Share This Article:

Restoration of Stocks of the Sea Cucumber Holothuria fuscogilva in the Red Sea with Transplanted Wild Juveniles

Abstract Full-Text HTML XML Download Download as PDF (Size:422KB) PP. 959-980
DOI: 10.4236/jwarp.2019.118057    64 Downloads   162 Views  


Over the last decade, holothuroid sea cucumbers in the Gulf of Aqaba of the Red Sea have been the target of continuous fishing. This has severely depleted sea cucumber stocks, especially the high-value species such as Holothuria fuscogilva. The present work demonstrates that restocking populations of H. fuscogilva that are at critically and chronically low levels by transplanting wild-captured juveniles can be effective. Juveniles were translocated from a robust population at Pharoan Island and released into two sites (Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay). Population density, growth rate and mortality at the original and two release sites were monitored for 2 yrs. The Pharoan population density was highest, with H. fuscogilva showing a strong preference for sandy habitat (21.3 - 18.4 ind./100m2), over seagrasses (3.6 - 2.5 ind./100m2) and corals (0.9 - 1.7 ind./100m2). The restocked population at Wadi Quny increased from 2.6 to 9.8 ind./100m2 from 2013-2015. In contrast, density at Hidden Bay decreased from 2.8 to only 0.1 ind./100m2 in the first year. Sea cucumbers in the restocked population at Wadi Quny had higher growth rates (0.65 - 1.29 cm/month) compared to the original population at Pharoan Island (0.21 - 0.45 cm/month), while Hidden Bay showed a negative growth rate. Mortality was low at Pharoan Island (1% - 2%) and Wadi Quny (0.5% - 0.75%), but high at Hidden Bay (49% - 100% in the first year). There was a negative relationship between mortality and size (P = 0.003). The restocking of H. fuscogilva populations using wild-captured juveniles was very successful at Wadi Quny but a failure at Hidden Bay.

1. Introduction

Due to the accelerating overexploitation of holothurians worldwide [1] - [8] , management strategies have been adopted to face their stock depletion. Conservative management should be the key to sustainable sea cucumber fisheries, especially at locations with severely depleted stocks. Restocking is an important procedure used for sea cucumber population management that can be employed when sites are depleted by overfishing [9] . Releases of juveniles can be used for stock enhancement [10] [11] and can improve the productivity at sites with relatively low natural recruitment or increase access of species to isolated habitats [12] . Most workers consider restocking by introducing hatchery-produced juveniles to a certain location, a very important procedure in increasing holothurians populations [13] [14] [15] . However, an alternative approach is to transfer wild natural holothurians juveniles from one area to another, especially from areas with high densities (full carrying capacity) and more suitable environmental conditions for juvenile sea cucumber growth. Restocking success of sea cucumbers depends on many factors such as predation [16] , adequate genetic diversity [17] , diseases [18] [19] , habitat quality [20] , depth [21] and food availability [22] . This report documents an example of successful restocking using wild juveniles of Holothuria fuscogilva, from an area of high density to two other areas of low densities at the Gulf of Aqaba.

The Gulf of Aqaba is valued as a unique environment with a wide range of habitats and outstanding marine biodiversity [23] [24] . In spite of the suitable environmental conditions provided at the Gulf for sea cucumber species, populations currently have low densities and diversity. High fishing pressure exerted on the sea cucumber populations at the Gulf, which began in the mid-1990’s, caused severe depletion in holothurid stocks, especially high-value species as H. fuscogilva [25] [26] [27] .

Holothuria fuscogilva is a deep water species usually found at depths ranging from 10 - 40 m on clean sand or seagrasses, the preferred habitat for this species [1] [28] . Like many other commercial species at the Gulf of Aqaba, overharvesting of H. fuscogilva, combined with poor management caused a severe depletion in its population over the last few years except for few sites, where high densities still occur. Pharoan Island as a protected area has a high abundance and diversity of sea cucumber species [26] . Presumably at some point, intraspecific competition would limit the number of individuals that could grow and survive to reproductive age [9] [10] . Transplanting juvenile H. fuscogilva to other locations with suitable habitat may be an effective way to enlarge this species’ populations at the Gulf of Aqaba. This strategy, coupled with the protection of remnant wild sea cucumber populations through the use of marine protected areas in this respect could be a sustainable solution for holothurid management [29] .

This study reports on the success of transferring juvenile H. fuscogilva from area of full carrying capacity (Phaeron Island) to two areas where stocks have been depleted from overfishing. Population densities at the three localities were monitored for two years, before and after restocking. The growth and survival of individually marked individuals at each locality were assessed to determined success or the failure of the recolonization efforts, and to identify habitat that may limit this approach in the future at new localities.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Study Sites

Of the three sites selected this study, Pharoan Island served as the control or original site, and Wadi Quny and Hidden bay as the restocked sites. All three sites had similar physical habitat (benthic substrate), food resource availability and exposure to natural enemies.

2.2. Pharoan Island

Pharoan Island is a small island south of Taba at the Gulf of Aqaba, separated from the coast by small (about 200 m wide) but deep (about 30 - 70 m) channel. It is small, with an area of approximately 3.9 hectares (9.6 acres). The island is a popular tourism site as it has an ancient citadel and spectacular coral reefs. The open sea side of the island has much greater biodiversity than the coast side. The site has a small reef flat that extends about 30 m and is composed of dead and live corals. The reef slope is steep and drops for about 15 m. The slope is composed of coral patches and white clean sand from the coral origin. The seabottom drops again for approximately 30 m, and is composed of sand and seagrasses. The island has a very flourishing marine life with a high species index for major taxonomic groups, particularly coral and fishes. It also has a high abundance of mollusks and echinoderms (personal observations). The algal cover is moderate at the island with high seagrass patches. The island is protected from fishing and other detrimental activities by a coast guard station.

