Do GMOs Accumulate Formaldehyde and Disrupt Molecular Systems Equilibria? Systems Biology May Provide Answers

Download Download as PDF (Size:1665KB)  HTML   XML  PP. 630-662  


Safety assessment of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is a contentious topic. Proponents of GMOs assert that GMOs are safe since the FDA’s policy of substantial equivalence considers GMOs “equivalent” to their non-GMO counterparts, and argue that genetic modification (GM) is simply an extension of a “natural” process of plant breeding, a form of “genetic modification”, though done over longer time scales. Anti-GMO activists counter that GMOs are unsafe since substantial equivalence is unscientific and outdated since it originates in the 1970s to assess safety of medical devices, which are not comparable to the complexity of biological systems, and contend that targeted GM is not plant breeding. The heart of the debate appears to be on the methodology used to determine criteria for substantial equivalence. Systems biology, which aims to understand complexity of the whole organism, as a system, rather than just studying its parts in a reductionist manner, may provide a framework to determine appropriate criteria, as it recognizes that GM, small or large, may affect emergent properties of the whole system. Herein, a promising computational systems biology method couples known perturbations on five biomolecules caused by the CP4 EPSPS GM of Glycine max L. (soybean), with an integrative model of C1 metabolism and oxidative stress (two molecular systems critical to plant function). The results predict significant accumulation of formaldehyde and concomitant depletion of glutathione in the GMO, suggesting how a “small” and single GM creates “large” and systemic perturbations to molecular systems equilibria. Regulatory agencies, currently reviewing rules for GMO safety, may wish to adopt a systems biology approach using a combination of in silico, computational methods used herein, and subsequent targeted experimental in vitro and in vivo designs, to develop a systems understanding of “equivalence” using biomarkers, such as formaldehyde and glutathione, which predict metabolic disruptions, towards modernizing the safety assessment of GMOs.

Cite this paper

Ayyadurai, V.A.S. and Deonikar, P. (2015) Do GMOs Accumulate Formaldehyde and Disrupt Molecular Systems Equilibria? Systems Biology May Provide Answers. Agricultural Sciences, 6, 630-662. doi: 10.4236/as.2015.67062.


[1] Ayyadurai, V.A. and Dewey, C.F. (2011) CytoSolve: A Scalable Computational Method for Dynamic Integration of Multiple Molecular Pathway Models. Cellular and Molecular Bioengineering, 4, 28-45.
[2] Kodama, T., et al. (2011) Qualitative PCR Method for Roundup Ready Soybean: Interlaboratory Study. Journal of AOAC International, 94, 224-231.
[3] Deonikar, P., et al. (2015) Discovery of Key Molecular Pathways of C1 Metabolism and Formaldehyde Detoxification in Maize through a Systematic Bioinformatics Literature Review. Agricultural Sciences, 6, 571-585.
[4] Kothandaram, S., Deonikar, P., Mohan, M., Venugopal, V. and Ayyadurai, V.A.S. (2015) In Silico Modeling of C1 Metabolism. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 6, 1444-1465.
[5] Mohan, M., Kothandaram, S., Deonikar, P., Venugopal, V. and Ayyadurai, V.A.S. (2015) Integrative Modeling of Oxidative Stress and C1 Metabolism Reveals Upregulation of Formaldehyde and Down Regulation of Glutathione. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 6, 1527-1542.
[6] Arruda, S.C., Barbosa, H.S., Azevedo, R.A. and Arruda, M.A. (2013) Comparative Studies Focusing on Transgenic through cp4EPSPS Gene and Non-Transgenic Soybean Plants: An Analysis of Protein Species and Enzymes. Journal of Proteomics, 93, 107-116.
[7] Barbosa, H.S., Arruda, S.C., Azevedo, R.A. and Arruda, M.A. (2012) New Insights on Proteomics of Transgenic Soybean Seeds: Evaluation of Differential Expressions of Enzymes and Proteins. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 402, 299-314.
[8] Mataveli, L.R., Pohl, P., Mounicou, S., Arruda, M.A. and Szpunar, J. (2010) A Comparative Study of Element Concentrations and Binding in Transgenic and Non-Transgenic Soybean Seeds. Metallomics, 2, 800-805.
