Bromination of Pd Compounds during Thermal Decomposition of Tetrabromobisphenol A

We conducted thermal tests using the reagent tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) and various Pd compounds to study the chemical forms of Pd obtained during the pyrolytic and oxidative decomposition of TBBPA. Thermal testing was conducted in an electric furnace at temperatures of 280 ̊C 800 ̊C in an Ar or Ar-O2 (5%) atmosphere for a heating period of 40 min. Scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy results revealed that Pd bromide was formed in the mixture of TBBPA and PdO after heating to 450 ̊C in the Ar atmosphere. In addition, thermogravimetry-differential thermal analysis showed that as the heating temperature was increased from 350 ̊C to 730 ̊C, weight loss occurred at a nearly constant rate, indicating that Pd bromide decomposed in this temperature range.


Introduction
Small electronic devices including mobile phones, laptop, digital cameras, and game consoles are essential in our daily lives, and the demand for these products is projected to increase.The increasing demand for small electronics will also lead to an increase in the generation of waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE).Approximately 4500 tonnes of WEEE is produced annually [1], and this quantity is projected to increase as developing countries grow.
Circuit boards in WEEE are highly valuable, since they contain metals including Cu, Ag, Au, and Pd [2] [3] [4].Several metal recovery methods have been proposed, including pyrometallurgy [5], hydrometallurgy [6] [7] [8], bio-technology [4] [9], and supercritical [10] [11] and high-voltage electrical pulse methods [12].In particular, pyrometallurgy has been commercialised because of its potential for processing large volumes of materials [5].From the perspective of metal quality, waste circuit boards rank higher than ores [13] and are suitable for recycling.However, they also contain flame retardants, which not only damage the equipment because of the halogens present within but also adversely affect metal recovery rates.Commonly used flame retardants include high impact polystyrene, acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene, and tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA), with TBBPA being the most widely used.
The principal decomposition component in the thermolysis and pyrolysis of TBBPA is HBr [8] [14]; however, many organic compounds such as phenols and bromophenols are also formed [14]- [20].The formation pathways [21] of polybrominated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans are still being studied.
Halogens are considered as aversive substances in metal recovery processes, with chloride volatilisation as an example of its positive use.By exploiting the chlorination reaction of metals [22] [23] [24], metal recovery can be in an energy-efficient manner; similarly, the bromination reaction of metals [25] can also be used.Basic information regarding the bromination reaction of metals is needed to increase the rate of metal recovery from waste circuit boards and prevent unintentional loss, and studies have been conducted using thermodynamic calculations [26].Experimental quantitative analysis regarding the bromination behaviour of Zn has been conducted through thermal testing of samples containing ZnO and TBBPA [27] [28] [29].Similar studies have been conducted for many other metals including PbO [30] [31], Fe 2 O 3 [31], Sb 2 O 3 [32], Cu [8], Ag [8], Au [8], and electric arc furnace dust [33].
In this study, we prepared samples and conducted thermal tests to study the chemical forms of metals observed during the thermal decomposition and combustion of TBBPA.Mixtures of TBBPA and Pd were prepared, and the TBBPA decomposition behaviour was studied by analysing the C and Br concentrations in solid samples and HBr emissions in the exhaust gas after thermal testing.Investigation of the chemical forms of Pd was primarily based on the results of crystal structure analysis using X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) elemental mapping images.

Samples
The reagents Pd, PdO, PdBr this study, the two prepared mixtures were referred to as Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA.

Thermogravimetry-Differential Thermal Analysis Measurements
Thermogravimetry-differential thermal analysis (TG-DTA) measurements of the sample mixtures were also performed (Rigaku Co., Ltd.Thermo Plus TG 8120 analyser).First, a 10 mg sample was packed in a 2.5-mm-diameter alumina boat and heated from room temperature to 1000˚C at a rate of 10˚C/min under a He or an Ar-O 2 (5 mol%) environment at 100 mL/min.

Thermal Testing in Electric Furnace
Figure 1 shows the schematic of the thermal testing equipment.Briefly, 2 g of each sample (4 granular samples) was packed in an alumina boat and placed at the end of a quartz reaction tube.Simultaneously, gas was passed through the reaction tube, and the electric furnace (Koyo Thermo Systems Co. Ltd.KTF 035N) was heated to a given temperature.Once the rising temperature process was completed, the alumina boat was moved to the centre of the reaction tube and heated for 40 min.The heating temperature was set at 280-800˚C, the gas used was Ar or Ar-O 2 (5 mol%), and the gas flow rate was set to 100 mL/min.
The exhaust gases emitted during the thermal test were collected in scrubbed bottles filled with 100 mL ultra-pure water and hexane.

