Circular Natural Geoforms , Sierras Pampeanas , Argentina

We describe two circular morphological features representing depressed areas. This preliminary work is based on visual interpretations from Landsat ETM satellite images and SRTM Radar scans. The two geoforms are located at the north of the Sierras Pampeanas in Argentina. The La Ciénaga circular indentation is 15 km in diameter and Las Cejas is 34 km in diameter. Until now rings of these characteristics, magnitudes and diameters are unknown and unheard of in Argentina.


Introduction
In the northern Sierras Pampeanas of Argentina we identified two circular natural geoforms for which we do not have any evidence to elucidate a process that gave rise to them (Figure 1).The 15 km wide La Ciénaga geoform is in the east of the Sierra de Fiambalá in the province of Catamarca (27˚25'S -67˚W) and the 34 km wide Las Cejas geoform is located to the north of Dorsal Mujer Muerta on the border between the provinces of Tucuman and Santiago del Estero (26˚50'S -64˚45'W).
In nature, there are morphological features produced by processes or natural phenomena and whose geoforms, by themselves, allow to identify the process that generated them.For example, alluvial fans, glacier circuses, moraines, river basins, curved structures, elliptic structures, volcanic cones, volcanic caldera, impact structures, karst geoforms, etc. (e.g., [6]- [12]).The importance to study these geoforms lies in being able to understand the processes that formed them, abundance, geographical location, etc., in order to prevent and minimize natural risks.
These two structures are not associated with volcanic rocks, limestone, tectonic processes, glaciers, etc., with which we could link their origin; thus, it was thought that they could represent impact structures.Circular geoforms such as those studied in this work, are important not only for geomorphological analysis, because they could be associated with impact cratering, but also as a tool for analysis of the effects that the impact of large objects could produce and cause to our climate and biosphere in the affected area.
According to [13], an object of 750 m width can generate a geoform of 15 km diameter, which would be sufficient to produce an atmospheric explosion over the impact site, reducing solar radiation, causing temperature distortion and injecting of dust into the stratosphere, with a residence time of 1 Ma, and if the target composition was right, inject 5 times more sulphur than the current content in the atmosphere and thereby destroying the ozone layer.To generate a geological landform of 34 km in diameter, it would require an object of 1700 m width, causing a much greater impact, considering the impact of an object only 50 m wide that produces a crater of 1 km in diameter could obliterate an area of several hundred km 2 around the impact site [14].
The impact structure Araguainha (Brazil) of 40 km in diameter [15], was dated in 246 Ma (40 Ar/39 Ar) [16].It is a complex crater that was eroded; its central part rises about 150 m with respect to the surrounding surface, marked by rings of about 8 km in diameter and an internal elliptical depression of about 3 to 4.5 km [16].
Argentina has been alleged to have seventy-four meteorite impacts and seven other pseudo-meteorite impact sites [17] [18] [19].In the strewn field of the Campo del Cielo meteorite in Chaco, 20 small craters are located within an area of 15 km length [20] [21], and the structures at Rio Cuarto (Cordoba) consist of elongated depressions that stretch over 40 km [22].These meteorite impacts are arranged into five bands of NNE strike with a gap in the Santa Rosa region between 35˚ and 37˚S and another in the Río Gallegos region (Figure 2).We only know the age of 27 meteorite fall.The oldest are Luján in the province of Buenos Aires (50,000 -20,000 years) and Campo del Cielo in the province of Chaco (4000 ± 80 years, determined by radiocarbon) [19] [23]- [43].The age of the other meteorite fall is between 1879 and 2008 (Table 1).

The La Ciénaga Geoform (15 km in Diameter)
The circular feature of La Ciénaga is located in the province of Catamarca, inside an intermountain depression situated between the Sierra de Fiambalá to the west and the Sierra de Belén to the east and south.To the north, a set of lower elevations separate the circular geoform from the Hualfín valley.This valley is limited to the NW by the Sierra de Hualfín and to the SE by the Farallon Negro Volcanic Complex; toward the NE it is connected with the Campo del Arenal (Figure 1).
La Ciénaga, situated southeast of the geoform, is the most important locality in the area.The Belén River flows to SW along the eastern edge of the circular feature; it is the main collector of water in the area and the Loconte River and smaller channels flow down towards it from the mountains located to the west (Figure 3).

