Formatting Online Image of “Halal” Destination through Photography

Web 2.0 or social media as a digital instrument of the internet marketing is increasingly significant in formatting an online image of the tourist destination. The study collected photographic information of two destinations in Indonesia (West Sumatera and Aceh) from the official Instagram account of each of their local authorities to explore the online image of these destinations. Visual content analysis was applied to examine the image formation of this halal tourism within the collected photograph. The results indicate that various dimensions of an image are composed of five dimensions: social opportunity and attraction, natural and cultural amenities, accommodation and transportation, infrastructure, food and friendly people, physical amenities, and recreation activities. However, similarly natural and cultural amenities are the most emphasized dimension. Conversely, the dimension of accommodation and transportation is less stressed by these official webs. Meanwhile, categories of some image dimensions were emphasized differently. The implication of halal destination and study findings to the theoretical development of the image of halal tourism and some recommendations for future study were discussed.


Introduction
The significance of the internet in tourism marketing has been well documented by some previous studies [1] [2] [3]. While, web site features and web site promotion techniques, and programs of customer relationship management are factors that influence the effectiveness of web marketing strategies [4], including in marketing tourism, since it influences on tourist's destination selection. Indeed, Akyol & Kilinc [31] and Suradin [32] examined marketing web content to identify how halal destination is promoted. However, both studies highlighted various Islamic attributes emphasized in the selected marketing web content. Therefore, various image dimension conceptualized by scholars is still unexamined within the context of halal tourism marketing.
Government/public agencies is one element in destination marketing (branding) [33]. Additionally, the government in several countries adopt web marketing into their tourism marketing strategy [1]. This article study tried to fill this lacuna, particularly by examining how halal tourism image is projected visually by the public tourism agency through producing online photographs as their promotional materials posted on their official Instagram account. Focusing on two famous halal destinations of Indonesia (West Sumatera and Aceh), the study applied image theory developed by Fakeye & Crompton [12] to understand how each of their public agencies creates the image of both destinations.

Image Definition
There are several image definitions conceptualized by scholars. Through reviews of tourism literature, Gallarza, Saura, & García found 13 image definitions [34].
According to Baloglu & McCleary, the image consists of two elements: cognitive and affective [39]. The cognitive refers to knowledge and beliefs about a destination. In contrast, the affective element refers to feelings about a destination [40] or emotions that a tourist destination can evoke (e.g., pleasure, excitement] [41]. Gartner adds one more component in addition to the two components already mentioned earlier, conative, which refers to behaviour or tourist's action [15]. Dann [42], Pike & Ryan [43], Agapito, Valle, & Mendes [44], and Kim, Lee, Shin, & Yang [20] agreed with this three-element of the image. Some previous studies showed tourist's image formation was influenced by these elements [39], [45] as well as some other factors, such as motivation, experience gender, social class, the country of origin, source of information and social characteristics (age and education level of tourist) [46].
On the other hand, a source of information is an essential element in the process of image formation through which information is portrayed to the targeted tourists. It is as reflected through a definition of image formulated by Reynolds "the development of a mental construct based upon a few impressions chosen from a flood of information [14]". In this context, Fodness & Murray introduced two categories of the source of information: commercial and non-commercial [47].
Two categories of image developed by Gunn: organic and induced image likely is also reflected the differences of media, which take part in image formation [48]. The author explained that the organic image is created by the non-touristic source of information consisting of News reports, magazines, books, movies), education (school courses), and the opinions of family/friends. In contrast, the induced image is formatted by the commercial source of information. Travel brochures, travel agents, and travel guidebooks were included in the last category of the source of information.
Further, Gartner added some other image categories created by the differences in the source of information [15]. For instance, solicited organic image is created through word-of-mouth advertising, while Overt Induced one image by the agent of traditional forms of advertising by using several media, such as television, radio, brochures, billboards, and print media advertising.
Besides, Gunn's image categories (organic and induced image), the projected image, and re-evaluated image were introduced by Selby & Morgan [49]. He defined the first as the image created by the official destination organization, while tourist itself creates the last through destination visitation. Therefore, the re-evaluated image is similar to the complex image, as theorized by Fakeye & Crompton, a kind of image created by tourists after his destination visitation [12].

