A Note on Secondary Buyouts-Creating Value or Recycling Capital

Jana KITZMANN, Dirk SCHIERECK

.

DOI: 10.4236/ib.2009.12015                

Abstract

This paper analyzes whether secondary buyouts of private equity (PE) investors in general create value and therefore are a suitable alternative to exit strategies like trade sales and IPOs. Theoretically, two conflicting approaches might explain the use of secondary buyouts as an exit channel of private equity investors: the capital recycling effects and different potential sources of value creation. We present empirical tests of these approaches. The profitability of secondary buyouts is assessed by a comparison of exit multiples realized with secondary buyouts and trade sales. The results are not unequivocal, but overall we interpret our findings in a way that awards secondary buyouts a profitability that is not significantly different from trade sales. Therefore, we argue that secondary buyouts have the potential for adding value that arise from different sources like the reduction of agency costs or the functions of the financial investor. Secondary buyouts should thus not be seen as a second best alternative for recycling the PE investors’ capital in situations where alternative—and supposedly more attractive—exit channels are unavailable.

Keywords

Management Buyouts, Performance, Private Equity, Secondary Buyout

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	Thies, A., “Steuerliche optimierung bei buy outs durch pe-gesellschaften,” in M&A Review, pp. 479–484, November 2003.
[2]	Bance, A., “Special paper–why and how to invest in PE, an EVCA investor relations committee paper,” European PE & Venture Capital Association, 2002, http://www.evca.com.
[3]	Bascha, A. and Walz, U., “Financing practices in the Ger- man venture capital industry: an empirical assessment,” Working Paper, University of Tübingen, February 2001, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=267572.
[4]	K?hler, P., and SCH?NAUER, F., “Bankfusionen lassen Angebot am Beteiligungsmarkt anschwellen, überschneidungen in den Firmenportfolios—Kreditinstitute geben Private-Equity-Gesch?ft ab,” in Handelsblatt, No. 17, pp. 26, January 26, 2004.
[5]	Sonter, D. and Fountain, K., “Alternative exits,” in Venture Economics, w/o y., available at: http://www.ventureeconomics.com.
[6]	Black, B. S. and Gilson, R. J., “Venture capital and the structure of capital markets: Bank versus stock markets,” in Journal of Financial Economics, No. 47, pp. 243–277, 1997.
[7]	Sormani, A., “Exits: The IPO alternative,” in EVJC, pp. 20–23, November 2002, http://www.evjc.com.
[8]	Wright, M., Chiplin, B., Thompson, S., and Robbie, K., “Realisation of venture capital investments: The case of management buyouts in the UK,” in The Service Industries Journal, No. 10, 499–520, 1990.
[9]	Cumming, D. J. and Fleming, G., “A law and finance analysis of venture capital exits in emerging markets,” Working Paper, University of Alberta and Australian National University, February 2003.
[10]	Laine, M. and Torstila, S. “The exit rates of liquidated venture capital funds,” May 2003, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=417641.
[11]	Timmreck, C., “Beteiligungsgesch?ft in Deutschland,” in M&A Review, No. 5, pp. 225–229, 2003.
[12]	Wang, C. K. and Sim, V. Y. L., “Exit strategies of venture capital-backed companies in Singapore,” in Venture Capital, No. 3, pp. 337–358, 2001.
[13]	Sahlmann, W. A., “The structure and governance of venture-capital organizations,” in Journal of Financial Economics, No. 27, pp. 473–521, 1990.
[14]	Hellmann, T., “IPOs, acquisitions and the use of convertible securities in venture capital,” Working Paper, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, December 2000, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=257608.
[15]	Houben, E., “Venture capital, double-sided adverse selection, and double-sided moral hazard,” December 2002, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=365841.
[16]	Sapienza, H. J., ‘When do venture capitalists add value?” in Journal of Business Venturing, No. 7, pp. 9–27, 1992.
[17]	Cumming, D., Franzke, S., and Walz, U., “Kann es eine Venture Capital-Industrie ohne B?rseng?nge geben? Notwendigkeit der Finanzierung von Innovationen—IPO ist attraktivste Exit-L?sung—Pool erfahrener VCs steht für den n?chsten Aufschwung zur Verfügung,” in B?rsen- Zeitung, No. 10, pp. 19, January 16, 2004.
[18]	Sapienza, H., Manigart, S., and Vermeir, W., “Venture capitalist governance and value-added in four countries,” in Journal of Business Venturing, No. 11, pp. 439–469, 1996.
[19]	Schwienbacher, A., “An empirical analysis of venture capital exits in Europe and in the United States,” Berlin Meeting Discussion Paper, July 2002, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=302001.
[20]	Prester, M., “Exit-strategien deutscher venture capital Gesellschaften,” Betriebswirtschaftliche Schriftenreihe Band 87, Münster, 2002.
[21]	Smith, G. D., “Control over exit in venture capital relationships,” 2001, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=272231.
[22]	Cumming, D. J. and Macintosh, J. G., “Venture capital exits in Canada and the United States,” in University of Toronto Law Journal, Vol. 53, pp. 101–200, 2003, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=321641.
