Energy Metabolism and Allocation in Selfish Immune System and Brain : A Beneficial Role of Insulin Resistance in Aging

There is relatively limited knowledge concerning our understanding of how our immune system and brain take most of the available energy in a selfish manner to compensate for their own needs on priority in high energy demanding situations. The main objective of this review is to understand the energy allocation to immune system and brain in infections and/or fight or flight situations. The immune system and brain behave in a selfish manner as they allocate themselves majority of the total available energy. Insulin resistance (IR) is used as a tool for energy allocation by these systems. The immune system is activated as a response to stress and infection. Similarly, the brain gets activated as a response to any external environmental impulse, anxiety, and/or mental factor. These situations need to be dealt in a way to minimize their adverse health effects. The immune system and the brain in such situations need enormous energy for activation which is derived from the energy quota otherwise allocated to other organs. This maximum flux of energy towards these systems is achieved by making rest of the organs less responsive to insulin, a condition known as IR. As immune system and brain do not depend upon insulin for uptake of glucose, these systems are benefited from IR. IR is indicated as a beneficial role ensuring maximum energy allocation to these systems for improving health and well-being.


Introduction
Energy metabolism (EM) is the main driver of life [1] [2] [3].One of the primary aims of human energy metabolism research is to explore the ways and mechanisms whereby the "energy balance (EB)" is ensured.EB is the relationship between "energy in" (food calories taken into the body through food and drink) and "energy out" (calories being used in the body for our daily energy requirements), which is closely related to a number of disorders, for example, obesity [4] [5] diabetes (Type II) [6] [7], hypertension [8], cardiovascular diseases (CVD) [9] [10], renal failure [11], and a wide array of immunological disorders [12].Over the past more than hundred years, this area has been particularly investigated using both animal models as well as human subjects [13] [14].Some other important research areas that have a close link with energy metabolism that have been extensively investigated are to (a) explore specific metabolic rates of major organs and tissues across the human life-span [15] (b) investigate energy allocation to various organs and tissues of the body [16] [17], and finally (c) investigate the factors that affect this complex network of energy metabolism [18].In this connection, aging [19] and IR [20] have been under particular focus of research as these two traits interlinked to each other affecting various metabolic pathways of EM.

Aging and Insulin Resistance Relationship in Immune System and Brain
Aging is the climax of natural phenomena as far as the extent of extraordinary physical and physiological changes are concerned.Age associated IR has been investigated and studied extensively.Some of the findings suggest that IR is found in many physiological and disease states.A few examples are diabetes mellitus [21] [22], obesity [23], sepsis [24], different types of arthritis (including rheumatoid arthritis) [25], systemic lupus erythematosus [26], ankylosing spondylitis [27], trauma [28], painful states such as postoperative pain [29], migraine [30], schizophrenia [31], major depression, and mental stress [32] [33].
Thus, IR seems to be not restricted to diabetes but is a common feature in great variety of disorders.When considering these diseases, one observes two major clusters of clinical entities that are linked to insulin resistance: 1) inflammation with an activated immune/repair system, and 2) increased mental activation.
At this point, it is important to understand the question how the overall background and pathophysiology of IR is related to disease clusters.Some theories have been presented in an effort to explain the phenomenon.These include the glucose-fatty acid cycle theory [34], thrifty genotype hypothesis [35], starvation-related insulin resistance, thrifty phenotype hypothesis [36], fight infections theory of insulin resistance, central nervous resistance model, breakdown of robustness theory [6], cellular pathogen-and nutrient-sensing pathway theory (metaflammation) [37] [38], and good calories-bad calories theory [6].However, none of these fully explain the two clusters [6].
While IR is most often regarded as a pathological state to be treated, these numbers and fact that IR is linked to so many disease states are indicative of a beneficial role of IR.It is utmost important to find an explanation why IR is an "all-time" phenomenon and a common attribute to many disease conditions that are non-diabetic in nature.Other questions of interest might be: whether IR is always a sign of abnormality?In what ways some organs (particularly those that do not depend upon insulin for glucose intake) benefit from IR? What happens if IR is acute or chronic?And finally, how does the human organism control its energy supply, particularly in the context of "aging"?The answers to these questions are the key to treating many diseases: obesity and the so-called metabolic syndrome with diabetes mellitus, hyperlipoproteinemia, hypertension and cardiovascular diseases belonging to these disorders.To answer some of these questions, relatively, a recent concept; the model of energy regulation has emerged [6], which suggests that central nervous system and the immune system are the two main areas which actually benefit from IR-related hyperglycemia because they do not become insulin-resistant.In addition, the immune system receives an added benefit from insulin because it is an important growth factor for leukocytes.IR-related hyperglycemia offers approximately 900 kJ (215 kcal) per 24 hours to the two systems.In this review we will discuss these new concepts with a focus of their possible implications in the context of aging.

