Materialism , Fashion Involvement , Fashion Innovativeness and Use Innovativeness : Exploring Direct and Indirect Relationships

The objective of the current study was to examine the direct and indirect impacts of materialism on use innovativeness in case of fashion products among Indian consumers. An empirical study was conducted to test these relationships with 282 respondents comprised of 59 percent males and 41 percent of females. Proposed conceptual study model was tested with the help of higher order structural equation modeling by using IBM AMOS 21.0. We confirmed full mediation of fashion involvement in the relationship between materialism and use innovativeness. Furthermore, our study results found full mediation of fashion innovativeness in the relationship between materialism and use innovativeness. On the other hand, materialism had a direct significant negative impact on use innovativeness in case of fashion products. We strongly recommend to the fashion product marketers to highlight the concept of use innovativeness in the entire marketing mix for better business prospects.


Introduction
Retail environment in the present scenario provides multiple options to the consumers across the globe for collecting information about various products from different sellers.This facility is adding to the shopping convenience and complete freedom in deciding what to purchase, where to purchase, and when to V. Gautam, V. Sharma DOI: 10.4236/tel.2018.8111582445 Theoretical Economics Letters purchase etc.The advent of internet has provided an additional retail channel to the customers.Retailers with multi-channel retaining strategies are adding into dimensions of consumer convenience and easy availability.This strategy is adding to the competitive advantage for a retailer.Multi-channel retailers are more successful and generating higher revenues as compared to single-channel retailers [1].According to indiaretailing.com[2], the retail market of India is expected to reach USD 1576 billion by 2026, growing at a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 10%.It is predicted that the current Indian fashion retail market will grow at a promising CAGR of 9.7 per cent to reach USD 115 billion by 2026.
In 1990s, the internet broadened the horizon of retailing for customers with the help of making availability of non-physical stores.Moreover, globalization has played a vital in creating interest among consumers about fashion products.
According to [3], globalization is bringing changes in societal aspects across countries.In addition, globalization is able to create awareness among consumers across all regions.Fashion products of one country are quite popular among consumers from different countries.The branding has really gone out of geographical boundaries.Now there are multinational brands available in all markets.According to [4], consumers are very much aware about multinational brands of fashion products.In case of individuals, brands are replica of personal image and we all associate ourselves with the brands.In society, desire to purchase specific brands is linked with self-image in societal context of individuals [5].
Consumer researchers have common understanding that values shape consumer behavior and consumption decision is derived out of it.A value that is catching up in India is materialism and it seems to be a very important factor of consumer behavior.Possession of high-end products like big houses, luxury cars, lavish lifestyles, branded clothes and accessories etc. is becoming a trend among Indian consumers.Humongous increase in credit card business and liberal thoughts about personal loans, car loans, home loans etc. are evidence for materialistic consumerism.
According to [6], an individual understands possession of materialistic products as a vehicle to communicate personal status to society.Materialism possibly

Materialism
Materialism can be related to possessions, social status and happiness of individuals [7].[8] defined materialism as "The importance a consumer attaches to worldly possessions".It can be understood as a bundle of interrelated traits, attitudes, and values that center on possessions [9].[10] posited materialism as a value.Moreover, [11] defined materialism as "The importance a person places on possessions and their acquisition as a necessary or desirable form of conduct to reach desired end states, including happiness".According to [12], materialism is "a set of attitudes which regard possessions as symbols of success, where possessions occupy a central part of life, which include holding the belief that more possessions lead to more happiness".
Past research found the materialistic consumers as; self-absorbed, self-gratifying, and purchase only branded goods and services [11] [13] [14].For materialistic consumers, happiness lies in possessing premium articles.Authors found three aspects of materialism such as; 1) the role of acquisition in happiness, 2) the role of possessions in defining success, 3) acquisition centrality.Possession of visible wealth and product consumption in public are used by materialistic consumers to boost their status [13].Authors further argued that demand for money-oriented possessions leads to higher degree of materialism, which subsequently create more demand for fashion products.The materialistic consumers show big concerns about their possessions of fashion products and get involved to a large extent with them.

