Histological Findings of Bone Marrow Lesions on Magnetic Resonance Images in Patients with Varus Knee Osteoarthritis ()
1. Introduction
Osteoarthritis of the knee is extremely common. Nearly 75% of individuals aged ≥65 years in the United States have evidence of degenerative joint disease on knee radiographs [1] . A recent Japanese epidemiological study revealed that the prevalence of radiographic knee osteoarthritis was 42.6% in men and 62.4% in women aged ≥40 years [2] . Because knee osteoarthritis reduces the quality of life of elderly people, the high incidence of osteoarthritis and increased average lifespan have resulted in worldwide social problems in terms of reduced mobility. To address these issues, prediction and prevention―in addition to treatment of osteoarthritis―have become increasingly important.
In order to predict the severity and progression of osteoarthritis, several methods such as biological markers [3] and diagnostic imaging [4] -[6] have been used to date. Bone marrow lesions (BMLs) on magnetic resonance (MR) images, which have been previously defined as “ill-defined low-signal-intensity areas on T1-weighted images (T1WI)” [7] and “high-signal-intensity areas on T2-weighted images (T2WI)” [8] [9] within subchondral regions, have been reported to correlate with the severity [8] [10] , progression [11] [12] and cartilage damage [13] - [16] of knee osteoarthritis. However, the exact pathology of BMLs remains uncertain since only a few studies have investigated the histological findings of these lesions [7] [17] [18] and no histological explanations of the differences in the severity and progression between patients with or without BMLs have been reported. Therefore in the present study, we evaluated histological findings of the subchondral area of the medial femoral condyle with BMLs on MR images and compared them with those without BMLs.
2. Patients and Methods
The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of our clinic. Written informed consent for the use of data in the study was obtained from all patients.
2.1. Patients
Between October 2012 and February 2013, 24 total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) were consecutively performed for 24 patients with varus knee osteoarthritis. Those patients were the subjects of this study. The study comprised 4 males and 20 females. The demographic data of the patients are shown in Table 1. The average age at surgery, height, weight and body mass index were 72 years (range 62 - 80 years), 1.52 m (range 1.39 - 1.75 m), 66 kg (range 54 - 89 kg) and 28.3 kg/m2 (range 23.3 - 37.2 kg/m2), respectively. Grade of osteoarthritis in all patients showed grade 4 according to Kellgren and Lawrence grading system [19] . The average femoro-tibial angle on a standing posteroanterior radiograph was 186˚ (range 179˚ - 198˚).
2.2. MRI Examinations
MR images of the affected knee were acquired before the TKA. In our clinic, a Signa-Profile system (0.2 T; GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, WI) is used routinely to acquire T1- and T2-weighted sagittal and coronal images to assess knee pathologies. The section thickness of the sagittal planes was 4 mm. Because the patients had varus knee osteoarthritis, we used T1- and T2-weighted sagittal MR images through the center of the medial femoral condyle for the imaging evaluation of the patients. BMLs were generally represented by ill-defined areas of low-signal intensity on T1WI [7] and by areas of high-signal intensity on T2WI [8] [9] in the subchondral area (Figure 1).
2.3. Histological Examinations
During the TKA, bone pieces were obtained from the distal medial femoral condyle. They were cut sagittally and the specimens―approximately 5 mm thick, from the center of the medial femoral condyle―were prepared for histological examinations (Figure 2). The specimens were immediately fixed in 10% formalin, decalcified with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid at 4˚C, embedded in paraffin, and stained with hematoxylin-eosin and elastica-Masson. Antibodies against type-II collagen were also used to prepare the specimens for immunohistological examination. Stained specimens were analyzed using light microscopy.
3. Results
The MR images revealed BMLs for 20 patients but no BMLs for 4 patients. All the lesions were confirmed by
![]()
Table 1. Demographic data of the patients in the present study.
![]()
Figure 1. T1- and T2-weighted MR images of bone marrow le- sions. Diffuse low-signal intensity on T1-weighted images (T1, white arrow) and high-signal intensity on T2-weighted images (T2, black arrow) demonstrates bone marrow lesions.
imaging of the middle slice of the medial femoral condyle. Plain radiographs showed no differences between patients with or without BMLs on MR images (Figure 3(a), Figure 3(b)). Histologically, BMLs were shown to exhibit various features: the formation of fibrofatty or fibrovascular bone marrow; cyst formation (Figure 4(a)); active bone remodeling with bone formation and resorption (Figure 4(b)); and the formation of cartilaginous tissues, including articular cartilage, subchondral bony end plate and bone trabeculae. In all 20 patients, the articular cartilage either partially remained or had completely disappeared. Bared subchondral bony end plate was thin or disintegrated. Dense fibrous or fibrovascular bone marrow tissues with thick trabeculae were observed
![]()
Figure 2. Photo of medial femoral condyle during total knee arthroplasty. A central sagittal specimen (asterisk) was obtained from the resected distal medial femoral condyle.
![]()
![]()
(a) (b)
Figure 3. Plain radiographs of the patients with or without BMLs on MR images. No obvious differences can be detected by the plain radiographs. (a) A plain radiograph of the patient with BMLs; (b) A plain radiograph of the patient without BMLs.
under the end plate (Figure 4(c)). Bone necrosis with empty lacunae was occasionally found in this end plate. After immunostaining for type-II collagen, cartilaginous tissues were detected not only on the surface of the specimen but also in the subchondral region (Figure 4(d)). In some specimens, articular cartilage partially remained. Moderately fibrofatty or fibrovascular bone marrow and normal-thickness trabeculae were observed beneath a thin or disintegrated subchondral bony end plate (Figure 4(e)).
