Assessment of Diarrheal Disease Management Practice in Under-Five-Year Children According to WHO Guideline in Health Facilities of Hawassa City, SNNPR, Ethiopia

Objective: To explore the practice of management of diarrhea in under-5-year children at health facilities found in Hawassa town, and associated factors with malpractice in comparison. Methodology: Cross Sectional study was conducted in 2 hospitals, 2 health centers and 2 private clinics that are found in Hawassa city which is found in Southern Nations, Nationalities and peoples (SNNP), 275 KM to south from Addis Ababa, capital city of Ethiopia from august 2017-October 2017. Structured checklist was used to retrieve the required information from the patients on arrival and stay in pediatrics OPDs and wards. The data analysis carried out using SPSS version 20.0. Logistic regression was carried out to analyze the association between the independent and dependent variables. Statistically significant associations were declared at p-values of less than or equal to 0.05. Results: Out of 420, about 397 (94.5%) children with diarrheal disease between the ages of 3 59 months were studied. The study subjects were from governmental hospitals (35.5%), health centers (34.5%) and private clinics (30%) that are found in Hawassa City. Sign of dehydration was 66 (17%) of which majority 59 (83%) of them were rehydrated. As to Zink supplementation, only 180 (45%) received it; antibiotics were the commonly (59.1%) prescribed drugs. Only 43.3% of children were appropriately managed. Hospitals had higher odds of inappropriate management of diarrhea with AOR = 1.61 (95% CI: 1.04 2.5) and children one year or younger were more inappropriately managed for diarrhea at the health facilities with AOR of 2.3 (95% CI: 1.57 4.41). Conclusions: In the current study the management of diarrhea at the health facilities is unsatisHow to cite this paper: Huluka, U.A. and Dessiso, A.H. (2020) Assessment of Diarrheal Disease Management Practice in Under-Five-Year Children According to WHO Guideline in Health Facilities of Hawassa City, SNNPR, Ethiopia. Health, 12, 1345-1359. https://doi.org/10.4236/health.2020.1210096 Received: August 29, 2020 Accepted: October 12, 2020 Published: October 15, 2020 Copyright © 2020 by author(s) and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY 4.0). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Open Access U. A. Huluka, A. H. Dessiso DOI: 10.4236/health.2020.1210096 1346 Health factory as only less than half of children with diarrhea were properly managed. Treatment of diarrhea at hospital level and the patient’s age being less than 1 year were found to significantly affect the level of mismanagement of the diarrheal disease. Therefore, orientation and trainings for health care providers especially GPs and Residents should be given to adhere to recommended zinc therapy, Oral Rehydration Salts (ORS) replacement therapy and rational antibiotics prescription.


Introduction
Diarrhea is defined as passage of 3 or more unusually loose stool or watery stool of any frequency within 24 hrs [1]. Diarrheal disease remains second cause of death in under-5-year children globally [2]. According to WHO report each year there are about 2 billion cases of diarrheal disease in under-5-year children of which 1.9 million die [3]. In Africa, 800,000 children die each year from diarrhea and dehydration which account for 25% to 75% of all childhood diseases [4].
Ethiopia has one of the highest under-five mortality rates with more than 321,000 children under the age of five dying every year and 20% of the deaths are attributed to diarrheal diseases [5]. Furthermore, according to Ethiopia Demographic Health Survey (DHS) 2016, 12% of children younger than 5 years of age had diarrhea in the preceding two weeks and the figure was as high as 23% amongst children 6 -11 months of age [6]. More than three-quarters of all diarrheal deaths could be prevented with full coverage and utilization of ORS and adjunct zinc supplementation [7]. There is evidence that ORS may reduce diarrhea specific mortality by as high as 93% [8]. In sub-Saharan Africa, only about one in three children experiencing diarrheal episodes receive ORS, and the proportion receiving zinc is below 5% [9]. Coverage of ORS from 2005-2014 in Ethiopia was 26% and the coverage of zinc during the same period was amazingly nil (0%) [10].
According to WHO Guidelines, children that will be benefited from antibiotics are only those with bloody diarrhea (probable shigellosis), suspected cholera with severe dehydration, and serious associated non-intestinal infections such as pneumonia [1]. "Antidiarrheal" and anti-emetics drugs didn't show benefits for children with acute or persistent diarrhea and some may even end with fatal side effects [1].
Appropriate management of children with diarrheal disease requires basic knowledge & essential clinical evaluation skills for identifying possible etiology, hydration status, identifying predisposing factors and doing necessary investigations [11]. Although mismanagement and malpractice of families during man- 1347 Health agement of children with diarrheal disease at home, like preventing from fluid intake including feeding, may contribute much for the deaths [12], it is difficult to argue that the management of children who sake medical care is optimal.
Antimicrobial resistance is dramatically increasing worldwide in response to antibiotic use but much of it is due to inappropriate over uses and causing significant morbidity and mortality [13]. Irrational use of drugs does not benefit children with diarrheal disease and may even harm by resulting in unwanted adverse effects and resistance of antimicrobials [13]. In addition to this, it will impose unnecessary costs for the family as well as for the country [13].
The use of treatment guidelines based on clinical presentation is common in developing countries due to unavailability of laboratory services and patient overload [14].