Old Concepts New Meanings-Old Wine in New Bottles
There are always some old concepts with numerous new perspectives.The notion of physiological division of labor, for example, introduced in the 1820s by the French physiologist Henri Milne-Edwards, allowed to "compare and study living things as if they were machines created by the industry of man."Inspired in the work of Adam Smith, Milne-Edwards wrote that the "body of all living beings, whether animal or plant, resembles a factory-where the organs, comparable to workers, work incessantly to produce the phenomena that constitute the life of the individual."In more differentiated organisms, the functional labor could be apportioned between different instruments or systems (called by him as appareils) [39].
In a way, the organs and systems of the body are usually considered to behave within definite boundaries of their assigned physiological functions.In a conventional way, it has been a usual practice to designate certain physiological functions to certain body systems in a strict manner and lesser is attributed to other systems towards their possible contribution for the accomplishment of that particular function.The energy metabolism and its allocation and distribution have been a topic of great interest for researchers and biologists.There were certain beliefs about the organ systems that restricted their role(s) to a particular domain, and there were little or no consideration of the possible potential role of these systems to some other non-conventional domains of human physiology.
As an example, the immune system has been conceived to perform many func-DOI: 10.4236/fns.2019.101006 A. Almajwal et al.
tions for the human organism; most are of a defense nature and mainly concerning the protection of the body against foreign organisms, and maintenance of homeostasis by eliminating damaged cells.Not much, if any, have been thought of about the immune system in a non-conventional way of its functioning.A previously lesser investigated aspect of immune system was the regulation of energy metabolism; an area which seems too much diverse from the body defense.The "selfish immune system" and the "selfish brain" theories, however, came up with some new perspectives and possibilities of the potential roles of immune system and the central nervous system in the overall energy regulations.

Background
Selfish immune system is a theoretical concept recently articulated by Rainer Straub [6] with inspiration of "selfish brain theory".The "selfish immune system" and the "selfish brain" concepts put immune system and brain hierarchically above the rest of the organism in allocating energy/nutrition.Different organs have different energy needs (Table 1).For example, brain is of high energy consumption [40] [41], but of low energy capacity [42] [43].In addition, the brain also exhibits substrate specificity with the preference of lactate, ketones and glucose [44] [45].During the "fight-or-flight" response or trauma/infection, the organism vitally depends on either the immune system and thus these organs are privileged in energy allocation.

Immune System Energy Regulation and Allocation
Immune response is energetically a highly demanding process as activated immune/repair system required huge amounts of energy (25% -30% of the basal metabolic rate).For example, as previously reported [46]  put that expenditure in context, the same man requires 373 calories daily for his brain and 168 calories daily for his heart [50].Other immune activities that require energy include producing proteins and generating new immune cells in order to fight against infection [51].

Background
Brain also behaves in a selfish manner and allocates most of the energy for itself.
Brain is also a high energy consuming organ despite its relatively small mass.
According to the "Selfish Brain" theory, cerebral energy homeostasis has highest priority in human energy metabolism.The pathologist Marie Krieger was the first to provide evidence that the brain behaves in a "selfish" manner.She showed that the human brain mass is preserved during inanition, while all the organs of the body such as heart, liver, spleen, kidneys, and pancreas lose about 40% of their mass [52].Her seminal findings have been confirmed both in humans and animals in adult and fetal life by using modern state-of-the-art techniques [53]- [58].These observations provide clear evidence that the brain must actively demand energy from the body in order to maintain cerebral energy homeostasis.