Researches on the Tourism Web Marketing and Image Formation
Several forms of media are vital in image formation, such as visual and written content of movies, guidebooks and magazines [54]; film [55], and [56]; mass media [57]; TV news, travel documentaries, news report, and the internet [21].
Internet is another form of media integrated into the tourism marketing strategy. Gertner, Berger, & Gertner revealed that country portal with country name-dot-com has contributed to country branding development as well as synergizing all activities, such as investment, product offerings, and services [1].
Since the portal with country name-dot-com domain could be accessed easily by users.
Also, the study of Nusair indicated that e-commerce web sites successfully develop e-relationship through reinforcement of two categories of customers' commitment (calculative dan effective) [3]. The commitment reinforcement is measured by the quality of alternatives, investment size, satisfaction, and trust.
Kuster showed a similar finding that the internet is a relational tool to improve the relationship between the travel company and its customers [2].

Methods
The West Sumatera and Aceh are the provincial region of Indonesia located geographically in the Sumatera Island. Mainly, The West Sumatera is located in the centre part of Sumatera island, whereas Aceh occupies the western end of the island. Recently, both local authorities of the province have been developing their destination by the concept of halal tourism. The geographical position of those provincial regions is presented in Figure 1.
Battour & Ismail define halal as permissible practices allowed by the Islamic teachings [64]. While, in the dictionary of Leisure, Travel, and Tourism, the term of tourism is defined as the business of providing travel, accommodation, food, entertainment for tourists [65]. Accordingly, the concept of halal tourism may be viewed merely as a business that supplies various kinds of services or products, such as food, accommodation, travel, which are allowed by Islamic teachings. It is in line with what Ahmed & Akbaba said that halal tourism refers to the product of tourism created to provide hospitality services following Islamic beliefs and practices [24].
Halal tourism grows as a promising niche market, as statistic showed in 2018, 140 millions of Muslim tourists participated in tourism activities. It is forecasted that in 2026, the number of Muslim travellers will reach 230 million [25]. Seven factors were identified to encourage the growth of the global market of the halal tourism market, such as growing Muslim population, growing middle class, younger population, increasing access to travel information, increasing availability of Muslim-friendly travel services and facilities, Ramadhan travel, business travel [25].
In general, Indonesia destinations are globally-known as Muslim friendly destinations among Muslim travellers. In 2019, the Indonesia destinations ranked 2nd under those of Malaysia as the best Muslim destinations [25]. Besides, Indonesia won 12 categories of the 2016 halal tourism award held in Abudhabi. Mainly, the West Sumatra won two categories: the world's best halal destination and World's best halal culinary, while Aceh won the category of the World's best halal cultural destination [26].
Recently, each local authority takes part in promoting its halal destination through web marketing. Hundreds of photographs are produced and posted on that official web. Besides, the photos are reposted on their official accounts of several social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and Instagram). Their website address and official Instagram account are presented in Table 2.
The photograph is a crucial promotional material for creating and communicating destination image [27] attracting tourist and stimulating a behavioural intention [66], and improving destination image [11]. Several previous studies presented photograph in the touristic media represented the image of destination [22] [23] [29] [30] [67].   At the same time, public agency or government is an element of tourism marketing [33]. Several public agencies of tourism marketing have integrated web marketing into their branding strategy by which the county-name-com domain is used to reach the global audience [1].
The article highlighted how the image of two halal destinations in Indonesia is created by their local authorities (West Sumatera and Aceh) through which photographs were produced and posted in their official Instagram accounts. The photograph as the study data were taken manually from their official account by using a feature of the screenshot. A feature is available commonly in various electronic devices (laptop, computer desktop, smartphone, tablet). The process of taking photos on the two official websites is carried out in approximately two months, from 05 August to 30 September 2019. Therefore, any photo posted on those websites after the expiration time of data retrieval was not covered by the study. All photos are analyzed to ascertain whether they are relevant to the issue ad-dressed by the study. Then, each photo was registered by giving them a number and listed into a table. The amount of the selected photos derived from two official websites were presented in Table 2. Then, a visual content analysis was applied to analyze the selected photographs. Content analysis may be briefly defined as the systematic, objective, quantitative analysis of message characteristics [68]. The message as object analysis may be visual, verbal graphic, oral-indeed, any kind of meaningful visual/verbal information [69].
Notably, in the photo analysis, a classification scheme is formulated to measure the photographs [29]. He added the measurements might include the frequency with which particular subjects occur, the dominant colours and compositions, the distribution of particular poses or landscapes, and clusters of particular photographic techniques. In this case of study, the appearance of a particular subject in the photograph was measured and compared. The six dimensions of image developed by Fakeye & Crompton (social opportunities and attraction, natural and cultural amenities, accommodation and transportation, infrastructure, food and friendly people, physical amenities and recreation activities, and nightlife and entertain) were applied to analyze how those photos create the destination image [12]. In the study, all selected photographs were coded to calculate and compare the appearance of a certain subject or attribute in the photo. Atlas.Ti, a software application for qualitative data analysis, is used for coding each photo. For a description of image dimensions and coding guidance, see Table 3. Table 4 presents the frequency of occurrence for each dimension of the image in the photograph derived from official websites of both public agencies. Generally, Table 3. Description of image dimension, adopted from (Fakeye & Crompton, 1991).

