Share This Article:

Essentials of Teamcare in Randomized Controlled Trials of Multidisciplinary or Interdisciplinary Interventions in Somatic Care: A Systematic Review

Full-Text HTML XML Download Download as PDF (Size:456KB) PP. 1089-1101
DOI: 10.4236/ojn.2015.512116    3,664 Downloads   3,995 Views   Citations


Background: Teamcare should, like all patient care, also contribute to evidence-based practice (EBP). Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) focusing on teamcare have been performed but no study has addressed its essentials. How far this EBP has progressed in different health aspects is generally established in systematic reviews of RCTs. Aim: The aim is to determine the essentials of teamcare including the nurse profession in RCTs of multi- or interdisciplinary interventions in somatic care focusing on the stated context, goals, strategies, content as well as effectiveness of quality of care. Methods: A systematic review was performed according to Cochrane review assumptions to identify, appraise and synthesize all empirical evidence meeting pre-specified eligibility criteria. The PRISMA statement guided the data selection process of 27 articles from PubMed and CINAHL. Results: Eighty-five percent of RCTs in somatic care showed a positive effectiveness of teamcare interventions, of which interdisciplinary ones showed a greater effectiveness compared with the multidisciplinary approach (100% vs 76%). Also theory-based RCTs presented higher positive effectiveness (85%) compared with non-theory-based RCTs (79%). The RCTs with positive effectiveness showed greater levels for professional-centered ambition in terms of goals and for team-directed initiatives in terms of strategy, and a significantly higher level for patient-team interaction plans in terms of content was shown. Conclusions: Teamcare RCTs are still grounded in the multidisciplinary approach having a professional-centered ambition while interdisciplinary approaches especially those that are theory-based appear to be essential with regard to positive effectiveness and preferable when person-centered careis applied.

Cite this paper

Fridlund, B. , Andersson, E. , Bala, S. , Dahlman, G. , Ekwall, A. , Glasdam, S. , Hommel, A. , Lindberg, C. , Persson, E. , Rantala, A. , Sjöström-Strand, A. , Wihlborg, J. and Samuelson, K. (2015) Essentials of Teamcare in Randomized Controlled Trials of Multidisciplinary or Interdisciplinary Interventions in Somatic Care: A Systematic Review. Open Journal of Nursing, 5, 1089-1101. doi: 10.4236/ojn.2015.512116.


[1] Fineout-Overholt, E., Melnyk, B.M. and Schultz, A. (2005) Transforming Health Care from the Inside Out: Advancing Evidence-Based Practice in the 21st Century. Journal of Professional Nursing, 21, 335-344.
[2] Angel, S. and Frederiksen, K.N. (2015) Challenges in Achieving Patient Participation: A Review of How Patient Participation Is Addressed in Empirical Studies. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 52, 1525-1538.
[3] Nancarrow, S.A.,Booth, A., Ariss, S., Smith, T., Enderby, P. and Roots, A.(2013) Ten Principles of Good Interdisciplinary Team Work. Human Resources for Health, 11, 19.
[4] Jessup, R.L. (2007) Interdisciplinary versus Multidisciplinary Care Teams: Do We Understand the Difference? Australian Health Review, 31, 330-331.
[5] Leplege, A., Gzil, F., Cammellin, M, Lefeve, C., Pachoud, B. and Ville, I. (2007) Person-Centredness—Conceptual and Historical Perspectives. Disability Rehabilitation, 29, 1555-1565.
[6] Ekman, I., Swedberg, K., Taft, C., Lindseth, A., Norberg, A., Brink, E., Carlsson, J., Dahlin-Ivanoff, S., Johansson, I.L, Kjellgren, K., Lidén, E., Öhlén, J., Olsson, L.E., Rosén, H., Rydmark, M. and Sunnerhagen, K.S. (2011) Person-Centered Care—Ready for Prime Time. European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, 10, 248-251.
[7] Starfield, B. (2011) Is Patient-Centered Care the Same as Person-Focused Care? Permanente Journal, 15, 63-69.
[8] Say, R.E. and Thomsen, R. (2003) The Importance of Patient Preferences in Treatment Decisions-Challenges for Doctors. British Medical Journal, 327, 542-545.
[9] Boivin, A., Currie, K., Fervers, B., Gracia, J., James, M., Marshall, C., Sakala, C., Sanger, S., Strid, J., Thomas, V., van der Weijden, T., Grol, R. and Burgers, J.; G-I-N PUBLIC (2010) Patients and Public Involvement in Clinical Guidelines; International Experiences and Future Perspectives. Quality and Safety in Health Care, 19, e22.
