Experimental Study on Performance and Combustion Analysis of a Diesel Engine Fueled with Diesel and Jatropha Oil Blended with Heptane

This work focuses on blending Jatropha oil with diesel fuel and heptane to improve its physico-chemical characteristics for production of blends and their use as fuel in a diesel engine. The influence of the heptane content was evaluated by comparing the results obtained from the engine (performance and combustion parameters) with those of the diesel fuel and straight Jatropha oil. The results obtained show an improvement in engine performance especially at low loads. Specifically, a reduction in the specific fuel consumption of the engine is obtained when the heptane content in the mixture is around 10% compared to that obtained with pure Jatropha oil. The best results were obtained with the blend containing 70% Jatropha oil, 20% diesel fuel and 10% heptane (J70G20H10). Overall engine efficiency and exhaust gas temperatures are comparable for all fuels tested. Engine combustion parameters are improved with J70G20H10. The results obtained with J70G20H10 are close to those of the engine operating on diesel fuel. The cyclic dispersion is low with coefficients of variation of the indicated mean effective pressure (COV IMEP ) whose values are less than 10%. The lowest values of the COV IMEP are obtained with the blend J70G20H10.


Introduction
Energy plays an important role in social and economic development of a country [1]. Indeed, the energy access is an important factor in food and industrial development and in the provision of social services to improve people living conditions. Particularly for sub-Saharan African countries, the poor access to modern energy services is glaring. For example, the electrification rate in this region was about 42.8% in 2016 [2], compared to some regions of the world (Middle East, North Africa, etc.) where this rate is above 90%. This energy gap affects more the populations in rural areas. Indeed, more than 80% of the population in these regions has no access to electricity [2]. To overcome this energy gap, renewable energies such as solar, wind, hydro, biomass, etc. are good alternatives. One of these interesting alternatives is the production and use of biofuels, in particular vegetable oils.
Vegetable oils can be produced locally to meet energy needs and they are not subject to the intermittency of the energy source as observed for other sources such as solar, wind etc. Thus, the combustion of vegetable oils in diesel engines has been the subject of many studies [3]- [11]. Most of these studies highlighted that the direct use of vegetable oils in a diesel engine could lead to many problems if certain conditions are not met. The main problems encountered are carbon deposits on certain parts of the engine, power and efficiency decreases, fuel over-consumption, fuel jet pumping and spraying problems, etc. [4] [8] [12] [13]. These problems are related to thermal conditions in the combustion chamber and the physical and chemical nature of vegetable oils (low volatility, fatty acid composition, high viscosity) [3] [5] [14]. Indeed, vegetable oils are mainly made up of fats (triglycerides) at more than 95% and 5% of free fatty acids, sterols, waxes, and other minority compounds. These fats are difficult to ignite and they polymerize on the engine cold parts when thermal conditions in the combustion chamber are not established (especially at low loads).
Most of technological solutions (from the literature) to improve the physico-chemical characteristics of vegetable oils (fuel preheating, oil esterification, diesel-oil blends or emulsions of oil and alcohol or water) still present some limits: ineffectiveness to overcome problems encountered, high costs, complex implementation in some areas etc. Recent work on the evaporation of vegetable oils droplets has shown that triglyceride break down into light and flammable volatile materials (alcohols, alkanes, alkenes, etc.) which, when they reach a critical threshold amount, ignite and trigger combustion [7] [14] [15]. Thus the formulation of fuels based on vegetable oils and light compounds such as alkanes can be a good way to overcome some problems observed with straight vegetable oils, specifically at low engine loads. When considering alkanes, heptane appears also like a good cetane number improver that can be used. However, there is few work in the literature on heptane as material to boost the combustion of vegetable oils in diesel engines. So the main objective of this work is to produce mixtures made from Jatropha oil, heptane and diesel fuel, whose combustion in a diesel engine gives performance and combustion parameters better to those obtained with straight Jatropha oil and close to those obtained with diesel fuel. It is expected that heptane and diesel will create an important mass of volatile and flammable compounds during the ignition process and improve the whole combustion.
To assess the combustion quality, a detailed analysis of the combustion cycles in the engine (cyclic dispersion) has been carried out. This work is part of a research effort led by the authors to develop sustainable technologies for the use of vegetable oils in specific applications. The emissions and the carbon deposit are expected to be measured in a future paper.