[9] Sammons, R.D. and Gaines, T.A. (2014) Glyphosate Resistance: State of Knowledge. Pest Management Science, 70, 1367-1377.
[10] Funke, T., Han, H., Healy-Fried, M.L., Fischer, M. and Schonbrunn, E. (2006) Molecular Basis for the Herbicide Resistance of Roundup Ready Crops. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 103, 13010-13015.
[11] Roberts, A.F. (2010) A Review of the Environmental Safety of the CP4 EPSPS Protein. Center for Environmental Risk Assessment, ILSI Research Foundation, Washington DC.
[12] Fernandez-Cornejo, J. (2014) Recent Trends in GE Adoption.
[13] de Vendomois, J.S., et al. (2010) Debate on GMOs Health Risks after Statistical Findings in Regulatory Tests. International Journal of Biological Sciences, 6, 590-598.
[14] Devos, Y., Sanvido, O., Tait, J. and Raybould, A. (2014) Towards a More Open Debate about Values in Decision-Making on Agricultural Biotechnology. Transgenic Research, 23, 933-943.
[15] McHughen, A. (2013) GM Crops and Foods: What Do Consumers Want to Know? GM Crops & Food, 4, 172-182.
[16] Ricroch, A.E. and Hénard-Damave, M.-C. (2015) Next Biotech Plants: New Traits, Crops, Developers and Technologies for Addressing Global Challenges. Critical Reviews in Biotechnology, 1-16.
[17] Rottman, D. (2013) Why We Will Need Genetically Modified Foods.
[18] Aldemita, R.R., Reaño, I.M.E., Solis, R.O. and Hautea, R.A. (2015) Trends in Global Approvals of Biotech Crops (1992-2014). GM Crops & Food.
[19] Domingo, J.L. and Gine Bordonaba, J. (2011) A Literature Review on the Safety Assessment of Genetically Modified Plants. Environment International, 37, 734-742.
[20] Paoletti, C., Flamm, E., Yan, W.; Meek, S., Renckens, S., Fellous, M. and Kuiper, H. (2008) GMO Risk Assessment around the World: Some Examples. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 19, S70-S78.
[21] Goldberger, B.A. (2001) The Evolution of Substantial Equivalence in FDA’s Premarket Review of Medical Devices. Food and Drug Law Journal, 56, 317-337.
[22] Administration, F.A.D. (2001) Draft Guidance for Industry: Voluntary Labeling Indicating Whether Foods Have or Have Not Been Developed Using Bioengineering: Notice of Availability. Federal Register.
[23] Marris, C. (2001) Public Views on GMOs: Deconstructing the Myths. Stakeholders in the GMO Debate Often Describe Public Opinion as Irrational. But Do They Really Understand the Public? EMBO Reports, 2, 545-548.
[24] Phillips, T. (2008) Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs): Transgenic Crops and Recombinant DNA Technology. Nature Education, 1, 213.
[25] Holdren, J.P., Shelanski, H., Vetter, D. and Glodfuss, C. (2015) Improving Transparency and Ensuring Continued Safety in Biotechnology.
[26] Borghini, A. (2014) Substantial Equivalence. In: Thompson, P.B. and Kaplan, D.M., Eds., Encyclopedia of Food and Agricultural Ethics, Springer Science + Business Media, Dordrecht, 1-6.
[27] Schauzu, M. (2000) The Concept of Substantial Equivalence in Safety Assessment of Foods Derived from Genetically Modified Organisms. Ag. Biotech. Net, 2, 1-4.
[28] Lennox, K. (2014) Substantially Unequivalent: Reforming FDA Regulation of Medical Devices. University of Illinois Law Review, 1363-1400.
[29] Patwardhan, B., Warude, D., Pushpangadan, P. and Bhatt, N. (2005) Ayurveda and Traditional Chinese Medicine: A Comparative Overview. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2, 465-473.
[30] Ayyadurai, V.A.S. (2014) The Control Systems Engineering Foundation of Traditional Indian Medicine: The Rosetta Stone for Siddha and Ayurveda. International Journal of System of Systems Engineering, 5.