Fashion Involvement
Fashion products focus on increasing self-image of an individual in a social set-up [15].These are considered as communicator of an individual in social space about his like and dislikes and also about personality and lifestyle.Clothing as a fashion product works as an aid to consumers in social adaptation and expression in public [16].Fashion is defined by [17] as "A form of collective behavior or a wave of social conformity".Individuals put efforts to enhance social self-image by judiciously selecting fashion products.Fashion orientation defines the lifestyle statement of an individual [18].[19] argued that materialistic individuals involve actively with products which communicate public meaning.According to [20], fashion product involvement includes 4 types of involvement namely; product, advertisement, purchase involvement and purchase decision involvement.Author found that all these involvement types are covering pre-purchase level to post-purchase level.Consequently there is high level of involvement on the consumer side.Later in 2013, [21] found that more involved consumers search very actively for additional information in order to become opinion leaders and induce product innovativeness.
Involvement is correlated with behavioral patterns of use in terms of volume and frequency [22].Author further found that in case of products with multi-functionality, volume and frequency are related with involvement and use innovativeness.[23] found positive relationship among involvement, innovativeness and usage variety.Variety seeking behavior of consumers makes them susceptible for broad range of innovativeness [24].Actually customers try to discover various ways of using fashion products in order to exhibit innovativeness.Hence fashion involvement is anticipated to be related to use innovativeness.
According to [25], a more involved consumer makes better decision with full confidence.Moreover, high fashion involved consumer attaches high importance for selecting and purchasing fashionable products in order to get best fit the individual personality.

Fashion Innovativeness
According to [26], fashion innovativeness is defined as "the degree of innovative propensity of individuals that affects the adoption and acceptance of new fashion products and related services".Fashion innovativeness is a basic characteristic of an individual, which is exhibited by actions of readiness towards new as well as uncommon products [27].[28] identified two predictors of fashion innovativeness such as; trend involvement, clothing involvement.Therefore, fashion involvement is expected to have relationship with fashion innovativeness.
As per the diffusion of innovation theory, innovative consumers adopt the latest fashion trends at the very early stage and express their innovative behavior with the help of many actions in different situations [29].These early fashion adopters develop innovativeness because of their psychological attributes.[30] developed the use innovativeness model and confirmed the influence of inherent innovativeness on fashion innovativeness as well as on use innovativeness.
Hence, there are high chances of interrelationships between fashion innovativeness and use innovativeness.Fashion innovativeness is related with buying behaviors of consumers and use innovativeness comes into picture after a fashion product is bought.There exists a visible sequence between fashion and use in-Theoretical Economics Letters novativeness.Therefore, fashion innovativeness is expected to pave the way to use innovativeness.

Use Innovativeness
According to [31], use innovativeness concept got its origin from the intuitive and progressive use propensity of an individual in order to keep it suitable for future consumption also.Use innovativeness doesn't deal with misuse of product, but it focuses on how innovatively and numerously a product is serving needs of the consumers [32].Authors further argued that use innovativeness doesn't deal with crises management, but it highlights the enjoyable behavior of users while using the existing products in a very fresh manner.Innovativeness adds a positive impact in case of a consumer groups who use products in a variety of ways [24].In the literature, it has been argued that in case of fashion products, use innovativeness takes care of variety in usage, whereas in case of consumable products, it deals with creative consumption.Creativity is understood in the literature as focusing on functional value of the product and honest consumption practice.Creativity in case of fashion products deals with using different fashion items and accessories in such a manner that it conveys style quotient and at the same time it maintains variety.Therefore, a high level of use innovativeness is also likely to persuade the increased use of available products in multiple ways and manners (Figure 1).

Research Methodology
In order to investigate the proposed relationships among study constructs such as; materialism, fashion involvement (product and purchase decision involvement), fashion innovativeness, use innovativeness, primary data were collected by using field survey method with the help of a research instrument (structured questionnaire with close-ended questions).The major focus of the indicators or statements used in questionnaire was to understand perception of consumers about materialism, fashion involvement, fashion and use innovativeness.

