Antibiotic Resistance in Campylobacter Isolated from Patients with Gastroenteritis in a Teaching Hospital in Ghana

Campylobacter is a leading causal agent of bacterial enteritis worldwide, but its prevalence is not well documented in Ghanaian hospitals. This study isolated Campylobacter species from patients with enteritis or urinary tract infections attending Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital and assessed the antibiogram profile of isolated species. Two hundred and two (202) in-patients and outpatients samples of all age groups diagnosed with enteritis or UTI infections were analyzed from May 2013 to August 2013. Campylobacter species were detected using selective agar (mCCDA) and confirmed on API Campy system (bioMérieux, France), with disk diffusion method determined the resistance profile of the species. Of the 128 enteritis and 74 UTI patients samples analyzed, 26 and 9 isolates were respectively confirmed as Campylobacter spp. giving a prevalence of 17.3% (35/202). Species identified were C. jejuni (40%), C. jejuni sub sp. doylei (2.8%), C. coli (37%) and C. lari (20%). Resistance was 92.3% 100% each to erythromycin and the β-lactams, 61.5% 86.7% to trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole, 92.3% 93.3% to tetracycline, 46.2% 80% to chloramphenicol, 0% 60% to aminoglycosides and 0% to imipenem. Multidrug resistance of 97.1% was detected among species. Empirical treatment of Campylobacter enteritis with erythromycin and other common and cheap drugs may result in treatment failure in the face of high level resistance observed among the Campylobacter species.


Introduction
Campylobacter is a major agent of gastroenteritis worldwide, and in developing countries infection has strikingly increased in recent years [1] [2].Worldwide, Campylobacter causes between 400 -500 million cases of diarrhea each year [3].Campylobacter jejuni (sub sp.jejuni and doylei) and C. coli have mostly been implicated in human infections as C. lari and C. upsaliensis are less prevalent [4].Campylobacteriosis is usually mild and self-limiting, but uncommonly associated with infections such as endocarditis, septicaemia, cholecystitis and urinary tract infections [5] [6].These infections typically warrant treatment as well as infections of the immunosuppressed, pregnant women, children, elderly and those with recurrent symptoms; in such cases the macrolides and fluoroquinolones are the first line drugs prescribed [7] [8].However, global reports of increasing resistance of Campylobacter to the drugs of choice and other clinically important antibiotics from human and animal origin are well established [3] [9] [10].The resistance situation in developing countries such as Ghana might become worse as a result of widespread and unrestricted use of antibiotics as well as inadequate research into antimicrobial resistance.
In Ghana, diarrhea has been identified as the second most common health problem treated in outpatient clinics [11].Routine screening of aetiological agents of diarrhea currently does not include Campylobacter as evident in the many hospital records in Ghana.In the proper management of diarrhea, a key agent such as Campylobacter cannot be ignored.This study reported on the prevalence of Campylobacter infections among patients presenting with gastric infections and the resistance profile of isolated species.

Study population and site
This study was undertaken at the Microbiology Laboratory of the Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (KATH), Kumasi.The hospital is the second-largest in Ghana and the only tertiary health institution in the Ashanti Region.It is a 1, 200 bed capacity referral hospital for 8 Regions in Ghana.In-patients at the various wards and out patients of KATH who were diagnosed with gastroenteritis or urinary tract infections (UTI) were enrolled in the study from May 2013 to August 2013.Patients of all age groups were recruited.
Sample processing, isolation and identification Stool and mid-stream urine specimens submitted to the Microbiology Laboratory for bacteriological analysis were processed to obtain our target organism.A loopful of fresh faeces and 0.001 mL of urine were plated directly onto modified charcoal-cefoperazone-deoxycholate agar (mCCDA Oxoid CM0689) supplemented with CCDA selective supplement (Oxoid, SRO155E) using sterile loop and 0.001 calibrated loop respectively.The plates were kept in a 2.5 L anaerobic jar and Campy-Gen gas generating kit (Oxoid CN0025A) introduced to keep the microaerophilic condition at 42˚C for 48 hours.Campylobacter species were identified by morphological characteristics and biochemically by Gram

Data Analysis
Descriptive analysis was carried out using percentages.Associations were determined using the Chi-square test at a significance level of <0.05.All statistical tests were two-tailed.Stata 14.0 software was used for statistical analysis.

Ethical Approval
Ethical clearance was obtained from the joint Committee on Human Research Publications and Ethics of the School of Medical Sciences and the Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (CHRPE/RC/066/14).Specimens collected and processed were given codes; all identities on samples were removed, which made the patients anonymous.

