Stability and Hydration/Dehydration Mechanisms of a Carboxylate-Containing Metal-Organic Framework

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising functional compounds; however, they are known to be moisture sensitive. Here, we investigate the hydration and dehydration processes of the carboxylate-containing MOFs [Ni 2 (nic) 4 (H 2 O)] n (nic = nicotinic acid) and the mononuclear complex [Ni(nic) 2 (H 2 O) 4 ], respectively. X-ray single crystal diffraction reveals that the hydrogen bonds between water and carboxylic oxygen play a key role in these processes. Molecular-level mechanisms of reversible hydration and dehydration are proposed, based on the competition between water and carboxylic oxygen for coordination with Ni. This study provides important information for future studies on the hydrolytic stability of MOFs in moisture. coordination, and the hydration and dehydration reactions are reversible.

Nevertheless, the relatively poor stability of MOFs in moisture has severely limited their industrial applications. Under isolated conditions, they are thermally stable at 350˚C -400˚C, which meets the requirements of most applications. However, water adsorption may degrade their structural ordering and stability, as hydration causes the carboxylic groups coordinated to the metallic core to detach in these materials [17] [18] [19].
For this reason, improvements in the hydrolytic stability of MOFs are urgently needed. Indeed, the stability of MOFs in water has been widely studied [20]- [31], and significant progress in structural stability has been achieved by theoretical and experimental means. For instance, the introduction of hydrophobic groups (e.g., −CH 3 and −OCH 3 ) is an effective way to improve the framework stability of MOFs, because the hydrophobicity and steric hindrance of the substituent groups can separate the coordinatively unsaturated metal ions from water molecules [32] [33] [34]. Therefore, considerable efforts have been made to understand the relationship between the structure of MOFs and their water stability, in order to synthesise more moisture-resistant MOFs [14]. We reported here that hydration of framework complexes is a coordination competition of different oxygen atoms, in which the hydrogen bonds play a key role. This study of framework complex hydration at the molecular level facilitates the understanding of the corresponding mechanisms, and provides good references for improving the hydrothermal stability of framework complexes.

Experimental
All reagents and chemicals were commercially obtained, and used without further purification.

Instrumentation
The crystal structures were obtained on a Bruker Smart-1000 CCD diffractometer. X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD) measurements were recorded on a Bruker D8 ADVANCE diffractometer at 40 kV, 40 mA for Cu Kα radiation (λ = 1.5406 Å), with a step size of 0.01˚ in θ and a scan speed of 0.1 s per step. Elemental analyses of C, H and N were carried out on a Carlo-Erba 1112 Elemental Analyzer. Infrared (IR) spectra were recorded on an EQUINOX55 spectrophotometer (Bruker) in the range of 4000 -400 cm −1 with the KBr disk technique. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed under N 2 at a heating rate of 5 ˚C/min on a TA-Q600 system. A Quantachrome AUTOSORB-MP surface area analyser was used to measure the gas adsorption. The water adsorption/desorption tests were conducted using a high-pressure volumetric analyser (HPVA II, Micromeritics Instrument Ltd., Shanghai, China).

Experimental Details
Synthesis of MOFs 1 [Ni 2 (nic) 4   Transformation of the MOFs 1 crystal to the mononuclear complex 2, . The 3D framework structure of 1 was first reported by Wu [35], but the sorption of water following its hydration was not noted. MOFs 1 can transform to 2 [36] completely at room temperature in atmosphere [37].
When 1 was heated in water, the transformation process is accelerated. Anal.

