Share This Article:

Expectations and Perspectives of Users with the Screening Program for Cervical Cancer

Full-Text HTML XML Download Download as PDF (Size:374KB) PP. 565-572
DOI: 10.4236/ojn.2016.68060    1,012 Downloads   1,256 Views  

ABSTRACT

Objective: Evaluate user satisfaction before and after taking the Pap. Methodology: Observational and prospective study. It was carried out in two health centers in San Luis Potosicity, Mexico in 93 users which attended for a Pap test from February to June 2015. The satisfaction was assessed using multidimensional scaling SERVQUAL whit 5 dimensions to evaluate the quality of services in an organization: reliability, responsibility, security, empathy and touchable and materials goods (tangible elements). This scaling was obtained internal consistency by Cronbach’s alpha coefficient with a value of 0.74. For data analysis, nonparametric test Wilcoxon for related samples was used. Results: In all cases, perspective was less than expectancy where the means of the scores before attention (expectation) and after care (perspective) there was a statistically significant difference (p = 0.000). Before receiving care users had an expectation of 192.96 points, after care perspective score dropped to 184.49 points indicating that the care provided was not what they expected. The difference in scores was 8.47 points (p = 0.004). Conclusions: Users of the screening program for cervical cancer were unsatisfied because the attention was not what they expected. In most of the indicators studied, a high percentage of dissatisfaction was obtained.

Received 12 June 2016; accepted 21 August 2016; published 24 August 2016

1. Introduction

The appreciation of users is essential to improve all health programs. In this 21st century, the global competition among service providers is to render qualitative services to satisfy the desires of customers [1] . The quality of care is a judgment that is made by the customer after receiving the service and comparing their expectations with the received service [2] . Most of the organizations, for improving customer’s satisfaction and, consequently, their own survival, are willing to evaluate the strategies of their service quality, and so, the customer is considered the key indicator in this evaluation [3] . Expectations are customer’s demands, meaning that what they feel a service provider must present and perceptions are customer’s experiences [4] with the service received and the difference between costumer’s expectations and perceptions is called service quality gap [5] .

Researchers of service marketing have developed nineteen service quality models during the period 1984- 2003 [6] . The service quality model “SERVQUAL” ranks as the most important of these models. By determining the gap between costumer’s perceptions and expectations of the quality of provided services, the process of service provision could be improved and costumer’s satisfaction, as a very sensitive element in today’s field of competition, could be provided [7] .

Quality in the field of health services has a special place because the critical duty and mission of protecting the health and lives of the society is the responsibility of this part and any mistake could be irreparable; on the other hand, health services are related to a vast part of the society [10] . Different studies have been conducted to evaluate customer’s satisfaction for improving the quality of provided services using SERVQUAL model in different areas from higher education [11] to health services [12] , but a little attention has been paid to evaluation of service quality in different sections of primary health care of health centers [13] , including service timely detection of cervical cancer. It is in this sense that the aim of the present study was to evaluate the perspectives of users of the cervical cancer detection service in two health centers of a Mexican province.

2. Patients and Methods

2.1. Data Source

Quantitative, observational, prospective and longitudinal study. It was conducted in two health centers in San Luis Potosicity, Mexico. The work was conducted with a total of 93 users (49 health center called for this study as 1, and 44 health center labeled 2), which they received attention for taking cervical cytology (Pap) by nurses in the period from February to June 2015. Satisfaction was measured using the multidimensional SERVQUAL model.

This survey was designed by Parasuraman et al. in 1985 for validation and reliability [14] . In Mexico the survey was validated in 2011 at the General Hospital of Celaya, Guanajuato, obtained an internal consistency by Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of 0.74 in full scale and factor analysis that wasdetected in the five dimensions of the scale 0,82 for expectations and perceptions to 0,66 for ; showing that it is valid and reliable [15] .

Multidimensional SERVQUAL model measured and related customer perception and expectations regarding the quality of service. The 5 dimensions contained to the evaluation, in this case of a health service are:

1) Reliability. Ability to develop the service as promised, agreed and accurately.