[23]	Wall, J. and Smith, J., “Better exits, results of a survey of the venture capital exit market and guidance on how venture capitalists can improve exit performance,” Price Waterhouse Corporate Finance, 1998.
[24]	Achleitner, A., “Handbuch investment banking,” 2 Editon, Wiesbaden, 2000.
[25]	Jensen, M. C., “Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers,” in American Economic Review, No. 76, pp. 323 – 329, 1986.
[26]	Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R. W., and Jaffe, J. F., “Corporate finance,” 6 Editon, New York, 2002.
[27]	Barney, J., Busenitz, L., Fiet, J., and Moesel, D., “The structure of venture capital governance: An organisational economic analysis of relations between venture capital firms and new ventures,” in Academy of Management Proceedings, pp. 64–68, 1989.
[28]	Fried, V. H. and Hisrich, R. D., “Towards a model of venture capital investment decision making,” in Financial Management, pp. 28–37, Autumn 1994.
[29]	Jensen, M. C., “Eclipse of the public corporation,” in Harvard Business Review, No. 67, pp. 5, 1989.
[30]	Lehn, K. and Poulsen, A., “Free cash flow and stockholder gains in going private transactions,” in: The Journal of Finance, No. 44, pp. 771–787, 1989.
[31]	Frankfurter, G. M. and Gunay, E., “Management buyouts: The sources and sharing of wealth between insiders and outside shareholders,” in Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, No. 32, pp. 82–95, 1992.
[32]	Liebeskind, J., Wiersema, M., and Hansen, G., “LBOs, corporate restructuring, and the incentive-intensity hypothesis,” in Financial Management, Vol. 21, No. 1, pp. 73–88, Spring 1992.
[33]	Brous, P. A. and Kini, O., “The valuation effects of equity issues and the level of institutional ownership: Evidence from analysts’ earnings forecasts,” in Financial Management, pp. 33–46, Spring 1994.
[34]	Chen, S. S., Ho, K. W., Lee, C. F., and Yeo, G. H. H., “Wealth effects of pe placements: Evidence from singapore,” in The Financial Review, No. 37, 2002, pp. 165– 184.
[35]	Kieschnick, R. L., “Management buyouts of public corporations: An analysis of prior characteristics,” in AMIHUD, Yakov: Leveraged management buyouts—Causes and consequences, New York, pp. 35–67, 1989.
[36]	Deangelo, H. and Deangelo, L., “Management buyouts of publicly traded corporations,” in Financial Analysts Journal, pp. 38–49, May–June 1987.
[37]	Deangelo, H., Deangelo, L., and Rice, E. Y., “Going private: Minority freezeouts and stockholder wealth,” in Journal of Law & Economics, No. 27, pp. 367–402, 1984a.
[38]	Admati, A. R. and Pfleiderer, P., “Robust financial contracting and the role of venture capitalists,” in: The Journal of Finance, No. 49, pp. 371–402, 1994.
[39]	Barry, C. B., “New directions in research on venture capital finance,” in Financial Management, No. 23, pp. 3–15, 1994.
[40]	Opler, T. and Titman, S., “The determinants of leveraged buyout activity: Free cash flow vs. financial distress costs,” in: The Journal of Finance, No. 48, 1985–1999.
[41]	Martola, J. M., “Developing a framework for venture capitalists to increase the value of investments,” Working Paper, Helsinki University of Technology, February 2002.
[42]	Gompers, P. A., “Optimal investment, monitoring, and the staging of venture capital,” in Journal of Finance, No. 50, pp. 1461–1489, 1995.
[43]	Triantis, George G., “Financial contract design in the world of venture capital,” 2001, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://papers.ssrn.com/paper.taf?abstract_id=258392.
[44]	Dushnitsky, G. and Lenox, M. J., “When does corporate venture capital investment create firm value?” Working Paper, September 2003.
[45]	Siemes, M., “Going private unter Beteiligung von Finanzinvestoren in Deutschland,” Dissertation European Business School Oestrich-Winkel, Auflage, Wiesbaden, 2003.
[46]	Chan, Y., “On the positive role of financial intermediation in allocations of venture capital in a market with imperfect information,” in Journal of Finance, No. 38, pp. 1543–1561, 1983.
[47]	Norton, E. and Tenenbaum, B. H., ”Specialization versus diversification as a venture capital investment strategy,” in Journal of Business Venturing, No. 8, pp. 431–442, 1993.
[48]	Cumming, D. J. and Macintosh, J. G., “The extent of venture capital exits: Evidence from Canada and the United States,” University of Toronto Law and Economics Research Paper, No. 01–03, October 2000, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=250519.
[49]	Cumming, D. J. and Macintosh, J. G., “A cross-country comparison of full and partial capital exits,” in University of Toronto Law and Economics Research Paper No. 01–04, May 2002, available on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Electronic Library at: http://ssrn. com/abstract=268557.
[50]	w/o a, Deals: Result Summaries, available at: http://www. mergermarket.com/deals/dealSummary.asp?npid=500& contextid =4788927, date of retrieve: 26.01.2004.
[51]	Cole, S., “Exits and entrances,” in CA Magazine, Vol. 130, No. 7, pp. 41–42, 1997.
[52]	Damodaran, A., “Investment valuation—tools and techniques for determining the value of any asset,” New York, 1996.
[53]	Mcclave, J. T., Benson, P. G., and Sincich, T., “Statistics for business and economics,” 8 Edition, New York, 2001.