Quantification of Heavy Metal Accumulation in Edible Wild-Mushrooms in Copperbelt and Western Provinces of Zambia

The mushrooms are highly regarded as one of the most nutritious foods across the globe but also recognized bio-accumulators of heavy metals. The nature and level of industrial activities are continually changing and affecting the environment adversely. The mushrooms are not an exception and may inevitably have heavy metal contaminations. In this vein, this study aimed to determine heavy metal (Cu, Ni, Co, Zn, Pb, and Cd) uptake levels in wild edible mushrooms from the sites with different economic activities. The wild mushrooms considered for this study included Tente (Amanita Zambiana), Ichikolowa (Termitomyces Titaniscus), and Kabansa (Lactarius Tataniscus). The analysis of heavy metal concentration was carried out using atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS). For the selected mushrooms, concentration ranges (mg∙kg total dry weight (dw)) of 46.90 141.80 for Cu, 0.10 6.60 for Cd, 1.10 2.00 for Pb, 19.00 38.90 for Zn, 1.00 3.40 for Ni, and 44.80 79.70 for Co were obtained. However, for the respective soil samples, concentration ranges (mg∙kg∙dw) of 51.00 279.40 for Cu, 1.00 99.50 for Cd, 8.00 10.00 for Pb, 22.80 209.10 for Zn, 9.00 33.70 for Ni, and 60.00 111.90 for Co were obtained. To a certain degree, the concentrations reflected the impact of diversity in the surrounding activities. This study discovered that for the selected mushrooms, the contamination level of cadmium, cobalt, nickel, and copper exceeded the World Health Organization (WHO)/FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization) recommended limits. Although some minor aberrations from the prescribed limits were also observed in the case of copper and nickel. Further, the data established that the heavy metal concentrations in respective soils are not the sole determinant of concentrations in mushrooms. Thus, these findings merit attention as, in some cases, the extent of contamination has exceeded the WHO permissible limit, and it may pose a health risk to consumers. How to cite this paper: Singh, I.S. and Nyau, C. (2020) Quantification of Heavy Metal Accumulation in Edible Wild-Mushrooms in Copperbelt and Western Provinces of Zambia. Journal of Environmental Protection, 11, 1-12. https://doi.org/10.4236/jep.2020.111001 Received: October 20, 2019 Accepted: December 31, 2019 Published: January 3, 2020 Copyright © 2020 by author(s) and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY 4.0). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Open Access I. S. Singh, C. Nyau DOI: 10.4236/jep.2020.111001 2 Journal of Environmental Protection


Introduction
Perhaps never before, there has been as much thrust for healthy foods. In this vein, mushrooms are one of the few best selects. These are incredibly healthy food laden with nutritious dietary constituents but minimal calorie [1] [2] [3].
They are richly packed with a range of amino acids and vitamins, and also, have an abundance of proteins and fibers [4]. Remarkably, these edible fungi contain fat, which is predominantly composed of unsaturated fatty acids [5] [6]. Moreover, many of them have significant medicinal properties [7] [8].
However, mushrooms are infamous for accumulating heavy metals [9]. Many of the heavy metals are toxic to human health. For example, lead and cadmium have reportedly no health benefits to humans [10] [11]. A substantial fraction of inhaled or ingested lead is absorbed by the human system and primarily disseminated among blood and soft tissues subsequently [12]. Lead and cadmium are known to be amongst the most toxic metals. They adversely impact human health through neurotoxic and carcinogenic functions [13] [14] [15] [16] [17].
Further, Cadmium has also been reported to have an adverse effect on several vital human organs [14].
As far as cobalt is concerned, it is essential biochemically and also part of vitamin B-12. However, some studies have reported adverse cardiovascular effects caused by cobalt toxicity [18] [19]. For robust health, an adequate amount of zinc is critically essential. In effect, deficiencies in zinc may cause many diseases [20]. However, instances of acute and chronic zinc poisoning pertaining to the cellular system have also been reported [21].
Nickel happens to be yet another health-unfriendly metal. The exposure to nickel-polluted environments causes a range of pathological problems such as lungs and nasal cancers [22]. In the past, nickel was even branded as "Allergen of the Year" [23]. Copper is considered essential for good health, and it has also been reported that its intakes up to 6 -7 mg•Cu•day −1 are not linked with adverse effects on human health [24]. However, exposer to excessive levels may have adverse effects. In this context, a case is citable, where a severe liver disease was developed due to excessive intake of Cu [25].
The mushrooms are consumed worldwide, and Zambia is not an exception. It is common for the rural populace in tropical Africa to use edible and medicinal mushrooms for their survival and trade [26]. It is noteworthy that mushrooms have an interesting capability to fragment organic materials considerably and bio-accumulate heavy metals. They can be an instrument to estimate the degree of pollution [27]. However, the review paper [28] shows that it is difficult to single out any one mushroom species as an indicator of pollution level.  [27]. Further, some of these metals are significantly essential for living organisms, while some of them, such as cadmium and lead, are significantly toxic even in small amounts [29].
Because of fascinating attributes of mushrooms and their various preparations clubbed with well-established mushroom delicacies in many cultures of the