General Geological Characteristics
The oldest rocks are represented by metamorphic rocks of the Loma Corral Formation of Upper Precambrian-Lower Cambrian age that was intruded by granitic rocks of the Chango Real Formation in the Lower Palaeozoic [3].These rocks form the core of the mountain that borders the geomorphic feature to the west; to the southeast there is a low outcrop of granitic rock that forms part of the Sierra de Belén (Figure 1 and Figure 3).The geological sequence ends with three sedimentary levels of Quaternary alluvial fans and fluvio-eolian deposits [3] (Figure 3).
The igneous-metamorphic basement of the range that ends to the west of the geomorphic feature constitutes the core of a major anticlinal fold, striking NNE, which dips to the north (Figure 3).The sedimentary sequence of the El Bolsón Group that forms part of the western flank of the fold dips westward.However, the eastern flank of the fold also consisting of the sequence of the El Bolsón Group is refolded, forming anticlines and synclines.Another outstanding feature of the eastern flank of the fold is that the sedimentary-volcanic sequence is not attached to the eastern flank of the igneous-metamorphic basement core.It is separated by the intermountain depression where the geomorphic circular feature is located.Only small outcrops are seen attached to the eastern edge of the mountain range (Figure 3).All folds at the eastern edge of the intermountain depression strike NE and are cut by faults, eroded or covered by quaternary deposits (Figure 3).

The metamorphic rocks of the Loma Corral Formation overlie the El Bolsón
Group sequence because of a NE reverse fault that dips to the NW [3].NW and NE regional lineaments parallel to the Loconte and Belén rivers are cutting folds in the northeast and southeast areas, respectively (Figure 3).Here occur other minor lineaments that affect the entire geological sequence.In the intermountain depression, some lineaments are cutting the Quaternary deposits and Neogene sediments (Figure 3).

Morphology of the Circular Feature
The circular geoform is a depressed area with respect to the rest of the intermountain region; the center of the depression is at 1800 masl.The western border is higher than the eastern with a 641 m drop; the center is at 400 m lower elevation compared to western side.The intermountain area is covered by Quaternary sediments that have formed as coalescing alluvial fans with a general slope to the southeast, distributed in three terraced levels.The depression of the circular geoform is evidence by the lowering sedimentary levels morphology.To the north, the second and third level deposits are truncated by the edge of the crater and the third level continually extends to the south.With greater development, but in the center of the depressed area, the third level can be seen only in the form of islands outcrops.Later the depressed area was filled with deposits of the first level (Figure 3 and Figure 4).
The mountain range of NE strike, to the west of the study area, forms part of the Sierra de Fiambalá (Figure 1).The section that occupies the area is cut by three

ESE striking lineaments. The lineament located between Azampay and Puesto
Chistin marks a break in the range, to the north the range strike NE, and to the south in NS direction (Figure 1 and Figure 3).This break, coupled with the intense erosion of the eastern slope of the range has created an eastern concave shape, defining a semi-circular contour which forms the western edge of the crater (Figure 3 and Figure 4).The Neogene folded sequence of the El Bolsón Group is separated from the eastern flank of the range by the basin.Western reaches of these folds appear to have been cut, as if the sedimentary sequence had slipped into the depression, as the morphology presented alluvial fans in the northern sector (Figure 3 and Figure 4).
Northeast and northwest, outside the area, are the Farallón Negro and Vicuña Pampa volcanic complexes of Neogene age [44] (Figure 1).The volcanic sequence of the El Cajón Formation (El Bolsón Group) originates from the Farallón Negro Volcanic Complex [3] [4]; the circular feature appears to predate the sedimentary sequence of the El Bolson Group (Figure 3 and Figure 4).The E-W relief of the structure has a slope of 8% and the western edge is abrupt; in this slope, surficial drainage development and consequent erosion processes have occurred (Figure 5(a)).The N-S profile highlights the concavity of the circular structure; the northern edge is higher than the southern edge and in the central area there are small elevations with quaternary sediment residues (Figure 5(b)).

The Las Cejas Geoform (34 km in Diameter)
The Las Cejas geoform is located at the northern end of the Dorsal Mujer Muerta.This area forms part of a topographic high of sub-meridian strike that is 340 km long and 90 km wide and closes eastward of the Tucuman basin.To the north continue the foothills of the Sierra del Campo, to the west border the Sierra de La Ramada highlands, and to the east extend the Chaco Pampeana plains (Figure 1).The locality of Las Cejas in the southern part of the depression is the most populated and important place around (Figure 6).