Quantification of Pd, Br, and C in Solid Samples
After the thermal testing, the granular samples were pulverised using an agate mortar.Subsequently, 0.1 g of the pulverised sample and 20 mL of aqua regia were placed in a Teflon container and sealed for dissolution by microwave radiation (Analytic Jena Co., Ltd.TOPwave).Table 1 lists the sample decomposition conditions.Once dissolved, the sample was filtered, and the filtrate was diluted to 100 mL, following which Pd was quantified by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (Perkin Elmer Co., Ltd.ELAN DRC-e).
Quantification of Br and C in the solid samples was performed using an organic halogen sulphur analysis system (Yanaco Co., Ltd.YHS-11) and a micro-corder (J-Science Lab Co., Ltd.JM10), respectively.

HBr Quantification
After the thermal testing, the reaction tube was rinsed with ultra-pure water.Furthermore, the quartz wool was cleaned for 1 h under ultrasonication in ultra-pure water.These cleaning fluids and ultra-pure water from the gas-scrubing bottles were filtered and diluted to 200 mL for subsequent analysis.The Br in the solution was quantified using ion chromatography (Dionex Co., Ltd.DX-120) and converted into HBr.

Crystal Structure Analysis
The crystal structure of the solid samples was determined by XRD (Bruker Co., Ltd.D8 ADVANCE/L).Table 2 lists the XRD measurement conditions.

Elemental Mapping
Elemental mapping images of the sample surface were obtained using field-emission SEM-EDS (JEOL Co., Ltd.JSM 7100F).In preparation for the SEM observations, a cross-section polisher was used to apply an Ar-ion beam sputter to the sample surface and expose the particle cross-sections.

Analysis of Pyrolytic and Oxidative Decomposition
Figure 2 shows the TG curves of the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples and of the reagents PdO, PdBr      Pd.The residual rates of C in the solid samples decreased with increasing temperature and the values were 89.3%, 44.3%, and 25.5% at 280˚C, 450˚C, and 780˚C, respectively.For Br, the residual rate was 96.1% at 280˚C, which decreased to 0.49% at 450˚C, and by 780˚C, Br had completely volatilised.
For the PdO + TBBPA sample, 13.0% Br residual content was observed at 450˚C, which was higher than the 0.49% content observed in the Pd + TBBPA sample.The Br volatilisation rate slowed down because of the presence of PdO, and it was surmised that decomposition occurred after Pd bromide was produced.
2) Ar-O 2 atmosphere Pd, C, and Br balances before and after heating are shown in Figure 6(a) for the Pd + TBBPA sample and in Figure 6(b) for the PdO + TBBPA sample.The Br volatilisation rate in the Pd + TBBPA sample at 280˚C was significantly higher than that in the Ar atmosphere.No other atmospheric-induced differences were observed.

TBBPA to HBr Conversion Ratio 1) Ar atmosphere
Figure 7 shows the relationship between the heating temperature of the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples and their respective HBr conversion rates.
The HBr conversion rate of the Pd + TBBPA sample was 2.5% at 280˚C and increased to 24.7% at 450˚C.Because all Br in the solid sample volatilised at 450˚C, it was believed that HBr represented 25% of the chemical form of bromine, with the remainder occurring as Br 2 or organ bromide compounds.The HBr conversion rate was 25.6% at 780˚C, nearly identical to that at 450˚C.The HBr conversion rate in the PdO + TBBPA sample at 280˚C was low (0.7%), similar to that of the Pd + TBBPA sample.However, not only were the rates higher than those for the Pd + TBBPA sample, 63.7% at 450˚C and 72.7% at 800˚C, but they increased as a function of temperature.This indicated that TBBPA thermal decomposition differed substantially in the presence of Pd and PdO.  2) Ar-O 2 atmosphere Figure 8 shows the relationship between heating temperatures of the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples and their respective HBr conversion rates.
The HBr conversion rates for the Pd + TBBPA sample were 1.4% and 30.7% at 280 and 450˚C, respectively.The rate substantially increased to 67.2% at 780˚C (nearly twice) in an inert atmosphere.This indicated that when Pd was present, oxygen in the atmosphere promoted HBr conversion in TBBPA.
The HBr conversion rates in the PdO + TBBPA sample were 51.6% and 57.4% at 450 and 800˚C, respectively, with higher values in the inert atmosphere under identical temperature conditions.When PdO was present, HBr conversion rates were lower than that in the inert atmosphere at temperatures greater than 450˚C due to the presence of oxygen, and the impact on Br 2 production was likely substantial.PdO + TBBPA samples, respectively.For the Pd + TBBPA sample, at 280˚C, in addition to a clear Pd peak, peaks arising from TBBPA and its decomposition products were observed in the 2θ range 10.4˚ -38.3˚.However, at 450˚C and higher, only Pd peaks were detected.