[10] Olsson, L.-E., Jakobsson Ung, E., Swedberg, K. and Ekman, I. (2012) Efficacy of Person-Centered Care as an Intervention in Controlled Trials—A Systematic Review. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 22, 456-465.
[11] Coulter, A., Entwistle, V.A., Eccles, A., Ryan, S., Shepperd, S. and Perera, R. (2013) Personalised Care Planning for Adults with Chronic or Long-Term Health Conditions (Protocol). The Cochrane Collaboration, 5, No. CD010523.
[12] Ellen, M.E., Léon, G., Bouchard, G., Lavis, J.N., Ouimet, M. and Grimshaw, J.M. (2013) What Supports Do Health System Organizations Have in Place to Facilitate Evidence-Informed Decision-Making? A Qualitative Study. Implementation Science, 8, 84.
[13] Lewin, S., Glenton, C. and Oxman, A.D. (2009) Use of Qualitative Methods Alongside Randomised Controlled Trials of Complex Healthcare Interventions: Methodological Study. British Medical Journal, 339, b3496.
[14] Kilgore, R.V. and Langford, R.W. (2010) Defragmenting Care: Testing an Intervention to Increase the Effectiveness of Interdisciplinary Health Care Teams. Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America, 22, 271-278.
[15] Rios, L.P., Ye, C. and Thabane, L. (2010) Association between Framing of the Research Question Using the PICOT Format and Reporting Quality of Randomized Controlled Trials. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 10, 11.
[16] Fineout-Overholt, E., Melnyk, B.M., Stillwell, S.B. and Williamson, K.M. (2010) Evidence-Based Practice Step by Step: Critical Appraisal of the Evidence—Part I. American Journal of Nursing, 110, 47-52.
[17] Tuckett, A.G. (2005) The Care Encounter: Pondering Caring, Honest Communication and Control. International Journal of Nursing Practice, 11, 77-84.
[18] Fridlund, B., Jönsson, A.C., Andersson, E.K., Bala, S.-V., Dahlman, G.-B., Forsberg, A., Glasdam, S., Hommel, A., Kristensson, A., Lindberg, C., Sivberg, B., Sjöström-Strand, A., Wihlborg, J. and Samuelson, K. (2014) Essential of Nursing Care in Randomized Controlled Trials of Nurse-Led Interventions in Somatic Care: A Systematic Review. Open Journal of Nursing, 4, 181-197.
[19] Martin, J.S., Ummenhofer, W., Manser, T. and Spiriga, R. (2010) Interprofessional Collaboration among Nurses and Physicians: Making a Difference in Patient Outcome. Swiss Medical Weekly, 140, w13062.
[20] Forbes, A. (2009) Clinical Intervention Research in Nursing. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 46, 557-568.
[21] Zwarenstein, M., Goldman, J. and Reeves, S. (2009) Interprofessional Collaboration: Effects of Practice-Based Interventions on Professional Practice and Healthcare Outcomes. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3, CD000072.
[22] Valderas, J.M., Kotzeva, A., Espallargues, M., Guyatt, G., Ferrans, C.E., Halyard, M.Y., et al. (2008) The Impact of Measuring Patient-Reported Outcomes in Clinical Practice: A Systematic Review of the Literature. Quality of Life Research, 17, 179-193.
[23] Liberati, A., Altman, D.G., Tetzlatt, J., Mulrow, C., Gotzsche, P.C. and Joannidis, J.P. (2009) The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Metaanalyses of Studies That Evaluate Healthcare Interventions: Explanation and Elaborations. British Medical Journal, 339, b2700.
[24] Swedish Council on Health Technology Assessment (2009) Evaluation and Synthesis of Studies Using QuantitativeMethods of Analysis. SBU, Stockholm.
[25] Higgins, J.P.T. and Green, S. (2011) Cochrane Collaboration Handbook for Systematic Review of Interventions. The Cochrane Collaboration, London.
[26] Chan, J.C., So, W.Y., Yeung, C.Y., Ko, G.T., Lau, I.T., Tsang, M.W., Lau, K.P., Siu, S.C., Li, J.K., Yeung, V.T., Leung, W.Y. and Tong, P.C., SURE Study Group (2009) Effects of Structured versus Usual Care on Renal Endpoint in Type 2 Diabetes: The SURE Study: A Randomized Multicenter Translational Study. Diabetes Care, 32, 977-982.