General Geological Characteristics
The area is totally cultivated, so it is impossible to perform a visual interpretation of satellite images.The Dorsal Mujer Muerta is buried, covered by Neogene and Quaternary sediments.The rocks outcrop only in the Sierra de Guasayán highlands (550 masl).The natural drainage that flowed from the Sierra de La Ramada was deactivated and replaced by artificial channels (Figure 1  In the Sierra de Guasayán outcrop metamorphic rocks of Upper Precambrian-Lower Cambrian age, intruded by granitic rocks, granodiorites and tonalities of Ordovician to Carboniferous age, which are covered by sedimentary rocks of Neogene and Quaternary age [5] (Figure 1).
To the west, in the ranges of La Ramada and Medina, there are outcrops of small bodies of intrusive subvolcanic rock of Cretaceous age [45].However, near the circular structure, we have not identified in satellite images or in the field any, rocks, or morphologies that could be thought typical for volcanic activity (Figure 6 and Figure 7).

Morphology of the Circular Feature
The Las Cejas geoform is a semi-circular indentation of about 34 km diameter that seems to have obliterated the northern tip of the Dorsal Mujer Muerta.In the radar image this feature is linked to a flat morphology elongated ESE (40 km), a smooth surface that contrasts with the raised, truncated edges of the ridge to the west and south, and with others of lesser height to the north and east.Its minor axis is about 32 km long.In topographic maps, it shows that the ground is not completely flat, with hills and depressions marking some 380 m of topographic gradient (Figure 7 and Figure 8).
The center of the geoform is at 370 masl; the western edge is higher than the eastern edge, with a vertical drop of 160 m.The drop between the western edge and the central zone is 90 m (Figure 6 and Figure 7).The E-W relief on the  western edge has a slope of 0.9% that then decreases eastward to 0.2% to 0.5% (Figure 8(a)).In Figure 8(b) the concavity of the structure is best appreciated and shows the abrupt edge of the south wall.
It is possible that the circular feature was formed prior to the deposition of Neogene sedimentary rocks.