Crystal Structure Analysis
For the PdO + TBBPA sample, at 280˚C, peaks originating from TBBPA decomposition products could be observed at 2θ = 14.0˚ and 22.7˚ -24.1˚.Furthermore, both PdO and Pd peaks were detected.Since the thermal decomposition of PdO to Pd occurred at 750˚C or higher (Figure 2), PdO reduction reactions with TBBPA decomposition products occurred.The PdO peaks disappeared at 450˚C and 800˚C, and only Pd peaks could be confirmed.For the PdO + TBBPA sample, at 280˚C, no significant difference with respect to the Pd + TBBPA sample was observed in the Pd and Br mapping images.
However, in addition to the comparatively high concentration of Br (7.3%) at 450˚C, partial overlap of Pd and Br was observed.This suggested that Pd bromide compounds were present, and that Pd bromination reactions occurred between 280˚C and 450˚C.As shown in the TG curves (Figure 2), weight loss occurred at a nearly constant rate between 350˚C and 730˚C, which was likely caused by bromide decomposition.This was confirmed by the absence of Br at 800˚C and the sole presence of Pd.

Conclusions
In this study, thermal testing of TBBPA and Pd/PdO mixtures (Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA) was conducted to study the chemical form of Pd obtained during TBBPA pyrolytic and oxidative decomposition and combustion.
In the pyrolytic test of the Pd + TBBPA sample, Pd bromination did not occur.Furthermore, Pd primarily existed as a metal, regardless of the temperature conditions or the presence of oxygen.In the PdO + TBBPA sample, SEM-EDS indicated that Pd bromide was present in the solid samples obtained in an Ar atmosphere at 450˚C.The absence of Pd bromide at 280˚C suggested that the bromination reaction occurred at 280˚C -450˚C.Weight loss occurred at an almost constant rate, as indicated by TG-DTA, between 350˚C and 730˚C, indicating that Pd bromide decomposed in this temperature range.
2 , and TBBPA (C 15 H 12 Br 4 O 2 ) were used to prepare the test samples.Sample mixtures of Pd and TBBPA and PdO and TBBPA were prepared in weight ratios of Pd:TBBPA 1:10.22 and PdO:TBBPA 1:8.89, respectively, and were subjected to thermal testing in an electric furnace.Granular samples were fabricated by subjecting the pulverised mixtures to a pressure of 12 MPa for 30 min to form shapes with dimensions of φ = 5 mm and h = 21 mm.In S. Kuzuhara, A. Sano DOI: 10.4236/eng.2018.104013189 Engineering range.The total weight loss at 730˚C was 70.3%, almost identical to that of the Pd + TBBPA sample.

Figure 3 Figure 4 . 3 . 2 . Pd Bromination Accompanying TBBPA Decomposition 3 . 2 . 1 .Figure 3 .
Figure3shows the TG curves of the Pd + TBBPA sample in Ar-O 2 and He atmospheres, and the same comparison is made for the PdO + TBBPA sample in Figure4.The TG curves for the Pd + TBBPA sample were nearly identical, and no major atmospheric-induced differences were observed.In addition, the TG curves were consistent for the PdO + TBBPA sample up to 470˚C.Subsequently, the mass of the sample gradually decreased until 730˚C in the He atmosphere and rapidly decreased until 590˚C in the Ar-O 2 atmosphere, and remained nearly constant afterwards, although slight rises and falls were observed.3.2.Pd Bromination Accompanying TBBPA Decomposition3.2.1.Solid/Gas Distribution of Pd, Br, and C1) Ar atmosphereThe mass balance of Pd, C, and Br before and after heating is shown in Figure5(a) for the Pd + TBBPA sample and in Figure5(b) for the PdO + TBBPA sample.For the Pd + TBBPA sample, Pd volatilisation through heating was not observed.Considering the TG results (Figure2) and the initial Pd content of 28 wt%, it could be inferred that the main residue in the sample at temperatures over 690˚C was Pd.However, the balance of C and Br was different from that of