Sample Sites and Sample Size
The mushroom samples were collected from two randomly selected sites in clean carefully. The soil samples were collected simultaneously with that of mushrooms. Thus, a total of 15 soil samples were also collected corresponding to each mushroom. All the mushroom samples considered in this study were edible wild mushrooms grown naturally.

Sample Digestion and Analysis
After collection, each mushroom sample was individually cleaned with double distilled water. The flower parts of the mushroom samples for each species were cut into smaller pieces with a clean knife and placed in a labeled glass container.
These samples were then oven-dried at 105˚C overnight. The respective dried mushroom samples were thoroughly blended into the powdered form using a commercial blender.
All the chemicals and standards used in this study were analytical grade and procured from Inorganic Ventures (Christiansburg, VA 24073, USA). A 1.0 g sample of Powdered mushroom was added to a beaker containing 15 mL mixture of HNO 3 (70%), H 2 SO 4 (70%) and HClO 4 (65%) in a proportion of 5:1:1 and digested at 80˚C following the reported method [35] until the solution became transparent [36]. Subsequently, the solution was cooled down to room temperature and filtered through a Whatman No.42 filter paper. The filtrate was then diluted to 50 mL with double distilled water. The digestion of soil samples were also carried out following the same procedure as dried mushroom powders.
The concentration determination of lead, nickel, cobalt, cadmium, copper, and zinc in the diluted filtrate for mushroom and respective soil samples was carried out using an atomic absorption spectrophotometer (PerkinElmer Inc. -AAnalyst 200) and specific lamp for respective metal. The analysis was carried out at the Mining and Geological Laboratory at the Copperbelt University.
The necessary measures were taken to ascertain the correctness of the results.
In this vein, therefore, repetitive analysis of samples was carried out against the reference standards procured from Inorganic Ventures (Christiansburg, VA 24073, USA) for all the heavy metals considered in this study.

Results
The results of the mean concentration of heavy metals (Cu, Cd, Pb, Zn, Ni, and Co) in the samples of mushrooms from two study sites are stipulated in tables below in mg•kg −1 dry weight (dw). For all the mushroom samples, results were compared with FAO/WHO standard limits.

Mean Heavy Metal Concentration in Edible Mushroom Samples from Mpongwe
The heavy metal concentration analysis in mushroom samples from the Mpongwe area is stipulated in Table 1

Mean Heavy Metal Concentration in Edible Mushroom Samples from Solwezi
The heavy metal concentrations obtained in mushroom samples from Solwezi area are stipulated in Table 2 below.

Mean Heavy Metal Concentrations in Soil Samples Collected froms from Solwezi and Mpongwe
The heavy metal concentrations obtained in soils samples from Mpongwe and solwezi are stipulated Table 3 below.

