Investigation of the Role of ABC Transporters in Pyrethroids Resistance in the Major Malaria Vector Anopheles coluzzii from Northern Nigeria

Resistance to currently available insecticides in the major malaria vectors like Anopheles coluzzii is seriously reducing the effectiveness of core vector control tools. Overexpression of ATP binding cassette transporters (ABC transporters) has been implicated in insecticides resistance in the major malaria vector Anopheles funestus and An. gambiae. To identify the potential role of ABC transporters in pyrethroids resistance in this work, we use verapamil-a p-glycoprotein inhibitor in a synergist bioassay with pyrethroids on one An. coluzzii populations from northern Nigeria. Genomic DNA extraction and SINE 200 PCR established that the Anopheles s. l. from Auyo, Jigawa State was An. coluzzii. Pre-exposure to verapamil followed by Permethrin results in 0.12% knockdown after 1 hour exposure and 10.7% mortality after 24 hours, which was higher than that for permethrin alone, but not statistically significant. This bioassay result reveals that ABC transporters possibly do not contribute to the resistance.


Introduction
Malaria is an infection caused by a parasite Plasmodium falciparum, and it's transmitted by the bite of female Anopheles mosquito which is the major malaria vector. Due to the lack of an effective vaccine, the fight against malaria relies mostly on chemotherapy and vector control [1].
However, resistance to currently available insecticide is seriously reducing the effectiveness of the vector control tools [2]. The trend in insecticides resistance is becoming alarming because after one half-decade in reduction in the burden and death due to malaria the progress achieved has leveled off, with the number of malaria-related deaths similar for the year 2015 and 2016 [3].
Insecticides resistance in malaria mosquitoes is mainly caused by two mechanisms 1) increased detoxification/clearance of the insecticides by overexpression and/or over activity of the major metabolising enzymes (cytochrome P450s, carboxylesterases, glutathione S-transferases, etc.); and 2) reduced sensitivity of the target of the insecticide due to point mutation (s), for example, the knockdown resistance (kdr) mutations conferring resistance to the voltage-gated sodium channel target of pyrethroids and DDT insecticides [4].
ABC transporters have been implicated in insecticides resistance in the major malaria vectors, exposure to ABC inhibitor verapamil synergizes the activity of insecticides in some malaria vectors. Over-expression of ABC transporter can protect insect against insecticide by protecting tissues. ABC-transporters are potential targets of inhibitors which could reduce resistance [5]. However, the role of ABC transporters in pyrethroids resistance in malaria vectors from northern Nigeria region is lacking and it needs to be established.

Sampling Site
The collection was carried out in Hadiyau, Auyo as shown in Figure 1   sucrose solution. In the next few days, these mosquitoes were made to oviposit, after laying eggs, the parent was taken for subsequent experiment and the eggs obtained were put into disposable cups containing water in order to obtain the larvae. The larvae were maintained in a deionized water and fed daily with Tetramin baby fish food. The emerging F 1 progenies were used for insect susceptibility bioassays.

c) Morphological Specie Identification
Mosquitoes were identified morphologically as An. gambiae s. l. complex species using the morphological identification keys [8].

Molecular Species Identification
Genomic DNA was extracted from the parental F 0 females using the LIVAK extraction protocol [9].
The species identity of the An. gambiae s. l. mosquitoes and the molecular forms of all the An. gambiae s. s. were determined according to the SINE PCR method [10]. Open Journal of Immunology [11]. Three replicates of 20 -25 females were first pre-exposed to verapamil for 1 hour and then transferred to tubes containing 0.75% permethrin. Insects were exposed to permethrin for 1hr counting knockdown at 5 min, 15 min, 30 min, 45 min and 1 hour. For first positive control, one tube of 20 females was exposed to permethrin alone without pre-exposure to verapamil. For second positive control, 20 females were exposed to 0.01% verapamil alone without exposure to permethrin. For control 20 females were placed in paper coated with Dow Corning oil plus ethanol with neither permethrin, nor verapamil. Following exposure, mosquitoes were then transferred to a holding tube as shown in Figure 2 and supplied with 10% sucrose solution and kept overnight under insectary conditions at 25% -28˚C and ~70% -80% humidity [7]. Mortality was recorded for each tube after 24 hours. Data were analysed using Microsoft Excel 2016 and Values are expressed in mean ± S.D.

Species and Molecular forms identification
Seven female An. gambiae s. l. mosquitoes collected from Auyo were analysed using SINE PCR method for species identification. All of them were An. coluzzii (formerly M form) as shown in Figure 3 because the PCR product of 479 bp was amplified [10]. Neither An. gambiae s. s. (formerly S form), nor An. arabiensis were detected.

Insecticide susceptibility bioassays
Adult female An. gambiae mosquitoes from Auyo that were used in conducting insecticide bioassay revealed high resistance to permethrin with only 0% knockdown after 1hr exposure ( Figure 4) and mortality of 8.7% after 24 hours ( Figure 5). However, pre-exposing mosquitoes to verapamil and followed by permethrin resulted in 0.12% knockdown after 1 hr exposure ( Figure 4) and 10.7% mortality after 24 hours ( Figure 5), which there is no difference between the groups. Also, mortality in all control groups was consistently 0% ( Figure 5).
No knockdown was seen when the mosquitoes were exposed to Ethanol + Dow corning oil (Figure 4) proving that the Dow corning oil and the ethanol were not toxic to the mosquitoes and any mortality should be due to presence of insecticide or verapamil Plus insecticide.

Discussion
From the result, no significant difference was seen between exposure to permethrin alone and pre-exposure to verapamil followed by permethrin. This indicates that ABC transporter may not be involved in the pyrethroid resistance in populations from Hadiyau, Auyo Northern Nigeria. In contrast, Joseph et al. 2016 [12] reported in An. gambiae s. l. collected from rice irrigation fields of Okyereko in Ghana, that An. coluzzii and An. gambiae s. s. expressed resistance to pyrethroids with less than 35% mortality. However, there is significant increase in mortality to permethrin after a pre-exposure to verapamil.

Conclusion
An. coluzii from Hadiyau is highly resistant to pyrethroid insecticide and this research work reveals that ABC transporters possibly do not contribute to the resistance. However, further research needs to be carried out with a larger number of mosquito populations from different places in northern Nigeria as well as transcriptional analyses to identify if ABC transporter is over expressed in the An. coluzii from northern Nigeria.