Annealing effect on the optical and solid state properties of cupric oxide thin films deposited using the Aqueous Chemical Growth (ACG) method ()
1. INTRODUCTION
Copper oxide exist in two stable forms [cupric oxide or copper monoxide (CuO) and cuprous oxide (Cu2O)] and an unstable state [paramelaconite (Cu4O3)] [1]. Copper monoxide has a monoclinic structure having the following lattice parameters a = 4.684 Å, b = 3.425 Å, c = 5.129 Å and β = 99.28˚ [2,3]. CuO exhibit a square-planar co-ordination.
Cupric oxide has been known to be a p-type semiconductor having a narrow band-gap of about 1.2 eV - 1.36 eV [4-7]. Bulk CuO exhibit a second-order transition from paramagnetism to incommensurate antiferromagnetism at a Neel temperature of about 230 k and also exhibit a first-order transition from incommensurate to commensurate antiferromagnetism at a temperature of about 213 k [8-12].
Since the chemical and physical properties of CuO solely depend on its size and morphology [13], so many researchers have concentrated their effort on the synthesis of nano structures of CuO in order to apply them in nanoelectronics, optoelectronics, biosensors etc. [14].
Some of the nanostructures of CuO that has been synthesized include nanorods, [Xu C.K., Lin Y.K., Xu G.D., Wang G.H. (2002)] mater, res. Bull, 372,365 nanoribbons [15,16], nanowires [17], nanobelts, nanosheets [18], nanoplatelets [19] nanoneedles [20].
CuO, an inexpensive substance, does not pollute its environment and is often used in the manufacture of Li/CuO primary cells [21,22]. Other known applications of CuO are in catalysts [23,24], field emission devices [25], gas sensors [26-29], photovoltaic device [30-35], superconductors [36-38]. Several techniques have been used to synthesis CuO. These include, rapid precipitation, spin coating [40,42], solid state reaction [42], chemical vapor deposition, sonochemical reaction, sol-gel techniques [43], chemical bath deposition, solvothermal route [44,45], electrochemical route [46], spray pyrolysis, thermal oxidation, hydrothermal method [47].
We have used a relatively novel method, the aqueous chemical growth method, introduced by Lionel Vaysirres [48] to deposit thin films of cupric oxide on glass substrates from a solution of 0.1 M Cu(NO3)2, 0.1 M C6H12N4 and 80 ml, H2O. Some of the samples were annealed at different temperatures. The solid state and optical properties of the annealed samples were then determined and compared with those of the as-prepared sample.
This method has the advantages of simplicity, low cost of production, ease of reproduction, local availability of production materials, environmental friendliness, non requirement of surfactants, templates and complexing agents, ability to produce nanostructures and suitability for large scale production among others [49-51]. This paper presents the effect of annealing temperature on the optical and solid state properties of cupric oxide thin films deposited using the aqueous chemical growth method.
2. THEORY
In order to control and optimizethe physical and optical properties of nanomaterials, the most important parameter to observe and control is the interfacial free energy of the system (solution) [52].
In order to control the interfacial tension of a system, we have to control its nucleation, growth and ageing using experimental method [53].
The occurrence of adsorption (deposition of a layer of solid liquid or gas) at an interface reduces the interfacial or surface tension at the interface.
The reduction in surface tension due to adsorption is quantitatively given as
This is Gibb’s adsorption equation where y is the superficial adsorption density and μ is the chemical potential of the adsorbed species.
where G is Gibb’s free energy and ni is the amount of substance of the component or specie i.
Using Gibb’s adsorption equation as a basis, the variation of water oxide surface (interfacial) tension with ionic strength (I) maximum surface charge density (σmax), and pH has been developed from Gibbs adsorption equation. It is given as
where y is given in (interfacial tension) I is given in (ionic strength) is given in (max.surface charge) y0 means interfacial tension at equilibrium [52].
We assume that at equilibrium, all the chemical potentials of the different species in the solution are the same and the interfacial tension is zero (point of zero, interfacial tension (PZIT).
This assumption is correct if our system is compared with microemulsion systems which have very low (ultralow) surface tension at equilibrium [54].
The quantitative stable thermodynamic condition for the precipitation (growth) of metal ions in an alkaline medium is given as
pH above PZIT where secondary growth (Ostwald ripening) does not occur and the nanoparticles have definite stage is the stable state.
The size of the nanoparticles is directly related to the conditions for nucleation. These include pH, ionic strength and concentration of precursors [55].
Solid phases (particles, crystals thin films) evolve from solutions through nucleation and growth processes. The nucleation in this case occurs heterogeneously since the nuclei forms on an external object (glass slide).
The total change in free energy of the system is given as
where is the chemical component while
is the surface component is the free energy per unit volume.