Image dimension Description
Social opportunities and attraction (SOA) SOA refers to tourist involvement in the touristic event. Several categories were attributed to this dimension festival, cultural performance, music concert, some other cultural events.
Natural and cultural amenities (NCA) NCA refers to two categories of attraction offered for tourists (nature and culture). Natural attraction covers some elements, such as mountains, beaches, lakes, coastal. Second, cultural attraction consists of historical buildings, cultural heritage, cultural performance, museums.

Accommodation and transportation (AT)
Any depiction of a hotel, apartment, condominium, villa and various forms of transportation service, such as a ship, bus, airplane, airport, seaport was coded as AT.
Infrastructure, food and friendly people (IFFP) Infrastructure refers to the work system of the state required of tourism activity. Food and friendly people are the unique experiences offered for tourists while purchasing a destination.
Physical amenities and recreation activities (PARA) PARA refers to any physical comforts and touristic activities as a part of touristic attraction. Open Journal of Business and Management Sub-total 15 31 they emphasized more dimension of natural and cultural amenities (NCA) than that of social opportunity and attraction as well as other dimensions, as the total amount of appearance of some categories included into NCA are higher than those of other dimensions. Vice versa, similarly, both agencies less emphasized the dimension of accommodation and transportation (AT). Firstly, It is indicated by a few categories of AT promoted through their photograph production (Particularly Aceh only appeared two categories: boat and seaport); secondly, low rate of occurrence of those categories.
However, the differences in image categories of each dimension were highlighted by those agencies. First, for the dimension of Social opportunities and attraction, West Sumatera agency portrayed sports events prominently, such as race bikes, crossed motorbikes, horse racing. Additionally, a special event is emphasized by portraying several kinds of the festival (music concerts, photo contests). However, the last image categories were not promoted remarkably.
Also, the Aceh tourism agency is more likely to picture various kinds of festivals (cooking competition, cultural festival). It was indicated by the highest amount of occurrence numbers reached by that image category. Also, sports events were pictured in Aceh; however, its occurrence number is less significant. Notably, the category of a concert is not pictured in Aceh.
Second, for the dimension of natural and cultural amenities, various categories were promoted by those official accounts, such as beach, forest, waterfall, mountain, lake, canyon, valley. Mainly West Sumatera agency more likely to picture green scenery and cultural performance since those categories occurred dominantly in its photos. Through the category of green scenery, the natural Open Journal of Business and Management beauty of West Sumatera nature is portrayed, as if offered to users for consumption. In contrast, the category of cultural performance depicted local people wearing their traditional dress and performing local arts or dance.
Mosque building and cultural heritage are two other categories highlighted in the official account of West Sumatera agency, as Aceh webs did, mainly mosque buildings. However, especially for natural amenities, Aceh emphasized the beach. It is different from West Sumatera, which stresses more green scenery, as presented earlier.
Third, accommodation and transportation (AT) were likely not accented by those official webs, since only a few categories were pictured with the less significance of occurrence number. In the West Sumatera agency, four categories of AT were portrayed. Two of them (boat and airport) appeared (2 times), while the rest only one time (train and ship). Even in the official account of Aceh tourism, as presented earlier, only two categories were pictured (boat and seaport). Also, they appeared less significantly in the data.
Fourth, the official web of West Sumatera and Aceh emphasized similarly local food in their visual promotional materials, as one category in IFP appeared prominently in the data. Friendly people, good highways, and café are other categories promoted by the official web of west Sumatera, while the Aceh account promoted friendly people, food market, and shopping centre. Finally, several recreation activities were depicted by both official accounts, such as ride a hinging bike, hang out, surfing, however not emphasized remarkably, as their frequency of appearance was low. Meanwhile, several religious activities were portrayed, such as pilgrimage, praying at the mosque, reciting the Qur'an, and so on. Finally, some image categories depicted prominently by the two official Instagram account are presented in Figure 2 and

