Sustainability of Sheep Fleece Utilization in Jordan as an Insulation Material to Decrease Environmental Pollution, Increase Farmers’ Income, and Create New Job Opportunities

This study is planned to investigate the problems associated with the wasted sheep fleece in Jordan and to suggest methods to decrease its environmental impact. Results indicate that sheep fleece in Jordan makes an excellent resource for buildings insulation material. A linear regression model is used to predict sheep number for the period (2017-2030). Based on the predicted number of Sheep an estimated annual average production of wool is found for the period (2017-2030) to be (3.586 × 10 3 ton). The average cost per kg of fleece produced is calculated to be 0.39 JD, and the estimated price of fleece per head, if market is available for raw fleece, is 1 JD. Average annual financial losses by farmers are calculated to be (3.743 × 10 6 JD) for the period 2002-2016, and they were estimated to be (9.421 × 10 6 JD) for the years 2017-2030. Physical characteristics of sheep-wool are presented and compared to other competitive insulation materials (polystyrene and rockwool). Sustainability of sheep-wool production to be utilized as an insulation material is found to be an excellent solution to the huge waste of wool with respect to farmers and National income and to the problems associated with environmental impact. Results can be generalized to similar cases worldwide.


Introduction
Sheep plays a very important role in the life of humanity. Besides providing by Awassi, which is a type of non-European origin and widely spread in southwest of Asia, especially in the Arabian Desert [7] [8]. The main purpose of acquisition of this breed is for dairy products and meat [9]. The range of stable length and diameter of Awassi wool fibers are (10 -19 cm) and (30 -45 μm), respectively [5]. The Awassi breed wool is considered as part of the 41% sheep wool produced worldwide [1]- [9]. Jordanian Awassi wool is of this type, which can be used only in carpet and blanket production, because its average fiber length is about 15 cm and its average fiber diameter is about 34 μm [5]. The weight of fleece produced by head of Awassi breed ranges between 1.5 and 3 kg [3]; however, a study on Jordanian sheep reported a value of 2.5 kg/head [10].
People of Jordan used to make bed mattresses and quilts from sheep wool. Also, they used to weave tents out of sheep wool as well as goat hair. These types of tents are used to protect people in winter rainy seasons and summer sunny seasons. However, modern style of living forced people to abandon sheep wool in favor of synthetic materials, which makes farmers exposed to two major challenges. The first one is the reduction of his yearly income because of closing the door to national fleece market, and the second is the accumulation of waste wool material. Therefore, sheep breeders are forced to burning the accumulated waste. As a solution, several sheep owners, burn their wool crop every year [11].
Besides the above problems that face sheep breeders, the environment also suffers from fleece waste accumulation. Burning such waste, launches several unwanted gases such as CO 2 , NO x , and SO 2 . Moreover, the other problem is the pollution by un-burned fleece, which cannot be decomposed easily, since it is reported that, the average time it takes to decompose such material is about fifty years [12].
Due to the economic circumstances experienced by Jordan as a country and the economic hardships that face the people, measures must be taken to create job opportunities and suitable market for the huge production of fleece every year. Only one previous study considered the fleece accumulation problem [10].
The study included the feasibility of establishing a firm that collects the pro- Therefore, the first objective of this study is to investigate the serious problems facing sheep Breeders with sheep fleece collection and the associated impact of its disposing on the environment. The second objective is to prove sustainability of wool production and to investigate Jordanian sheep-wool thermal characteristics. The third objective is to suggest solutions to the above problems through technology transfer.

Methodology
Data associated with specific objectives were obtained from different sources. First, Annual sheep numbers and their distribution were obtained from the statistical yearbook of Jordan [13]. Then, other data required were obtained from farmers' interviews, Jordan Industrial Estate Company (JIEC), and interviews of former glass wool (insulation material) factories owners in Jordan which had been closed for different reasons. After that, a simple mathematical regression model was used to predict the number of Sheep for the period (2017-2030). Also, experiments were performed to investigate the thermal characteristics of Jordanian sheep-wool and other thermal insulation materials that are used in the construction market in Jordan. Moreover, major sources of financial and environmental problems associated with sheep wool were investigated through local reports and sheep breeders' interviews. Finally, results were presented, discussed, and solutions were suggested.