2.3. Wadi Quny

The site located north of the city of Dahab on the coast of the Gulf of Aqaba. This site has a typical fringing reef, in which the reef flat area is divided into 3 zones. The “back reef” is composed of a fossil reef with very high algal cover. The “mid-reef” is composed of rocky patches and sand patches over a rocky basement from fossil reef. The “fore reef” is mainly composed of live corals with a small percentage of dead corals. The reef slope also has a well-developed coral formation that ends at depths around 20 m deep and transitions to a sandy bottom. This site supports a high density and diversity of fishes, corals and invertebrates. Benthic algae and seagrasses make up a high percentage of cover especially at the reef flat and in the sand of the seabed. The site has excellent conditions for sea cucumber existence [25] [26] . After the collection pressure on sea cucumbers was stopped by a governmental decree to ban its fishery, some species had the opportunity to reestablish and increase in density.

2.4. Hidden Bay

This site located inside Ras Mohamed National Park, located 12 km from the city of Sharm El Sheikh at the Southern tip of the Gulf of Aqaba. The park spans an area of 480 km2, including 135 km2 of surface land area and 345 km2 area of water. The site is a semi-closed inland bay, with low wave and current action. The site has a shallow depth ranging between 1 and 2.5 m, with extensive sandy habitat. Benthic algae and dense seagrass beds mainly composed of Halophilla stipulacea provide cover with large sandy patches of coarse coral origin sand interspersed. The site has high biological diversity and density of invertebrates that preferred the sandy bottom areas, with fewer fish species. Inside the national park, this site has full protection from fishing or harvesting.

2.5. Field Surveys and Sampling

Field surveys of sea cucumber faunal composition and population densities of H. fuscogilva were conducted at Pharoan Island, Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay, at the Gulf of Aqaba over a period of 25 months, from April 2013 to April 2015. Faunal surveys were conducted twice a year, H. fuscogilva densities were quantified at (approximately) 3-month intervals. For each survey, a number of transects were made starting from the highest watermark (HWM), parallel to the shore and covering different zones and habitats. Transects were made at the back reef, mid reef and fore reef at the reef flat, then at depths 5, 10, 20, 30, 40 and >40 meters. The length of each transect was 150 m, with 2 - 5 replicate transects at each zone. Along each transect 10 quadrats were established, each 10 m × 10 m (100 m2). Reef flats were surveyed by snorkeling, while deep water was surveyed by SCUBA diving. All species of sea cucumbers were recorded based on visual observation. Population densities of H. fuscogilva were determined from counts in quadrats and expressed as number of individuals/100m2. At each quadrat, visual surveys were used to describe different biotopes of the reef and composition of substrate in terms of percent of sand, small stones, seagrasses, algae, rocks, dead and live corals. At each site, the water temperature was also recorded.

2.6. Collection, Transport and Release of Wild Sea Cucumbers

In April 2013, 240 juveniles and 100 adults of H. fuscogilva were collected by SCUBA diving from Pharoan Island. The specimens were collected from depths ranging from 25 - 30 m. Juveniles ranged in body length from 3 - 10 cm, while lengths of the adults ranged from 28 - 36 cm. Most were collected from habitat defined as clean sand from the coral origin at the reef slope and sea bed.

There are two commonly used methods for transporting sea cucumbers: dry and wet. The former is used for short distances within three hours of the destination [30] . We used the wet method for transporting the collected individuals, which involves a canvas tank of 50 × 50 × 80 cm3 half full of aerated seawater. 60 juveniles or 20 adults were put into each tank. Animals were transported in the early morning to avoid exposure to direct sunlight. The temperature inside the tanks maintained below 20˚C. The first group of animals was released at Wadi Quny, which is 90 minutes (100 km) from Pharoan Island. 120 juveniles and 50 adults were released into sandy habitat by SCUBA diving at a depth of about 23 m. The second group of animals was released at Hidden Bay at Ras Mohamed National Park, which is approximately three hours (250 km) from Pharoan Island. 120 juveniles and 50 adults were released into sandy habitat at depths ranging from 2 - 2.5 m by snorkeling.

Animals were released into 10 m × 10 m (100 m2) quadrats along 150 m-transects at each site. Quadrats were spaced 5 m apart along the transect and there were 5 replicate transects. The total area of release at each site was slightly more than 1000 m2.

2.7. Tagging

In order to distinguish individuals, before their release 100 juvenile H. fuscogilva were tagged at each site to monitor the growth. All juvenile body lengths ranged from 3 to 10 cm. Adults were not marked or monitored in this part of the study.

Tagging was performed by using the heat branding technique commonly used to individually mark sea cucumbers, as described in [3] . At each of the three study sites, individuals were given the numbers from 1 to 100 by branding. The branded numbers were visible on the animals’ skin throughout the study period, with only a little blurring due to the growth of the animals. The branded marks provide an ideal way to monitor the growth of juveniles and the disappearance of the marks is slow; animals can be re-branded if necessary [3] .

2.8. Growth Measurement

After a two-week acclimation period, tagged animals were measured bi-monthly. Body lengths were measured using a measuring tape held above the animals but without touching it to avoid its contraction. Although there are other methods of measuring body size using wet or dry mass, these methods require considerably more transport and handling of animals. We chose to carry out less intrusive body length measurements when the animals were in a relaxed (e.g. non-locomotory, unexcited) state. If done carefully, body length measures are repeatable and have low standard errors. Animals were recorded as present/absent. If animals were not relocated in subsequent surveys they were considered to have either died or dispersed from the study area.

