Open Journal of Soil Science

Volume 3, Issue 5 (September 2013)

ISSN Print: 2162-5360   ISSN Online: 2162-5379

Google-based Impact Factor: 1.36  Citations  

Comparison of Methods to Remediate Compacted Soils for Infiltration and Vegetative Establishment

HTML  Download Download as PDF (Size: 811KB)  PP. 225-234  
DOI: 10.4236/ojss.2013.35027    4,284 Downloads   7,671 Views  Citations

ABSTRACT

The process of constructing roads and buildings usually involves the removal of topsoil and grading of the subsoil followed by a variety of activities using heavy equipment. This presents multiple challenges in attempts to establish vegetation on these areas: low nutrient soils with little organic matter, high bulk densities, and low infiltration rates. The goals of this preliminary study were to quantify the impacts of soil compaction remediation methods on infiltration, runoff water quality, and vegetation establishment. The objectives were to measure: 1) steady state infiltration rate (IR); 2) quantity and quality of storm water runoff; and 3) ground cover, biomass production, and rooting depth of vegetation during early establishment. We evaluated four treatments: a compacted soil (C), a compacted soil with core aeration (A), a compacted soil with deep (20 - 30 cm) tillage (DT), and a compacted soil with deep tillage and incorporated compost (CT). Sites 1 and 2 received C, A and DT treatments and Site 3 received only DT and CT treatments. At Site 1, runoff from natural rainfall events was collected in plastic tubs at the bottom of each 2 × 1 m plot, and samples were measured for volume and sediment. Infiltration rates were determined using a Cornell Sprinkle Infiltrometer at all three sites. At Site 1, the A treatment had a higher erosion rate during two of four rain events and higher runoff volume during three of four rain events, when compared to C and DT. However, the aerator was only able to penetrate 1 - 2 cm due to the compacted soil. Average event runoff ranged from 0 to 22% (0 - 9.3 mm), 10 to 60% (1.9 - 26.2 mm), and 0 to 3.5% (0 - 1.1 mm) of the total rainfall for C, A, and DT, respectively. There was no difference between C and A for vegetative biomass and IR, but both biomass and IR were greater in the DT plots. Treatment DT had an average IR of 15 cm·hr-1, compared to 0.16 and 0.21 cm·hr-1 for C and A, respectively. Roots were much more abundant at the 20 - 50 cm depths with DT. At Site 2, there were no significant differences in IR, with many values too low to be measured with the infiltrometer. Vegetative cover also did not differ between the three treatments due to poor (16% - 22% cover) grass establishment. Infiltration rates at Site 3 were measured immediately after tillage and were 10× those at Site 2, measured 2 months after tillage, but DT and CT values were not different. The results suggest that deep tillage prior to seeding could maximize long-term vegetation growth and provide areas of high infiltration to minimize post-construction stormwater discharges, as long as vigorous vegetation can be established quickly.

Share and Cite:

M. Haynes, R. McLaughlin and J. Heitman, "Comparison of Methods to Remediate Compacted Soils for Infiltration and Vegetative Establishment," Open Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 3 No. 5, 2013, pp. 225-234. doi: 10.4236/ojss.2013.35027.

Cited by

[1] Characterizing Compost Rate Effects on Stormwater Runoff and Vegetation Establishment
Water, 2022
[2] Comparison of infiltration test methods for soil health assessment
Journal of Soil and Water …, 2022
[3] Where Can the Water Go? A Characterization of Urban Infiltration Capacities Through Measurement, Modeling, and Community Observation
2021
[4] Comparison of Cornell sprinkle infiltrometer and double‐ring infiltrometer methods for measuring steady infiltration rate
Soil Science Society …, 2021
[5] Where Can the Water Go? A Characterization of Urban Infiltration Capacities Through Measurement, Modeling, and Community Observation.
2021
[6] Reducing roadside runoff: Tillage and compost improve stormwater mitigation in urban soils
2021
[7] Properties of Soils Affected by Highways
2017
[8] Feeding megacities by urban agriculture
2017
[9] Urban soils
2017
[10] Effect of Organic Amendment and Cultural Practice on Large Patch Occurrence and Soil Microbial Community
Crop Science, 2017
[11] A multi-year study of tillage and amendment effects on compacted soils
Journal of Environmental Management, 2017
[12] Amendment effects on soil physical properties and restoration of decommissioned forest roads
2017
[13] Sustainable landscaping practices for enhancing vegetation establishment.
2016
[14] Assessment of a Single-ring Sprinkle Infiltrometer Method for Evaluating Soil-based Stormwater Management Practices.
2016
[15] Restoring hydrologic function in urban landscapes with suburban subsoiling
Journal of Hydrology, 2016
[16] Effects of tillage and compost amendment on infiltration in compacted soils
2016
[17] STATE HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION RESEARCH REPORT
2015
[18] Potential for Existing Detention Basins to Comply with Updated Stormwater Rules: Case Study
Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2015

Copyright © 2024 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.