Sheep Numbers and Distribution
Total number of Sheep and their distribution over all Jordanian northern, central, and southern regions were obtained from the statistical yearbook (2002-2016) (Department of Statistics) (DOS) [13] (Table 1). Northern region shows the highest percentage of Sheep holdings, and therefore the corresponding highest fleece production. The distribution of the average number of Sheep with respect to Jordanian Governorates (2002-2016) is presented in Figure 1. Hence, these data are used, in part, to decide on the location of the proposed industrial firm to produce a sustainable thermal insulation material. It is obvious that the lowest percent of sheep holdings is seen to be associated with Jerash governorate and the highest is in Mafraq governorate. Therefore, Mafraq governorate has an excellent potential to be an optimum incubator of sheep-wool thermal-insulation industry.
The total number of Sheep is observed to increase with time. The percent increase between 2002 and 2006 is about 38%, between 2006 and 2011 is about 15%, and between 2011 and 2016 is 44%. The average increase of sheep number is about 33% every 5 to 6 years.

Mathematical Model
To investigate the sustainability of sheep wool for any possible manufacturing  product, a mathematical model is to be used to predict the future sheep number.
Two mathematical models were investigated. The first one was the exponential growth model, and the second was the linear regression model. The general equ- ation of the exponential growth model is [14]: where K is Malthus factor, P is the sheep number, 0 P is the number at 0 t , and t is time in years.
Excel sheet was used to solve for the Equation (1) using available data (2002)(2003)(2004)(2005)(2006)(2007)(2008)(2009)(2010)(2011)(2012)(2013)(2014)(2015)(2016) to get K and R 2 as: To investigate the accuracy of the forecasting of both models, the mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) was calculated for both models as: where, t y is the actual value and t f is the forecast value. MAPE values for the exponential growth model and the linear regression model are reported in Table 2. The average value of MAPE for exponential growth model was 7.51%, whereas it was 7.49% for the linear regression model.   The interpretation of mean absolute percentage error MAPE values was suggested by Lewis [15] as follows: Less than 10% is highly accurate forecasting, 10% to 20% is good forecasting, 21% to 50% is reasonable forecasting and 51% and above is inaccurate forecasting. Values of MAPE for both models are less than 10%, which can be considered, according to Lewis (1982) [15], to be highly accurate forecasting models ( Table 2).
The results on sheep number prediction between 2017 and 2030 are shown in Table 3 and Figure 2 & Figure 3. For long-term prediction, exponential model gives high predicted numbers as compared with that predicted from linear regression model. In 2030, exponential model predicts the sheep number to be 6,018,282, while the linear regression model gives a value of 4,221,412. Therefore, to minimize the risk of over prediction of sheep numbers, we considered using the linear regression model for further analysis.

Major Losses Due to Wool-Waste
The major losses due to wasted wool are divided into two categories. The first    Table 4 shows the amount of wool produced between the years (2002-2016), the cost of the collection process, and the number of sheep each year obtained from DOS [13].
Applying these data, the corresponding specific cost of wool collection (JD/kg), and the yearly wool produced (kg/head) are calculated and reported in Table 4.
Taking the calculated average cost of collecting (mowing) 1 kg of wool to be 0.39 JD, (Table 4), and assuming the selling price of wool produced per head is 1JD, if suitable market is available [11], then total financial loss is calculated by adding the cost of collection to the estimated farmers' financial loss due to market un-availability and shown in Table 4.
The average of annual wool production (1.89 kg/head) and the average of the collected wool costs (0.39 JD/kg), shown in (Table 4) were used to estimate their corresponding values for the years (2017-2030) and were presented in Table 5.
The estimated total financial losses were, also, obtained by adding the financial losses due to lack of market availability to the collection costs ( Table 5).
The second part of losses is due to random disposal of the mowed fleece by Table 4. Wool produced and total cost of collection in Jordan (2002-2016) and the corresponding cost of wool (JD/kg), in addition to yearly wool produced (kg/head) (*Data obtained from reference [13]).
Year Yearly wool produced* (ton)  farmers. They collect the wool in medium size bags and dump them randomly at the sides of roads or dry valleys or through random burning process.
Their losses here are due to transportation cost. In addition to this, the environment suffers through land pollution due to random dumping, and air pollution due to the produced gases resulting from the burning of wool. Figure 4 shows a sample of disposed wool along the highway sides in Mafraq governorate [16]. Farmers suffer financially and physically, and they ask the Government for help to find possible industrial processes for their vast wool product [16].
Therefore, if this problem is not solved, livestock breeding will be at risk, the level of unemployment will increase, and rural area population will be partially depleted due to migration to the city.