Engine Test Bench
The tests were carried out at "Laboratoire de Physique et de Chimie de l'Environnement" of the Université Joseph KI-ZERBO (Burkina Faso). A Lister diesel engine is installed on a test bench. It is a water-cooled indirect injection diesel engine with a maximum power output of 7.35 kW. It is coupled, using transmission belts, to a generator that produces the electrical current necessary for the diesel engine load. The characteristics of the engine and generator are given in Table 1. The test bench consists of the engine, the current generator, a fuel consumption measurement system, an engine combustion parameter acquisition system and a resistive load bench (consisting of 150 W, 500 W and 1000 W lamps respectively used to apply an electrical load to the generator). The schematic diagram of the experimental set-up is given in Figure 1. For the measurement of the cylinder pressure, a KISTLER piezoelectric sensor type 6125C11 was used. The signals received from the sensor are amplified by a KISTLER 5011B charge amplifier. For the measurement of the injection pressure, a KISTLER piezoresistive sensor type 4067C3000A2 was used. This sensor is connected to a signal conditioner that amplifies the voltage variations measured by the sensor. The two signals from these sensors are collected by a National instruments NI 9215 acquisition module. Three type K thermocouples are used to measure the ambient air temperature, exhaust gas temperature and engine lubricating oil temperature. The thermocouples are connected to National instruments NI 9211 module. A KISTLER angle encoder type 2614C11 is used to clock the signals received from the various sensors with a resolution of 720 points per cycle. Lab-VIEW is used to record the different signals. The average sample selected is 100 cycles; this number offers a good accuracy for the calculations [16]. Figure 2 illustrates the procedure used for all tests. The characteristics of diesel fuel and Jatropha oil are given in Table 2.

Test Procedure
The overall performances considered in this study are fuel specific consumption, thermal efficiency and exhaust gas temperature. The combustion parameters are ignition delay, rate of heat release and cyclic dispersion.
For the estimation of the fuel ignition delay, the start of combustion was identified with the injection curve and the ignition start of combustion corresponding of the first positive point of curve of heat release rate after the injection of fuel. The heat release rate was determined from Equation (1) [18].  with P the gas pressures in the cylinder, V the volume of the combustion chamber as a function of the crank angle, This parameter is obtained from the Equation (2) [18].
with A gas-wall contact surface, h heat transfer coefficient (in this work, the coefficient used is the one of hohenberg), T the instantaneous gas temperature, T wall the temperature of the walls and ω angular speed.
Cyclic dispersion was evaluated using variations in the indicated mean effective pressure for the number of mean samples selected. The coefficient of variation of the indicated mean effective pressure is the most commonly parameter used for a quantitative evaluation of cyclic dispersion [18]. So, this coefficient, given by Equation (3), were used in this work [18] [19] [20].
with Std IMEP : the standard deviation of the indicated mean pressure and IMEP : the average indicated mean effective pressure.

Formulations
The formulation consists of mixing different components that do not react with each other and whose purpose is to obtain a final product with particular properties for a given use. The vegetable oil used in this work is Jatropha oil for its availability and it is non-edible. The contents of Jatropha oil retained for the formulations are 70%, 80% and 90%. In fact, the proportions of vegetable oils in blends or emulsions are generally low (less than 40%) to ensure proper engine operation [3] [5]. The idea is to reverse the trend by using high contents of Jatropha oil in the formulation so that to get a maximum level of biofuel used. The two other components used are conventional diesel fuel and heptane. Diesel fuel has been chosen because it is the reference fuel in this type of engine. Heptane has been chosen due to the fact that it is generally used as fuel in the modelling of diesel combustion in diesel engines [21]. Furthermore, it has a high cetane number (56) and can therefore be used as a pro-cetane additive to improve the flammability of the mixture. Some work have shown that adding "procetane" fuels up to 8% to vegetable oils improves their combustion in diesel engines by reducing ignition delay in a similar way to those obtained for diesel fuel [22] [23]. The proportion of heptane in blends ranged from 0 to 10% in steps of 5%. The different formulations used and their characteristics (determined in this work) are given in Table 3.    [26]. However, the specific fuel consumption of the engine with products containing at least 10% heptane remains higher than those obtained with diesel fuel (around 10% -13% for the case of J90H10). The blend whose specific fuel consumption is close to that obtained with diesel is J70G20H10. Comparable thermal efficiencies are observed regardless of the fuel used (diesel, vegetable oil and blends). But it can be observed, when comparing the thermal efficiencies obtained with these different fuels, that the thermal efficiency is improved for blends containing 10% heptane compared to that of Jatropha oil. Figures 5(a)-(c) show the engine exhaust gas temperatures for different loads when operating with diesel, vegetable oil and its derivatives.