Study Design and Study Population
A health facility based cross sectional study was conducted in 2 hospitals (one of which is teaching referral hospital), 2 health centers and 2 private clinics that are found in Hawassa city from August 2017 to October 2017. The target population of our study was Children under five years of age with diarrheal disease who visit the randomly selected health centers, private clinics and hospitals during study period.
Inclusion criteria: -Children from age between 2 months and 5 years with diarrhea.
-Children who visited health centers in the study period. Health -Participants who signed informed consent.
Exclusion criteria: -Children who were already on treatments before they visit the health institution.
-Infants younger than two months of age and older than five years of age.
-Children who developed diarrhea while they were in the hospital.
-Children who have diarrheal lasting more 14 days.
-Participants who refuse to participate in the study and those with incomplete patient data were excluded.

The Sample Size Determination
The sample size was calculated by using formula where: n = the minimum sample size required. p = prevalence of inappropriate practice of diarrheal disease management from study conducted in health centers of Addis Ababa [16]. D = the margin of tolerance. Z = the standard normal variation at confidence level.
The minimum sample size required was obtained by taking a prevalence rate of 54% (0.54) and confidence interval of 95% and the margins of error is 5% (0.5).
The sample was calculated as

Sampling Procedure
Preliminary data on patient load of the hospitals, private clinics and health centers for under-5-year children who were diagnosed to have diarrheal disease was collected. Number of institutions that were required for data collection in order to get the calculated sample size in above mentioned study period was estimated.
Among the hospitals, pediatric patient flow was found to be very minimal in the 4 private hospitals and the 2 governmental hospitals were selected without using any sampling method. 2 Health centers were selected using simple lottery method. Among 3 private pediatrics clinics, 2 were selected using simple lottery sampling methods. Data collection process continued during the study period till above stated quota was filled.

Study Variables
Dependent variable: practice of diarrheal disease management.
Independent variables are categorized as follows:

Data Collection Technique and Management
The structured and pretested checklist was developed after reviewing relevant literature to include all the possible variables that address the objectives of the study. The data collectors had selected eligible children during triage by asking their complaints and then took consent if the caregivers are willing to participate in the study. The data collectors filled some of the data like socio-demography and complaints of patient initially. The other components of the questioners like investigations and medications given to the child were filled after they finished their stay either from the card or checking medications from prescription paper.
The treating health personnel were blinded about the ongoing study in order to avoid bias.

Data Processing and Analysis
SPSS version 20 software package was used for data entry as well as analysis.
Descriptive statistics like frequencies and percentages were used to summarize the socio-demographic characteristics of the study participants calculated to describe findings while binary logistic regression was used for looking association in variables. Those variables showing p value < 0.25 with outcome variables in the bivariate analysis and deemed to be important from previous study were selected as candidate variables for multivariable logistic regression analysis. Before further analyses were carried out using multivariable analysis, multicollinearity was checked among selected independent variables using the variance inflation factor and none was found. Additionally, Goodness of fit of the final model was checked by Hosmer and Lemeshow and was found fit. p value less than 0.05 was taken as statistically significant.