Mechanisms for Energy Allocation and Regulation to Brain
In case of environmental stresses, the typical energy pathway resembles the sequence of events as shown in Figure 1.As elaborated by Peters et al., [58], brain regulates energy homeostasis via "brain-pull mechanisms", that function by demanding energy from the body.Two brain-pull mechanisms have been detected so far: first, allocative brain-pull mechanisms, which activate the stress system to favor glucose allocation to the brain, and, second, direct astrocytic brain-pull mechanisms, which enhance glucose transport through the blood-brain barrier.
The "body-pull functions" demand energy from the near environment by initiating ingestive behavior to replenish body stores and blood glucose concentra-

Sickness Behaviour as a Main Tool for Energy Allocation to Immune System and Brain
During infection, calories must be made available for the increased energetic demands of the immune system.How our immune system and brain make DOI: 10.4236/fns.2019.101006 A. Almajwal et al.
sure the supply of required energy to them in infections/stress has been partly explained by the pheonmena known as sickness behaviour [59] thus accompanying fever [60], lethargy, depression, anxiety, malaise, loss of appetite, sleepiness [61] [62] [63], hyperalgesia [64], reduction in grooming [65], and failure to concentrate [66].Sickness behavior is a motivational state that reorganizes the organism's priorities to cope with infectious pathogens [67].It has been suggested as relevant to understanding depression [66] and some aspects of the suffering that occurs in cancer [67].Sick animals and humans provide such calories with a dramatic decrease in activity caused by increased fatigue and decreased interest in pleasurable pursuits such as food, socializing, and sex [68].The responses of sleep and withdrawal that dominate sickness behavior conserve energy that is then available for use by the immune system.Sickness behavior is initiated by the host and not by the infectious agent; these changes can also be induced by experimental injection with a noninfectious substance that activates the immune system.Furthermore, this response has been conserved during evolution.Even caterpillars and crickets show decreased interest in food and courtship during infection [69].
An acute infectious disease can be self-limiting and involve an innate immune response of 2 to 3 days; the subsequent phase of the adaptive immune response infectious diseases [72].Acute self-limiting infectious diseases can be very energy consuming although, in the presence of disease-induced sickness behavior and related anorexia [73] [74].Intake of energy-rich substrates can be significantly inhibited.To explain these seemingly disparate observations, it can be proposed that sickness behavior represents an element of an adaptive program that has been positively selected for transient immune and inflammatory reactions to limit energy utilization for such activities as foraging and courtship behavior [65] [75].In such situation, the immune response can not last forever because energy stores run empty.Furthermore, sickness behavior can restrain activity and, for example, confine the affected individual to a safe place to keep away predators [65] [75].In considering energy stores available during these responses, it is important to note that storage occurs primarily in fat tissue (12 kg of triglycerides in the body of a contemporary person, 500,000 kJ), as well as in the liver (150 g glycogen, 2.500 kJ) or muscles (300 g glycogen, 5000 kJ; 6 -7 kg muscle protein, 50,000 kJ) [3] [76].Under conditions of sickness behavior and anorexia without uptake of energy-rich substrates but an increased sickness-related metabolic rate, the total amount of stored energy would only last for 19 to 43 days in females and 28 to

IR and Its Beneficiaries-The Immune System and Brain
The non-insulin-dependent tissues play a vital role in IR, which, as a result, increases circulating glucose (hyperglycemia) and free fatty acids (Figure 2).Energetic substances are not taken up in adipose tissue, liver, and muscle, and thus are now freely available to all non-insulin-dependent tissues.The two main profiteers of hyperglycemia are the central nervous system and the immune system.Both of these organs do not become insulin resistant.In contrast, the immune system profits from insulin because it is an important growth factor for leukocytes and, with the help of insulin, major glucose transporters like glucose transporter-3 and glucose transporter-4 are up regulated on all leukocyte subpopulations [77].Insulin resistance-related hyperglycemia offers approximately 900 kJ (215 kcal) per 24 hours to the two systems.While insulin resistance is most often regarded as a pathological state to be treated, these numbers and the fact that insulin resistance is linked to so many diseases and disease states are indicative of a beneficial role of insulin resistance.