Discussion
Ingold defines culture as a human capacity manifested in various forms, for instance, the artefact (material culture), ritual, belief, art, dance, and music [70]. At the same time, culture is closely related to advertising or marketing, as some various studies demonstrate that advertisings promote various cultural values [71] [72] [73]. Particularly in the tourism marketing context, a study of Mok & Defranco presents the cultural value of Chinese tourists influence on their tourism practices covering the process of travel decision making and their touristic behaviour while visiting or consuming the destination [74].
Besides, human value is embedded in the concept of the brand [75]. Empirically, work of Saji, Vij, & Kabiraj demonstrates that the tourist' human value affect their destination purchasing [76]. The study's findings certainly have implications for tourism marketing, as presented by the study of Taufiqqurrachman that photographs as promotional materials of Bali destination derived from several official Instagram account of tourism marketing agency promote human values [28]. Accordingly, several depictions of objects (destination, people (host    Nevertheless, these study findings can be seen in the perspective of halal tourism. As conceptualized by Ahmed & Akbaba, halal tourism is produced to provide Muslim tourist needs while visiting a specific destination [24]. Also, Battour, Battor, & Bhatti confirmed that the availability of mosques is one attribute of halal tourism [77]. From this perspective, the depiction of mosque buildings in several photos is a way to fulfill the halal tourism attributes.
In the study, the religious event is a category included in the dimension of SOA since it is viewed as a social opportunity provided for tourists. By depicting these events, tourists are invited to participate and feel a different experience when interacting with other tourists in the event. In contrast, religious activities are included in the dimension of physical amenities and recreation activities. Somehow, the photo is one of the promotional materials; therefore, various religious activities pictured in specific photos may be viewed as an attraction in the form of physical activities provided for tourists to enjoy their pleasure.
Finally, in the study, the mosque building is a category included in the dimension of NCA. On the one hand, within the context of touristic image formation, the depiction of mosque building could be coded as a historical site. It is following Gearing et al. explain that this historic image site is characterized by the depiction of some elements, such as ancient ruins, religious significance, and historical prominence [50]. Indeed, these three elements are circulated in the photo when depicting several mosque buildings, as shown in Figure 4.
Additionally, the atmosphere of Muslim friendly destinations also is rein- Bars and evening entertainment are other dimensions of the image destination [12]. Nighttime recreation is similar to that dimension found in the work of Gearing et al. [50]. Some categories (gambling casinos, discotheques, cinema, theatres) are attributed to that dimension by the author. However, none of the photo derived from both official tourism agency promotes these image categories. This finding is in line with El-Gohary clarifying halal tourism requires no nightclubs or nighttime entertainment [78]. Along with this, some activities closely associated with nightlife do not meet the criteria of halal tourism, such as consuming drinks containing alcohol [78], gambling games [79]. However, the contradiction finding is shown in this study. On the one hand, aspects of the food. For instance, the halal logo accompanying the highlighted food is no depicted. Halal food is one indicator to measure the level of a Muslim-friendly destination [25]. Also, halal food availability is one of the attributes that directly impact tourist satisfaction [79].
Indeed, there are none of the photos that depict foods containing pork, alcohol, but it does not mean the foods they describe have met halal standards. Since Hanzaee & Ramezani describe the product of halal food need to fulfill two aspects: first, the product does not contain pork or its byproduct, alcohol, prohibited food ingredients of animal origin, and prepared and manufactured on clean equipment. Second, the food product has been certified as halal product shown by the halal certificate and the halal logo issued by an Islamic organization [80].
By visual content analysis toward photographs posted on two official Instagram accounts successfully identify some dimensions of the projected image of two halal destinations in Indonesia: West Sumatera and Aceh. At the same time, the study contributed to the development of destination image theory in general; and six factors of image dimension conceptualized by Fakeye & Crompton in particular [12]. Principally, halal tourism is also a tourism product created for commercial purposes like other destinations. However, Muslim tourist is the main target for the marketing of this kind of destination. Therefore, for tourism marketing, mainly through the creation of the projected-image, the marketer needs to convert various Muslim needs and attractiveness into elements of an image, such as four elements found by the study (religious event, religious activities, mosque buildings, women in hijab).
Besides, some recommendation is provided by the study. First, different audiences, time, and situation, create polysemic meanings of advertising [81] as well as a photographic image [82]. Semiotic analysis is recommended to deal with that issue since Rose argues the method of analysis provides an analytical tool uncovers the different levels of meaning communicated by a photo [83].
Second, different stakeholders (commercial and public) take part in marketing the destination. The study only covers visual materials of tourism marketing produced by public agencies of two halal destinations. Therefore, the future study needs to expand the scope of the study by covering promotional materials produced by the different agencies to gain a holistic understanding of the creation of a halal destination image. Besides, the notion of the 'circle of representation' conceptualized by Jenkin described that tourism organizations and tourists format images. The study provided empirical findings on the projected-image of halal destination. Therefore, future research needs to question how tourist creates the perceived-image of halal destination.
Third, various image dimensions conceptualized by some scholarly studies; however, they have been summarized by Lian & Yu into three dimensions (tourism facilities, tourism services, tourism resources] [23]. The two agencies did not cover these image dimensions proportionally since they emphasized more tourism resources dimension, for instance, natural and cultural amenities and social opportunity. At the same time, some other dimensions are not highlighted (accommodation), as no photo depicts accommodation services (hotel, apartment, villa).

