Overview of Industrial Materials Detection Based on Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation Analysis Technology

Prompt gamma neutron activation analysis (PGNAA) is a non-destructive online measurement nuclear analysis method. With its unique advantages, it has been widely used in online analysis of industrial materials such as coal, cement, and minerals in recent years. However, there are many kinds of lite-rature on PGNAA in the field of industrial materials detection, and there are still a few concluding articles. To this end, based on the principle of PGNAA online analysis, the status quo and development of the real-time online detection of industrial material components in the field are reviewed and discussed by consulting a large number of domestic and foreign PGNAA related litera-ture and data, to facilitate the reference of relevant scientific researchers.


Introduction
Industrial material composition real-time online detection technology is a real-time and accurate online analysis and detection technology for material composition in the process of industrial feeding and batching. It can be widely used in industrial production processes such as coal, cement and minerals. It is an important means to promote the upgrading and transformation of traditional heavy industry enterprises and to energy-saving and emission reduction.
At present, the main means of real-time online detection of industrial material components are: X-ray fluorescence analysis technology, infrared analysis, neutron activation analysis (NAA) and prompt gamma neutron activation analysis technology (PGNAA). Among them, due to the limitations of the characteristics of the radiation source used, X-ray fluorescence and infrared analysis techniques can only analyze the composition of the surface layer for bulk materials, but cannot perform volume analysis. NAA technology can be used for non-destructive measurement with high sensitivity and good accuracy, but it cannot be used for real-time online analysis. Moreover, it is more powerless for the determination of some light elements (such as H, B, N, P, etc.) [1]. The PGNAA technology has a significant advantage in the sensitivity of non-destructive light element analysis. At the same time, because both neutrons and γ-rays have strong penetrating capabilities, the entire element information of bulk materials can be obtained, so this technology has become the best choice for industrial bulk material composition testing needs [2] [3] [4]. Table 1 compares the four online analysis technologies.
Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation Analysis (PGNAA) is a non-destructive, efficient, multi-element online nuclear analysis technology [5]. In principle, it can measure most of the elements on the periodic table [6], especially in the analysis of elements with large (n, γ) reaction cross-sections (B, Cd, Gd, H, etc.), its sensitivity is high, and it is usually used as a supplement to conventional analysis, the analysis of light elements in large samples is the only method [7].
Based on relevant international studies, this paper discusses PGNAA technology from the following four aspects: The first part briefly summarizes the basic principle of PGNAA technology and its development direction in recent years; The second part introduces the theoretical research of PGNAA technology in industrial material detection. Further, in the third part of the paper, it mainly discusses the international research on the application of PGNAA technology in industrial material detection system equipment. Finally, in the conclusion part, it summarizes the industrial application of PGNAA technology.

Basic Principles
The technical principle of Prompt gamma neutron activation analysis (PGNAA) is shown in Figure 1. When the neutron beam emitted by the neutron source bombards the nucleus of the measured substance, undergoes a nuclear reaction (mainly inelastic scattering nuclear radiation capture) and emits instantaneous characteristic gamma rays in a very short time. These characteristics γ are collected through the detection system, and qualitatively and quantitatively analyzing the elemental composition and content of the measured material by analyzing the energy and intensity of these characteristic γ rays [8].
In PGNAA technology, the intensity of γ rays with a certain energy can be given by the following formula [9]:   A(t) is the count of a certain energy γ-ray in time t; φ represents the neutron flux; ω represents the mass of the detected element; M represents the atomic weight of the detected element; N A represents the Avogadro constant; α represents the isotopic abundance of the detected element; σ represents the reaction cross section of the element and neutron; λ represents the branching ratio of γ rays; ε represents the detection efficiency of the all-energy peak.