The histological findings of the four patients with no BMLs showed normal bone marrow tissue beneath either well-preserved articular cartilage with a normal-thickness subchondral bony end plate (Figure 5(a)) or a completely bared articular surface with a thick subchondral bony end plate (Figure 5(b)). Cyst formation or bone necrosis were not found.
4. Discussion
BMLs are defined, based on MRI findings, as “low-signal-intensity on T1WI” [7] and “high-signal-intensity on T2WI” [8] [9] within subchondral regions. Recently, many studies have revealed an association between BMLs and knee pain and the structural progression of osteoarthritis [8] - [16] . Felson et al. [8] reported that BMLs were strongly associated with the presence of pain. Iwasaki et al. [10] stated that irregularity of BMLs served as a possible indicator of objective severity when assessed by the Lysholm knee scoring scale. A couple of longitu-
![]()
![]()
(a) (b)
Figure 5. Histological features of the knees with no bone marrow lesions (stained with hematoxylin-eosin, original magnifi- cation 20×). (a) Well-preserved articular cartilage, normal-thickness subchondral bony end plate, normal-thickness tra- beculae, and normal bone marrow tissue are observed; (b) Bared subchondral bony end plate, thick subchondral bony end plate, normal-thickness trabeculae, and normal bone marrow tissue are observed. (C: articular cartilage; M: bone marrow region; P: subchondral bony end plate).
dinal studies revealed a significant relationship between BMLs and progression of knee osteoarthritis [11] [12] . Studies have also shown an association between BMLs and articular cartilage damage [13] - [16] . Lim et al. [9] reviewed the association between non-biomechanical factors and BMLs. Therefore, BMLs should play an important role in the etiology of osteoarthritis; however, only a few studies have been conducted in which the histology of BMLs has been directly observed [7] [17] [18] .
Zanetti et al. [7] compared tibial plateau abnormalities on MR images with those on histological maps for 16 patients. They concluded that the bone marrow edema depicted on MR images in osteoarthritis knees mainly consisted of normal tissue with smaller areas of various abnormalities, such as bone marrow necrosis, necrotic or remodeled trabeculae, bone marrow fibrosis, bone marrow edema and bone marrow bleeding. In another study, Bergman et al. [17] reported that seven of nine osteoarthritis knees exhibited MR signal abnormalities corresponding predominantly to the replacement of fatty marrow with fibrous tissue. In addition, Sadat et al. [18] observed subchondral ingrowth of fibrovascular tissue and increased bone remodeling in the bone marrow edema pattern zone on the MR images of one patient. Although such studies have explored an aspect of BML pathology, the full and exact significance of the lesions is yet to be elucidated.
In the present study, the center of the medial femoral condyle―where BMLs were confirmed by MR imaging―was histologically examined. In addition, histological differences between patients with or without BMLs were evaluated. BMLs were shown to exhibit various histological features: the formation of fibrofatty or fibrovascular bone marrow; cyst formation; active bone remodeling with bone formation and resorption; and the hyaline cartilage in the subchondral region. Nevertheless, the MR images of the four patients with no BMLs revealed normal bone marrow tissues. The most interesting histological difference between patients with or without BMLs was the condition of the subchondral bony end plate; the end plate was thin or disintegrated in patients with BMLs but thick in patients with no BMLs. Although histological findings of BMLs in this study were similar to those of previous studies [7] [17] [18] , those studies did not describe the condition of the subchondral bony end plate in detail, regrettably. Based on the current study, the condition of the subchondral bony end plate should play a key role in the pathology of BMLs and should explain the differences in the severity and progression of knee osteoarthritis between patients with or without BMLs. It is not known whether the disintegration of the subchondral bony end plate is the cause or result of the underlying pathology of BMLs. However, once the plate has been disintegrated, the bone marrow beneath the plate becomes directly exposed by compression force, which may accelerate the disease progression of osteoarthritis. Furthermore, once the plate is disintegrated, unmyelinated free nerve endings present in the subchondral bone can presumably worsen the severity of osteoarthritic pain [20] .
In addition to the relatively small sample size and imbalance in the number of samples with or without BMLs, the current study has some limitations. First, only 0.2 T T1- and T2-weighted MR images, which were routinely acquired in our clinical practice, could be used for this study. Such MR images cannot detect cartilage, but can identify BMLs. Second, the specimens examined in this study were obtained from advanced osteoarthritis knees during TKAs. Therefore, it may be difficult to surmise the etiology of BMLs in early-stage osteoarthritis knees and the progression of the lesions. Finally, it was very difficult to determine the exact correlations between the BMLs and the histological findings since the MR images were acquired using sections 3 - 4 mm in thickness while histological examinations were conducted on very thin specimens.
5. Conclusion
BMLs on MR images of the subchondral area of the medial femoral condyle of varus osteoarthritis knees exhibited various histological findings. The condition of the subchondral bony end plate is likely to influence the histological features of the subchondral area―whether or not BMLs are present. We consider that the histological findings of BMLs are critical to better understand the severity or progression of knee osteoarthritis.
NOTES
*Corresponding author.