Assessment of the Willingness to Buy and the Use of Insecticide Treated Nets (ITN) among Caregivers of Under-Five Children Attending Immunization Clinics in a Private Tertiary Hospital in Plateau State, Nigeria

Introduction: Malaria control becomes effective if countries adopt the World Health Organization & Global Malaria Programme (WHO/GMP) recommendation with includes diagnosis of malaria cases and treatment with effective medicines, distribution of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS). Ownership and utilization of mosquito nets for malaria prevention is still sub-optimal with only 62% ownership of at least one mosquito net and only 37% of children using the nets. This seeks to investigate the willingness to buy and the use ITN use among caregivers of under five children attending immunization clinic in Bingham University Teaching Hospital. Methodology: A descriptive cross sectional study design carried out among 242 caregivers of all ages and sex of under-five children attending immunization clinic at Bingham University Teaching Hospital (BHUTH) in Jos North Local Government Area of Plateau State, Nigeria. A Simple Random Sampling technique was used to select respondents. Findings: Two hundred and sixteen 216 (89.3%) of the children use ITNs, majority of the children 190 (78.5%) slept under ITN the night before the interview, 226 (93.4%) owned ITNs, 156 (64.5%) got the ITNs for free while 60 (24.8%) paid for it and majority 172 (71.1%) of the children use ITN every night. Tertiary education, having much younger children (less than 3 years) and perception as a means of malaria prevention were associated with higher use of ITNs. Majority 220 (90.9%) the caregivers were willing to buy ITN and also recommend ITN to others. Caregivers who were traders and civil servants were willing to buy ITN than farmers, tertiary education, having children 1 3 months old, and owning 3 or How to cite this paper: Idoko, L., Okafor, K.C., Amlabu, G.M., Idika, C.N. and Oguche, B.E. (2020) Assessment of the Willingness to Buy and the Use of Insecticide Treated Nets (ITN) among Caregivers of UnderFive Children Attending Immunization Clinics in a Private Tertiary Hospital in Plateau State, Nigeria. Advances in Infectious Diseases, 10, 90-110. https://doi.org/10.4236/aid.2020.102008 Received: April 3, 2020 Accepted: May 8, 2020 Published: May 11, 2020 Copyright © 2020 by author(s) and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY 4.0). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Open Access


Introduction
Malaria remains a global burden contributing to morbidity and mortality especially in under-five children. The control of vector-borne diseases such as malaria is a major global health challenge of the 21 st century [1].
Malaria, a life threatening disease caused by plasmodium and transmitted by female anopheles mosquito is the second most common cause of infectious disease related deaths in the world [2] [3]. The case prevalence of malaria was 216 million and mortality of 445,000 worldwide with 90% and 91% respectively occurring in Africa and remains a public health problem in endemic areas [4] [5]. It is estimated that 1 out of every 20 children is likely to die from malaria-related illness before their fifth birthday in Sub-Saharan Africa [6] [7].
Nigeria accounts for 27% of the global malaria burden with under-five children and pregnant women most at risk [3]. It is implicated in approximately 60% of outpatient visits and 30% of admissions, with up to 25% of infant mortality and 30% of under-five mortality within the country [4] [8]. In Plateau State, a study carried out to quantify the prevalence and transmission patterns in the highlands and lowlands areas of Plateau State showed that the prevalence is 48.1% and it showed stable transmission [9]. In endemic areas or areas with stable transmission such as Plateau State, children under five are particularly prone to infection, illness and death as they lack acquired immunity accounting for the majority of malarial disease, particularly severe disease with rapid progression to death. This age group accounts for more than two-thirds (70%) of all malaria deaths [10]. About 285,000 children in Africa died before their fifth birthdays tive measures (such as sleeping under insecticide-treated nets [ITNs]) and curative measures (seeking timely health care for fevers) and conversely, malaria might further impoverish poorer households through the costs of preventive and curative measures, as well as for the inability to work while ill [11] [14] [15].
Using mosquito nets as a protection against insects was practiced in historical times especially during World War II (1939)(1940)(1941)(1942)(1943)(1944)(1945), Russian, German and United States armies treated bed nets to protect soldiers against vector-borne diseases [16]. Ownership and utilization of mosquito nets for malaria prevention is still sub-optimal with only 62 percent ownership of at least one mosquito net and only 37 percent of children using the nets [17]. The WHO Global Malaria Programme (WHO/GMP) recommends 3 primary interventions for effective malaria control which includes; diagnosis of malaria cases and treatment with effective medicines, distribution of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs), indoor residual spraying (IRS) [2] [3].
ITN function in three main ways: first they act as a physical barrier to pre- years in sub-Saharan Africa, 63% -73% has been attributed to the extensive distribution of ITNs [2]. ITNs have been shown to reduce severe disease due to malaria and mortality (by 20%) in endemic regions [23]. The provision of insecticide-treated nets was a key strategy in successful malaria elimination programs in some countries, in Sri Lanka, ninety-one percent of these nets in households were obtained from free distribution programmes, 69% of households in Sri Lanka possess at least one mosquito net and usage by under-fives stands at seventy-one percent. By 2006, the country recorded less than 1000 cases per year and since October 2012, the indigenous cases were down to zero [2] [20] [24].
There is still a lot of work to be done to meet the 75% target for reduction in mortality and incidence of malaria globally as set in the global technical strategy for malaria of the World Health Organization [21]. Perceived malaria risk increases the likelihood of ownership and use of ITN with a mean of 1.33 nets in households with children aged 0 to 4 years as against 1.14 nets in households with children aged 10 to 14 years [25]. Other determinants of use of ITNs include occupation [26] [27] age of caregivers [28] [29] season of the year [30] and living close to a health institution [31].
The most important determining factor of ITN usage is ownership [23]. Insecticide-treated nets reduce child mortality from all causes by 17% compared to no nets (rate ratio 0.83, 95% CI 0.77 to 0.89) [32]. This study is of importance as it seeks to investigate the willingness to buy and willingness to use ITN use among caregivers of under five children attending immunization clinic in Bingham University Teaching Hospital. Given the fact that use of ITN is critical to the reduction of Malaria burden, and the inadequate level of use among communities, there is need to find out factors associated with increased utilization of ITN in Nigeria. The objective of this study is to determine the proportion of caregivers whose children are sleeping under ITNs, identify factors affecting use of ITNs and determine the proportion of caregivers willing to buy ITNs.

