Compact Thermal Management Device Using Electrocaloric Effect

The electrocaloric effect (ECE) is defined as the fact that the temperature of dielectric material changes, when an electric field is applied to or removed from the material [1]. It might be a possible solution for the increasing energy consumption for thermal management because of its high effectiveness. Previous research on the ECE has investigated several possible methods to build a model based on ECE and feasibilities to increase the efficiency of the model. But there has been no study on all the factors that may affect the performance of the device. Thus, in this paper, we designed a cooling device based on ECE and simulated it by using the control variates method showing that a high efficiency can be reached through stated model.


Introduction
Significant amount of energy has been used for thermal management all over the world presently.In common American families, more than 30% of the power usage is spent on space cooling and refrigeration [1].If we assume there to be a 10% increase of efficiency in the performance of thermal management applications, 110 terawatt hours of energy would be saved in America in 1 year.This is about the entire energy consumption of Mexico estimated annually [2].Based on such huge benefits from energy saving, scientists have studied four types of cooling technologies, including the vapor compression system, thermoelectric cooling, magnetocaloric cooling and the electrocaloric cooler [3].
Vapor Compression Refrigeration (VCR) [4], currently the most widely used thermal management technology, was invented about two hundred years ago.The improvement of efficiency is limited currently.Moreover, it is not environment-friendly because the emission of Chlorofluorocarbons can cause great Ozone depletion, and influence the climate all over the word.Also, the development of this cooling system is restricted by its size.Over the years, there has been little progress in the minimization of such compressors due to many physics problems.Considering that too much energy has been used for thermal management, including but not limited to air conditioning, improvements for cooling technology become more and more important.
Thermoelectric effects have been studied for decades.The Peltier effect is the utilization of the physics thermoelectric cooling [5].It is defined by the presence of heating or cooling at an electrified junction of two different conductors.With Peltier effect, heat is supposed to be transported from one side of an electrode to the other side with directed motion of charge carriers.One of the most significant advantages of a thermoelectric cooling device is that it can work under many extremely severe conditions.For instance, Thermoelectric coolers and generators have been used in the space.Usually thermoelectric thermal management devices are very simply-built and can be made quite compacted, which VCR system can't solve.However, thermoelectric coolers often suffer from their low efficiency.The fundamental physics requires low thermal conductance and high electric conductance of the materials for high efficiency thermoelectric cooling devices.While for a thermoelectric cooler, these are incompatible requirements, making material exploration for high performance thermoelectric materials challenging.
Magnetocaloric cooling utilizes the thermodynamically reversible magnetocaloric effect (MCE) [5], to transfer heat from cold sources to hot sources in a manner similar to VCR system.Theoretical analyses suggest that compared with the current best air-cooling system, the VCR system, magnetic cooling could have a higher cooling efficiency.However, it is limited by its high magnetic field requirement.
The discovery of the electrocaloric effect (ECE) has offered us a possible solution to the thermal management system efficiency problem [6].Specifically, variations in the electric field cause change of the dipolar state in the dielectric materials, causing the material to change from a less ordered state to a more ordered state, or vice versa when an electric field is removed.The entropy change results in the temperature change.Scientists reported that a temperature change of 12 K can be achieved by tuning the material's composition or introducing higher electric field [7].This makes it promising to study the ECE, when aiming at designing a system that can increase the efficiency for thermal management.

Fundamentals of Electrocaloric Effect
In 2004, Zhang predicted a large ECE in ferroelectric P(VDF-TrFE) based polymers.The equation of the ECE is basically derived from the equation of Gibb's free energy.

Y. C. Xi Journal of Electronics Cooling and Thermal Control
The derivation is shown below.
, d ∫ G: Gibbs free energy; S: Entropy of material; C_E, ρ: Specific heat of material, density of material; T: Temperature.D: Displacement; Q: Heat; E: Electric field.
From the derivation of the above equations, it could be seen that temperature change of Electrocaloric materials arises from the entropy change, and is directly related to the displacement under given electric fields.The higher the voltage of the electric field is, the more the temperature changes [8].