Glucose Uptake and Insulin Resistance during Aging
Immune cells, upon activation, switch their metabolism to increased aerobic glycolysis to support rapid synthesis of macromolecules; this switch is associated with increased glucose consumption by immune cells.Increased aerobic glycolysis was originally described by Otto Warburg in cancer cells and it is now recognized as being common for proliferating cells [78] for example during development [79].According to Straub, IR, leading to lower consumption of glucose and hyperglycemia, is a physiological way for the brain or immune system to use energy/nutrition during acute stress from the rest of the organism because brain and immune cells themselves do not become insulin resistant.This is "wise-selfishness", because this selfish behaviour of the immune system or brain is for short time and subsides gradually.Chronic insulin resistance, caused by chronic inflammation or by chronic mental activation, on the other hand, is "foolish-selfishness" as it leads to various pathologies such as diabetes, obesity, metabolic syndrome or chronic inflammatory diseases.
As another example, inflammation is lifesaving when controlled and lasting for a short duration, but deadly when not.Danger appears to put the immune system on top in hierarchy, which overrides the "selfish brain".The longer inflammation lasts the more organs and substances are co-opted by the immune system.Chronic stress and low-grade inflammation can become immune suppressive [80], which in itself can be protective to prevent further damage.It's been found that Alzheimer's disease AD patients show a higher body temperature [81], but low brain metabolism and temperature, as you would expect when the body is inflamed, but the brain "disposed" of.On the contrary, healthy older people demonstrate lower body temperature and energy saving strategies like DOI: 10.4236/fns.2019.101006These organs cannot use glucose as a fuel in situations of IR.The reason is they need insulin for glucose uptake.The glucose made in the liver is mobilized to the brain and immune system.These organs can use glucose as they do not depend upon insulin for glucose uptake.slightly lower metabolism, but normal brain function.The same strategy used in all mammals and humans during calorie restriction [82].Whilst humans can't truly hibernate in the strict sense of the word, a number of parallels can be drawn.During the reduced physiological activity of torpor [83] animals showed Alzheimer-anatomy [84].But unlike humans, these changes disappear 72 hours after emerging.Persistent low-grade inflammation can produce a metabolically-induced hibernation [85] through reduced activity of the thyroid gland in order to conserve energy to divert to the immune system.If it is possible, then why AD develops because of an evolutionary conserved mammalian hibernation response that causes a low brain metabolic rate in order to put the immune system at rest?In this way, the pathways leading to AD, whilst pathological, are actually protective [86].