Data Quality Control
From every selected study center one nurse was selected and all the selected nurses were given one day intensive training on the aim of the study, data collection tools and informed consent process. They were also trained on how to assess for malnutrition and dehydration. To ensure data quality, pretest of data collection was done in 40 patients (5%) that were not included in the data for the final study. Trained nurses under the supervision of the investigator have done the data collection. The treating health personnel were not informed about the ongoing study in order to avoid bias.

Ethical Consideration
Ethical clearance was obtained from Hawassa University, College of Medicine and Health Science Institutional Review Board. The permission to conduct the study was obtained from the regional health office and administrators of respective health institutions. The information from the patient was kept confidential, only the data collector had the access to information, which talks about the patient information other than the topic of interest. The study participants were not harmed by any means for their involvement in the study.

Demography of Study Participants
Among the total 420 selected participants, 397 mothers/caretakers having children between the ages of 3 -59 months were studied giving a response rate of

Characteristics of Diarrhea in Children 3 -59 Months
The duration, type, frequency and management of diarrhea in under-5-year children assessed and presented in Table 2. Accordingly, most of 357 (90%) of the children presented to the health facilities within the 72 hours of diarrhea, and the diarrhea was mostly (240, 60.5%) watery in type, and up 3 -4 times in frequency per day in 297 (75%) of the cases. In addition, vomiting was complained by nearly half, 185 (46.6%) of the children with diarrhea, and cough or shortness of breath was complained by one fifth of the study participants (Table   2). Figure 1 shows immunization status of studied children and found that majority 372 (93.7%) were either completed or up-to-date vaccinated. The defaulters and unvaccinated children were 3.8% and 1.3% respectively for unknown reasons.  As per WHO diarrhea management guidelines the appropriate diarrhea management practices was 172 (43.3%) while, more than half, 225 (56.7%) were inappropriately managed at the health facilities. Accordingly, after multivariable analyses only child age and health institution type were found to be statistically associated with malpractices of diarrhea in <5 years children, while the rest variables lost association after the model.

The Factors Associated with Management Practices of Diarrhea in Under-Five-Year Children
Age of children with diarrhea was found to be associated with diarrhea management malpractices in that those children ≤ 1 year were about one and half   59.1% of the children received antibiotics. The appropriate management practices of diarrhea among 2 -59 months children was 43.3%.