2.9. Statistical Analysis

Absolute growth rates and body lengths for the three populations (two released populations and the original source population) were compared at two-month intervals for 2 years after establishment with ANOVA’s and t-tests (when only two populations remained) computed in R version 3.5.0 [31] . The initial body sizes of juveniles assigned to the three sites did not differ.

Absolute growth rates were also calculated for animals in different size classes. Animals were allocated to seven size classes that differed by 1 cm and the growth rate for each month was computed as current-previous body length. Absolute growth rates allowed for better visualization of the growth of juveniles in different size classes and across different seasons.

3. Results

3.1. Faunal Composition

Bi-annual surveys carried out at the three sites (Pharoan Island, Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay), documented a total of 22 species of holothurian sea cucumber species (Table 1). Sea cucumber species richness at Pharoan Island was much greater than the other two sites. At the beginning of the survey (April 2013), 22 species were found at Pharoan Island, but only 4 at Wadi Quny and 3 at Hidden Bay. H. fuscogilva was observed only at Pharoan Island. The release of H. fuscogilva at the other two sites increased the number of species to 5 at Wadi Quny and 4 at Hidden Bay. After transplantation, H. fuscogilva became established at Wadi Quny and was recorded during subsequent surveys (Sep. 2013, Feb. 2014, Jul. 2014 and Apr. 2015), but in Hidden Bay it disappeared after few months (from Feb. 2014 onwards).

Table 1. Comparison of holothurian species recorded from the three investigated sites during the period from April 2013 to April 2015.

3.2. Population Density and Habitat Distribution of H. fuscogilva

The population densities of H. fuscogilva differed widely across the three study sites and habitats. Very high densities occurred at Pharoan Island in all surveys with no marked variations between seasons. However, densities at the receiving sites (Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay) were more variable (Table 2). After transfer H. fuscogilva to Wadi Quny, densities increased during the study period, from an average of 2.6 ± 1.5 ind./100m2 in April 2013 to 9.8 ± 3.1 in April 2015. Conversely, the density of H. fuscogilva dramatically decreased at Hidden Bay from 2.8 ind./100m2 at April 2013 to only 0.1 ind./100m2 at January 2014, and then it completely disappeared from the site (Table 2).

Populations of H. fuscogilva at Pharoan Island, Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay showed a distinct preference for sandy habitats. Individuals were more concentrated on sandy substrate either on or near the reef slope and among the coral patches. Although average densities were greatest on sandy substrate (ranged from 21.3 to 18.4 ind./100m2 at Pharoan Island, 9.8 and 2.6 ind./100m2 at Wadi Quny and 2.8 to 0.1 ind./100m2 at Hidden Bay), substantial densities were also observed in the seagrass (ranged between 3.6 and 2.5 ind./100m2 at Pharoan Island, 0.4 and 0.2 ind./100m2 at Wadi Quny and no individuals from seagrass at Hidden Bay). Densities on corals ranged from 1.2 to 0.9 ind./100m2 at Pharoan Island, while no individuals were observed on corals at Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay.

3.3. Growth Rates of Holothuria fuscogilva

Individuals of H. fuscogilva exhibited different growth patterns at the three sites. Table 3 lists the ANOVA and t-test comparisons of body size and growth rates

Table 2. Seasonal variation in densities of H. fuscogilva (ind./100m2) found in different habitats at the study sites from April 2013 to April 2015 (values shown are means ± SE of replicate transects).

Table 3. ANOVA results from monthly comparisons of body lengths and growth rates among the three populations (from month 0 to 12), and t-test comparisons between Pharoan and Wadi Quny after 12 months.

at different time points during the 24 months after transplantation. Both Pharoan Island and Wadi Quny sea cucumbers increased in body size during the period of study (Figure 1, Table A1 and Table A2). In contrast, Hidden Bay showed no sign of growth, or at least average body size increased only slightly. The increases in body lengths of H. fuscogilva at Wadi Quny were much higher than those of the original population at Pharoan Island. For example, individuals that began with a mean length of 3.51 cm on April 2013 reached 12.54 cm after two years at Pharoan Island (Table A1). At Wadi Quny, individuals that began with mean length of 3.58 cm at April 2013 reached 25.87 cm after the same period (Table A2). There were significant differences (P < 0.0001) in lengths of H. fuscogilva between the two sites from month 4 onwards.

When growth rates of the three populations were compared, it became evident that individuals at Hidden Bay initially had negative growth, and lost body mass during the first months (Figure 2). This was followed by an apparent modest increase in body length due to the disappearance of smaller individuals, which caused the average body length to appear to remain constant or increase slightly.

Figure 1. Average size (body length) of H. fuscogilva at Pharoan Island compared to those transplanted to Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay from April 2013 (month 0) to April 2015 (24 months later). Symbols indicate mean values ±SE. Some SE bars are smaller than symbols. Initial sample sizes consisted of N = 100 marked juvenile individuals.

Figure 2. Comparison of growth rates of H. fuscogilva between the restocked juveniles at Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay with the original population at Pharoan Island during the period from April 2013 to April 2015. Symbols indicate mean values ±SE. Some SE bars are smaller than symbols. Initial sample sizes consisted of N = 100 marked juvenile individuals.

When growth rates were examined relative to body size, it was apparent that smaller individuals had slightly higher growth rates than larger individuals. At Pharoan Island, growth rate ranged between 0.27 to 0.45 cm/month for size class 3 - 3.9 cm and from 0.21 to 0.30 cm/month for size class 9 - 9.9 cm (Figure 3), the same pattern was observed at Wadi Quny (Figure 4) although absolute growth rates were higher.

Figure 3. Growth rates of different size classes of the original population of H. fuscogilva at Pharoan Island during the period from April 2013 to April 2015.