Discussion
No other circular structures of such diameters are known in Argentina.Of the seventy-four cases of meteorite falls and other seven pseudo-meteorites mentioned in the literature, only two are special cases of large meteorites (Campo del Cielo in Chaco and Rio Cuarto in Córdoba).The meteorite falls in Argentina are aligned in a NNE strike, distributed from north to south, but in the central area (Santa Rosa) and to the south (Río Gallegos) there is no evidence of meteorite fall.The oldest meteorite falls (Lujan and Campo del Cielo) are dated between 50,000 -20,000 years and 4000 ± 80 years, respectively; the remaining meteorite falls age between the years 1879 and 2008 (Figure 1 and Figure 2; Table 1).
An impact structure can be simple or complex in its construction [46].A simple crater on Earth is small, less than 4 km in diameter, with a bowl-shaped geometry and a raised rim.A complex structure has diameters > 4 km and on Earth the largest known such structure was ca 250 -300 km wide, prior to erosion (Vredefort, South Africa) [47].With the exception of very low-angle impact events, the resulting crater structures are invariably circular.According to impact magnitude and target composition, the interiors of complex impact structures will have a central peak (stratigraphic uplift), peak ring, or multiple ring structures.
The La Ciénaga structure with a 15 km diameter and the Las Cejas structure Open Journal of Geology with a 34 km diameter have circular shapes and in plan views on satellite images show a flat morphology with marked edges (Figure 4 and Figure 7).Being seen in a profile, both structures have a central depression of about 2.7 km (La Ciénaga) and 12 km (Las Cejas); the general slope towards the E strike is smooth (Figure 5 In Chaco, more than 20 impact craters are known from which numerous meteorite fragments were recovered; apart from Campo del Cielo other prominent craters are La Perdida, Rubin de Celiz, Gomez and Laguna Negra [18]. At 24 km and 83 km south of the Campo del Cielo meteorite strewn field, at the southeastern edge of the Lomadas de Otumpa, we identified in radar images the remains of four semi-circular and elliptical structures.These structures of 15.0, 16.5, 18.0 and 31.5 km in diameter occur as in showing the aftermath of an object's impact.These depressions have now become lakes, as one is called El Cisne (Figure 9).Are these geoforms impact structures related with meteorites fallen 4000 ± 80 years ago, in Campo del Cielo?With other age meteorites?Or are they natural erosional features?In this area, no volcanic manifestations were found which could be associated with these circular features.
In South America, the only known impact crater is Araguainha (Brazil) with 40 km in diameter [16].The La Ciénaga and Las Cejas structures do not have the Figure 9. Four semi-circular structures located in the Lomadas de Otumpa area south of the Campo del Cielo meteorite strewn field.These four structures represent lakes or small bodies of water.morphology that characterizes Araguainha crater impact, perhaps because they are covered by Neogene and Quaternary sediments that bury those characteristic features.However, the erosion of these sediments marks the outer rings of structures, and can be observed in satellite images.They are not related to volcanic structures because there are no lava flows associated with them nor have there been volcanic rocks identified near the structures nor on satellite images nor during field work.
La Ciénaga and Las Cejas structures are geomorphic features that need to be investigated in more detail to elucidate their origin and age.A relation with meteorite impact or other natural events must be elucidated, considering that: 1) They are circular, slightly elongated geoforms that are well defined.
2) No impact structures have been identified in Argentina yet.
3) The sediments that cover them appear to have slumped inward towards their rings and the erosion permits you to see the circular morphology of the structures.
4) Both structures appear to have originated before deposition of the Neogene sediments.5) Nearby in the La Ciénaga area there are volcanic manifestations (Farallón Negro and Vicuña Pampa) but the circular structure does not seem to be related to a volcanic event.
6) In the Las Cejas area, no volcanic manifestations have been found that could be associated with the circular structure.
7) The impact of large objects would produce catastrophic effects on the climate and biosphere.To generate an impact structure of 15 km in diameter (La Ciénaga) it would require an object of 750 m wide and to generate a structure of 34 km (Las Cejas) an object of 1700 m wide, at an average velocity of 25 km/s [48].The impact of objects with these dimensions can produce an atmospheric explosion over the impact site, reducing solar radiation, temperature distortion and injection into the stratosphere, for periods of up to 1 Ma, five times more sulphur that the current content, destroying the ozone layer [13] [14].

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Regional SRTM radar image showing the location of the La Ciénaga and Las Cejas geoforms.It indicates the most important cities, the mountain ranges, and the largest basins.

Figure 2 .
Figure 2. Map of Argentina with the location of meteorite falls.With the dashed lines indicating that these sites lie in five bands with NNE strike.In the central and south area (Santa Rosa and Rio Gallegos) there are no records of meteorite falls.
The igneous-metamorphic rocks supporting continental sediments (El Cajón and El Morterito formations) of Tertiary age belong to the El Bolsón Group.The volcanic rocks of the El Áspero Formation intrude the sequence of the El Morterito Formation and underlie the El Cajón Formation, which is also part of the El Bolsón Group[3] [4].The El Bolsón Group has its major development in the eastern sector of the area close to the geomorphic feature; towards the northwest it overlies the igneous-metamorphic basement (Figure3).DOI: 10.4236/ojg.2017.790861308 Open Journal of Geology

Figure 4 .
Figure 4. Schematic location of the profile lines and view of the regional morphology on a Landsat image.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. Profiles illustrating the general morphology of the structure.In profile (a) La Ciénaga structure, EW profile; the regional WE slope is observed; and in profile (b) La Ciénaga structure, NS profile; the cup-shaped structure with marked edges are shown.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Planialtimetric map of the Las Cejas geoform.It indicates localities, roads, artificial drainage and the interprovincial border.

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. Schematic location of the profiles AA' and BB' lines and view of the regional morphology on a SRTM Radar image.

Figure 8 .
Figure 8. Profiles indicating the general morphology of the Las Cejas structure.In profile (a) Las Cejas structure, EW profile; you can see a regional slope along the W-E profile; and in profile (b) Las Cejas structure, NS profile; the cup-shaped structure with marked edges is.
(a)    and Figure8(a)) however in the N-S profile it reflects a concave cup-shaped morphology (Figure 5(b) and Figure 8(b)).

Table 1 .
Age of meteorites fall in Argentina.WL: west latitude.SL: south latitude.