Intrathecal Igg Synthesis in Relapsing-remitting Multiple Sclerosis (ms) Is Decreased by Natural Human Alpha Interferon

Intrathecal IgG synthesis (IT IgG Syn) is an established biomarker used for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS). Earlier studies used this biomarker to assess the impact of 2 different synthetic forms of in-terferon alpha (IFN-α) in chronic progressive MS. Unexpectedly, IT IgG synthesis was increased by this treatment. For the first time, we have assessed this parameter in relapsing-remitting patients to measure the impact of natural IFN-α treatment in a dose-ranging study in six dosage groups (5, 10, 15, 20, 25, & 30 MIU). We have found that IFN-α normalized IT IgG Synthesis at 12 weeks treatment for all dosage groups. Two weeks after stopping IFN-α results rose slightly. At 52 weeks, 28 weeks after stopping IFN-a results revealed cessation of IT IgG Synthesis in half of the patients (15, 20, 25 MIU weekly). These results reflect different outcomes for relapsing-remitting patients vs. chronic progressive patients. They may, however, reflect differences in the biological properties of the interferon products used. An optimal range of dosage with natural human IFN-α dosage for MS is suggested by the results.


INTRODUCTION
Tourtellotte established intrathecal IgG synthesis (IT IgG Synthesis) as an important biomarker for the presence inflammatory disease within the intrathecal compartment [1].Synthesis rates derived from the Tourtellotte formula are typically "0" ± 3 mg/24 hrs.Rates are rarely in-creased in non-inflammatory central nervous system (CNS) disease.Measurement of IT IgG synthesis is now established as important in the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS) [2].Oligoclonal bands found in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) also reflect intrathecal IgG synthesis but do not easily lend to quantification.Despite the ability to accurately measure low concentrations of IgG in CSF, determination of IT IgG Synthesis has been rarely used to evaluate therapeutic responses in MS.Ideally a therapy, if successful, might be expected to reduce or eliminate IgG synthesis.The first use of natural human interferon alpha (IFN-α) in a prospective therapeutic trial in relapsing-remitting MS was reported by Knobler in 1984 [3].A salutary outcome far outlasted the 6 months of active drug administration [4].This trial was later followed by additional trials, employing two different forms of interferon-α, where IT IgG Synthesis was measured.
Lymphoblastoid interferon alpha (Wellferon®), used in a trial that included only "chronic progressive" MS patients, was unexpectedly found to increase IT IgG Synthesis [5].In another report, recombinant interferonalpha-2b, (IFN-α-2b) was limited to "chronic progresssive" MS.This trial also resulted in increased IT IgG Synthesis in 4 of 6 patients and was also associated with a negative clinical outcome [6].In contrast, our initial observations in relapsing-remitting MS patients revealed an apparent decrease in IT IgG Synthesis following natural IFN-α administration.Our experience with different sources of highly purified natural human IFN-α in trials and off-label use [7] has shown them to be generally well tolerated and seemingly effective; in keeping with the outcomes of the trial reported by Knobler et al [3,4].In an IRB approved dose ranging therapeutic trial of highly purified IFN-α in relapsing-remitting (RRMS), we prospectively collected and stored serial serum and CSF laboratory specimens for subsequent IT IgG Synthesis measurement.
Patient Population; Study subjects were selected from the University of Miami Multiple Sclerosis Center patient population, after completion of IRB approved informed consent.A total of 24 RRMS patients were entered into a dose ranging study to examine the tolerability and safety of IFN-α (Life Sciences, St. Petersburg Florida).
Clinically indicated examinations of CSF are regularly performed at our center, as a standard of care.All 24 relapsing patients recruited into the study (Table 1) had been clinically stable for at least 2 months prior to entry and had not received any form of drug treatment includeing steroids and antibiotics in that time period.At study entry, all patients agreed to subsequent lumbar punctures for CSF examination at 12, 26, and 52 weeks.They were re-consented prior to each subsequent procedure.All patients underwent clinical evaluations with documented disability status at entry and every 3 months during the year of study.Blood draws were planned to coincide and to accompany CSF submitted for subsequent IT IgG Synthesis determination.Patient were provided standard of care.
Patient Demographics: Mean age of onset was 29.6 ± 6.5 years (range 19 -40 years).Mean age at entry was 37.4 ± 7.8 years (range 20 -50 years).Sex ratio was 19 females: 5 males.All were Caucasian.All were relapsing but 7 required an assistive device to walk at the time of study entry.

Randomization
Patients were randomized to one of six IFN-α dosage groups.These groups received weekly total doses (Millions International Units; MIU of IFN-α): 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, or 30; in divided subcutaneous injections 3 -6 times weekly.Treatment was planned for 24 weeks.There were no placebo recipients.

IT IgG Synthesis Determination
Serum and CSF albumin (ALB) and IgG concentration were determined using batched stored specimens.Testing was performed in quadruplicate, in blinded fashion, using high quality immunodiffusion plates (Hoechst- Boehringer Ingelheim).Calculation of IT IgG Synthesis expressed as mg IgG/24 hrs.) was determined using the Tourtellotte formula [1]: The established normal range for the laboratory was −3 mg/24 hrs. to 4.1 mg/24 hrs.