Results and Discussions
Although the structures of 1 and 2 have been reported previously [35] [36], the interconversion between them via dehydration/hydration processes has not been fully understood [37]. According to previous studies [35], 1 is a green block crystal with a 3D mushroom-like crystal structure, and it can be completely converted to the pale blue powder of 2 when exposed to air for about 60 days.   and O6 were each located between and connected to two coordinated water molecules in the same plane. Meanwhile, the four carboxylic oxygen atoms above and below this plane (O7−O10) were located between the coordinated water molecules and nitrogen atoms, and linked to the water molecules via individual hydrogen bonds. In this way, the equatorial plane of the uncoordinated octahedron was established.
Based on the above spatial configuration, we concluded that the two octahedrons competed against each other for coordinating with Ni1. Under ambient conditions, the carboxylic oxygen atoms were located far from Ni1 due to steric hindrance effects, and 2 was favoured over 1 in terms of stability. The coordinated octahedrons in 1 were squeezed, while those in 2 were stretched which were more stable due to the Jahn-Teller effect.
On the other hand, under hydrothermal conditions with high temperature and pressure, the bulky carboxylic oxygen atoms were more effective than the small water molecules at coordination. The two coordinated nitrogen atoms were not substituted by oxygen atoms, due to their high coordination affinity. Because of steric hindrance, one coordinated carboxylic group of the niacin was substituted by a small water molecule (O7 in Figure 1), which acted as a bidentate ligand that connects two adjacent Ni1 ions to form a dimer structure. In this way, Ni was coordinatively saturated and compound 1 was obtained. Note that the nitrogen atoms, although still coordinated, were shifted from their positions in 2 by the repulsive force.
From the TGA result, guest water was not observed in the pores of the 3D porous structure of 1. Only two intra-molecular hydrogen bonds would be formed between the uncoordinated carboxylic oxygen atoms and the hydrogen atoms in the coordinated water molecules. As shown in the stacked graph (Figure 3), the presence of mushroom-shaped pores in 1 could severely limit the free space in the vicinity of Ni1, and no uncoordinated octahedrons were allowed. Within these pores, up to four water molecules localized by hydrogen bonds were allotted the free space between two coordinated carboxylic oxygen atoms, specifically.
The maximum quantity of moisture adsorption observed was 8.44% ( Figure  4), which is equivalent to three water molecules per Ni1. This is close to the theoretical prediction of four water molecules per Ni1, and we attribute the difference to experimental errors. The hydration was expected to occur in multiple steps, and as many as seven water molecules were required for each 1 molecule. World Journal of Mechanics  Therefore, the extra water molecules must come from adsorption. Specifically, the 3D structure of 1 was destroyed when one coordinated carboxylic oxygen was substituted by water, creating more free space in the vicinity of Ni1. This enabled external water molecules to enter this space to further hydrolyse the carboxylic groups, resulting in 2. This multi-step mechanism may explain the extremely slow hydration rate of 1 under ambient conditions. As mentioned earlier, the coordinated nitrogen atoms were not substituted by water, due to their higher coordination affinity. Water molecules that were localized by hydrogen bonds generated another ligand field in the vicinity of Ni1. Due to their small size, these water molecules were close to Ni1 to readily substitute the carboxylic groups under ambient instead of hydrothermal condition. This also serves as an explanation to the moisture sensitivity of MOFs. By comparison, in all N-coordinated MOFs such accumulation of water molecules in the vicinity of metal ions and additional ligand fields have not been observed, as no hydrogen bonds could be established due to the high alkalinity of these MOFs. Hence, the N-coordinated MOFs exhibited excellent water stability.
In the solution phase, the water molecules could be dispersed without estab-lishing the additional ligand fields. In real solutions, however, water molecules were nevertheless localized in the vicinity of metal ions by the hydrogen bonds, resulting in a local micro-environment in which the substitution of carboxylic groups by water molecules was favoured.
In summary, we propose that water adsorption on 1 is a dynamic process based on crystal structure change; and the hydration of 1 is achieved in multiple steps in which the hydrogen bonds play a key role. The two coordinated nitrogen atoms are not substituted during the conversion between 1 and 2, although their locations are shifted.

Conclusions
In the dehydrated MOFs [Ni 2 (nic) 4 (H 2 O)] n 1, the adsorbed water molecules were localized in the vicinity of the metal ions, due to the hydrogen bonds between the coordinated water molecules and carboxylic groups (since other parts of the structure were hydrophobic). Located in the free space within the octahedron of coordinated water molecules and carboxylic groups, the adsorbed water molecules generated another ligand field (at an angle to the first octahedron) that interacted with the Ni ion and competed with the original oxygen ligands. Under ambient conditions, the adsorbed water molecules exhibited higher affinity to the metal ions due to their proximity. As a result, the MOFs were hydrolysed. The nitrogen atoms were not substituted due to their high coordination affinity.
Similarly, in the mononuclear complex 2, an accumulation of uncoordinated carboxylic groups in the vicinity of the metal ions were also observed, which can be attributed to hydrogen bonds. Located in the free space within the octahedron of coordinated water molecules, these uncoordinated carboxylic groups formed another octahedron and competed with the coordinated octahedron. Under high temperatures and pressures, the carboxylic oxygen atoms exhibited higher coordination affinity than water, and the reversible dehydration of 2 was favoured. In essence, we found that the hydration of MOFs occurred by the coordination substitution of oxygen atoms, in which hydrogen bonds played a key role. This study of MOFs hydration at the molecular level will facilitate the understanding of hydration mechanism of frameworks, and provide important information for improving the hydrothermal stability of MOFs.