[27] Ennis, M., Thain, J., Boggild, M., Baker, G.A. and Young, C.A. (2006) A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Health Promotion Education Programme for People with Multiple Sclerosis. Clinical Rehabilitation, 20, 783-792.
[28] Gade, G., Venohr, I., Conner, D., McGrady, K., Beane, J., Richardson, R.H., Williams, M.P., Liberson, M., Blum, M. and Della Penna, R. (2008) Impact of an Inpatient Palliative Care Team: A Randomized Control Trial. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 11, 180-190.
[29] Jack, B.W., Chetty, V.K., Anthony, D., Greenwald, J.L., Sanchez, G.M., Johnson, A.E., Forsythe, S.R., O’Donnell, J.K., Paasche-Orlow, M.K., Manasseh, C., Martin, S. and Culpepper, L. (2009) A Reengineered Hospital Discharge Program to Decrease Rehospitalization: A Randomized Trial. Annals of Internal Medicine, 150, 178-187.
[30] Margalit, A.P. and El-Ad, A. (2008) Costly Patients with Unexplained Medical Symptoms: A High-Risk Population. Patient Education and Counseling, 70, 173-178.
[31] Nielsen, D., Ryg, J., Nissen, N., Nielsen, W., Knold, B. and Brixen, K. (2008) Multidisciplinary Patient Education in Groups Increases Knowledge on Osteoporosis: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 36, 346-352.
[32] Nielsen, D., Ryg, J., Nielsen, W., Knold, B., Nissen, N. and Brixen, K. (2010) Patient Education in Groups Increases Knowledge of Osteoporosis and Adherence to Treatment: A Two-Year Randomized Controlled Trial. Patient Education and Counseling, 81, 155-160.
[33] Trento, M., Basile, M., Borgo, E., Grassi, G., Scuntero, P., Trinetta, A., Cavallo, F. and Porta, M. (2008) A Randomised Controlled Clinical Trial of Nurse-, Dietitian- and Pedagogistled Group Care for the Management of Type 2 Diabetes. Journal of Endocrinological Investigation, 31, 1038-1042.
[34] Austin, J., Williams, W.R., Ross, L. and Hutchison, S. (2008) Five-Year Follow-Up Findings from a Randomized Controlled Trial of Cardiac Rehabilitation for Heart Failure. European Journal of Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation, 15, 162-167.
[35] Azad, N., Molnar, F. and Byszewski, A. (2008) Lessons Learned from a Multidisciplinary Heart Failure Clinic for Older Women: A Randomised Controlled Trial. Age and Ageing, 37, 282-287.
[36] Davidson, P.M., Cockburn, J., Newton, P.J., Webster, J.K., Betihavas, V., Howes, L. and Owensby, D.O. (2010) Can a Heart Failure-Specific Cardiac Rehabilitation Program Decrease Hospitalizations and Improve Outcomes in High-Risk Patients? European Journal of Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation, 17, 393-402.
[37] Nguyen, V., Ducharme, A., White, M., Racine, N., O’Meara, E., Zhang, B., Rouleau, J.L. and Brophy, J. (2007) Lack of Long-Term Benefits of a 6-Month Heart Failure Disease Management Program. Journal of Cardiac Failure, 13, 287-293.
[38] Del Sindaco, D., Pulignano, G., Minardi, G., Apostoli, A., Guerrieri, L., Rotoloni, M., Petri, G., Fabrizi, L., Caroselli, A., Venusti, R., Chiantera, A., Giulivi, A., Giovannini, E. and Leggio, F. (2007) Two-Year Outcome of a Prospective, Controlled Study of a Disease Management Programme for Elderly Patients with Heart Failure. Journal of Cardiovascular Medicine (Hagerstown), 8, 324-329.
[39] Wood, D.A., Kotseva, K., Connolly, S., Jennings, C., Mead, A., Jones, J., Holden, A., De Bacquer, D., Collier, T., De Backer, G. and Faergeman, O., EUROACTION Study Group (2008) Nurse-Coordinated Multidisciplinary, Family-Based Cardiovascular Disease Prevention Programme (EUROACTION) for Patients with Coronary Heart Disease and Asymptomatic Individuals at High Risk of Cardiovascular Disease: A Paired, Cluster-Randomised Controlled Trial. The Lancet, 371, 1999-2012.