Figure 4. Growth rates of different size classes of the restocked population of H. fuscogilva at Wadi Quny during the period from April 2013 to April 2015.

Seasonal differences in growth rate were also observed. At both high-quality sites, the minimum growth rate occurred during winter between February and April (months 10 - 12 and 22 - 24), while the maximum growth rate was recorded between June and October (months 2 - 6 and 14 - 18). Comparison of growth rates between the two sites revealed that the restocked H. fuscogilva juveniles at Wadi Quny increased body length faster (ranged between 1.29 and 0.65 cm/month) than the original population at Pharoan Island (ranged between 0.45 and 0.21 cm/ month) (Figure 3). There were also significant differences in growth at the two sites during the summer months (Table 3). Growth rates at Wadi Quny were low after the first two months after transplantation (by June 2013), ranging between 0.21 and 0.15 cm/month, but increased from August 2013 onwards.

3.4. Mortality

Natural mortality is an important factor in determining the success of any given population to disperse and establish at a new area. Results from this study showed that natural mortality (disappearance) of H. fuscogilva juveniles ranged from 1% to 2% at Pharoan Island (original population) and ranged between 0.5% and 0.75% at Wadi Quny (released population) during the two-year study period. At Wadi Quny mortality occurred (0.75%) shortly after the restocking process, but after two months only a few juveniles died. Conversely, Hidden Bay exhibited high mortality (Figure 5). By two months after introduction to the site, 49% of the restocked H. fuscogilva juveniles were dead. The mortality rate increased to 59% by August 2013; 76% by October 2013; 81% at December 2013; 96% at February 2014 and all animals had completely disappeared by April 2014 (Figure 5).

The size of individuals played an important role in mortality. There was a correlation (P = 0.003) between the size of the individuals and mortality at Hidden Bay, with smaller sizes suffering a higher mortality rate. For example, in size class 3 - 3.9 cm, 84.6% of the individuals were dead after two months. The mortality decreased to 55.56% for size class 4 - 4.9 cm, 53.86% for size class 5 - 5.9 cm, and 26.67% for size class 9 - 9.9 cm (Figure 5). Larger individuals survived for a longer time than smaller ones; whereas all individuals in size class 3 - 3.9 cm were dead at October 2013, size class 4 - 4.9 persisted until December 2013, size classes 5 - 5.9, 6 - 6.9 and 7 - 7.9 cm survived until February 2014 and individuals in both size classes 8 - 8.9 and 9 - 9.9 did not disappear until April 2014 (Figure 5).

3.5. Assessing Restocking Success

The present study generally followed a BACI (Before-After-Control Impact) approach [32] [33] to assess the success of the restocking of H. fuscogilva juveniles from the original population at Pharoan Island to the released populations at Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay. Surveys conducted at the original (the control site) before, during and after the restocking effect (e.g. after 1 and 2 years) allowed better assessment of the effect of restocking from natural variability arising from other environmental factors.

Our findings indicate that the restocking of H. fuscogilva was successful at Wadi Quny, where the population density increased from 2.6 ind./100m2 at the releasing time to 4.0 ind./100m2, one year after the release (April 2014) and to 9.8 ind./100m2 after two years (April 2015). In contrast, Hidden Bay failed to support the restocking. Initial densities were 2.9 ind./100m2 at the release time but all animals had completely disappeared before the end of the first year (Figure 6). Densities at the original population, Pharoan Island, remained unchanged during the study period.

Figure 5. Mortality (or disappearance) of different size classes of the released juveniles of H. fuscogilva at Hidden Bay during the period from April 2013 to April 2014. Initially, ten animals in each size class were transplanted.

Figure 6. Assessment of the restocking success (density of animals) of H. fuscogilva juveniles before, at and after (1 year and 2 years) transplanting from the original population at Pharoan Island (Control) to the two released populations at Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay using BACI (Before-After-Control Impact) design.

4. Discussion

During the past few years, over-exploitation of sea cucumber in the Gulf of Aqaba has caused a severe decline in the population densities of almost all species [25] [34] at most locations monitored [26] . The high fishing pressure leads to the disappearance of many commercial species and reduction of the others. The recovery of over-fished sea cucumber stocks is a lengthy process and can take several years [35] [36] [37] . The enhancement of natural populations at over-fished areas with new wild stocks combined with an adequate management scheme is recommended as a management strategy. In the present study, we translocated H. fuscogilva juveniles ranging in size from 3 to 10 cm from a flourishing population at Pharoan Island to two sites (Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay). All three sites have favorable environmental conditions for sea cucumbers in terms of food availability and suitable substrate. After two years, the introduced population of H. fuscogilva showed a marked success in Wadi Quny, with sustained densities, high survival and even higher growth rates than the original population at Pharoan Island. In contrast, Hidden Bay individuals exhibited negative growth rates and very low survival, especially among smaller sized individuals.

4.1. Species Ecology

Favorable environmental conditions are no longer the only factor controlling the existence of sea cucumber at the Gulf of Aqaba; over-exploitation from commercial harvests strongly influences sea cucumber densities and distribution [26] . Even though the chosen sites (Pharoan Island, Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay) all appeared to have good environmental conditions for the existence and well-being of sea cucumbers, their sea cucumber fauna varied. Pharoan Island supported a very high species richness (22 species) and densities, most likely due to the protection of the site with a coast guard station, which prevents fishing. The same number of species was recorded at Pharoan a decade ago [26] . On the other hand, Wadi Quny supported very low taxonomic richness (4 species) and density, illustrating a dramatic decrease in sea cucumber density and diversity in just the past few years due to fishing pressure and weak protection and management. The site supported 12 species in 1995, 8 species in 2002 [25] [35] , and only 4 species in 2003 [26] . After the sea cucumber population was decimated, fishermen moved to other areas, providing the opportunity for restocking of H. fuscogilva at the site on April 2013. The species not only re-established at the site but also grew well due to suitable natural conditions and the absence of sea cucumber fishing. In contrast, at Hidden Bay in spite of the existence of apparently favorable environmental conditions and no fishing pressure, there was low sea cucumber richness (3 species) and H. fuscogilva transplanted to the site did not succeed.