[31] Technology, M.I.O. (2015) Research.
[32] Tepfer, M., Jacquemond, M. and Garcia-Arenal, F. (2015) A Critical Evaluation of Whether Recombination in Virus-Resistant Transgenic Plants Will Lead to the Emergence of Novel Viral Diseases. New Phytologist, 207, 536-541.
[33] Harrigan, G.G., et al. (2010) Natural Variation in Crop Composition and the Impact of Transgenesis. Nature Biotechnology, 28, 402-404.
[34] Millstone, E., Brunner, E. and Mayer, S. (1999) Beyond “Substantial Equivalence”. Nature, 401, 525-526.
[35] Miller, H.I. (1999) Substantial Equivalence: Its Uses and Abuses. Nature Biotechnology, 17, 1042-1043.
[36] Halford, N.G., et al. (2014) Safety Assessment of Genetically Modified Plants with Deliberately Altered Composition. Plant Biotechnology Journal, 12, 651-654.
[37] Simo, C., Ibanez, C., Valdes, A., Cifuentes, A. and Garcia-Canas, V. (2014) Metabolomics of Genetically Modified Crops. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 15, 18941-18966.
[38] Vahl, C.I. and Kang, Q. (2015) Equivalence Criteria for the Safety Evaluation of a Genetically Modified Crop: A Statistical Perspective. The Journal of Agricultural Science, 24 p.
[39] Miller, J.G. (1978) Living Systems. McGraw-Hill, New York.
[40] Klir, G.J. (1972) Trends in General Systems Theory. Wiley-Interscience, New York.
[41] Boulding, K.E. (1953) The Organization Revolution: A Study in The Ethics of Economic Organization. Harper, New York.
[42] von Bertalanffy, L. (1968) General System Theory. George Braziller, Inc., New York.
[43] Ideker, T., et al. (2001) Integrated Genomic and Proteomic Analyses of a Systematically Perturbed Metabolic Network. Science, 292, 929-934.
[44] Schuler, G.D., et al. (1996) A Gene Map of the Human Genome. Science, 274, 540-546.
[45] Pennisi, E. (2003) Human Genome. A Low Number Wins the GeneSweep Pool. Science, 300, 1484.
[46] Hodgkin, J. (2001) What Does a Worm Want with 20,000 Genes? Genome Biology, 2. COMMENT2008.
[47] Putnam, N.H., et al. (2007) Sea Anemone Genome Reveals Ancestral Eumetazoan Gene Repertoire and Genomic Organization. Science, 317, 86-94.
[48] Watson, J.D. and Crick, F.H. (1953) Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids; a Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid. Nature, 171, 737-738.
[49] Schaffner, K.F. (1969) The Watson-Crick Model and Reductionism. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 20, 325-348.
[50] Hood, L., Heath, J.R., Phelps, M.E. and Lin, B. (2004) Systems Biology and New Technologies Enable Predictive and Preventative Medicine. Science, 306, 640-643.
[51] Subbarayappa, B.V. (1997) Siddha Medicine: An Overview. The Lancet, 350, 1841-1844.
[52] Cannon, W.B. (1933) The Wisdom of the Body. Norton, New York.
[53] Wiener, N. (1948) Cybernetics or Control and Communication in the Animal Machine. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
[54] Kitano, H. (2001) Foundations of Systems Biology. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
[55] Keller, E.F. (2007) A Clash of Two Cultures. Nature, 445, 603.
[56] Noble, D. (2006) Systems Biology and the Heart. Biosystems, 83, 75-80.
[57] Duarte, N.C., et al. (2007) Global Reconstruction of the Human Metabolic Network Based on Genomic and Bibliomic Data. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104, 1777-1782.
[58] Bhalla, U.S. (2003) Understanding Complex Signaling Networks through Models and Metaphors. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology, 81, 45-65.
[59] Ayyadurai, V.A.S. (2011) Services-Based Systems Architecture for Modeling the Whole Cell: A Distributed Collaborative Engineering Systems Approach. Communications in Medical and Care Compunetics, 1, 115-168.