Physical Characteristics of Jordanian Sheep Wool
Thermal characteristics represent the most important factor to decide the suitability of the material of being competitive to be used as an insulation material.
The thermal resistance R of the three materials was calculated using the following equation: ( ) Obtained R values for L = 0.05 m (R-5) are reported in Table 6. Sheep-wool thermal resistance is 1.515 ± 0.002 K/W, whereas it is 1.563 ± 0.002 K/W for polystyrene, and 1.471 ± 0.002 K/W for rockwool sample. Ignition temperature for sheep wool, polystyrene, and rockwool were measured using a temperature-controlled muffle furnace (100˚C -1200˚C). Each sample was placed in the furnace, and temperature is increased in steps of (25˚C). Then, the temperature was left to equilibrate, and the sample was observed at equilibrium state for 120 s. If no ignition is observed the temperature is increased for the next equilibrium state repeatedly until ignition is achieved. The ignition temperature of sheep wool was found to be (550˚C ± 12.5˚C), whereas, it was (800˚C ± 12.5˚C) for rockwool, and (500˚C ± 12.5˚C) for polystyrene which was observed to melt at about 100˚C (Table 6).
Sheep-wool is a good material to maintain constant relative humidity indoors

Possible Processes to Manufacture Fleece Product Ready for Marketing
Several approaches are possible processes to manufacture fleece product with acceptable revenues. However, a limited number of such approaches are feasible in the case of Jordanian fleece. One approach involves fleece collection, packaging, and marketing. This approach has been studied by "Productivity Promotion Centers" (IRADA), Jordanian Government, in 2003 [10], which was presented for investment purposes to establish a firm in Mafraq Governorate. Unfortunately, it failed to attract any investor, despite the provision of many government incentives. The second possible approach, which has never been proposed in Jordan, involves fleece collection, washing, and either to be used as buildings insulation material or blanket and mattress manufacturing. Cloth production from wool may be considered as another approach; however Jordanian sheep

Infrastructure Availability for Investment
Jordan Consequently, the presence of industrial cities in the densest areas for sheep, increases the feasibility of producing sustainable sheep-wool products.
All Industrial Cities include a complete infrastructure that involves internal roads, besides, electric, communications, water, sanitary, and rain drainage networks. They also include all necessary Governmental offices to provide easy and fast services. Moreover, the Jordanian Government reduces income tax to 5%, sales tax to 0%, custom tax to 0%, community service tax to 0% and shares profit distribution tax to 0% for all industrial activities carried out within industrial cities. Also, hangars necessary to construct production lines within these cities can be rented or bought at preferential rates.

