Comparison of fatigue behaviour of eight different hip stems: a numerical and experimental study

Mahmut Pekedis, Hasan Yildiz

.

DOI: 10.4236/jbise.2011.410080                

Abstract

In this study, finite element analysis was used to investigate the fatigue behavior of eight different hip stems. All of the prostheses investigated in the analysis are already being used in Turkish orthopaedic surgery. All stems were compared with each other in terms of fatigue, deformation and safety factors. Primary analysis was applied on three of the stems, which were tested experimentally. It was observed that the simulation and the experimental results are in good agreement with each other. After determining the reliability of the numerical method, the analysis was applied on all other stems. To obtain a more realistic simulation, boundary conditions were applied according to standards specified in the ISO 7206-4 standard. Three different types of materials were selected during analysis. These materials were Ti-6Al-4V, cobalt chrome alloy and 316L. Minimum fatigue cycles, critical fatigue areas, stresses and safety factor values have been identified. The results obtained from the finite element analysis showed that all stems were safe enough in terms of fatigue life. As a result of fatigue analysis, all stems have been found to be successful, but some of them were found to be better than the others in terms of safety factor. The current study has also demonstrated that analysing hip stems with the finite element method (FEM) can be applied with confidence to support standard fatigue testing and used as an alternative. Further studies can expand the simulations to the clinical relevance due to complex physical relevance.

Keywords

Hip Stem; Fatigue; The Finite Element Method

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Garbuz, D.S., Tanzer, M., Greidanus, N.V., Masri, B.A. and Duncan, C.P. (2010) The John Charnley Award. Clin Orthop Relat Res, 468, 318-332. doi:10.1007/s11999-009-1029-x
[2]	Affatato, S., Mattarozzi, A., Taddei, P., Robotti, P., Soffiatti, R., Sudanese1, A. and Toni, A. (2003) Inves- tigation on the wear behavior of the temporary PMMA- based hip Spacer-G, A proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 217, 1-8.
[3]	Fusaro, I., Mari, G. and Bilotta, T. W. (1996) Trattamento riabilitativo nel reimpianto e nell’espianto di protesi d’anca. In Artroprotesi e Riabilitazione. XXIV Congresso Nzionale SIMFER, Bologna, 102-113.
[4]	Bauer, T.W., Schils, J. (1999) The pathology of total joint arthroplasticity.II, Mechanics of implant failulure. Skeletol Radiology, 28, 483-497. doi:10.1007/s002560050552
[5]	Scifert, C.A. (1999) Finite element investigation into biomechanics of total artificial hip dislocation. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Iowa.
[6]	ISO7206-4. (2002) Determination of endurance proper- ties of stemmed femoral components, Implants for Sur- gery. Partial and total hip joint prostheses, International Organization for Standardization.
[7]	Ploeg, L., Bürgi, M. and Wyss, U.P. (2009) Hip stem fatigue test prediction. International journal of fatigue, 31, 894-905. doi:10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2008.10.005
[8]	Kayaba??, O., Ekici, B. (2007) The effects of static, dyna- mic and fatigue behavior on three-dimensional shape optimization of hip prosthesis by finite element method. Materials & Design, 28, 2269-2277. doi:10.1016/j.matdes.2006.08.012
[9]	Viceconti, M., Mc, B.P., Toni, A. and Giunti, A. (1996) FEM analysis of the static stresses induced in a THR femoral components during a standardized fatigue test. In: Middleton, J., Jones, M. and Pandi, G., Eds., Second International Symposium on Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, London. 57-66.
[10]	Akay, M., Aslan, N. (1995) An estimation of fatigue life for a carbon fibre/polyesther ketone hip joint prosthesis. Proceedings of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers Part H: Journal Engineering in Medicine, 209, 93-103. doi:10.1243/PIME_PROC_1995_209_325_02
[11]	Sivasankar, M., Chakraborty, D. and Dwivedy, S.K. (2006) Fatigue analysis of artificial hip joints for different materials. XVI Conference of Society for Biomaterials and Artificial Organs-India on Biomaterials, Tissue Engineering and Medical Diagnostics, Delhi, 24-26 February 2006.
[12]	Styles, C.M., Evans, S.L. and Gregson, P.J. (1998) Devolopment of fatigue lifetime predictive test methods for hip implants: Part 1, Test methodology. Biomaterials, 19, 1057-1065. doi:10.1016/S0142-9612(98)00031-3
[13]	McCormack, B.A.O., Prendergast, P.J. and Dwyer, B.O. (1999) Fatigue of cemented hip replacements under tor- sional loads. Fatigue fracture engineering material struc- ture, 22, 33-40.
[14]	Yildiz, H., Ha, S.Y. and Chang, F.K. (1998) Composite hip prosthesis design. I. Analysis. Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part A, 39, 92-101. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(199801)39:1<92::AID-JBM12>3.0.CO;2-Q
[15]	Titanium Ti-6Al-4V (Grade 5). (2011) Annealed. http://asm.matweb.com/search/SpecificMaterial.asp?bassnum=MTP641
[16]	Materal Property Date, (2011) Carpenter MP35N* Ni- Co-Cr-Mo alloy, 25% cold reduction. http://www.matweb.com/search/DataSheet.aspx?MatGUID=b78f5c9066924c5eb6c16d949f27d928
[17]	Murray, K., Kearns, M. and Mottu, N. (2009) Alloy powd- ers for medical applications. Med Device Technol., 20, 50-51.
[18]	Saha, S., Pal, S. (1984) Mechanical properties of bone cement. Journal of Biomed Mater Research, 18, 435-462. doi:10.1002/jbm.820180411
[19]	Litchman, H.M., Richman, M.H., Warman, M. and Mit- chell, J. (1978) Improvement of the mechanical proper- ties of polymethylmethacrylate by graphite fiber reinfor- ce-ment. Transaction Orthpadidc Resesrch, 2, 86.
[20]	SpecSearch, (2011) AISI type 316L. http://www.efunda.com/materials/alloys/stainless_steels/show_stainless.cfm?ID=AISI_Type_316L&show_prop=all&Page_Title=AISI%20Type%20316L
[21]	Teoh, S.H. (2000) Fatigue of biomaterials: a review. International Journal of Fatigue, 22, 825-837. doi:10.1016/S0142-1123(00)00052-9
[22]	ANSYS (2007) Theory reference manual. Release 11.0, ANSYS Inc.
[23]	Pilliar, R.M., Blackwell, R., Macnab, I., and Cameron, H.U. (1976) Carbon-fiber reinforced bone cement in or- thopaedic surgery. Journal of Biomedical Materals Resesrch, 10, 893-906. doi:10.1002/jbm.820100608
[24]	Bayrak, O., Yetim, A.F., Alsaran, A. and ?elik, A. (2010) Fatigue life determination of plasma nitrided medical Materials & Structures, 33, 303-309.
[25]	Taira, M., Lautenschlager, E.P. (1992) In vitro corrosion fatigue of 316L cold worked stainless steel. Journal of Biomedical Materals Resesrch, 26, 1131-1139. doi:10.1002/jbm.820260903
[26]	Budynas, R.G., Nisbett, J.K. (2008) Shigley’s mechani- cal engineering design. 8th Edition, Mc Graw Hill, Boston.