Isolation rate of Campylobacter from patients with UTI and enteritis
Of the 128 enteritis and 74 UTI cases, 26 (20.3%) and 9 (12.2%)isolates were respectively confirmed as Campylobacter spp.giving a prevalence of 17.3% (Table 1).No significant difference was observed in the isolation rate of Campylobacter from enteritis and UTI infections (p = 0.1403).All the Campylobacter

Antibiotic resistance profiles of Campylobacter species from patients
Resistance among isolates from enteritis to the beta-lactams (Ampicillin, cefotaxime and cephalexin) was 96% -100%; as 96% was to erythromycin, 92% to tetracycline, 81% to trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole and 54% to chloramphenicol.Against the quinolones resistance was 23% each to nalidixic acid and norfloxacin and 35% to ciprofloxacin.Resistance to the aminoglycosides was 42% to gentamicin and 8% to kanamycin.Resistance among UTI isolates to the beta-lactams, erythromycin and tetracycline was 100% each, 67% to trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole and 56% to chloramphenicol.Against the quinolones, resistance was 67% each to nalidixic acid, norfloxacin and ciprofloxacin as 44% and 11% was observed respectively against gentamicinand kanamycin.All isolates exhibited 0% resistance to imipenem (Table 3).The difference in resistance levels between enteritis and UTI isolates was highly significant (p < 0.0001).

Multidrug resistance in Campylobacter isolates from patients
Multidrug resistance (MDR) in this study was defined as resistance to three or more classes of antibiotics.Thirty four (34) out of the 35 Campylobacter species were multidrug resistant (97.1%).Isolates from enteritis showed MDR of 96.3% as 100% was observed among UTI isolates and the difference was significant; p = 0.0434 (Table 5).

Discussion
The 17.3% prevalence obtained in our study is within the documented range of 20% in developing countries [13] and similar to other studies in Algeria (17.7%),Nigeria (16.5%) and Tanzania (18.0%) [14] [15] [16].However, higher rates have been reported in Bangladesh (26%), Thailand (41%), Nigeria (62.7%) and Ethiopia (72.7%) [1] [2] [17] [18].Lower rates than in our study have also been reported in Zimbabwe (9.3%) and Egypt (5.8% -9%) [10] [19].Abraham et al. also reported 6.6% and 12.8% in studies in urban and rural Ghana [20].Although Campylobacter is normally recovered from children less than 2 years in most developing countries [21] [22], this study rather had higher prevalence in the 21 -30 age group [2].This may be attributed to the design of this study which did not focus on children with acute diarrhoea and also a reflection of the infection sources which were mostly obtained from the outpatient department which is usually dominated by these age groups in the study hospital.According to Friedman et al. two age peaks occur in Campylobacter acquisition in developed nations, which are ages less than1year and at 15 -55 years [23].Secondly, Campylobacter infections were more prevalent in female (68%) than in male (32%) patients.In studies by Fitzgerald et al. and Friedman et al., Campylobacter was more prevalent in male patients compared to females [23] [24].The results from this study probably speculate the gender distribution of Campylobacter infections in patients attending the Komfo Anokye Teaching hospital (KATH).Although no obvious reason has been reported on the impact of gender in Campylobacter acquisition, Gillespie et al. found that being an infant and a female has an increased risk of acquiring Campylobacter infection [25].
Campylobacter jejuni (sub species jejuni) and C. coli are the most frequently encountered species in human infections [4].This trend was observed in this study where 80% of our isolates were identified to be C. jejuni (43%) and C. coli Multidrug resistance defined as resistance to 3 or more classes of drugs.
(24.5%) from human samples in Nigeria [2].Campylobacter lari is known to infrequently cause human diseases compared to C. jejuni and C. coli.In this study, C. lari was largely found in UTI infections (44%) as well as patients with enteritis (11.5%).The isolates were from adult patients with age ranging from 62 -77 years and a 3 year old child.Megraud et al. isolated urease positive C. lari from adult patients with diarrhoea and a child with appendicitis [27].
Resistance of species to erythromycin was alarmingly high (92.3%-100%), but macrolide resistance among Campylobacter has reportedly been low and stable for a long period of time [7]; nonetheless 31%, 51%, and 79% have been reported from Bulgaria, Singapore, and Nigeria, respectively [28].Erythromycin resistance in Campylobacter has been described as gradual processes that demands prolonged exposure [8], and in agreement with this observation, Newman and colleagues have indicated that drugs such as erythromycin has been on the Ghanaian market for a relatively long period of time [29].It is therefore reasonable to associate the high level resistance in our study to misuse and abuse of this drug due to the long exposure.
Similarly, high level resistance was observed against the β-lactams (96% -100%) which is comparable to data from Egypt (100%) [10].Literature reports suggest that majority of C. jejuni and C. coli strains are intrinsically resistant to the β-lactam agents caused by the production of β-lactamases which are frequently observed [30].It can therefore be speculated that perhaps our C. jejuni and C. coli strains were β-lactamase producing strains accounting for the high resistance.
Resistance to tetracycline was 92.3% -100% but 72% has been described in Spain and a much lower rate documented in Ethiopia where tetracycline resistance of 22% has been reported in human isolates [1] [32].Worldwide, the tetracyclines are a heavily used class of antibiotics both in human and veterinary medicine [33], and in Ghana they are largely applied in animal husbandry leading to its widespread resistance [29] [34], possibly accounting for the high resistance currently observed.All isolates were sensitive to imipenem underlining speculation that carbapenems are an exception to the general β-lactam resistance and considered to be effective also in the treatment of campylobacteriosis [3] [8]; but there is the need for caution in its use; as 17% of the isolates exhibited intermediate susceptibility.Also, the low resistance against imipenem could partly be explained by the high cost resulting in infrequent prescription and less abuse.
Multidrug resistance among our isolates was 97.1% which agrees with reports from China (90%) but higher than rates established in France (37%) and Korea (56%) [35] [36] [37].High resistance levels discovered in our study may be attributed to misuse and unwarranted prescription of antibiotics by physicians who contribute largely to the growth and spread of antibiotic resistance [38].
Furthermore, self-medication is a common feature of patients attending this hospital due to readily available antibiotics across the counter in pharmaceutical stores, market stalls, by the roadside and from hawkers.This practice generally leads to antibiotic under use (sub-optimal dosages) that invariably increases selective pressure and antimicrobial resistance.Macrolides and fluoroquinolones still remain the drugs of choice for Campylobacter infections in some countries, however empirical treatment of patients presenting with Campylobacter enteritis at KATH with these drugs may result in treatment failure.