Figure 4 .
Figure 4. TG curves of PdO + TBBPA sample in Ar-O 2 and He atmospheres.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. Pd, C, and Br mass balances before and after heating for (a) Pd + TBBPA and (b) PdO + TBBPA samples in Ar atmosphere.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Pd, C, and Br mass balances before and after heating for (a) Pd + TBBPA and (b) PdO + TBBPA samples in Ar-O 2 atmosphere.

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. Pd, C, and Br mass balances before and after heating for (a) Pd + TBBPA and (b) PdO + TBBPA samples in Ar-O 2 atmosphere.

Figure 9
Figure 9(a) and Figure 9(b) show the XRD patterns for the Pd + TBBPA and

Figure 8 .
Figure 8. Relation between heating temperature and HBr conversion rate in Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples in Ar-O 2 atmosphere.

Figure 10 ( 3 . 2 . 4 .
Figure 10(a) and Figure 10(b) show the XRD patterns for the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples, respectively.The peaks originating from the TBBPA decomposition products and Pd were observed for the Pd + TBBPA sample at 280˚C.Similar to observations in the Ar atmosphere, only Pd peaks were detected at 450 or 780˚C.The XRD patterns of the PdO + TBBPA samplewere similar to those obtained in the Ar atmosphere, and no significant atmospheric-induced differences were observed in terms of the chemical form of Pd.3.2.4.Pd and Br Elemental Mapping1) Ar Atmosphere

Figure 11 (
Figure 11(a) and Figure 11(b) show the SEM images and Pd and Br elemental mapping of the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples, respectively, before and after heating.Table3lists the semi-quantitative analysis results for Pd and Br obtained by SEM-EDS.The presence of Pd and Br was clearly confirmed in the Pd + TBBPA sample before heating and at 280˚C, although the images did not perfectly overlap.Br was believed to exist primarily in the form of an organic compound, which was consistent with the XRD results (Figure9(a)).However, only Pd was observed at temperatures greater than 450˚C.

Figure 12 (
Figure 12(a) and Figure 12(b) show the SEM images and Pd and Br elemental mapping images of the Pd + TBBPA and PdO + TBBPA samples, respectively, before and after heating.Table 4 lists the semi-quantitative analysis results

Figure 11 .
Figure 11.SEM images and Pd/Br elemental mapping images before and after heating for (a) Pd + TBBPA and (b) PdO + TBBPA in Ar atmosphere.

Figure 12 .
Figure 12.SEM images and Pd/Br elemental mapping images before and after heating for (a) Pd + TBBPA and (b) PdO + TBBPA in Ar-O 2 atmosphere.

Table 1 .
Sample decomposition process conditions-microwave decomposition equipment.
2, and TBBPA in a He atmosphere.At 200˚C, rapid weight loss was observed for the Pd + TBBPA sample, with the weight loss rate reaching 64% at 310˚C.Since this weight loss behaviour was virtually identical to that of TBBPA in this temperature range, it was believed that TBBPA voloss occurred at a nearly constant rate, differing substantially from the behaviour of the Pd + TBBPA sample.Furthermore, this weight loss behaviour did not correspond to those of the other two reagents (PdO and PdBr 2 ) in this

Table 4
lists the semi-quantitative analysis results for Pd and Br obtained by SEM-EDS.Similar to the results in the Ar atmosphere, Pd and Br were present at 280˚C, although the mapping images did not overlap.Furthermore, no Br was observed at 450˚C or 780˚C.

Table 3 .
Semi-quantitative analysis results for Pd and Br concentrations using SEM-EDS in Ar atmosphere.Although Pd and Br were present up to 280˚C in the PdO + TBBPA sample, no overlap of the mapping images was observed.The Br concentration was 5.0% at 450˚C, but no areas were observed with a clear overlap of Pd and Br mapping images.As in the inert atmosphere, only Pd was detected at 800˚C.

Table 4 .
Semi-quantitative analysis results for Pd and Br concentrations using SEM-EDS in Ar-O 2 atmosphere.