Habitat suitability is a critical factor that can limit the number of individuals that can recruit successfully without retarded growth and survival [9] . High population densities can be achieved when the number of individuals and/or species at the site utilize the habitat efficiently but do not hamper the growth of the individuals from stress or lack of food, substrate, space or other resources needed for established and growth of the species [10] . The greatest densities of H. fuscogilva were observed at Pharoan Island, where the values were almost on order of magnitude higher than those at the other two sites. H. fuscogilva showed negligible temporal variation in density at Pharoan Island during the period of study (April 2013-April 2015). An earlier study [38] also reported that there was no significant difference in temporal abundance measured on a monthly basis over a 14-month period. This suggests that Pharoan Island may be near its full carrying capacity. In contrast, at Wadi Quny, sea cucumbers increased rapidly in density, especially in the second year (April 2014-April 2015). The rapid increase suggests the high suitability of habitat at this site could sustain many more individuals and perhaps additional species.

Hidden Bay initially appeared to have favorable conditions that could sustain a large sea cucumber population. However, the density of H fuscogilva decreased from the beginning of the study and disappeared after January 2014. The failure of H. fuscogilva to establish at this site may be attributed to the shallow depth and high water temperature. In addition to substrate [39] [40] , food availability [22] [41] , a variety of niches and small numbers of natural predators [42] [43] , depth is one of the most important factors controlling the distribution and well-being of sea cucumber species [44] [45] [46] . H. fuscogilva is a deep water species, usually found at depths ranged between 10 to 40 meters [45] on clean sand of coral origin on the reef slopes of fringing, patch or barrier reef [28] . Temperature plays a very important role in the well-being of the sea cucumber. The movement and feeding activity of young sea cucumbers sharply decreased when water temperature exceeds 23˚C [47] . When environmental factors at the two release sites (Wadi Quny and Hidden Bay) are compared, it appears that Wadi Quny has high availability of food, suitable substrate, high variety of niches and a low number of natural enemies. In addition, water depth ranges between 20 to 25 m, and temperatures at this depth do not exceed 22˚C during the summer season. On the other hand, Hidden Bay also appears to have high food availability, suitable substrate, a high variety of niches and low numbers of natural enemies. However, the shallow depth of the site, which ranges between 1.2 and 2.5 meters, accompanied by higher water temperatures, which can exceed 36˚C during the summer season, cause the site to be unfavorable. Subsequently, transplanted animals failed to establish at the site and disappeared after 10 months.

The analysis of benthic habitat in the current study suggests that H. fuscogilva prefers sandy habitat, followed by seagrass. Similar findings were reported at New Caledonia [1] . Low densities of the species were recorded from the coral habitat only from Pharoan Island, indicating that coral is not the favorable habitat for the species and it occasionally exists on corals. The study never recorded H. fuscogilva from dead corals or rocks.

The right habitat features to release juveniles are critical for restocking. In optimal habitats, the survival of juveniles can exceed 90%, whereas survival in unsuitable habitat is much lower and highly variable [16] [48] [49] . The best habitat for releasing juveniles may not be the same as the habitats where adults are found [9] [50] . Adult habitat may offer better foods but a higher risk from predators. Moreover, juveniles may survive and grow better in certain microhabitats within the general habitat in which they occur with adults. The presence of very a small density of H. fuscogilva in seagrass habitat at Wadi Quny suggested that juveniles preferred the same habitat of the adult (sandy habitat).

4.2. Growth Rate

Growth rates of H. fuscogilva showed marked differences between sites and seasons. The released population at Wadi Quny showed a higher growth rate than the original population at Pharoan Island during the two years of study period except for the first two months when the growth rate at Wadi Quny was very low. This may be due to the need for released juveniles to acclimatize on the new site. The released population at Hidden Bay showed a negative growth until animals completely disappeared after a few months from introducing to the site. Growth rates of holothuroids are affected by population density [51] and the availability of food, which is determined by the number of animals feeding upon the resource [52] . From the results obtained it seems clear that Wadi Quny had more suitable habitat and food resources for the density of animals located there compared to Pharoan Island.

The high growth rates of H. fuscogilva, especially at Wadi Quny, were greater than rates reported in the literature for H. scabra and Actinopyga echinites (0.5 cm/month) [28] . Generally, at Wadi Quny the commercial length of H. fuscogilva was achieved within 10 to 12 months after transplantation. This is shorter than the period taken by wild juveniles of Apostichopus japonicas when reared in ponds (10 - 18 months) at Dalian [47] . H. fuscogilva at Pharoan Island needed a longer period (22 - 24 months) to reach similar lengths. When food is plentiful, animals can grow faster. A. echinites in aquaria grow to sexual maturity within one year and full size in another year [28] .

The growth rates of sea cucumber are closely related to water temperature, with the highest growth occurring in spring and winter months [47] . The optimum water temperature for sea cucumber growth is 17˚C, but juveniles can maintain high growth rates at 24˚C to 25˚C [53] . The present study recorded higher growth at both Pharoan Island and Wadi Quny during summer and autumn, where H. fuscogilva populations were at depths of 20 to 25 m and water temperatures of 22˚C in summer and 20˚C in autumn, favorable temperatures for the species to achieve high growth rates. This temperature decreased to 12˚C in winter, which slowed growth rates. At Hidden Bay, the negative growth may be attributed to the unfavorable shallow depth (1.2 to 2.5 m) and high fluctuation in water temperature across different seasons.