Conclusion
The presence of multidrug resistant Campylobacter strains present among patients at Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital indicates that most of the cheap and common antibiotics may not be reliable in the empirical treatment of patients with enteritis caused by Campylobacter and other related enteric pathogens and therefore necessary for laboratory confirmation of antibiotics.Nevertheless, imipenem and kanamycin proved to be highly effective.A more extensive, multi-regional study would aid in establishing the extent of Campylobacter infections in Ghana.
stain, catalase and oxidase test.Colonies that were small curved Gram negative, oxidase and catalase positive were further analysed on API Campy to identify to species level (bioMérieux, France).
cin as CLSI Campylobacter breakpoints for these antibiotics has not yet been established.Quality control was achieved using E. coli (ATCC25922) and S. aureus (ATCC25923) strains.

Table 1 .
Isolation rate of Campylobacter from patients with UTI and enteritis.fromenteritiswere isolated from patients at the out-patient department (OPD), while 4 of the patients in the ward and 5 from the OPD UTI cases were positive for Campylobacter.About 88%(31/35)of cases came from the OPD and 11.4% (4/35) from the Wards.Species specific prevalence of Campylobacter from patients with UTI and enteritis Campylobacter coli (46.2%) were the dominant species recovered from enteritis followed by C. jejuni (38.5%) and C. lari (11.5%) but 44.4% C. jejuni, 44.4% C. lari and 11.1% C. coli were recovered from UTI infections.One (1) C. jejuni sub sp.doylei was obtained from enteritis but none was found in UTI infections (Table 2).Demographic distribution of Campylobacter infections Isolation rate of Campylobacter was highest in the 10 -29 (34.3%) age group, followed by 30 -49 (28.6%) and 0 -9 (22.8.0%) with age group above 50 recording the least (14.3%).The proportion of female and male patients was 67.6% and 32.4% respectively. species

Table 2 .
Campylobacter spp.isolated from patients with UTI and enteritis.Resistance profile of C. jejuni and C. coli isolates from patients Resistance among C. jejuni strains to the β-lactams and erythromycin was 100% each, to the quinolones, 33.3% -46.7%, to the aminoglycosides 13.3% -60%, 93.3% to tetracycline, 80% to chloramphenicol and 86.7% to trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole.Strains of C. coli showed resistance of 92.3% -100% to the βlactams and erythromycin, 0% -23% to the quinolones and aminoglycosides, 92.3% to tetracycline, 46.2% to chloramphenicol and 61.5% to trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole.No resistance was observed among C. coli strains to nalidixic acid, norfloxacin and kanamycin.All strains of C. jejuni and C. coli were sensitive to imipenem.Generally resistance was common among C. jejuni strains than C. coli and the difference was significant, p < 0.0001 (Table4).

Table 3 .
Antibiotic resistance profile of Campylobacter spp.recovered from patients with UTI and enteritis.

Table 4 .
Resistance profile of C. jejuni and C. coli species.

Table 5 .
Multidrug resistance of Campylobacter species from patients.