A Rare Case of Atypical Recalcitrant Hailey-Hailey Disease and a Literature Review

Hailey-Hailey disease also known as familial benign chronic pemphigus is a rare bullous genodermatosis that affects intertriginous area symmetrically. It presents with flaccid blisters, erosions and maceration resulting in increased morbidity, reduced quality of life for affected patients. It is rare in occurrence with an incidence of rate of 1 in 50,000. It is diagnosed with a combination of clinical and histopathological findings. While there is no known cure, its relapsing remitting course can be managed with medication. This case describes an unusual presentation of familial benign chronic pemphigus with a late age of onset of symptoms, atypical distribution and resistant to multiple therapies.


Introduction
First described by the Hailey brothers in 1939, Hailey-Hailey disease also known as familial benign chronic pemphigus is a rare genodermatosis inherited in an autosomal dominant fashion with complete penetrance and variable expressivity [1] [2] [3] [4]. Though the exact aetiology factor is unknown, defect in keratinocyte adhesion had been noted in the pathophysiology of the condition [5]. It could also coexist with other medical conditions with skin manifestations which could add to the difficulty in diagnosis [6] [7].
Given its rare nature, diagnosis may be missed, and commencement of treatment delayed often prolonging patient's distress [8]. A combination of clinical

Discussion
Our patient had Hailey Hailey's disease, a rare skin condition with an estimated incidence of 1/50,000 without any predilection for any gender or ethnic group.
[2] it would initially present as painful flaccid vesicle and blistering lesions on a background of erythematous skin, resulting in erosions, fissures, scales, and maceration, these lesions often occur symmetrically in intertriginous regions [5].
Most patients will present in the second to third decade of life and very rarely as in our patient, it can present in the fifth decade of life [9]. Clinically, it presents with painful, flaccid vesicles and blisters on a background of erythematous skin resulting in erosions, fissures, scales, and maceration. Malodourous discharges and yellow crust can be seen with superinfection. The lesions are distributed symmetrically in intertriginous areas, such as the axillae, inguinal areas, nape, lateral aspect of the neck, inframammary folds, retro-auricular fold, perineum, and back [10]. Rarely, it presents with unilateral as well as mucosal or vulvar involvement [2]. It has chronic, relapsing-remitting course and frequently exacerbated by excessive sweating, heat, sun exposure, skin trauma, friction from cloths, patch testing, moisture, and herpes infection [11]. These exacerbations worsen during the summer months and may be reduced by wearing loose-fitting, light-weight clothing and avoiding activities that result in sweating or skin friction [12]. Common complication associated with HHD is colonization and secondary infections with bacterial, fungal, or viral microorganism. However, on rare occasion these patients may have an increased risk of squamous cell carcinoma [10].
The diagnosis is suggested clinically based on characteristic distribution of lesion with involvement of intertriginous areas, and a positive family history. Confirmation of diagnosis is made with histology, which shows characteristic pathologic feature of intraepidermal vesicles and bullae with suprabasalar acantholysis. This has been described as dilapidated brick wall appearance [2].
Due to its rare, chronic relapsing and remitting course, and lack of gold standard treatment despite myriad of options, this condition poses a significant challenge to physicians and greatly affects the patient's quality of life [3]. Different therapeutic modalities have been used for the treatment of HHD. However, no cure is available as the various therapeutic strategies used are for symptoms control, reducing recurrence and improving patient's quality of life [4].
Nonpharmacological measures that can improve outcomes in patients with HHD include lifestyle modifications and patient education. This involves avoiding or limiting exposure to exacerbating factors. Example of these measures include wearing of soft and loose clothing and underwear, weight control, and reduced physical activity that increase friction against skin surface [3].
Pharmacological therapies may show short-term benefit, but generally do not induce prolonged remissions, and are limited by their long-term use and side effect. They include topical/intralesional corticosteroids, topical and/or systemic antibiotics, and antifungals. Reports have shown some benefit with topical vitamin D analogues, dapsone, cyclosporine, methotrexate, Naltrexone, alitretinoin, azathioprine, intradermal botulinum toxin, thalidomide, and topical tacrolimus, in recalcitrant cases [9] [10].
Long term treatment measures shown to achieve prolonged remission and even cure in some cases include surgical treatment (wide excision with splitthickness grafting, primary closure, healing by secondary intention) and dermabrasion. However, they are associated with increase morbidity such as scar contractures, limited mobility, venous thromboembolism, graft failure, infections, and cosmetic issues [13]. Case Reports in Clinical Medicine On the other hand, laser therapy (CO 2 Lasers, Erbium: YAG Lasers, Radiofrequency Ablation, Vascular Lasers, and Diode Lasers) are less invasive, safe, and effective treatment for HHD with good side effect profile [14]. While this therapy provides faster healing, less scarring and can be done as a day case in an outpatient setting using local anaesthetic, dyspigmentation is common side-effects [14].
With onset of symptom at 59 years, our patient presented with late-onset HHD compared to the typical age of onset in the third decade of life [1]. Furthermore, she had a mixture of the classic presentation of HHD, with symmetrically distributed, recurrent erosions in the axillae, sub-mammary areas, groin, and atypical presentation in the lower back area.

Conclusions
This case clearly highlights the challenge behind the treatment of HHD, which can be refractory to multiple known therapies and can significantly reduce patients' quality of life.
It should be noted that though rare, Hailey Hailey's disease can occur in non-intertriginous areas such as the back.
Clinicians should have a high index of suspicion in diagnosing patients presenting with late onset disease.

Conflicts of Interest
We have no competing interest.

Authors' Contributions
Udoka Ogbuneke, Emmanuel Odega, Yakub Ibrahim and Mustapha Abubakar contributed equally to gathering information, literature search, writing this case, overall supervision, and review of the piece. We have read and agreed to the final manuscript.

Informed Consent
Our patient gave her consent for the use of her clinical information and images for this case report.
Written consent was taken from the patient prior to the preparation of this manuscript.