Final Words and Future Outlooks
The human brain and the immune system have become so important for human physiology and evolutionary fitness that both systems have developed selfish behaviours by their capabilities to pull on energy and other resources, with the solemn purpose to maintain their own anatomies and optimal functioning [17] [40] [58] [87] [88] and for the selfish immune system [6] [85].Upon challenge, an optimal human response therefore depends on the flexibility to (re)distribute energy, and thereby in first instance prevent energy conflicts between the brain and the immune system.The circadian rhythm, allowing the brain to dominate daytimes and the immune system to exploit night times, illustrates how evolution shaped collaboration between these two highly selfish systems, while avoiding conflict [46].The selfish behaviour of the immune system may, from a pathophysiological point of view, explain why lower gastrointestinal system (LGI) disturbs the functioning of many other organs, including the brain.LGI puts the immune system on top of hierarchic priorities as evidenced by the observation that the system even endorses breakdown of an essential muscle like the diaphragm.Based on these arguments and scientific facts, we may conclude that "foolish selfish" would mean pursuing the narrow self-interest in ways that will work for the immune system and brain but might later bring animosity toward the whole organism, while a "wise-selfish" would mean seeing that the well-being of the immune system and the brain lie in the welfare of all the rest of organs and system of the body.How these selfish behaviors of the immune system and brain can be exploited in old age.As we have previously reported that the aged are already having a malfunctioning in their energy metabolism and energy allocation mechanism [89], more prone to pro-inflammatory diets [90], disturbed by changes in their body composition [91] and have compromised immunity [92] [93] [94] [95].For example, old age develops defective responses to counteract low blood sugar, leaving them more exposed to the serious consequences of disabling hypoglycaemia.Age associated changes in the brain's ability to sense glucose may cause this defect.As a clear understanding of how the brain of the elderly regulate glucose may allow us to develop new and better treatments for age-associated abnormalities in glucose metabolism resulting in diseases like diabetes.It also raises some interesting questions.Is the rise in diabetes, the consequence of a selfish immune system or a selfish brain promoting glucose levels to cover their own high energy requirements?Is this similar to a selfish immune system or a selfish brain promoting hunger to cause obesity?Indeed, the parallel epidemics of obesity and diabetes may have a common origin in hypothalamic dysfunction.
In rodents, high fat diet consumption leads to defective hypothalamic glucose-sensing and hypothalamic inflammation, both of which lead to insulin resistance and glucose intolerance.So is the major form of diabetes, in fact, a disease of the immune system or the brain?The future research should also focus on the allocation of other nutritional resources.Whether the selfish immune DOI: 10.4236/fns.2019.101006 tions.In this connection, mechanisms driven by extracellular cerebral glucose, which is closely related to blood glucose, fulfill the function of exerting ingestive body-pull.Cerebral supply chain; The supply chain of the brain with the central nervous system as the final consumer; describes the energy fluxes from the remote environment to the near environment, through the body and finally toward the brain.The brain regulates energy homeostasis via brain-pull mechanisms of cerebral insulin suppression (CIS).With cerebral activation of the stress systems, energy particularly glucose is allocated to the brain.With activation of the sympathetic nervous system, insulin secretion from the beta cells is suppressed and the insulin-dependent glucose uptake into body periphery becomes limited.As a consequence of CIS, glucose is available via insulin-independent transport across the blood brain barrier.In this way, CIS can be interpreted as a brain-pull mechanism.DOI: 10.4236/fns.2019.101006 A. Almajwal et al.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Pathway of glucose metabolism.Generally glucose metabolism involves these main organs.They work in a close coordination to ensure steady supply of glucose to all organs of the body.The glucose metabolism takes place in these basic steps: (A).The hypothalamus senses the signals, (B) and then it influences the brain stem, (C) where the autonomous nervous system has its origination, (D) this in turn, controls liver glucose output, glucagon and insulin release.

can last approximately 3
to 4 weeks.Similarly, many transient inflammatory episodes include a healing phase that involves adaptive immune responses.The typical germinal center reaction of affinity maturation of B cells occurs for 3 to 4 weeks from the beginning to end [70] [71].The accompanying proliferative T cell response undergoes a similar time course.The response of the adaptive immune system with a maximum of proliferation until days 12 to 14 and subsequent contraction until days 21 to 28 is surprisingly constant in various acute

Figure 2 .
Figure2.Insulin resistance and energy allocation.In response to the external factors (stress, infections, fasting and/or famine) insulin resistance initiated.The liver and adipose tissues react to IR. Liver starts making glucose from its glycogen stores.Adipose tissues start making free fatty acids (FFA) as a result of lipolysis.The FFAs are mobilized to skeletal muscles, cardiac muscles and all other parts that use FFA for energy generation.These organs cannot use glucose as a fuel in situations of IR.The reason is they need insulin for glucose uptake.The glucose made in the liver is mobilized to the brain and immune system.These organs can use glucose as they do not depend upon insulin for glucose uptake.

Table 1 .
Fuel reserves in organs of a typical 70-kg man.