Sampling Design and Data Collection
The population under study included consumers residing in National Capital Region (NCR) of India.NCR consists of Delhi (Capital of India), Gurugram, NOIDA, Faridabad, Ghaziabad, Meerut.This region attracts people from all over India.We can witness people from all corners of India staying here at NCR.
Survey administration in such area provided us an added advantage as our sample got diverse set of respondents, representing various parts of India.We used purposive sampling method to collect primary data for the study.
We have collected 303 duly filled questionnaires from the target respondents.
After removal of incomplete questionnaires (21)

Data Analysis
After collection and preparation of study data, we analyzed it to meet the objectives of the study and draw meaning insights.

Reliability Analysis
According to [39], in order to pass the test of reliability for measurement scales, the reliability coefficient (Cronbach's alpha) should be greater than 0.70.It can be seen from Table 2 that all Cronbach's alpha values range from 0.763 to 0.972.
Hence the measurement scales of the current study pass the test of reliability (Figure 2).
This study had one second order construct namely fashion involvement and three other first order constructs.The Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) model with these 4 constructs had a total of 110 distinct parameters and 630 distinct sample moments.During model estimation, a minimum was achieved with Chi-Square value 904.014 (DF = 520, p < 0.000).All the parameters of the given study were practicable and standard errors in acceptable limits.Statistical significance of parameter estimates was established as test-statistic (t-value) in each case was greater than threshold limit of 2.58 (5 percent significance level).
It can be seen from Table 3 that all absolute fit indices and comparative fit indices are meeting their threshold levels [41] [42].Hence measurement model of the study is confirmed.

Convergent and Discriminant Validity
In order to generalize sample results for entire population under study, it is very important to pass the test of construct validity.According to [40], construct validity can be tested through convergent and Discriminant validity.Construct validity can be achieved if Composite Reliability (CR) of all study constructs reaches or crosses the threshold of 0.70 and Average Variance Explained (AVE) should be a minimum of 0.50.
In case of Discriminant validity, the AVE should be greater than Maximum Shared Variance (MSV) or AVE should be greater than Average Shared Variance (ASV) or ASV should be greater than MSV, and the square root of AVE should be greater than correlation among the constructs under consideration [40] [43].
It is quite evident from Table 4 that Composite Reliability (CR) and Average Variance Explained (AVE) in case of all 4 study constructs met the desired criteria.

Structural Equation Modeling Results
It is evident from Table 5 that the direct impact of materialism on use innovativeness is negative and significant (β = −0.427,p = 0.007).Further, materialism positively impacts fashion involvement (β = 0.783, p < 0.000).We also found positive and significant impact of materialism on fashion innovativeness (β = 0.744, p < 0.000).Study results confirmed significant positive impact of fashion involvement on use innovativeness (β = 0.297, p < 0.000).Additionally, we found significant positive impact of fashion innovativeness on use innovativeness (β = 0.9781, p < 0.000).
[44] suggested the steps to conduct mediation analysis by using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with IBM AMOS.
The following 4 steps were followed: 1 st Step: Firstly, path coefficient with p-value was calculated for direct relationship between Materialism (Predictor Variable) and Use Innovativeness (Dependent Variable) was calculated 2 nd Step: Secondly, path coefficient with p-value was calculated for direct relationship between Materialism (Predictor Variable) and Use Innovativeness (Dependent Variable) with inclusion of fashion involvement as mediating variable.
3 rd Step: Thirdly, path coefficient with p-value for indirect relationship was checked with the help of bootstrapping (standardized indirect path coefficient with confidence interval) to decide about no, partial or full mediation.

th
Step: The same above 3 steps were followed for second mediating variable.
It can be seen from Table 6 that fashion involvement fully mediates (β = 0.158, p = 0.010) the path between materialism and use innovativeness.Further, it is also evident that fashion innovativeness mediates fully (β = 0.589, p = 0.010) the path between materialism and use innovativeness.