Results of Engine Performances
The influence of heptane on engine exhaust gas temperature can be noted for all the loads studied. Compared to diesel fuel, engine exhaust temperatures are   high with blends particularly at low loads (of the order of 5% to 10% at 26% loads applied to the engine). Using heptane in the formulation results in a slight decrease in engine exhaust gas temperatures compared to those obtained with pure Jatropha oil. However, this drop is not significant in view of the order of magnitude of the uncertainties (of the order of 3%), because the addition of relatively small quantities of heptane does not allow significant differences to be observed on a macroscopic parameter such as the exhaust temperature. Nevertheless, one of the blend records Energy and Power Engineering a relatively interesting decrease in exhaust gas temperature, namely J70G20H10 (6% for 26% load applied to the engine). This can be due to the combined effect of heptane and diesel in the formulation allowing a reduction in engine exhaust temperature.  phase increases relatively with the heptane content in the blend (especially for fuel J70G20H10, which is comparable to that obtained with J40G60 and diesel fuel) compared to that of vegetable oil (Table 4). This increase in the premix  phase is due, on the one hand, to an improvement in the flammability of the mixture (increase in the overall cetane number of the mixture [23] [27]). On the other hand, this is due to an improvement in the fuel spray that is related to a reduction in the viscosity of the blend when both diesel and heptane proportions are increased. The reduction in viscosity of the mixture is 144% compared to that of Jatropha oil measured at the same temperature. This improves the spray droplets size and their vaporization. As a result, the blend, J70G20H10 vaporizes easily with finer droplets than oil and ignites quickly, giving a higher kinetic peak. Diffusing combustion phases are relatively lower when adding heptane and diesel in the blends compared to those obtained with Jatropha oil (Table 4). This supports the drop obtained in engine exhaust temperature as the heptane and diesel content increases in the formulation. For all the tests carried out, the combustion cycles are regular because the values of the coefficient of variation of the indicated mean effective pressure do not exceed 10% for all the loads tested and regardless the fuel used (this limit is set by the literature) [18]. Previous work has shown that combustion in the type of engine used is more stable compared to the direct injection engine [22]. However, depending on the type of fuel, or the load, the differences in cyclic dispersion become more or less important.

Results of Engine Combustion Parameters: Ignition Delay, Heat Release Rate and Cyclic Dispersion
The instabilities of engine combustion cycles (cyclic dispersion) decreases with the increase in heptane content in the blend especially at low loads. Engine combustion cycles stability specifically improve with J70G20H10 blend. This could be explained by the combined effect of heptane (10%) and diesel (20%) in the blend. Especially for this fuel, the values of the COV IMEP are lower compared to those of vegetable oil and similar to those of the J40G60 blend and very close to that of diesel fuel (Figure 8). This blend has a relatively short fuel ignition delay. Indeed, the phenomena that occur during the delay phase (quantity of fuel Energy and Power Engineering vaporized, quantity and reactivity of the air-fuel premix, etc.) are less repeatable when the fuel ignition delay is long [28] [29] [30].
Previous work has shown that there is a correlation between cyclic dispersion, premix combustion peak and fuel ignition delay extension. However, the high premix is not always a prerequisite for the occurrence of gas fluctuation (or resonance) in the cylinder, other random effects can also induce cycle oscillation [29]. So, even if the premix phase is important with J70G20H10, this seems to have limited effect on the stability its combustion. The results obtained for cyclic dispersion are consistent with the engine performance results, i.e., fuels that lead to instabilities in the combustion cycle also lead to a deterioration in engine performance. The differences in cycles stability are small for all fuels tested at high load. This is consistent with the results of previous studies on the tendency of vegetable oils, their derivatives and diesel fuel (delays, evaporation constants, etc.) to have a single behavior due to the high temperature levels favorable to the degradation of all the products formed during the combustion process [5] [14].
These observations reflect the improvement in the flammability of the mixture with heptane (10% proportion) and consequently the improvement and regularity of the cycles. Figure 9 show a multi-criteria diagram of variations in engine parameters with the various blends compared to those obtained with pure Jatropha oil at 26% of load.
By comparing the variations in engine parameters using formulations, compared to pure Jatropha oil, the blend J70G20H10 stands out. The engine operating  on it shows a significant improvement in the parameters considered compared to pure Jatropha oil and the other blends.

Conclusions
The aim of this work was to determine blends from Jatropha oil, diesel fuel and heptane with improved combustion conditions in the engine. Analysis of engine performance, combustion parameters and particularly cyclic dispersion shows that: -Increasing the heptane content in the blends improves its energy density and leads to a reduction in the specific fuel consumption of the engine compared to that obtained with pure vegetable oil. This specific fuel consumption of the engine is close to that obtained with diesel. This improvement in specific engine fuel consumption is greatest for J70G20H10; however, the overall efficiencies of the engine operating on all the blends are very close to those obtained with diesel. -Engine exhaust gas temperatures decrease relatively as the heptane content in the blends increases. -The influence of the heptane content in the blends on the ignition delay is relatively small. There is a slight decrease in fuel ignition delays as the heptane content increases in the blends. -The flammability of blends is improved with the proportion of heptane in the mixture. This is shown by significant kinetic peaks compared to the results obtained with pure Jatropha oil. It should also be noted that the kinetic combustion peaks are similar to those obtained with diesel. -Cyclic dispersion is less important when the heptane content in the blend is around 10%. For formulations based on Jatropha oil, diesel fuel and heptane, the best results are obtained with J70G20H10 fuel.
Globally, the results show that the use of Jatropha oil, blended with diesel fuel and heptane is relevant to improves the combustion of Jatropha oil. Further investigation on the engine emissions and carbon deposits, when using the various blends tested, is needed for better assessment of the relevance.