Patient Retention & Specimen Collection
Serum and CSF were collected in all 24 subjects prior to IFN-α administration.At 12 weeks, 24 subjects con-sented to their second study CSF examination.However, at week 13, four subjects ended their study participation (1 at 10, 1 at 15 MIU and 2 at 30 MIU weekly doses).Of the remaining 20 subjects, 19 had at least 3 CSF examinations (19 at week 26 and 13 at week 52).

Statistical Analysis
Statistical Analysis for Social Sciences (SPSS) package was used for performance of analysis of variants (ANOVA) to evaluate significant different between pretreatment and 3, 6, and 12 months post-treatment.Students T-test was also used to evaluate potential differences in IT IgG Syn outcomes using the lower dosage range (5, 10, 15 MIU weekly) vs. the higher dosage range (20, 25, 30 MIU weekly) at 12 months.
At week 52, 28 weeks after stopping IFN-α, the mean synthesis rate (13 subjects) increased to 18.6 ± 18.4 mg/24 hours.Interestingly, in 3 subgroups (5, 10, and 30 MIU weekly) mean IT IgG Synthesis was increased at 52 weeks.However, in the 15, 20, and 25 MIU weekly groups IT IgG synthesis appeared to have stopped at 52 weeks, 28 weeks after IFN-α cessation.T-test compareson of the 5 -15 MIU IFN-α recipients with the 20 -30 MIU recipients did not reach significance, due to the small number of values and scatter.The 15 -25 MIU IFN-α patient groups appeared clinically to tolerate IFN-α better than those receiving 30 MIU weekly.
Although IFN-α was well tolerated, increased MS relapses were seen in the 5 MIU group, where 3 who had received for the full 24 weeks of IFN-α treatment, relapsed within 6 weeks of stopping their IFN-α treatment.The highest 30 MIU dosage was not so well tolerated and 2 withdrew prior too 52 weeks because of adverse experience.One of these two in the 30 MIU dose group that completed through week 52 had developed chronic progressive disease.

COMMENT
We report a significant decrease of IT IgG synthesis at 12 weeks of natural human IFN-alpha (IFN-α): therapy in RRMS.Although not reaching significance, values at 26 weeks, 2 weeks after stopping drug, values were much lower than those prior to treatment.Of interest, IT IgG Synthesis appeared to have ceased at 52 weeks in 3 higher dosage groups (15, 20, and 25 MIU weekly; NS).Our results clearly differ from earlier reports on the use of lymphoblastoid interferon alpha [5] and use of recombinant IFN-α-2b in "chronic progressive" MS [6].Additionally, in the lowest dosage group in the current study, 5 MIU weekly, there appeared to be a withdrawal effect with relapses and a measurable increase of IT IgG Synthesis shortly after cessation of treatment in 3 subjects.These results suggest a dosage range between 15 and 25 MIU of natural IFN-α may be optimal for future study.
Corticotrophin and steroids reduce IT IgG synthesis promptly but only transiently [1,9].The only report of the impact of interferon-beta, (an Italian intrathecal interferon-beta trial), did not show clinical benefit to the patients and resulted in increased numbers of oligoclonal bands (OCB) [10].Most recently natalizumab (Tysabri®) was reported to decrease the number of oligoclonal bands in CSF [11].These and other reports also suggest that increasing numbers of OCB in CSF reflects increased IgG synthesis in MS, with disease progression, despite treatment [10][11][12][13].Data showing a correlation between increased IT IgG Synthesis and increased OCB has not been published.
Explanation of the differences in our findings from the earlier demonstration of increased IT IgG Synthesis with IFN-α treatment reflect at least two possible factors, operating separately or together: 1) relapsing-remitting patients have fundamentally different biological processes than progressive disease, [14,15] and, 2) the synthetic interferon products differ in many respects from the highly purified natural products [16,17].Numerous observations support the first explanation.However, the presence of 18 different fully glycosylated forms of interferons alpha, that comprises the natural product, may well provide an alternative explanation.Certainly, immune responses to "contaminants" like C1q in natural IFN-α [16] could contribute to benefit from the product, or may decrease any benefit.
Clinical experience with IFN-α products has shown a difference in adverse experience.Previously lymphoblastoid interferon increased both serum and CSF IgG with increased IT IgG synthesis is associated with prominent adverse experience [18].This type of experience was not reported with Cantell standard IFN-α in MS [3] nor has it occurred with natural IFN-α products in our trial and off-label with MS [7] and human retrovirus as-sociated myelopathy (HAM/TSP) [19].Reasons for this difference in clinical experience with IFN-α are unknown.Adverse experience with higher doses in the management of hepatitis is well known [17,20].
In summary, use of natural human IFN-α in the originnal MS trial [3] and the current clinical population was generally well tolerated.It resulted in long lasting clinical benefit in many of the subjects; particularly those receiving higher doses that appeared to result in cessation of IT IgG synthesis.Apart from the relevance to the biology of RRMS, these collective observations suggest that normalizing IT IgG synthesis in RRMS may be an effective biomarker for clinical efficacy.The measurement of IT IgG Synthesis may be an important and useful tool for selection of therapeutic products for study in RRMS such as highly purified natural human interferon alpha.

Table 1 .
Demographics for 24 MS patients entered into the dose ranging trial of INF-α.