Conclusion and Implications of the Study
The results of the current study revealed the direct and indirect relationships of materialism with use innovativeness.Specifically, the mediating role of fashion product involvement in explaining use innovativeness is strongly supported.The hypothesis test clearly indicated that materialistic consumers do not go for use Theoretical Economics Letters Further, we found significant positive impact of fashion involvement on use innovativeness.This indicates that consumers who are involved with reference to product and purchase decision express innovativeness in the use of the fashion products.On the other hand, our study model confirmed significant positive impact of fashion innovativeness on use innovativeness.This tells that fashion innovators devise various ways of innovativeness while using the fashion products.Similarly our model found positive significant impacts of materialism on fashion involvement and fashion innovativeness.
Another very interesting relationship we found in our model was full mediating impacts of fashion involvement and fashion innovativeness in the relationships between materialism and use innovativeness.This finding in our model is vital especially when path from materialism to use innovativeness through fashion involvement and fashion innovativeness became insignificant.This highlights a very interesting aspect of consumer psychology that materialistic consumers exhibit use innovativeness in case of involvement and innovativeness in fashion products.
Based on findings of our research, a few academic implications can be proposed.In consumer research literature, majority of the researchers focused on purchase intentions and purchase decision.The post-purchase phase has not been highlighted to that extent.These findings make significant academic contribution in the area of post-purchase behavior of consumers.Taking cue from this research, scholars can think of using some new variables in their research works to get valuable insights about consumer characteristics.Other aspect our study highlighted that materialistic consumers exhibit different use innovativeness in case of fashion products with reference to involvement and purchase decision.This research contributes to the empirical research on the theme of role of materialism on use innovativeness in case of fashion products directly and indirectly through fashion involvement and innovativeness.

Limitations and Future Scope of the Study
Some boundaries may be appropriate when we generalize the results of this research due to the cross-sectional data collected from one geographical area.Future studies with broader samples with diverse demography and geography must be conducted to widen the generalizability and validation of the model with some additional constructs in order to better understand the purchase intentions of the consumers.Life cycle of the product has shortened in the current market conditions due to swift changes in tastes and preferences of consumers.This trend has convinced consumers to restrict usage of a fashion product for a short duration.As a result, innovativeness in use of different fashion products has come out a big research area for the scholars in the area of consumer psychology.Short life cycle of products also contributes towards environmental and health hazards due to wastage creation during new product production process.
Hence product involvement and also product purchase-process involvement are
To fill the gap in the consumer behavior literature, this study intends to assess the impact of materialism on fashion product purchase, fashion innovativeness and perceived use innovativeness.The contribution of this study will be twofold, firstly it will contribute to the body of literature for fashion will, therefore, symbolize a main indicator of a consumer's association with goods and services that consent to the fulfillment of such values and support in depicting adequate illustrations.During the last few decades, India has witnessed considerable socio-politicaleconomic changes.Indian consumers have developed strong aspirations for fashion products to be at par with global trends.Low income Indian consumers purchase fashion products to satisfy social needs rather individual needs.With this background of huge potential of this market, the important reasons associated with Indian consumers' attitude towards buying fashion products need to be investigated in order to develop the general understanding of the upcoming market and formulate suitable marketing strategies that would augment success V. Gautam, V. Sharma DOI: 10.4236/tel.2018.8111582446 Theoretical Economics Letters of the sector.

Table 1 .
The analysis includes general sample description, Cronbach's alpha to assess reliability of the research instrument, General sample description.
Source: Author compilation.

Table 2 .
Reliability analysis results.
Source: Author compilation.

Table 4 .
Convergent and discriminant validity results.Hence convergent validity is established.Moreover, AVE is greater than Maximum Shared Variance (MSV) or AVE is greater than Average Shared Variance (ASV) or ASV is greater than MSV, and the square root of AVE is greater than correlation among the study constructs.Therefore, following the criteria rec- Source: Author compilation.Theoretical Economics Letters