4.3. Mortality

One concern arising from the restocking of natural juveniles of H. fuscogilva is the relatively high mortality rates that could occur. The success of H. fuscogilva at any particular habitat depends on several factors such as substrate, depth, settlement, distance from the shoreline, availability of food and water temperature [40] [53] [54] [55] [56] . Depth is particularly important for H. fuscogilva; the species is more abundant at the deeper waters ranged from 10 to 40 m [45] . In our study, mortality was very low at both Pharoan Island and Wadi Quny. The high mortality rate at Hidden Bay may be attributed to the shallow depth and higher water temperatures. The depth at the site ranged between 1.2 and 2.5 m, which is not suitable for H. fuscogilva. The water temperature ranged between 30˚C and 32˚C in summer and 7˚C to 10˚C in winter. The juveniles of H. fuscogilva likely could not tolerate the extreme summer temperatures at Hidden Bay and died a few months after release.

This study also revealed that the small juveniles at Hidden Bay had a higher mortality rate than the bigger ones. The same conclusion was reached in another study that reported higher survival in larger sized juveniles; they also found that individuals larger than 2 cm had a survival rate of at least 20% - 30% under favorable conditions [47] .

4.4. Restocking Success

There is much recent interest worldwide in restocking sea cucumbers in the wild using hatchery-produced juveniles [13] [14] [15] [57] . However, the habitat preferences and ecology of many species of juvenile sea cucumber is poorly understood [48] [49] [50] [58] [59] . No study to date has evaluated the restocking of native juveniles by transferring them from sites of high density to a new site that would allow the juveniles to survive, grow and increase in density. Our study demonstrates that transplanting can be a viable alternative to restocking with hatchery juveniles to help rebuild damaged sea cucumber populations while maintaining the genetic diversity of wild populations, which is sometimes a concern [15] [17] [60] . Not only did the restocking of H. fuscogilva succeed at Wadi Quny, it resulted in a higher density of animals than the original population at Pharoan Island after two years. Wadi Quny appears to have a higher carrying capacity (food availability and space) that permits strong growth, survival and increase in H. fuscogilva population density.

Sea cucumbers are among the most fishery-targeted marine organisms due to their high demand in the fish market. The overfishing exerted on these species has severely depleted stock worldwide. Once depleted, fishermen move and seek new fishing grounds. The high-value and easy collection of sea cucumber due to their slow movement have caused the severe depletion of stocks all over the world. The need for new techniques to compensate and regenerate depleted stocks is very important worldwide.

Ethical Approval

All applicable international, national and/or institutional guidelines for the care and use of animals were followed by the authors.


Table A1. Increase in length (cm) of different size classes of H. fuscogilva during the period of study from April 2013 to April 2015 from the original population at Pharoan Island (values in bold are S.D.).

Table A2. Increase in length (cm) of different size classes of H. fuscogilva during the period of study from April 2013 to April 2015 from the restocked population at Wadi Quny (values in bold are S.D.).

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Cite this paper

Hasan, M. and Johnson, K. (2019) Restoration of Stocks of the Sea Cucumber Holothuria fuscogilva in the Red Sea with Transplanted Wild Juveniles. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 11, 959-980. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2019.118057.