[60] Hornberg, J.J., Bruggeman, F.J., Westerhoff, H.V. and Lankelma, J. (2006) Cancer: A Systems Biology Disease. BioSystems, 83, 81-90.
[61] Snoep, J.L., Bruggeman, F., Olivier, B.G. and Westerhoff, H.V. (2006) Towards Building the Silicon Cell: A Modular Approach. Biosystems, 83, 207-216.
[62] Klipp, E. and Liebermeister, W. (2006) Mathematical Modeling of Intracellular Signaling Pathways. BMC Neuroscience, 7, S10.
[63] Asthagiri, A.R. and Lauffenburger, D.A. (2000) Bioengineering Models of Cell Signaling. Annual Review of Biomedical Engineering, 2, 31-53.
[64] Ma’ayan, A., et al. (2005) Formation of Regulatory Patterns during Signal Propagation in a Mammalian Cellular Network. Science, 309, 1078-1083.
[65] Lauffenburger, D.A. (2000) Cell Signaling Pathways as Control Modules: Complexity for Simplicity? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 97, 5031-5033.
[66] Ayyadurai, V.A.S. (2007) Scalable Computational Architecture for Integrating Biological Pathway Models. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Biological Engineering Division. p. 2 v. (xvii, 303 leaves).
[67] Hanson, A.D. and Roje, S. (2001) One-Carbon Metabolism in Higher Plants. Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Plant Molecular Biology, 52, 119-137.
[68] Hanson, A.D., Gage, D.A. and Shachar-Hill, Y. (2000) Plant One-Carbon Metabolism and Its Engineering. Trends in Plant Science, 5, 206-213.
[69] Vanyushin, B.F. (2006) DNA Methylation in Plants. Current Topics in Microbiology and Immunology, 301, 67-122.
[70] Havir, E.A. and McHale, N.A. (1989) Enhanced-Peroxidatic Activity in Specific Catalase Isozymes of Tobacco, Barley, and Maize. Plant Physiology, 91, 812-815.
[71] Jozefczak, M., Remans, T., Vangronsveld, J. and Cuypers, A. (2012) Glutathione Is a Key Player in Metal-Induced Oxidative Stress Defenses. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 13, 3145-3175.
[72] Achkor, H., et al. (2003) Enhanced Formaldehyde Detoxification by Overexpression of Glutathione-Dependent Formaldehyde Dehydrogenase from Arabidopsis. Plant Physiology, 132, 2248-2255.
[73] Wippermann, U., et al. (1999) Maize Glutathione-Dependent Formaldehyde Dehydrogenase: Protein Sequence and Catalytic Properties. Planta, 208, 12-18.
[74] Chew, O., Whelan, J. and Millar, A.H. (2003) Molecular Definition of the Ascorbate-Glutathione Cycle in Arabidopsis Mitochondria Reveals Dual Targeting of Antioxidant Defenses in Plants. The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 278, 46869-46877.
[75] Martinez, M.C., et al. (1996) Arabidopsis Formaldehyde Dehydrogenase. Molecular Properties of Plant Class III Alcohol Dehydrogenase Provide Further Insights into the Origins, Structure and Function of Plant Class p and Liver Class I Alcohol Dehydrogenases. European Journal of Biochemistry, 241, 849-857.
[76] Nijhout, H.F., Reed, M.C., Budu, P. and Ulrich, C.M. (2004) A Mathematical Model of the Folate Cycle: New Insights into Folate Homeostasis. The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 279, 55008-55016.
[77] Yokota, A., Kitaoka, S., Miura, K. and Wadano, A. (1985) Reactivity of Glyoxylate with Hydrogen Perioxide and Simulation of the Glycolate Pathway of C3 Plants and Euglena. Planta, 165, 59-67.
[78] Goyer, A., et al. (2004) Characterization and Metabolic Function of a Peroxisomal Sarcosine and Pipecolate Oxidase from Arabidopsis. The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 279, 16947-16953.
[79] Brody, J.E. (2015) Fears, Not Facts, Support G.M.O.-Free Food in Well. New York Times, New York.

comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2016 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.