Discussion
In this study, 19% of children were diagnosed to have dehydration and majorities (83%) of them were rehydrated as per the recommendation. This is in line with the recommendations of FMOH guideline stating that the presence of dehydration, blood in the stool and duration of diarrhea should be assessed properly before initiating treatment, for it guides healthcare providers on the appropriate medications and other therapeutic interventions [5]. And also, the target of treating diarrheal disease should be to prevent and treat dehydration [17].
This study identified zinc supplementation to children with diarrhea as only 180 (45.3%). This result is comparative to the finding from study done at Addis Ababa Health centers (43.8%) and much higher than report of study from health centers of Iraq and Tanzania which were 1.25% and 28% respectively [14] [18].
However, this finding is in contrary to the WHO recommendations in the management of acute diarrhea to include zinc usage in combination with the supplementation of ORS [19]. This zinc supplementation found essential as the WHO and UNICEF brought attention to the impact of zinc in reducing the severity of the diarrheal episode and the number of subsequent acute diarrheal disease episodes in children younger than 5 years. As to the antibiotics prescription rate, this study distinguished about 234 (59.1%) of children to have received antibiotics. These findings are even higher than WHO estimate that more than 40% of the children with acute diarrhea in developing countries received antibiotics [20]. However, this result is not as significant as similar study conducted in Tanzania and Addis Ababa which shown 80% and 73% of children with acute diarrhea were given antibiotics respectively [14] [16]. These differences might be related to the study setting differences that this study included private and government institutions like hospitals while the latter were exclusively done at the public health centers. Unlike Indian study, which was conducted in New Delhi, which showed significant difference in antibiotics prescribing patterns between public and private institutions 43% and 69% respectively, there was no substantial difference (58.2% vs 61.3%) [21]. The current findings is supported by a body of science stating overprescribing, misuse of drugs including antibiotics as the most common problems of irrational drug use by prescribers as well as consumers [22].
Moreover, the findings of this study shows almost all (96%) of mothers were advised to provide ORS per loss to their children with diarrhea. This is in line with recommendation by WHO stating, unless the patient is comatose or severely dehydrated, ORS solution therapy is accepted as the gold standard to achieve clinically efficacious and cost-effective management of dehydration and its complication [23]. This finding shows much better practice with regard to ORS prescription when it is paralleled to WHO estimates which showed among children with acute diarrhea in developing Countries, less than 60% of them received ORS [20]. And, also consistent with other similar study done in Kenya reported ORS prescription rate by healthcare workers to be as high as 90% [19].
On the other hand, the finding of the current study is little bit higher to study conducted in Indian Hospitals reported 82% of children with diarrhea received ORS [24]. And much higher to study conducted in Addis Ababa Health centers which revealed 49.4% of children with diarrhea received ORS [16].
Malpractices like Antiemetic and Antidiarrheal agents' prescription were 3.4% and 0%. This is much lower than study done in Baghdad which showed 33.2% and 12.8% prescription of Antiemetic and Antidiarrheal agents respectively [18]. It is closer to finding of study from Addis Ababa health center showing only 7% of children were given Antiemetic with null Antidiarrheal prescription [16]. Stool microscopy was done for 344 (86.6%) of children who visited the health facilities with diarrheal complaint which is significantly higher than the study done at health centers of Addis Ababa which shown to be 37.4% [16]. When the necessity of stool microscopy was analyzed based on the type of diarrhea the rate of malpractice was found to be 56.3%. WBC count was done for 64 (16.1%) of children and 26.4% of the order were not rational.
Appropriate diarrhea management practices was 172 (43.3%) in the current study while, more than half, 225 (56.7%) were inappropriately managed. Similar to the current study, in Tanzania about 54% of watery diarrhea was managed inappropriately by healthcare providers [14]. Age of children with diarrhea was found to be statistically associated with inappropriate management practices of diarrhea in which those children ≤ 1 year were about one and half times more likely to be inappropriately managed compared with children aged above one year. This findings are similar to study conducted in Addis Ababa reporting appropriate management of diarrhea for children with 2 -11 months were 54% less compared to older children [16].
However, this association is in contrast with the study done in Tanzania where inappropriate antibiotic prescription was significantly associated with prescriber being a clinical officer and assistant medical officer instead of age and levels of health institutions providing diarrhea treatment [14]. Another variable showing strong association with inappropriate diarrhea management practices was health facilities where hospitals odd of malpractices was about three times higher compared to health centers. This indicates diarrhea management practices were unsatisfactory in Government Hospitals where children are mainly managed by General practitioners and Residents. This could be due to poor adherence to guidelines like IMNCI.

Conclusions and Recommendations
This study assessed patterns and appropriateness of diarrhea management practice among < 5 years children in health facilities at Hawassa City. The health professionals especially general practitioners and residents were not sticking to the guidelines regarding laboratory investigations, the use of zinc supplementation and antimicrobials prescription in management of diarrhea. Hence, majority of the children diagnosed with signs of dehydrations were rehydrated, while only 45% of the children with diarrhea supplemented with zinc. The pattern of antibiotics prescription shows more than half of the children received it to treat diarrhea. There is over investigating children with diarrheal disease. Diarrhea was inappropriately managed in more than half of the cases, and as a factor hospitals had higher odds of inappropriate management of diarrhea, and children one year or younger were more inappropriately managed for diarrhea at the health facilities.
From the findings of this study, it is recommended that: -Zinc prescription should be scaled up for the management of diarrhea in all the health facilities of Hawassa City. -The health professional at the government Hospitals should stick to the recommended WHO or IMNCI guidelines in the management of diarrhea. -Emphases should be given to the management of diarrhea in younger children aged 1 year or lower. -Further studies should be done to identify whether this malpractice is knowledge or attitude gap and then should be acted accordingly.