Methodology
The study was carried out at Bingham University Teaching Hospital (BHUTH), 250 bed spaced, faith based tertiary health institution located in Jos North Local Government Area of Plateau State, Plateau State. It is owned by the Evangelical Church Winning All (ECWA). Participants were recruited at the Immunization clinic, in the department of Paediatrics. The clinic provides routine immunization for underfive children, breastfeeding and nutritional counselling for caregivers of the children. The clinic runs on Wednesdays with an average of 50 under-five children attending weekly. The study involved all caregivers of all ages and sex of under five children attending immunization clinic at BHUTH from August to November, 2018. The study excluded children whose caregivers declined consent and those who were ill and referred out of the clinic. A descriptive cross sectional study design was used in conducting this study. It utilized an interviewer administered structured questionnaire.
Sample Size was determined using the Cochran's formula [33]. North-central geopolitical zone in a study done from Nigeria malaria indicator survey-59.7% [4]. The calculated minimum sample size was 370 and 10% of the minimum sample size was added to the sample size to give room for errors to achieve a sample size of 407. A Simple Random Sampling technique was used to select participants. A list of registered caregivers who attending immunization session was used as the sampling frame, selection was done by balloting. The data was collected from caregivers of under-five children attending immunization clinic using a structured interviewer-administered questionnaire.
Data collected includes use of ITN and reasons for not using ITN, ownership, number, type & source of mosquito net in their homes, duration, frequency, and time of the year of use of ITN. Caregivers off label use, dipping in water, and sun drying of ITNs since purchase, caregivers willingness to buy ITN. At the end of the data collection period, 242 participants were interviewed. A response rate of 65.4% was achieved. Ethical clearance was obtained from the Ethical Review Committee of BHUTH, Jos. Study limitation include the interviewers did not go to the houses of the respondents to see their ITNs or observe the children sleeping under ITNs; it was based on self report. The completed questionnaires were analysed using Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) version 20. Statistical significance was determined using chi square. A 95% confidence interval was used for the study and P value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant in bivariate analyses. On reasons for not using ITNs, 3 (11.5%) of the caregivers do not use ITNs because they feel that ITNs are suffocating, 3 (11.5%) have an unpleasant smell, 5(19.3%) of them say that ITN use is inconveniencing and another 5 (19.3%) do not use ITNs for their children because their mother did not use it, 1 (3.8%) feel it is not necessary, 1 (3.8%) cannot disclose, 2 (7.8%) say doors are not left open, 3 (11.5%) said they do not feel like using it, 3 (11.5%) did not give any reason.