Development Direction of PGNAA Technology
Since the first use of PGNAA technology to detect elements in 1936, the application research of PGNAA technology has started abroad [10] [11] [12]. In recent years, with the development of nuclear electronics instruments, the detector's ability to detect γ rays has been continuously improved [13], and the rapid development of technologies such as neutron beam devices [14] [15] [16], nuclear databases [6] [17], and energy spectrum analysis [18] [19]. The prompt gamma neutron activation analysis technology has been widely used in the analysis of World Journal of Engineering and Technology multi-element composition of large samples in many disciplines including environmental science [20] [21] [22], industry [23] [24] and health sciences [25] [26]. At this time, with the development of radioisotope neutron sources [27] and portable neutron generators [28], the technology has been able to conduct in-situ and rapid online analysis of large samples such as mining [29] [30], biological [31], manufacturing and construction quality control tasks [32] [33] [34], as well as homeland security contraband detection [35].
In recent years, with the widespread application and in-depth development of PGNAA technology, the international research hotspots mainly include the following three aspects: 1) PGNAA system methodology [36]: In the field of methodology, the research of prompt γ neutron activation mainly includes the study of k0 method in the quantitative analysis of PGNAA technology [37] [38], the methodological study of the calibration of the wide energy range γ-ray detection efficiency [39], as well as evaluation and analysis techniques of γ energy spectrum [19] [20] [40], etc.
2) PGNAA system device design: Since the late 20th century, with the progress and development of electronic technology and detection systems, the current development trend of PGNAA technology has also changed from increasing the neutron fluence rate to increasing the lower detection limit of elements, etc. On the other hand, compared with hot neutron beams [41] [42], the cold neutrons have a higher reaction cross-sections and lower energy; at the same time, due to the small fraction of fast neutrons in the cold neutron beam and the low γ-ray interference [43], the design and research of the cold neutron beam system with high fluence rate has become a hot spot in the world [43]- [48].
For example, in the US National Institute of Standards and Technology [49] [50] [51], Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute [52], Korea HANARO [53] [54] and other reactors have established their own advanced PGNAA system devices.
In China, there are currently two PGNAA facilities in operation. One is prompt gamma neutron activation analysis (PGNAA) system based on the In-Hospital Neutron Irradiator (IHNI) developed for the Boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) project on a 30kW micro research reactor in Beijing [55]; the other is based on the Prompt gamma Neutron Activation Analysis (PGNAA) system on the China Advanced Research Reactor (CARR) [56] [57]. In recent years, in order to be able to irradiate the target sample with a higher neutron fluence rate to improve the sensitivity of PGNAA system analysis, a focused neutron beam analysis method has been proposed internationally [58] [59]. At the same time, the detection technology of Compton suppression gamma spectrometer was developed to improve the detection defects of low-energy gamma rays, which greatly reduced the Compton effect and improved the detection efficiency of low-energy gamma rays [60] [61].
3) Application of PGNAA technology: As a high-sensitivity, multi-element non-destructive online analysis method, PGNAA has been widely used in more World Journal of Engineering and Technology than 30 PGNAA facilities worldwide. In recent years, PGNAA technology has proved to be valuable in a variety of applications, and its research field covers many aspects such as materials science, biology and medicine, earth science and cultural research.

Application of PGNAA Technology in Industrial Material Inspection
The use of the prompt gamma neutron activation analysis (PGNAA) method for the on-line analysis of the total element composition of industrial materials has been a hot spot in the field of nuclear detection and analysis in recent years [62].
Its application is mainly aimed at resource-intensive and high energy consumption industries such as coal, cement and metallurgy. This technology is used to conduct real-time detection of material composition in the production process so as to timely adjust the ratio of materials, so as to realize the optimization of the production process and ultimately improve the production efficiency [63].
For example, the coal blending process of thermal power, and the raw material proportioning process of cement and metallurgical industries can all use online testing equipment to reduce fuel consumption, improve production efficiency, and control product quality.

Online Analysis and Detection of Coal
Online detection of coal has been studied in the United States since the late 1970s. [1]. At the same time, its research and development equipment was ap- showed that the accuracy of carbon in the sample can be nearly 1%, and the accuracy of sulfur reached 0.05% [67].

Total Element Analysis of Cement Materials
In the cement industry, Argentine scholar Daniel L. and others pioneered the analysis of elements in cement samples, and the analysis results showed that PGNAA technology could achieve the measurement of elements such as Fe, Ca, Si and Cl in the samples [70].

Applications in the Mineral and Metallurgical Industries
The iron and steel industry is an important pillar industry for national construction and national economic development, and is a basic industry for industrialization, as well as an intensive consumption of technology, capital, resources, and energy. The traditional detection techniques are mostly X-ray fluorescence analysis, neutron activation analysis (NAA), etc., and with the help of the high-sensitivity analysis performance of PGNAA technology, research teams in various countries have begun to use PGNAA technology to carry out elements in various ores. Qualitative and quantitative analysis, as well as quality inspection in the production process of iron and steel smelting. During the metal smelting process, the presence of hydrogen may cause the brittleness of the material to increase, which has a great impact on the performance of the steel, so it has always been the focus of attention [76]. The Cold neutron instantaneous gamma activation analyzer at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Center for Neutron Research (NCNR) has been shown to detect trace hydrogen in advanced materials such as titanium alloys [77]. In 2010, H.J. Cho et al. used PGNAA technology to analyze the hydrogen element in low-alloy steel and obtained good test results [78]. In 2017, the Danyal team used PGNAA technology to evaluate the performance of trace hydrogen elements in titanium alloys, and the uncertainty range was consistent with the experimental values [79]. In the application of ore element analysis, in 2009, Nicola's team used the PGNAA method to detect and analyze the Cl element in the ore sample. The re-World Journal of Engineering and Technology sults showed that the uncertainty of the Cl element content was less than 5%, which was the element of the ore. The analysis provides new technical methods [80].