2) Liability (answer’s capacity). Willingness to help customers and provide prompt service.

3) Security. Knowledge of employees about what they do, their courtesy and their ability to convey trust.

4) Empathy. Ability to provide care and personal attention to their customers.

5) Tangibles. Related to the appearance of physical facilities, equipment, personnel and communication materials. They are the physical aspects in the organization that the customer perceives [14] .

For the development of research scale it was modified and used prior review by experts for validation. It was applying in two-phase: Before the consultation (Pap) for determining the expectation of the users and after of consultation for determining perceptions. To determine the degree of satisfaction of users were compared Perspectives (P) and Expectations (E), and it analyzed according to the numerical ratings assigned to each element of the 21 that make up the survey divided into 5 dimensions. To qualify, a numerical scale 1 - 7 was used, whereas 1 is the lowest value and 7 the highest [16] . The satisfaction of users is handled as shown in the following table:

2.2. Data Analysis

Descriptive statistics were applied as percentages and frequencies, confidence intervals were estimated at 95%, the normality of the data was validated with the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test and based on the results of this test, nonparametric Wilcoxon test was applied to compare the scores of perspectives and expectations.

2.3. Ethical Considerations

The research protocol was reviewed and approved by the Ethics Committee of the School of Nursing of the Autonomous University of San Luis Potosi which assigned a registration number CEIFE-2015-118. Discretionary criteria were taken into account as the Declaration of Helsinki brand and general health law of Mexico, article 17. All participants signed a letter of informed consent.

3. Results

In this study, 93 users from San Luis Potosí, México were selected and some of its characteristics were analyzed, which indicate, from Table 1, that most of them are between 31 and 35 (52.7%), 21.5% between 21 and 30 years and 25.8% are in the range of 36 to 40 years. in relation to level education, the highest percentage (44.1%) have baccalaureate education and the lowest (12.9%) have high school education. As for marital status, most are married (82.8%). Regarding health services they have, 76.3% it affiliated to the Mexican Social Security Institute, 19.4% to Publicly Provided Health Insurance and 4.3% to Services Institute of Social Security for State Workers.

By measuring expectations and prospects in each dimension of scale SERVQUAL model, it was found that in all averages the scores before the attention (expectations) and after this (perspectives) there is a difference statistically significant (p = 0.000). In all cases, prospects were below expectations, which it means that users expected better care that they received (Table 2).

Degree of user satisfaction by dimension (as after care) was obtained as a percentage. Intangibles (the physical aspects that the customer perceives of the organization), 53.8% of them was unsatisfied and 3.2% very satisfied. Regarding reliability (ability to develop the service as promised as agreed and accurately), 54.8% of them was satisfied and 3.2% unsatisfied. On the other hand, responsibility (willingness to help customers and provide service fast), 51.6% of them was little satisfied and anyone was very satisfied. With regard to security dimension (knowledge of employees about what they do, their courtesy and their ability to convey trust), 52.6 % of them was little satisfied and anyone was unsatisfied. In the dimension empathy (ability to provide care and personal attention to their customers), 59.1% of them was little satisfied and anyone was unsatisfied about the service. It is important to note that the satisfaction’s degree “very satisfied” never obtained the highest percentage and that the degree “satisfied” only responsibility dimension occupied the highest percentage (Figure 1).

Before receiving care users had an expectation of 192.96 points. Considering that the highest score that can be obtained by applying the scale SERVQUAL is 196 points, we can assume that the expectation was high. However, after receiving the service perspective score was 184.49 points, indicating that the care provided was not that they expected. Difference between scores was 8.47 points (p = 0.004) (Figure 2).

4. Discussion

In this century, global competition among service providers is to provide quality care to meet the customer’s wishes. This has been increasingly important in developing countries, allowing service providers to provide greater value, competitiveness, opportunities, services growth and increased customer satisfaction. The role of service quality as a key factor in user satisfaction and organizational performance is widely recognized in developed countries [1] . Although the quality of health services has been a topic widely discussed in the literature

Table 1. Socio-demographic data of users who came to take pap.