Discussion of Results
The comparison between the heavy metal concentration in mushrooms and the corresponding soil samples do not show direct proportionality. For example, TET mushroom (Table 2) and corresponding soil sample (Table 3) from Solwezi have highest Cu concentration but AMZ from Solwezi (Table 2) does not have with lowest Cu concentration while the corresponding soil has the lowest Cu concentration (Table 3). Several other aberrations are observed with correlating the concentrations in mushrooms (Table 1 and Table 2) and respective soil samples. In a nutshell, there is no proportional relationship between the heavy metal concentration in the mushroom and corresponding soil.
The concentrations of Cu, Co, and Cd for mushroom samples from both Mpongwe (Table 1) and Solwezi (Table 2) were found to be higher than the WHO recommended limits. Notably, the extent of cadmium contamination in TET and LAT from both the sites has been significantly high and merits to be underlined. It warrants attention because cadmium reportedly affects many human organs [14]. However, the extent of Cd concentration in Mpongwe samples is much greater as compared to those from Solwezi. Intense agricultural activities characterize the Mpongwe site, and the higher concentration of Cd may be attributed to the extensive use of nitrogenous fertilizers. In this context, it has been reported [37] that nitrogen fertilizers increase Cd concentrations in soil. Although a mushroom species, namely Agaricus macrosporus have been reported [38] to have a much higher concentration of Cd in a study from Spain. Further, the Cd concentrations in soil samples in Mpongwe (Table 3) are not  higher than those in Solwezi soil samples (Table 3). These results further reinforce that the metal concentrations in mushrooms are not consistently dependent on the corresponding soil sample concentrations.
The Cu content (Table 1 and Table 2) is much higher than the reported range of 21.1 to 40 µg/g [39]. Some other workers have also reported similar results [32] [40]. Further, the Solwezi sample has the highest Cu concentration. The higher Cu concentration may be ascribed to the intensive copper mining in Solwezi. The concentration of Co (Table 1 and Table 2) is much higher as compared to some of the reported ranges of 0.28 -1.32 µg/g [41] and 0.15 -6.03 µg/g [42]. The higher concentration of Co may be attributed to extensive mining activities in Copperbelt and Western provinces of Zambia.
The Ni concentrations were found to be within the WHO recommended limits in all the samples from Solwezi (Table 2), but they exceeded in AMZ and LAT samples from Mpongwe (Table 1). A range of 1.19 -54.12 µg/g concentration has been reported [43]. The higher concentrations of Ni can be due to the agricultural activities in Mpongwe. It has been reported that fertilizer can be one of the significant sources of Ni into soils [44].
The Pb and Zn concentrations in all the mushroom samples from both Mpongwe (Table 1) and Solwezi ( -158 µg/g [42]. The findings of the study strongly support the fact that the heavy metal concentrations differ significantly with the species of mushrooms in the same sampling areas. For example, Cu concentrations in AMZ, TET, and LAT from Solwezi ( Generally, Cu concentrations are quite high (Figure 1 and Figure 2) as compared to many reported studies. The higher Cu Concentration can be attributed to the higher copper content in the soil in Zambia, which has vast Copper resources and is a country with intensive copper mining activities. The other variations in heavy metal concentrations for different samples may be due to the difference in geological location and because of the free drained soils and waste due to mining activities.
Although Pb and Zn are within the permissible range set by WHO, the higher concentrations of Cu, Ni, Co, and Cd are a matter of concern. The most worrisome is the higher concentrations of Cd as it is highly toxic even in trace   amounts [48] [49] [50]. Moreover, the agricultural products have access to global markets these days and may affect consumers across the globe. Therefore, it is essential to embark on measures to reduce bioavailable Cd to mitigate the problem. The alleviation measures may include the control of biosorption and bioavailable heavy metals in mushroom growing soils by reducing agricultural fertilizers and mining activities in the surroundings.

Conclusion
In conclusion, the concentrations of Cu, Cd, Co, and Ni in selected mushroom species were higher than the WHO recommended limits, while Pb and Zn concentrations were below the WHO set limits. The higher than acceptable concentrations are a matter of serious concern. The higher cadmium concentration may have a devastating health hazard. Therefore, corrective measures are warranted to reduce the contamination level to WHO suggested limits. The data of this study show that there is no consistent proportionality relationship between the heavy metal concentrations in a mushroom and corresponding soil sample. The findings are significant as they are reflective of the true picture of heavy metal contamination levels in some mushroom species and health implications to consumers. The study also entails the possible correlation between heavy metal concentration and type of economic activities such as farming and mining. Further, it may help consumers to select relatively safe species. This study strongly establishes the fact that different mushroom species have different biosorption efficiency for particular heavy metals. The relative concentration of heavy metal in differen mushroom species Amanita Termitomyces Lactarius