[1] Conand, C. (1990) The Fishery Resources of Pacific Island Countries. Part 2: Holothurians. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper, No. 272.2, 141 p.
[2] Conand, C. and Byrne, M. (1993) A Review of Recent Developments in the World Sea Cucumber Fisheries. Fish and Fisheries, 14, 34-59.
[3] Holland, A. (1994) The Status of Global Beach-De-Mer Fisheries with Special Reference to the Solomon Islands and the Potentials of Holothurian Culture. MSc. Thesis, University of Newcastle, Newcastle.
[4] Conand, C. (1998) Overexploitation in the Present Sea Cucumber Fisheries and Perspectives in Mariculture. In: Mooi, R. and Telford, M., Eds., Echinoderms, Balkema, San Francisco, 449-454.
[5] Jaquemet, S. and Conand, C. (1999) The Beche-de-Mer Trade in 1995/1996 and an Assessment of Exchange between the Main World Markets. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 12, 11-14.
[6] Trianni, M.S. (2002) Summary of Data Collected from the Sea Cucumber Fishery on Rota, Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 16, 5-11.
[7] Altamirano, M., Toral-Granda, M.V. and Cruz, E. (2004) The Application of the Adaptive Principle to the Management and Conservation of Isostichopus fuscus in the Galapagos Marine Reserve. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 247-257.
[8] Conand, C. (2004) Present Status of World Sea Cucumber Resources and Utilization an International Overview. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 13-23.
[9] Purcell, S. (2004) Criteria for Release Strategies and Evaluating the Restocking of Sea Cucumbers. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 181-191.
[10] Bell, J. D. and Nash, W. (2004) When Should Restocking and Stock Enhancement Be Used to Manage Sea Cucumber Fisheries. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 173-179.
[11] Ivy, G., Azari D. and Giraspy, B. (2006) Development of Large-Scale Hatchery Production Techniques for the Commercially Important Sea Cucumber Holothuria scabra var. versicolor (Conand, 1986) in Queensland, Australia. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 24, 28-34.
[12] Bell, J.D. (1992) An Introduction to the Potential and Problems of Enhancing Recruitment. In: Hancock, D.A., Ed., Recruitment Processes. Australian Society Fish Biology Workshop, Bureau of Rural Resources Proceeding No. 16, AGPS, Canberra, Australia, 177-182.
[13] Purcell, S.W., Mercier, A., Conand, C., Hamel, J.F., Toral-Granda, M.V., Lovatelli, A. and Uthicke, S. (2013) Sea Cucumber Fisheries: Global Analysis of Stocks, Management Measures and Drivers of Overfishing. Fish and Fisheries, 14, 34-59.
[14] Hair, C., Mills, D.J., Mclntyre, R. and Southgate, P.C. (2016) Optimising Methods for Community-Based Sea Cucumber Ranching: Experimental Releases of Cultured Juvenile Holothuria scabra into Seagrass Meadows in Papua New Guinea. Aquaculture Reports, 3,198-208.
[15] Han, Q.-X., Keesing, J.K. and Liu, D.-Y. (2016) A Review of Sea Cucumber Aquaculture, Ranching, and Stock Enhancement in China. Reviews in Fisheries Science & Aquaculture, 24, 326-341.
[16] Dance, S.K., Lane, I. and Bell, J.D. (2003) Variation in Short Term Survival of Cultured Sand Fish (Holothuria scabra) Released in Mangrove-Seagrass and Coral Reef Flat Habitats in Solomon Islands. Aquaculture, 220, 495-505.
[17] Utter, F. (1998) Genetic Problems of Hatchery-Reared Progeny Released into the Wild, and How to Deal with Them. Bulletin of Marine Science, 65, 623-640.
[18] Eeckhaut, I., Parmentier, E., Becker, P., da Silva, S.G. and Jangoux, M. (2004) Parasites and Biotic Diseases in Field and Cultivated Sea Cucumber. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 311-325.
[19] Wang, Y.-G., Zhang, C.-Y., Rong, X.-J., Chen, J.-J. and Shi, C.-Y. (2004) Diseases of Cultured Sea Cucumber, Apostichopus japonicus, in China. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 297-310.
[20] Mercier, A., Battaglene, S.C. and Hamel, J.F. (2000) Settlement Preferences and Early Migration of the Tropical Sea Cucumber H. scabra. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 249, 89-110.
[21] Hamel, J.F., Conand, C., Pawson, D.L. and Mercier, A. (2001) The Sea Cucumber Holothuria scabra (Holothuroidea: Echinodermata): Its Biology and Exploitation as Beach-de-Mer. Advances in Marine Biology, 41, 129-205.
[22] Weidemeyer, W.L. (1992) Feeding Behaviour of Two Tropical Holothurians Holothuria (Metriatyla) scabra and Holothuria (Halodeima) atra from Okinawa, Japan. Proceeding of the 7th International Coral Reef Symposium, Guam, 22-27 June 1992, 853-860
[23] Head, S.M. (1987) Chapter 1—Introduction. In: Edwards, A.J. and Head, S.M., Eds., Key Environments Red Sea, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1-21.
[24] Nasr, D. (2015) Coral Reefs of the Red Sea with Special Reference to the Sudanese Coastal Area. In: Rasul, N. and Stewart, I., Eds., The Red Sea. Springer Earth System Sciences, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 453-469.
[25] Hasan, M.H. (2003) Ecology and Distribution Patterns of the Threatened Holothuroids as Correlated with Over-Fishing in the Gulf of Aqaba, Northern Red Sea, Egypt. Journal of Egyptian Academic Society of Environmental Development, 4, 101-118.
[26] Hasan, M.H. and Hasan, Y.S. (2004) Natural Ecological Factors and Human Impacts Influencing the Spatial Distribution of Holothuroid Species in the Gulf of Aqaba. Journal of the Egyptian German Society of Zoology, 43, 287-306.
[27] Lawrence, A.J., Ahmed, M., Hanafy, M., Gabr, H., Ibrahim, A. and Gab-Alla, F.A. (2005) Status of the Sea Cucumber Fishery in the Red Sea—The Egyptian Experience. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper, 79-90.
[28] Shelley, C. (1981) Aspects of the Distribution, Reproduction, Growth and Fishery Potential of Holothurians in the Papuan Coastal Lagoon. MSc Thesis, University of Papua New Guinea, Port Moresby.
[29] Bungitak, J. and Lindsay, S. (2004) Marine Resources Survey and Assessment of Jaluit Atoll, Republic of the Marshall Islands. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 19, 31-38.
[30] Liu, X.Y., Zhu, G.H., Zhao, Q., Wang, L. and Gu, B.X. (2004) Studies on Hatchery Techniques of the Sea Cucumber, Apostichopus japonicus. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, C., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 287-295.