1) Under-five children that use ITN, 24 hour recall and reasons for non-ITN by of caregivers
2) Ownership, number, type & source of Mosquito Net in Their Houses were bought from a chemist.  Table 4 shows that 49.6% of the caregivers had either dipped their ITN in liquid or spread under the sun while 39.7% had never done any.
Majority of the caregivers 212 (87.7%) had used their ITNs for nothing else however 2 (0.8%) had used their ITNs to cover seedlings, 1 (0.4%) for fishing and 1 (0.4%) had used their ITNs as screen at backyard. 5) Association between Use of ITN and education, age of caregiver, and occupation of caregiver    Table 6 shows that most of caregivers who perceived ITN as a means of Malaria prevention used ITNs, 205 (86.1%). This finding was statistically significant (χ 2 = 23.716, p = 0.0017). Table 7 shows that majority of caregivers, 220 (90.9%) were willing to buy ITN however, 22 (9.1%) were not ( Figure 1). Also, majority of the caregivers 220 (90.9%) were willing to recommend ITN to others while 22 (9.1%) were not.      Table 9 shows that more 89 (38.2%) caregivers who had three or more ITNs where willing to buy ITNs while only 11 (4.7%) of caregivers without ITNs where willing to buy ITNs for their children. This finding as statistically significant (χ 2 = 11.208, p = 0.008).

Discussion
Nine in ten children used insecticide treated nets (ITN), from which three quarters slept under ITN a night before the interview. This finding is much higher than a studies done in Ekiti State (50%) [22], Abakaliki [23] [39], Ghana (66%) [40]. This disparity may be due to the fact that the mothers in Plateau State had exposure to campaigns and distribution of ITNs in the past. Much lower percentages were observed in Nkanu, Enugu State (20%) [41], a hospital based study in UNTH, Enugu [42]  This progress is reflected in the findings from this study where over three quarters of the children slept under ITN the night before the interview. This trend is also shown in a study done in Ibadan [46] where over a quarter slept under the ITN the night before the interview. This is contrast to studies done in Calabar [35] where about a quarter slept under the ITN the night before the interview. This study showed 79% of underfive children from this study slept under ITN the previous night, this is below the World Health Assembly target of 80%. However, this is above the World Malaria Report that estimates that 54% of children in sub-Saharan Africa sleep under it [3]. Data obtained from Nigeria Malaria Indicator Survey put National figures at 44% while North Central is 39% [4]. A study in Ogun State reported that 29% of under five children slept under ITN the previous night [38].
ITNs were not used by caregiver for their children because they complained about suffocation, unpleasant smell, some said it was inconveniencing, Others said their mother did not use it, they do not feel it is necessary, say doors are not left open, said they do not feel like using it. Similar reason were given in a study done in Imo State [34], Abia [47] and Abakaliki [22] these reasons will usually lead to non use of ITNs in the households. Thus, it is important to ensure behavioural change towards use of ITNs, especially as these reasons for non use are marginal when compared to the mortality and morbidity associated with Malaria. This study showed that 19% identified inconvenience as reason for non-use as observed in other studies in Lake Victoria [48], 12% mentioned that sleeping under ITN caused suffocation. Other reasons were bad odour from nets, doors are not left open as noted in a study by Ezeama et al. (2014). Some other care-givers said they did not feel like using ITNs for their children which is similar to findings in another study in Eastern Nigeria [49]. Other studies reported [50] itching and "do not work" as reasons for non-use. Other studies in Sub Saharan Africa [51] have cited problems with hanging up nets and lack of space as reasons for non-use.
Ownership of ITNs has always shown a rise over the past 10  Over a third had used their ITNs for up to a year and majority of the children use ITN every night and all year round. This is a good practice to reduce the burden of malaria and need to be promoted. This is comparable to findings in studies done in Ghana [5] and Abia [47]. In a study done in a rural community in Enugu [41] [54]. In another survey in Sri Lanka, 75% ITN use was recorded during dry season compared to 90% during rainy season.
Strangely, there are a few off label use of their ITNs like use to cover seedlings and use as fishing nets. Similar reports have been obtained in other parts of Africa; in a particular study in villages along Lake Victoria, ITNs were used by the indigenes for fishing instead of protection against malaria [55]. This finding is a common experience for household items and commodities. This off label use should be discouraged among care givers, since it deprived the children from sleeping under the nets.
Factors affecting the use of ITNs, Education was associated with a higher proportion of care givers with tertiary education use ITN. This is finding is similar to a study done in Enugu [41]. This finding is understandable as caregivers with tertiary education are more likely to understand the need to prevent Malaria and protect their children from mosquitoes.
More care givers with children within the age 1 -3 years used ITN, than other age groups, A significant driver to ITN use was number of under-fives in household with use of ITN highest (47.9%) in households with 2 under-fives. This relationship was reported in South Nigeria [56] where the highest ITN use rate among children in households with two or less children under five years who may be sleeping on the same bed with their parents. Another study in Lagos [37] stated that ITN use was highest in households with three or less children accounting for 63.8% in that study. This is because lower age groups are still tender and more prone to malaria even though all age groups are prone to malaria infection; caregivers with much younger children face a higher morbidity and mortality, thus the need to ensure compliance. Majority of caregivers who perceived ITN as a means of Malaria prevention used ITNs used ITNs. This demonstrates the importance of perception in adoption of the right behaviour for favourable health outcomes.
Nine out of ten caregivers were willing to buy ITN and also to recommend same to other mothers.In a study done in Ethiopia [53] (68.5%) were willing to buy ITNs if available in the market while in a multi state study, [52] 27.1% of respondents were willing to buy ITN in Akwa Ibom, [52] 67.9% in Kebbi, [52] 61.3% in Nasarawa [52]. Half preferred to buy ITN over other things when confronted with an option to choose. More caregivers who were traders and civil servants were willing to buy ITN than farmer. This finding could be attributable to the fact that traders and civil servants may have more cash available for purchasing the ITNs when compared to farmers. Thus, farmers and unemployed caregivers will need to be empowered to make cash available to them. They should also be the focus for mass distribution campaigns for ITNs across the country.
More caregivers with tertiary education were willing to buy ITN, more when compared those with primary school education. This finding may be attributable to the fact that those with education may be well employed or engaged in trading and would be willing to buy ITNs. Also, their level of education will give them an edge in making the right decision based on facts on the importance of Insecticide treated nets.
Caregivers with children 1 -3 months old, of were willing to buy ITNs than those with children 22 -24 months. This stands to reason as caregivers perceive infants and 3 month old are still fragile and have a higher risk of dying of malaria. This age group may not be able to cope with Malaria, while the older ones may not be too bothered in error. This practice should not be encouraged as Malaria is a huge risk for all children.