[40] Boyd, C.M., Reider, L., Frey, K., Scharfstein, D., Leff, B., Wolff, J., Groves, C., Karm, L.,Wegener, S., Marsteller, J. and Boult, C. (2010) The Effects of Guided Care on the Perceived Quality of Health Care for Multi-Morbid Older Persons: 18-Month Outcomes from a Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 25, 235-242.
[41] Counsell, S.R., Callahan, C.M., Clark, D.O., Tu, W., Buttar, A.B., Stump, T.E. and Ricketts, G.D. (2007) Geriatric Care Management for Low-Income Seniors: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of the American Medical Association, 298, 2623-2633.
[42] Hogg, W., Lemelin, J., Dahrouge, S., Liddy, C., Armstrong, C.D., Legault, F., Dalziel, B. and Zhang,W. (2009) Randomized Controlled Trial of Anticipatory and Preventive Multidisciplinary Team Care: For Complex Patients in a Community-Based Primary Care Setting. Canadian Family Physician, 55, e76-e85.
[43] Rinfret, S., Lussier, M.T., Peirce, A., Duhamel, F., Cossette, S., Lalonde, L., Tremblay, C., Guertin, M.C., LeLorier, J., Turgeon, J., Hamet, P. and LOYAL Study Investigators (2009) The Impact of a Multidisciplinary Information Technology-Supported Program on Blood Pressure Control in Primary Care. Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, 2, 170-177.
[44] White, D.K., Wagenaar, R.C., Ellis, T.D. and Tickle-Degnen, L. (2009) Changes in Walking Activity and Endurance Following Rehabilitation for People with Parkinson Disease. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 90, 43-50.
[45] Berggren, M., Stenvall, M., Olofsson, B. and Gustafson, Y. (2008) Evaluation of a Fall-Prevention Program in Older People after Femoral Neck Fracture: A One-Year Follow-Up. Osteoporos International, 19, 801-809.
[46] Hendriks, M.R., Bleijlevens, M.H., van Haastregt, J.C., Crebolder, H.F., Diederiks, J.P., Evers, S.M., Mulder, W.J., Kempen, G.I., van Rossum, E., Ruijgrok, J.M., Stalenhoef, P.A. and van Eijk, J.T. (2008) Lack of Effectiveness of a Multidisciplinary Fall-Prevention Program in Elderly People at Risk: A Randomized, Controlled Trial. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 56, 1390-1397.
[47] Stenvall, M., Olofsson, B., Lundström, M., Englund, U., Borssén, B., Svensson, O., Nyberg, L. and Gustafson, Y. (2007) A Multidisciplinary, Multifactorial Intervention Program Reduces Postoperative Falls and Injuries after Femoral Neck Fracture. Osteoporos International, 18, 167-175.
[48] Stenvall, M., Olofsson, B., Nyberg, L., Lundström, M. and Gustafson, Y. (2007) Improved Performance in Activities of Daily Living and Mobility after a Multidisciplinary Postoperative Rehabilitation in Older People with Femoral Neck Fracture: A Randomized Controlled Trial with 1-Year Follow-Up. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 39, 232-238.
[49] Brown, P., Clark, M.M., Atherton, P., Huschka, M., Sloan, J.A., Gamble, G., Girardi, J., Frost, M.H., Piderman, K. and Rummans, T.A. (2006) Will Improvement in Quality of Life (QOL) Impact Fatigue in Patients Receiving Radiation Therapy for Advanced Cancer? American Journal of Clinical Oncology, 29, 52-58.
[50] Cheville, A.L., Girardi, J., Clark, M.M., Rummans, T.A., Pittelkow, T., Brown, P., Hanson, J., Atherton, P., Johnson, M.E., Sloan, J.A. and Gamble, G. (2010) Therapeutic Exercise during Outpatient Radiation Therapy for Advanced Cancer: Feasibility and Impact on Physical Well-Being. American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, 89, 611-619.
[51] Korstjens, I., May, A.M., van Weert, E., Mesters, I., Tan, F., Ros, W.J., Hoekstra-Weebers, J.E., van der Schans, C.P. and van den Borne, B. (2008) Quality of Life after Self-Management Cancer Rehabilitation: A Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Physical and Cognitive-Behavioral Training versus Physical Training. Psychosomatic Medicine, 70, 422-429.
[52] Serclová, Z., Dytrych, P., Marvan, J., Nová, K., Hankeová, Z., Ryska, O., Slégrová, Z., Buresová, L., Trávníková, L. and Antos, F. (2009) Fast-Track in Open Intestinal Surgery: Prospective Randomized Study (Clinical Trials Gov Identifier No. NCT00123456). Clinical Nutrition, 28, 618-624.