Source: Multidimentional SERVQUAL scale. *IMSS: Mexican Social Security Institute, *SP: Publicly Provided Health Insurance, *ISSSTE: Services Institute of Social Security for State Workers.

Table 2. Expectations and perspectives of users by scale dimensions of SERVQUAL.

Source: multidimentional SERVQUAL scale. E = Expectations; P = Perspectives; D.E. = Standard deviation, D.B.A. = difference betweenthe average; L.L. = Lower Límit; U.L. = Upper limit. *Wilcoxon.

for over 40 years, its definition, interpretation and assessment rating remains controversial and complex because of the multiple factors involving construction, [17] plus it has been interpreted in different ways. The satisfaction of external users, expressing individual value judgments and subjective, is the key in the definition and assessment of quality.

Figure 1. Degree of user satisfaction by dimension of SERVQUAL model.

Figure 2. Degree of user satisfaction by dimension of SERVQUAL model. Nonparametric Wilcoxon test.

This is most often used to assess the quality of care in health services and measurement indicator is expressed in levels of user satisfaction [18] . The survey for validity and reliability is the most widely accepted to measure the quality of care in multidimensional tool business services [19] . Babakus and Mangold validated a new SERVQUAL construct to hospital [19] and in Mexico were validated in 2011 in a Celaya Guanajuato hospital [15] .

The incidence of cervical cancer has decreased substantially in developed countries due to the widespread success of Pap smears programs, however, these results have not been obtained in developing countries [20] [21] . Recognizing the limited effectiveness of the program in Mexico [22] , different strategies have been implemented, but the assessment of the prospects of the users of it is very important and little or nothing has been explored, marking the aim of this research using multidimensional SERVQUAL scale. In other countries like in Iran, was studied the customer’s perceptions and expectations of primary healthcare services quality in health centers of Bandar Abbas in this paper the authors found that the majority of participants (64%) assessed the services quality moderate and that the best dimension of service quality was assurance, followed by reliability, responsiveness and tangibles with empathy being the worst [23] . In our study, users had higher expectations that perspectives on the care provided, indicating low satisfaction. Furthermore, in this study itwas found that the dimension was more dissatisfaction was tangible, which include material, equipment, facilities and staff health. About, program quality and patient safety at Children’s Hospital of Mexico “Federico Gómez”, mentions that amenities include elements such as degree of comfort achieved, hotel services provided, the information system and situation of intimacy in which the patient is attending among others. This specifies that the quality is the application of science and medical technology in a way that maximizes their health benefits without increasing proportionately their risks [24] .

Thus, in our study we found that most users are dissatisfied with the elements related to the institution, which is important for future research are analyzed factors concerning the organization and specifically concerning the service provided by nurses, the qualitative aspects and everything that influences so that patients come to perform or notPap using new indicators. Health institutions in the public sector in Mexico, nursing staff is responsible for taking the cervical smear tests and the main contact with users of the program since one of its functions, in addition to providing care, is to provide the necessary information to women so they can achieve greater attachment to the early detection program. Such personnel must hear from women attending the screening on their expectations and experiences regarding the care in order to detect areas of opportunity later to become improvement strategies that increase the quality of this priority health program. In this sense, we have identified the main problems perceived by users, which lie in long waiting periods, conditions of inadequate physical spaces, lack of respect for privacy and lack of continuous and appropriate monitoring causing dissatisfaction with the service [25] .

The authorities of public organizations have realized that their achievements as the targets are not associated with the appreciation that management makes citizens. Political discourse and theoretical approaches are not always compatible with the operation of programs that impact poorly on the reality of the people they are intended. In this context, studies seeking to approach people and understand their complex reality of incorporating multidimensional aspects, are relevant to narrowing the gap between public policy planners and those who receive benefits [26] .

On the other hand, users have certain needs or desires which sometimes are not even concerning the care and can be obtained by the organization to design and deliver a service that no longer satisfied. Some systems are available to identify the real needs of customers, while others allow only perceive the needs of which the user is aware. Both perspectives are used to improve service quality and tend to greater satisfaction of people who receive it [16] .