Results and Discussion
Although collection of wool from sheep can be an important pillar of farmers' income as well as a significant contributor to the Gross National Income, however at this stage it causes a significant problem to both; farmers and the Government. Table 1  average value for both models less than 10%, which is considered, according to reference [15] highly accurate forecasting. However, as mentioned above, the linear regression model was favored above exponential growth model to avoid large discrepancies associated with long times under consideration. The average increase in actual sheep number for the 15 years period (2002-2016) is observed to be 123%, compared to a 92% increase for predicted results. Therefore, with this result and MAPE analysis, sustainability of wool production seems to be promising. Table 3  Based on the data presented in Table 4, an average value of wool produced per head was obtained to be 1.89 kg/head, which is different from the reported value of 2.5 kg/head reported by reference 10, however this estimated value lies within the reported literature values 1.5 to 3 kg. Results presented in Table 5 show a predicted annual average number of sheep was obtained to be 3,585,962 for the period 2017-2030 based on linear regression model. The annual estimated average of produced wool is 6778 ton, leading to an estimated total annual average loss of 9421 × 10 3 JD. This loss is borne by the farmer, which will be borne by the consumer through other farm products of meat, milk and cheese.
Moreover, the methods by which farmers dispose such huge amounts of wool, as mentioned above (Figure 4), create a continuing environmental problem that requires costly efforts borne on both, the farmer and the governmental environmental protection agencies. This environmental problem, if not solved, will affect the future of the livestock in Jordan. It will lead to force sheep breeders to abandon this profession in favor of finding other ways of living in the city, which will increase the rate of migration from rural area, and hence, will lead to an increase in un-employment rate. Eventually, livestock sector and the National Economy will suffer.
Starting wool industry in Jordan is one way to solve the above discussed prob- to construct the corresponding production lines, and the establishment of such industries will avoid just exporting wool as non-marketable raw material.
Moreover, massive construction expansion in Jordan due to forced immigration from neighboring countries in addition to the need of neighboring countries to rebuild after catastrophic wars indicates that the insulation material market will be favored over carpet blanket industry. Besides that, all the materials recently used in insulation for construction purposes are imported from outside the country. Therefore, insulation material industry is seen to be favored over the carpet and blanket industry which will be an option for the future. Machines and equipment required to start insulation industry are well established products worldwide, especially in China, and can be ready to be imported to build a production line, in addition to the available infrastructure within industrial cities and the different incentives given by the government of Jordan.
Because the number of sheep in Mafraq governorate is the largest in Jordan which accounts for 31% of the total (Figure 1), and the northern region including Mafraq accounts for 41% (Table 2), therefore, the optimum location for such an industry could be the industrial city of Mafraq. Sustainability of insulation industry with respect to wool availability is clearly seen from the results of the regression model and MAPE analysis that estimates the number of sheep for the period 2017-2030 (Table 5). An annual average number of sheep was predicted to be 3,585,962 head, and the corresponding estimated annual average wool produced is 6778 ton, which indicates a continuing source of wool to sustain the required raw material of this industry. in March 2019 [19]. It involves in implementation of a project to enhance the productivity and quality of sheep-wool in the Jordan desert. The program will last for three years with a total project funding of 1.84 million JD (2.6 million US$). It covers training of required employees on the new methods of mowing and collecting fleece with modern mechanization [19]. This also requires an employment of some veterinarians to supervise the mowing of wool to maintain animal safety. Therefore, employment opportunities will be created, which will be reflected on the National Economy. Moreover, starting a project involves production of insulation material from sheep-wool will be an added value to the new strategy of the Ministry of Agriculture towards "Rehabilitation of Badia (Jordanian Desert)".
Environmental impact of the current situation will be completely overcome if sheep-wool is used to produce insulation material or any other future possible product such as carpet and blanket industry. Achieving this goal will reduce the financial loss borne on the farmer as well as the National Environmental Agencies. Therefore, there will be a significant added value to the National Economy.
Landfill and water harvesting within Jordanian Badia will recover from the current impact of random disposal of wasted sheep-wool. As a result, the sheep breeders will have an environmental practice through mowing the wool in scientific ways that are harmless to the animal, under the supervision of veterinarians, and easily marketing the product to the line or lines of production. Moreover, production of thermal insulation material from sheep-wool will have a major contribution toward "Rehabilitation of Badia" and agrees well with the strategy launched by the Government of Jordan. Similar cases worldwide will benefit from the result of this study.
Comparing sheep-wool as a green building insulation material with popular material recently used in construction sector of Jordan, such as polystyrene boards of 3 cm thickness and rockwool, we find that sheep wool is better than both. Thermal conductivity data shows competitive values of sheep-wool to the other two. Also, its ignition temperature is high enough to be considered safe (550˚C). Polystyrene has low melting point (100˚C), and rockwool may affect the respiratory system of people, therefore they can be considered less competitive than sheep-wool. Both polystyrene and rockwool are either imported, in the case of Jordan, or the starting material are imported, while sheep-wool is renewably produced leading to lower the cost of insulation material. Therefore, utilization of sheep-wool in green building insulation material is better than other competitive materials.

Conclusion
Sustainability of Jordanian sheep wool, as a source of construction insulation material, can be a possible solution to the recent problems associated with wool waste. The results of this study are applicable to similar cases worldwide.