Conclusions
A high proportion (89.3%) of the children of caregivers use ITNs and over three quarters slept under ITN the night before the interview. And majority use it every night.
Caregivers do not use ITNs because they feel that ITNs are suffocating, have an unpleasant smell, inconveniencing, felt it is not necessary and because their mother did not use it.
Nine in ten owned ITNs, two third got the ITNs for free from outside the hospital, the hospital and family and friends and while a quarter paid for it in the market and chemist.
A few caregivers used ITNs for fishing and covering for seedlings.
Tertiary education, having much younger children (less than 3 years) and perception as a means of malaria prevention were associated with higher use of ITNs.
Nine in ten f the caregivers were willing to buy ITN and also recommend ITN to others Caregivers who were traders and civil servants were willing to buy ITN than farmers. Tertiary education, having children 1 -3 months old, and owning 3 or more ITNs was associated with willingness to buy ITNs.

To the Government & Health Care Workers
The Government and Health care workers should continue to encourage the Caregivers to keep using ITNs for their children.
ITNs should be impregnated with sweet smelling fragrances to reduce the unpleasant smells causing some caregiver to avoid its use.
More enlightenment needs to the carried for caregiver who still feel it is unnecessary to use ITNs. Older women and grandmothers can be used as ITN champions to help encourage caregivers to use ITNs especially for caregivers who felt their mothers did not use ITNs in their time.
Most caregivers got ITNs for free, thus it is important for Government and NGOs to continue and sustain the free distribution of ITNs to pregnant women for their children.
Continuous reinforcement of messages on ITN use as a means of malaria prevention is necessary. Though only 1.6% of caregivers used ITNs for other things like cover for seedlings, fishing and screen at backyard, the general public should be educated by the government or/and health workers on proper use of ITN.
Unemployed caregivers, farmers who may not be able to afford ITNs should be targeted for free ITN distribution to improve ownership and utilization of ITNs.
To caregivers Caregivers should not use ITNs for other things outside letting their children sleep under the ITN. Caregivers should continue to sustain the behavioural change by using the ITNs for their children.