Domestic Research on PGNAA Material Detection Technology
The on-line detection and analysis of the material composition of PGNAA technology first started in Europe and America and other developed countries.
In recent years, with the vigorous development of nuclear technology applications, the domestic market has slowly started. In 1996, Chen Boxian et al. conducted a preliminary analysis of coal using the Am-Be neutron source, which provided a feasibility study for PGNAA technology to analyze the main elements in coal [81]. Subsequently, Song Zhaolong, Jia Wenbao and other teams have successively carried out the research of PGNAA technology in the field of online coal detection, and achieved remarkable results [82] [83]. In terms of elemental analysis of cement, Cao Xuepeng's team used D-D neutron generator as the neutron excitation source to carry out relevant research on the main elements of cement raw materials. The relative deviation of the measurement results is less than 7%, which can meet the requirements of industrial production [84]. For the application of ore detection, Song qingfeng's team used PGNAA online analysis technology to measure the copper and nickel elements in the ore, and the detection accuracy can meet the requirements of online analysis of iron ore in the industrial site [85]. Then, through the combination of simulation and experiment, the team tested and verified the composition of iron ore pulp, and the results showed that the fitting degree of the experimental determination and analytical value of each component exceeded 0.99, proving the feasibility of PGNAA technology in the analysis of pulp composition [86].

Development and Application of Industrial Online Detection System Based on PGNAA Technology
The real-time online detection system of industrial material composition is mainly based on the PGNAA technology of isotope neutron source or neutron generator. By detecting the prompt γ-rays generated by the nuclear reaction between neutrons and nuclide in the material sample, and by online data analysis to obtain the element composition and content of the test object. A complete PGNAA online analysis system mainly includes three parts: field test, signal processing, data transmission and feedback. Among them, the on-site testing mainly includes detectors, neutron sources (or neutron generators), measuring mechanisms and protective devices; the signal processing part includes the spectrometer system, spectrometer analysis and data processing system; the data transmission and feedback part mainly includes the results display and data exchange of analyzer, industrial control unit, etc. [3].

Overview of Foreign Industrial Online Detection Systems
The traditional PGNAA industrial material online analysis system is mainly de-veloped based on isotope neutron source. In recent years, with the advancement of micro neutron generators and its unique advantages, it has gradually replaced the isotope neutron source and is used in the PGNAA industrial material online analysis system [1]. In the late 1980s, the original gamma metrics company (now Thermo Fisher Scientific) of the United States developed the first elemental composition analyzer for industrial sites after decades of technical research, and successfully applied it to the coal and cement industry [87]. At present, there are three major companies in the world that manufacture PGNAA systems for online real-time analysis of industrial material components: Thermo in the United States, Scantech in Australia, and Sodem in France [88]. The CB-Omni, which was launched by Thermo of the United States in 2006, is based on the isotope 252 Cf neutron source. The detection system uses two NaI detectors, and its application field is mainly oriented to the mining and cement industry [87]. Scantech in Australia has mainly developed the COALSCAN 9500 analyzer for the coal industry and the GEOSCANTM analyzer for the cement industry. Both analyzers use 252 Cf as the neutron source, among which, COALSCAN 9500 uses NaI detector as the detection system, which can perform complete online analysis of coal [89]; and GEOSCANTM uses multiple BGO detectors as the gamma rays of the device, and the detection system has a high γ photon counting rate. The CAN device of Sodern in France uses an electrically controllable D-T neutron generator as the neutron excitation source. Since the D-T neutron generator can provide neutrons with higher energy, it can generate inelastic scattering reaction with C, O and other elements captured in the material with smaller cross sections to stimulate the prompt γ rays. Therefore, the device can realize full-element analysis, and its analysis index is more comprehensive. At the same time, based on the advantage of neutron source electrical controllability, it can provide a safer environment for equipment maintenance [90].

Research and Application of Domestic Industrial Material Detection System
Now in Europe and America and other developed countries, the development and manufacturing of PGNAA technology-based real-time online detection system for industrial material composition has already formed a relatively mature industrial chain, and is sold through relevant enterprises. With the development of our country's industrial technology, domestic demand for real-time online detection systems for industrial materials has gradually increased. In the early 1990s, aluminum plants such as Shandong and Zhengzhou began to use the NH-501 system based on PGNAA technology for industrial online test and measurement [3]. Since the beginning of this century, the domestic market has become active. Based on the use of foreign equipment, Nanjing Continental Technology has achieved localization through innovation and reconstruction. Afterwards, scientific research units such as Kelun Company of Northeast Normal University, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Tsinghua University and China Atomic Energy Research Institute also launched related PGNAA World Journal of Engineering and Technology projects [24]. Based on the modern nuclear analysis technology, a series of testing equipment for the analysis of industrial components such as coal and cement has been developed and produced. Its quality and technology have made greater progress than before, but compared with similar products abroad, there is still a big gap in performance. High-sensitivity, multi-parameter measurement of high-end industrial material composition real-time online in-situ detection system still needs to rely on foreign imports. prompt characteristic γ rays, using the new high-efficiency γ-ray detection system obtains the γ energy spectrum and analyzes it to obtain the main elements and their contents in the material [91]. In this project, the two key technologies at the core are: the development of high-yield, long-life D-D small neutron sources, miniaturized of a long-life D-T sealed neutron sources, and the development of high-count rate detection systems [92]. At present, the project has completed the application development research in the fields of thermal power plants, ironworks, cement plants, etc., has built three demonstration projects, and passed the self-acceptance phase in December 2018.

Summary
As an effective nuclear analysis technique, prompt gamma neutron activation

Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.