In conducting this study there were different limitations, including the small influx of women who demand service and large span of time (45 minutes) to do this, which meant not being able to have a larger sample.

Finally, it should be mentioned that studies as performed by this research group and characteristics that were addressed are important to improve a program, in this case the timely detection of cervical cancer. Users’ opinion of the program is critical because they are the recipients of care and can provide useful information for decision makers’ information. For future research is suggested to address the point of view of health personnel regarding some variables analyzed in this study for comparison of the experiences of the major players in the program of cervical cancer screening. It should be mentioned that there are few studies on the quality of health care and user opinion, and much less those related to the service responsible for the early detection of cervical cancer.

5. Conclusion

Users of the program for early detection of cervical cancer were dissatisfied with it because attention was not what they expected. In most indicators addressed, a high percentage of dissatisfaction was obtained.

Acknowledgements

This project was supported by the National Council of Science and Technology of Mexico (CONACYT), code: PDCP2013-01-215888.

NOTES

*Corresponding author.

Cite this paper

Sandra Olimpia, G. , Darío, G. , Rosa Adriana, M. , Verónica, G. and Yolanda, T. (2016) Expectations and Perspectives of Users with the Screening Program for Cervical Cancer. Open Journal of Nursing, 6, 565-572. doi: 10.4236/ojn.2016.68060.