[31] R Core Team (2013) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.
[32] Underwood, A.J. (1991) Beyond BACI: Experimental Designs for Detecting Human Environmental Impacts on Temporal Variation in Natural Populations. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 42, 569-587.
[33] Underwood, A.J. (1992) Beyond BACI: The Detection of Environmental Impacts on Populations in the Real but Variable, World. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 161, 145-178
[34] Hasan, M.H. and Abd El-Rady, S.E.-D.A. (2012) The Effect of Fishing Pressure on the Ecology of Sea Cucumber Populations in the Gulf of Aqaba, Red Sea. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 32, 53-59.
[35] Skewes, T., Dennis, D. and Burridge, C. (2000) Survey of Holothuria scabra (Sandfish) on Warrior Reef, Torres Strait. CSIRO Division of Marine Research Final Report.
[36] Purcell, S., Gardener, D. and Bell, J. (2002) Developing Optimal Strategies for Restocking Sand Fish: A Collaborative Project in New Caledonia. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 16, 2-4.
[37] Bruckner, A.W., Johnson, K.A. and Field, J.D. (2003) Conservation Strategies for Sea Cucumbers. Can a CITES Appendix II Listing Promote Sustainable International Trade? SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 18, 24-33.
[38] Lokani, P. (1995) Fishery Dynamics, Ecology and Management of Beche-de-Mer at the Warrior Reef, Torres Strait Protected Zone, Papua New Guinea. MSc Thesis, James Cook University of North Queensland.
[39] Roberts, D. (1979) Deposit-Feeding Mechanisms and Resource Partitioning in Tropical Holothurians. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 37, 43-56.
[40] Mercier, A, Battaglene, S.C. and Hamel, J.F. (1999) Daily Burrowing Cycle and Feeding Activity of Juvenile Sea Cucumber H. scabra in Response to Environmental Factors. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 239, 125-156.
[41] Jontila, J.B.S., Balisco, R.A.T. and Matillano, J.A. (2014) The Sea Cucumbers (Holothuroidea) of Palawan, Philippines. AACL Bioflux, 7, 194-206.
[42] Guille, A. and Ribes, S. (1981) Echinoderms associes aux Scleractinaires d’un recif grangeant de l’ile de la Reunion (Ocean Indian). Bulletin de Musum de Natural History National Paris, 3, 73-92.
[43] Mezali, K. (2001) Abundance, Dispersion and Microdistribution of Aspidochirotid Holothurian (Holothuroidea: Echinodermata) in the Pasidonia oceanica Meadow of the Sidi Fredj Peninsula (Algeria). 6th European Congress on Echinoderms, Banyuls, France, 3-7 September 2001, 24.
[44] Price, A.R.G. (1982) Echinoderms of Saudi Arabia. Comparison between Echinoderm Faunas of Arabian Gulf, SE-Arabia, Red Sea and Gulfs of Aqaba and Suez. Fauna of Saudi Arabia, 4, 3-21.
[45] Preston, G.L. and Lokani, P. (1990) Report of a Survey of the Sea Cucumber Resources of Ha’apai, Tonga. June 1990, Inshore Fisheries Research Project, Country Assignment Report, SPC, New Caledonia, 17.
[46] Lokani, P., Matoto, S.V. and Ledua, E. (1996) Report of a Survey of Sea Cucumber Resources at Ha’apai, Tonga. May-June 1996, South Pacific Community, Noumea, New Caledonia, 13.
[47] Chang. Y.-Q., Yu, C.-Q. and Song, X. (2004) Pond Culture of Sea Cucumbers, Apostichopus japonicus, in Dilan. In: Lovatelli, A., Conand, C., Purcell, S., Uthicke, S., Hamel, J.F. and Mercier, A., Eds., Advances in Sea Cucumber Aquaculture and Management, FAO, Rome, 269-272.
[48] Eriksson, H., Jamon, A. and Wickel, J. (2012) Observations on Habitat Utilization by the Sea Cucumber Stichopus chloronotus. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 32, 39-42.
[49] Eriksson, H., Byrne, M. and de la Torre-Castro, M. (2012) Sea Cucumber (Aspidochirotida) Community, Distribution and Habitat Utilization on the Reefs of Mayotte, Western Indian Ocean. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 452, 159-170.
[50] Slater, M.J. and Jeffs, A.G. (2010) Do Benthic Sediment Characteristics Explain the Distribution of Juveniles of the Deposit-Feeding Sea Cucumber Australostichopus mollis? Journal of Sea Research, 64, 241-249.
[51] Jean Beth, S.J., Rodulf, A.T.B. and Glesselle, T.B. (2017) Species Composition, Density and Distribution of Sea Cucumbers (Holothuroidea) at Arreceffi Island, Honda Bay, Palawan, Philippines. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 37, 21-29.
[52] Weidemeyer, W.L. (1994) Biology of Small Juveniles of the Holothurian Actinopyga echinites Growth, Mortality and Habitat Preferences. Marine Biology, 120, 81-93.
[53] Chen, J. (2003) Overview of Sea Cucumber Farming and Sea Ranching Practices in China. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 18, 18-23.
[54] Massin, C. and Doumen, C. (1986) Distribution and Feeding of Epibenthic Holothuroids on the Reef Flat of Lang Island (Papua New Guinea). Marine Ecology Progress Series, 31, 185-195.
[55] Kerr, M.A., Stoffel, E.M. and Yoon, L.R. (1993) Abundance and Distribution of Holothuroids (Echinodermata: Holothuroidea) on a Windward and Leeward Fringing Coral Reef, Guam, Mariana Islands. Bulletin of Marine Science, 52, 780-789.
[56] Dissanayake, D.C.T. and Stefansson, G. (2012) Habitat Preference of Sea Cucumbers: Holothuria atra and Holothuria edulis in the Coastal Waters of Sri Lanka. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom, 92, 581-590.
[57] Battaglene, S.C. and Bell, J.D. (1999) Potential of the Tropical Indo-Pacific Sea Cucumber, Holothuria scabra, for Stock Enhancement. In: Mosksness, E.S., et al., Eds., Proceedings of the 1st International Symposium on Stock Enhancement and Sea Ranching, Blackwell Science, Bergen, Norway, 478-490.
[58] Shiell, G. (2004) Field Observations of Juvenile Sea Cucumbers. SPC Beche-de-Mer Information Bulletin, 20, 6-11.
[59] Asha, P.S., Diwakar, K., Santhanavalli, G. and Manisseri, M.K. (2015) Comparative Distribution and Habitat Preference of the Sea Cucumber Holothuria atra Jaeger at Protected and Unprotected Sites in Thoothukudi Region of Gulf of Mannar, South-East Coast of India. Indian Journal of Fisheries, 62, 52-57.
[60] Bell, J.D., Purcell, S.W. and Nash, W.J. (2008) Restoring Small-Scale Fisheries for Tropical Sea Cucumbers. Ocean & Coastal Management, 51, 589-593.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2019 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.