Electrocaloric Cooling Device Design
Theoretically, an ECE refrigerator working under a Carnot cycle can reach the highest possible efficiency, also named as Carnot efficiency.Figure 1 shows the comparison between VCR and Electrocaloric cooling cycles.As shown in Figure 1 for Electrocaloric cooling system, it is started with Electrocaloric materials under disordered state.When an external electric filed is applied, the materials tend to be transited into ordered state, which will release the energy in forms of heat during the transition process.After removing the electric filed, the materials will tend to become disorder again and this process requires the materials to absorb the surrounded heat as energy to support the disorder-to-order transition process.In this way, a Electrocaloric cooling system is achieved.And a successful design of Electrocaloric cooling devices should form a similar cycle by utilizing the Electrocaloric temperature changes [6].
Unlike the gaseous refrigerants of VCR systems, all Electrocaloric materials are in solid states.This is an advantage of EC devices, since it yields more compacted sizes, higher energy density, and no friction loss.However, when designing a functional EC system, the effeicient thermal transfer between EC materials and thermal ends requires a good thermal switch.A thermal switch is a functional thermal element that changes its thermal conductance in response to changes in thermal loading, and thereby helps maintain a target device or system to stay within desired temperature ranges.When a target device goes over a critical temperature, the switch turns on and dissipates heat to a cold surface.When the target device then returns to an acceptable temperature, the switch turns off.An ideal heat switch should meet the following needs: great on/off ratio, good sensitivity, and low specific heat.
Figure 2 shows the model of the cooling system using the Electrocaloric effect, coupling with a thermal switch that consists of fluid (water with high specific heat capacity as proposed).In this design, the Electrocaloric material's temperature changes alternatively with the application/removal of an external electric field.The water/air gap passes through the Electrocaloric material periodically.By synchronizing the frequency of the Electrocaloric electric field and water/air gap flow, the upper tunnel water is constantly heated and the lower tunnel is constantly cooled.When the water in the tunnel reaches the hot/cold side, heat exchange occurs, and the complete effect sees the heat being pumped from the cold side to hot side, while a directional heat transfer against the temperature gradient is achieved.
In this model, there are several factors that contribute to the device's performance.In the following section, this paper will discuss these factors in details.  1.

Y. C. Xi
The initial frequency is set at 1 Hz; thermal conductivity is at 0.12 W/m•K; Electrocaloric temperature change of the EC material is at 5 K; the thickness of water flow is 200 um; the thickness of the EC material is 200 um; and the liquid used for the thermal switch is water.The model illustrated here is a 1-D model.
For simplification, let's assume the length and height of the components to be 1cm.To quantify the quality of the model, the power of heat transfer, the change in temperature of the liquid, and the efficiency of the model are considered.

1) Frequency
The relationship between Frequency and the efficiency of EC devices is the first factor to be studied.The Temperature change of working fluids and cooling power are with various frequency as shown in Figure 3.As indicated from the Figure 3, when the frequency increases, the efficiency of the model gradually decreases.When the frequency increases, the temperature change of water decreases.When the frequency increases, the power of the model increases.
The explanation behind these facts may be that when the frequency increases, not enough time will be left for the complete transfer of heat into the liquid, which can cause temperature changes along with efficiency decrease.However, as the frequency increases, the time gap between each transfer decreases, which causes the power of the model to increase.An optimal operation frequency is the result of balanced efficiency, with temperature change and cooling power.After taking all these factors into consideration, an operational frequency of 1 Hz is applied.