[53] Close, J., Ellis, M., Hooper, R., Glucksman, E., Jackson, S. and Swift, C. (1999) Prevention of Falls in the Elderly Trial (PROFET): A Randomized Controlled Trial. The Lancet, 353, 93-97.
[54] Arnold, M.S., Butler, P.M., Anderson, R.M., Funnell, M.M. and Feste, C. (1995) Guidelines for Facilitating a Patient Empowerment Program. The Diabetes Educator, 21, 308-312.
[55] Weimann, A., Braga, M., Harsanyi, L., Laviano, A., Ljungqvist, O., Soeters, P., DGEM (German Society for Nutritional Medicine) Jauch, K.W., Kemen, M., Hiesmayr, J.M., Horbach, T., Kuse, E.R., Vestweber, K.H. and ESPEN (European Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition) (2006) ESPEN Guidelines on Enteral Nutrition: Surgery including Organ Transplantation. Clinical Nutrition, 25, 224-244.
[56] Wood, D., De Backer, G., Faergeman, O., Graham, I., Mancia, G. and Pyörälä, K. (1998) Prevention of Coronary Heart Disease in Clinical Practice: Recommendations of the Second Joint Task Force of European and Other Societies on Coronary Prevention. European Heart Journal, 19, 1434-1503.
[57] Harrison, M.B., Toman, C. and Logan, J. (1996) Partners in Care for Congestive Heart Failure. 2nd Edition, Continuity of Care Study, University of Ottawa Loeb Research Institute, Ottawa.
[58] Counsell, S.R., Callahan, C.M., Buttar, A.B., Clark, D.O. and Frank, K.I. (2006) Geriatric Resources for Assessment and Care of Elders (GRACE): A New Model of Primary Care for Low-Income Seniors. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 54, 1136-1141.
[59] Grady, K.L., Dracup, K., Kennedy, G., Moser, D.K., Piano, M., Warner Stevenson, L. and Young, J.B. (2000) Team Management of Patients with Heart Failure: A Statement for Healthcare Professionals from the Cardiovascular Nursing Council of the American Heart Association. Circulation, 102, 2443-2456.
[60] Bandura, A. (1977) Self-Efficacy: Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioural Change. Psychological Review, 84, 191-215.
[61] Weismann, D. (1997) Consultation in Palliative Medicine. Archives of Internal Medicine, 157, 733-737.
[62] Mesters, I., Creer, T.L. and Gerards, F. (2002) Self-Management and Respiratory Disorders: Guiding from Health Counseling and Self-Management Perspectives. In: Kaptein, A. and Creer, T.L., Eds., Respiratory Disorders and Behavioral Research, Dunitz, London, 139-174.
[63] Leventhal, H. and Carr, S. (2001) Speculations on the Relationship of Behavioral Therapy to Psychosocial Research on Cancer. In: Baum, A. and Andersen, B.L., Eds., Psychosocial Interventions for Cancer, American Psychological Association, Washington DC, 375-400.
[64] Eshet, I., Margalit, A. and Almagor, G. (1993) Short Family Therapy in Ambulatory Medicine (SFAT-AM): Treatment Approach in 10 - 15 Minute Encounters. Family Practice, 10, 178-187.
[65] Newman, P. and Peile, E. (2002) Valuing Learners’ Experience and Supporting Further Growth: Educational Models to Help Experienced Edult Learners in Medicine. British Medical Journal, 325, 200-202.
[66] Hildon, Z., Allwood, D. and Black, N. (2012) Making Data More Meaningful: Patients’ Views of the Format and Content of Quality Indicators Comparing Health Care Providers. Patient Education and Counseling, 88, 298-304.
[67] Allen, J.K. and Dennison, C.R. (2010) Randomized Trials of Nursing Interventions for Secondary Prevention in Patients with Coronary Artery Disease and Heart Failure: Systematic Review. Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, 25, 207-220.
[68] Prilleltensky, I. (2005) Promoting Well-Being: Time for a Paradigm Shift in Health and Human Services. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 33, 53-60.
[69] Specht, J.K., Taylor, R. and Bossen, A.L. (2009) Partnering for Care: The Evidence and the Expert. Journal of Gerontological Nursing, 35, 16-22.
[70] Shepperd, S., Lewin, S., Straus, S., Clarke, M., Eccles, M.P., Fitzpatrick, R., et al. (2009) Can We Systematically Review Studies That Evaluate Complex Interventions? PLoS Medicine, 6, e1000086.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2018 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.