidité (INAMI), National Institute for Sickness and Invalidity (2012). http://www.inami.fgov.be
- Institute for Professional Development of Physicians in Sweden (IPULS) (2012). http://www.ipuls.se
- Koninklijke Nederlandsche Maatschappij tot bevordering der Geneeskunst (KNMG) Royal Dutch Medical Association (2012a). The Accreditation Board Cluster 1. http://www.cvah.net
- Koninklijke Nederlandsche Maatschappij tot bevordering der Geneeskunst (KNMG) Royal Dutch Medical Association (2012b). http://knmg.artsennet.nl
- Lægeforeningen, Danish Medical Association (LAEGER) (2012). http://www.laeger.dk
- Latvijas Ārstu Biedrība (LAB), Latvian Medical Association (2012). http://www.arstubiedriba.lv
- Magyar Orvostársaságok és Egyesületek Szövetsége (MOTESZ), Hungarian Medical Association. (2006). Amendment of Regulation 52/2003 (VIII 22) on the training of doctors, dentists, pharmacists and clinical psychologists. (51/2006. (XII. 28.) EüM rendelet az orvosok, fogorvosok, gyógyszerészek és klinikai szakpszichológusok folyamatos továbbképzéséről szóló 52/2003. (VIII. 22.) ESzCsM rendelet módosításáról). http://www.motesz.hu
- Magyar Orvostársaságok és Egyesületek Szövetsége (MOTESZ), Hungarian Medical Association (2012). http://www.motesz.hu
- Murgatroyd, G. B. (2011). Continuing Professional Development: The International Perspective. General Medic Council. http://www.gmc-uk.org/CPD___The_International_Perspective_Jul_11.pdf_44810902.pdf
- Naczelna Izba Lekarska (NIL), Polish Chamber of Physicians (2009). Bureau of the Supreme Medical Council, Appendix 1 to Resolution 52/04/PV of 24 April 2009 on the mode of operation of the Centre for Medical Training CED Polish Chamber of Physicians mode of operation of the Centre for Vocational Dental Practitioners Physicians and the Polish Chamber of Physicians and Dentists. (Zalacznik nr 1 do Uchwaly 52/04/P-V Prezydium Naczelnej Rady Lekarskiej z dnia 24 kwietnia 2009 w sprawie trybu dzialania Osrodka Doskonalenia Zawodowego Lekarzy i Lekarzy Dentystów Naczelnej Izby Lekarskiej). http://www.nil.org.pl/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/7745/pu-52-09-tryb-dzialania-ODZ-zal.pdf
- Naczelna Izba Lekarska (NIL), Polish Chamber of Physicians (2012). http://www.nil.org.pl
- Pardell, H. (2008). CME and CME Accreditation in Spain. http://www.europeancmeforum.eu/ecf2008/presentations/1_hpardell.pdf
- Pardell, H., & Sierra, G. (2003). Continuing Medical Education and Continuing Medical Education Accreditation in Spain. The Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 23, 244-246. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/chp.1340230508
- Royal College of Physicians (RCP) (2012). http://www.rcplondon.ac.uk
- Royal College of Physicians of Ireland (RCPI) (2011). Professional Competence Scheme. http://www.rcpi.ie/PC/Documents/ICHMT/ICHMT%20Professional%20Competence%20Scheme%20-%20General%20Division.pdf
- Royal College of Physicians of Ireland (RCPI) (2012). http://www.rcpi.ie
- CGCOM (2012). Sistema Español de Acreditación de la Formación Médica Continuada (SEAFORMEC). http://www.cgcom.es/seaformec
- Slovenská akreditačná rada pre kontinuálne vzdelávanie, Slovak Accreditation Council for CME (SACCME) (2008). Continuing medical education (CME). (Slovenská akreditaãná rada pre kontinuálne medicínske vzdelávanieãlen Európskej akreditaãnej rady CME, kontinuálne medicínske vzdelávanie v sr (CME)). http://www.saccme.sk/sites/default/files/bulletin_SACME_2008.pdf
- Slovenská akreditačná rada pre kontinuálne vzdelávanie, Slovak Accreditation Council for CME (SACCME) (2012). http://www.saccme.sk
- Suomen Lääkäriliitto, Finnish Medical Association (FMA) (2012). Mail firstname.lastname@example.org
- Švietimo ir mokslo ministerija (SMM) Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Lithuania (2009). http://www.smm.lt/prtm/p_reng/docs/VET-pranesimas-LT-2010.pdf
- Česká lékařská komora (ČLK), Czech Medical Chamber, Board of Directors (2012). Professional Regulation n. 16. http://www.lkcr.cz/doc/cms_library/sp16-novela-17-112012-100504.pdf
- The Continuing Professional Development (CPD) Office of the Federation of Royal Colleges of Physicians of the UK (RCP) (2011). Continuing Professional Development. http://www.rcseng.ac.uk/surgeons/working/docs/cpd-guidance
- The Medical Association of Malta (MAM) (2012). http://www.mam.org.mt
- Tell Me (2012). Transparent Communication in Epidemics: Learning Lessons from Experience, Delivering Effective Messages, Providing Evidence (Tell Me). http://tellmeproject.eu/
- UEMS (2008a). Netherlands. http://www.ipcaa.org/assets/Netherlands42818.pdf
- UEMS (2008b). Denmark. http://www.ipcaa.org/assets/Denmark86423.pdf
- UEMS (2007). Greece. http://www.ipcaa.org/assets/Greece77669.pdf
- UEMS (2008c). Luxembourg. http://www.ipcaa.org/assets/Luxembourg44760.pdf
- UEMS (2008d). Portugal. http://www.ipcaa.org/assets/Portugal81875.pdf
- Valstybinė akreditavimo sveikatos priežiūros veiklai tarnyba (VASPVT) State Health Care Accreditation Agency (2012). http://www.vaspvt.gov.lt/node/168
- Van Hemelryck, F. (2009). Continuing Medical Education (CME) in Europe. A Survey of the Situation in the 27 EU Member States. http://www.acoe.be/~/media/ECCO%20documents/ACOE/Apply%20for%20accreditation/SurveyresultsSeptember09.pdf
- Vlassis, N. P. (2010). More Is Not Better: Concerning Congresses. The Hellenic Journal of Cardiology, 51, 189-191. http://www.hellenicjcardiol.com/archive/full_text/2010/2/2010_2_189.pdf
- Zdravniška zbornica Slovenije (ZZS), Slovenian Medical Chamber (2012). http://www.zzs-mcs.si