Conclusions
This study collects photographs from the official Instagram account of West Sumatera and Aceh tourism authority to identify how they project the image of their destination as halal tourism through photograph production. Qualitative visual content analysis is adopted to explore the various dimensions of the online image, and further investigate the distribution of each dimension in the selected photographs taken from both official webs. The online images of both halal destinations are explored from five dimensions of image conceptualized by Fakeye & Crompton (social opportunity and attraction, natural and cultural amenities, accommodation and transportation, infrastructure, food, and friendly people, physical amenities and recreation activities, and nightlife and entertainment) [12].
This research figures out the similarities of images emphasized by different official webs. The official account of West Sumatera and Aceh's authority stressed more dimensions of natural and cultural amenities than other dimen-sions. Besides, both of them less stressed the dimension of accommodation and transportation. However, they highlighted some categories of each dimension differently. In the dimension of NCA, green scenery and cultural performance are highlighted in the West Sumatera authority account, while beach and mosque building is accentuated in Aceh authority account. Some studies confirmed that that scenery is a factor to increase destination attractiveness [84] [85] [86] [87]. Therefore, the prominence of green scenery in the visual content of official West Sumatera account supports those previous studies. Likewise, "beach" depicted remarkably in that of official Aceh tourism account is in line with the work of Pearce [51].
Dilley theorizes culture as the dimension of destination image that covers various elements (local history, art, and architecture, remains of an earlier civilization, old buildings, castles, museums, and art galleries, illustrations of local economic life) [52]. Similarly, the importance of culture within the context of destination image formation is found by various studies: exotic local custom [51], architecture/buildings, historical sites/museums [50] [35] [30], cultural sites [85]. The study results also support the previous study findings by which some categories of the theme of culture are highlighted, such as cultural performance, mosque building, and local daily life.
Both official authority accounts also represent different categories of SOA remarkably. Sports events are the most stressed category in the account of West Sumatera, while some festival events are underlined in the account of Aceh. Gearing et al. (1974) included these two categories into the social factor of image formation [50]. These study findings are in line with Echtner & Ritchie [35] and Hu & Ritchie [85] presenting that various festival events, including sports events and competition, are elements of destination attractiveness.
Additionally, food is more underlined by both official accounts than other categories distributed in the theme of IFP. Some scholars conceptualize food as the attractiveness of destination [35] [50] [85]. In line with this, some other studies notably showed the importance of local food in tourism [88] [89]. Meanwhile, the World Wide Web (WWW) also is used for food tourism marketing (Kim, Yuan, Goh, & Antun, 2009) [90]. Therefore, the prominent depiction of various local foods in both official accounts supports those previous studies.

Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.