2) Thickness of water
The second factors to be studied in this paper is the thickness of the cooling fluid.In this second model, water is used as the cooling fluid for the reason that it has a relatively high thermal conductivity and specific heat.Temperature change of working fluids and cooling power are studied in relation with fluid thickness, as shown in Figure 4.The graphs show that when the thickness of water increases, the efficiency steeply increases at first, then its increment is slowed down.When the thickness of water increases, the temperature change of  water decreases steeply at first, then its decrement is slowed down.When the thickness of water increases, the power of the model increases.This indicates that the increase of water thickness, meaning the increase in the volume of water, increases the efficiency and power, since the more water is implemented the more heat released by the EC material can be absorbed.The temperature change of water will decrease, when the mass of water increases.As the thermal conductivity of the EC material increases, more heat can be conducted, which means the heat that transferred from the EC material to the water may be huge, and the process can occur more efficiently.This is made possible by higher temperature change of the liquid-water, the power, and high efficiency of the model.Hence, it can be concluded that it is meaningful to develop EC materials with high thermal conductivity to increase thermal treatment efficiency.

4) The Electric Field Applied
The level of EC temperature change is directly related to both material prop- that it will absorb more heat.Also, since the water absorbs more energy, the power and efficiency of the use water will also increase.The discrete dots in the first graph indicates that EC temperature change may not be an influential factor of the efficiency.Thus, some minor errors in the simulation may cause some data fluctuation.This partially explains why there isn't a positive correlation in the first graph above.

5) The Thickness of EC Materials
Furthermore, the performance of EC cooling devices is also related to the mass of EC materials used.As shown in the Figure 7, When the thickness of EC material increases, the efficiency decreases gradually.When the thickness of EC material increases, dT of water and the power of the model increases at approximately the same level.As the thickness of the EC material increases, more molecules of the material are being utilized.When this happens along with the application of the electric field, more molecules will transform from random movement to orderly movement, which results in an increase in the amount of heat being released.In this way, more heat can be transferred to the water, causing an increase in water temperature and power.However, with the increase of Y. C. Xi   EC thickness, the percentage of heat transferred from EC materials to the cooling fluid can be significantly decreased, which lowers the efficiency.

6) The Kind of Liquid Used
As shown from the Table 2 above, the use of gasoline in the place of cooling fluid can yield the greatest change in temperature, ceteris paribus, while the model that uses water yields the greatest power and best efficiency.The less the value of the specific heat a liquid has, the more temperature change may occur when the same type of electric field is applied.

Conclusion
In this paper, a compact cooling devices based on Electrocaloric materials has been designed.Factors which affect the performance of the thermal device have also been modeled and analyzed.Finite element simulation shows that a high efficiency can be reached through stated model.It is expected that this study can be a guide for further research in the discovery of better EC materials.

Figure 3 .
Figure 3. Efficiency, temperature change and power change as a function of operation frequency.

Figure 4 . 3 )Figure 5 .
Figure 4. Efficiency, temperature change and power change as a function of fluid thickness.
materials can contribute to EC device performance, the heat generated/absorbed by the ECE requires high thermal conductivity for efficient transport.When the thermal conductivity of EC material increases, efficiency, temperature change of the water, and the power of the model all increases by approximately the same degree.
erties and the voltage applied to the material.Scientists have put significant amounts of efforts to maximize EC temperature change.It has been reported that a temperature change of 50 K has been achieved using a composite material of PVDF based polymer and perovskite nanoparticle.However, high voltage has high requirement for the longevity and stability of EC materials to be used.It is interesting to study the relation between EC device performances (including total device temperature change, power density and energy efficiency) and EC materials temperature change.As we can see from Figure6, when the voltage of the electric field applied increases, the efficiency of the model generally decreases.When the voltage of the electric field applied increases, the increase of the water temperature and the power of the model is approximately linear.The increase of the applied electric field leads to immediate temperature change of the EC material.Thus, the temperature change of liquid water will increase, given

Figure 6 .Figure 7 .
Figure 6.Efficiency, temperature change and power change as a function of temperature change of EC materials.

Table 1 .
Xi Initial parameters of simulation.

Table 2 .
EC device performance vs cooling fluids.