References

[1] Asogwa, B.E. (2014) Use of ServQUAL in the Evaluation of Service Quality of Academic Libraries in Developing Countries. Library Philosophy and Practice (E-Journal), 1146, 1-25.
[2] Ruset, R.T., Lemon, K.N. and Zeithaml, V. (2004) Return on Marketing: Using Customer Equity to Focus Marketing Strategy. Journal of Marketing, 68, 109-27.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1509/jmkg.68.1.109.24030
[3] Kaplan, R.S. and Norton, D.P. (2001) The Strategy-Focused Organization: How Balanced Scorecard Companies Thrive in the New Business Environment. 1st Edition, Soundview Executive Book Summaries, Harvard Business School Press, Concordville, 148-159.
https://www.uaservice.com/pdf/The_Strategy-Focused_Organization.pdf
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/sl.2001.26129cab.002
[4] Mohammadi, A. and Shoghli, A.R. (2008) Survey on Quality of Rimary Health Care’s in Zanjuan District Health Centers. Journal of Zanjan University of Medical Science and Health Services, 16, 89-100.
[5] Kebriaei, A., Akbari, F., Hosseini, M., Eftekhare-Ardabili, H. and Purreza, A. (2004) Survey on Quality Gap in Primary Health Care in Kashan Health Centers. The Journal of Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, 31, 82-88.
[6] Seth, N., Deshmukh, S.G. and Vrat, P. (2005) Service Quality Models: A Review. International Journal of Quality & reliability Management, 22, 913-949.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/02656710510625211
[7] Tarahi, M.J., Hamozadeh, P., Bijuanvand, M. and Lshgrara, B. (2012) Survey on Quality of Health Services Provided in Khorramabad Health Care Centers Using the SERVQUAL Model. Journal of Lorestan University of Medical Sciences, 14, 13-21.
[8] Parasuraman, A., Berry, L.L. and Zeithaml, V.A. (1991) Refinement and Reassessment of the SERVQUAL Scale. Journal of Retailing, 67, 420.
[9] Nouri, H. (2006) Applying SERVQUAL Model in RasouleAkram Hospital. University of Medical Sciences, Tehran.
[10] Jackson, S. (2000) Successfully Implementing TQM within Health Care. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance (IJHQA), 14, 157-163.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09526860110392431
[11] Glavandi, H., Behaeshtirad, R. and Ghaleei, A. (2012) Investigating the Quality of Educational Services in the University or Urmia through SERVQUAL Model. Quarterly Journal of Management Development, 25, 49-66.
[12] Nadi, A., Shojaee, J., Abedi, G., Siamian, H., Abedini, E. and Rostami. F. (2016) Patients’ Expectations and Perceptions of Service Quality in the Selected Hospitals. Medical Archives, 70, 135-139.
http://dx.doi.org/10.5455/medarh.2016.70.135-139
[13] Oliaee, Z., Jabbari, A. and Ehsanpour, S. (2016) An Investigation on the Quality of Midwifery Services from the Viewpoint of the Clients in Isfahan through SERVQUAL Model. Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research, 21, 291-296.
http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/1735-9066.180377
[14] Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V. and Berry, L. (1988) SERVQUAL: A Multiple-Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality. Journal of Retailing, 6, 12-37.
[15] Calixto, O.M., Okino, S.N., Hayashida, M., Costa, M.I., Auxiliadora, T.M. and Godoy, S. (2011) Escala SERVQUAL: Validación en población mexicana. Texto Contexto Enferm, 20, 326-333.
http://producao.usp.br/handle/BDPI/3578
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0104-07072011000300014
[16] Castillo Morales, E. Escala Multidimensional Servqual (2005) Facultad de Ciencias Empresariales. Universidad de Bio-Bio, Chile.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1aLp1eZ2g2RIpHQ_3C0f81fax9YseQdYV0GeYqPtqSys/edit?pli=1
[17] Cabello, E. and Chirinos, J.L. (2012) Validation and Applicability of SERVQUAL Modified Survey to Measure External User Satisfaction in Health Services. Revista Medica Herediana, 23, 88-95.
http://dx.doi.org/10.20453/rmh.v23i2.1037
[18] Andía, C., Pineda, A.M., Sottec, V., Santos, J.R., Molina, M.E. and Romero, Z. (2002) User Satisfaction Services Outpatient from I Espinar Hospital. SITUA, 10, 3-11.
[19] Babakus, E. and Mangold, W.G. (1992) Adapting the SERVQUAL Scale to Hospital Services: An Empirical Investigation. Health Services Research Journal, 26, 767-786.
[20] Sahasrabuddhe, V.V., Parham, G.P., Mwanahamuntu, M.H. and Vermund, S.H. (2011) Cervical Cancer Prevention in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: Feasible, Affordable, Essential. Cancer Prevention Research, 5, 12-17.
http://cancerpreventionresearch.aacrjournals.org/content/5/1/11.full
[21] Forouzanfar, M.H., Foreman, K.J., Delossantos, A.M., Lozano, R., Lopez, A.D., Murray, C.J. and Naghavi, M. (2011) Breast and Cervical Cancer in 187 Countries between 1980 and 2010: A Systematic Analysis. Lancet, 378, 1461-1484.
http://ac.els-cdn.com/S0140673611613512/1-s2.0-S0140673611613512-main.pdf?_tid=1150ddb6-e574-11e5-864a-00000aab0f6b&acdnat
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61351-2
[22] Hernández-Avila, M., Lazcano-Ponce, E. and Martínez, O. (2011) Public Policies for HPV Screening and Vaccination in Mexico. 27th International Papilloma Virus Conference and Clinical Workshop. Berlin, 17-23.
[23] Agha Molaei, T., ZareShahram, Poudat, A. and Kebriaei, A. (2007) Customer’s Perceptions and Expectations of Primary Healthcare Services Quality in health Centers of Bandar Abbas. Medical Journal of Hormozgan Univestity, 11, 173-179.
[24] Programa de calidad y seguridad del paciente (2013) Hospital Infantil de México “Federico Gómez”. México, D. F.
[25] Vega Chávez, J., Gutiérrez Enríquez, S.O. and Terán Figueroa, Y. (2009) Use of Pap in Women Attending Early Detection of Cervical Cancer: An Approach to Meeting The Service. Investigación y Educación en Enfermería, 27, 201-208.
[26] Hamui Sutton, L., Fuentes García, R, Aguirre Hernández, R. and Ramírez de la Roche, O.F. (2013) Expectativas y experiencias de los usuarios del Sistema de Salud en México: Un estudio de satisfacción con la atención médica. Coyoacán, D.F. Formas e Imágenes, S. A. de C. V, 22.

  
comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2018 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.