We assume that the new phase is spherical and therefore has a volume of .
is the surface component of the free energy due to surface tension
where θ is the wetting angle S(θ) differentiates the expression for change in free energy of the system from that of homogeneous nucleation.
Otherwise, they are basically the same.
Hence, for homogeneous nucleation,
and the critical radius of the nucleus for nucleation to occur is obtained from the operation,
Or
The free energy barrier for nucleation at r* (ΔG*) is obtained by substituting the value of r* in the expression for ΔG.
Hence, the barrier for nucleation at r* varies directly as the third power of the interfacial tension.
However, interfacial tension is dependent on pH, ionic strength and concentration of solution.
Thus ΔG* can be reduced by reducing the interfacial tension through the control of the pH, ionic strength or concentration of the solution [56-59].
This paper examines the effect of annealing temperature on the optical and solid state properties of the solid phase (thin film of cupric oxide) which evolved from a solution of 0.1 M Cu(NO3)2, 0.1 M C6H12N4 and 80 ml of H2O through heterogeneous nucleation and growth processes.
3. EXPERIMENTAL DETAILS
CuO thin films were deposited on clean glass substrates using Aqueous Chemical Growth Method.
The precursors used were equimolar (0.1 M) concentration of Cu(NO3)2 and C6H12N4 in 80 ml water.
We used a laboratory analytical microbalance to measure the masses of the chemicals while a measuring cylinder was used to determine the volume of water. All the component chemicals were put into a 100 ml pyrex bottle and were thoroughly mixed using a magnetic stirrer.
Labeled clean glass substrates were inserted in the pyrex bottle containing the chemicals after which the pyrex bottle was properly corked.
The pyrex bottle was then placed in an oven and the temperature of the oven was adjusted to 80˚C.
The pyrex bottle was left in the oven for an average of six hours for deposition to occur. After deposition, one of the samples (XB1) was left as-deposited while three (XB2, XB3 and XB4) were annealed at different temperature of 150˚C, 200˚C and 250˚C respectively.
We propose that the following chemical reactions resulted in the crystallization of CuO on the glass substrates.
Cu2+ was obtained from (Cu(NO3)2 in solution [60].
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
We obtained the analysis of the elemental composition of sample XB1 using Rutherford Backscattering (RBS) spectroscopy. A 1.7 MV pelletron Tandem accelerator was used for this purpose.
This is shown in Figure 1.
Considering the elemental composition of sample XB1 shown in Table 1, it is established that the elements contained in sample XB1 are Cu (0.150%) and 0 (0.850%) while the glass substrate upon which the film was deposited consist of 0 (0.500%), Si (0.120%), Ca (0.100%), Al (0.100%) ad Na (0.180%). This is as contained in Figure 2.
The film thickness obtained is 720 nm.
The CuO thin film samples (XB1 and XB2) were scanned continuously between 2θ = 0 and 2θ = 70˚ at step size of 0.03 and at time per step of 0.15 s using a diffractometer with a CuKα radiation source having a
Figure 1. RBS analysis for ACG CuO thin film (sample XB1).
Table 1. Elemental composition of CuO thin film and substrate from RBS analysis.
(a)(b)
Figure 2. (a) Diffraction pattern of the as-prepared samples (XB1); (b) Diffraction pattern of the sample XB2 annealed XB2 at 150˚ for 2.5 hours.
wavelength of 1.54056 Å. This was done to enable us determine the crystalline nature of the thin film samples.
Figures 2(a) and (b) show the diffraction patterns of the as-deposited sample (XB1) and the sample annealed at 150˚C (XB2) for 2.5 hours.
As it is in Figure 2(a), all diffraction peaks can be indexed clearly to the monoclinic CuO phase having lattice constants a = 4.684 Å, b = 3.425 Å, c = 5.129 Å and β = 99.47˚ [61].
Figure 2(a) did not indicate the presence of impurities such as Cu2O or Cu(OH)2 as no other peaks except those of CuO are observed.
This suggests that the as-prepared sample is made purely of CuO molecules as confirmed from the RBS result.
However, this position does not rule out the possibility of the presence of small quantities of impurity molecules such as Cu(OH)2 which may have accumulated along grain boundaries of the crystallites that make up the film.
Figure 2(a) further indicate that reflections are strongest in the directions 2θ = 32.22˚ and 2θ = 35.13˚. These directions approximately correspond to the crystal planes having miller indices 110 and 111 respectively.
The diffraction patterns for CuO presented by F. Bayansal et al. (2011) [13], UnlingZou et al. (2011) [14] and A. Sagadevan et al. (2012) indicate that reflection is strongest along the 2θ = 35.13˚ and 2θ = 38.5˚ which correspond to the 110 and 111 planes respectively. Their diffraction patterns also indicate that reflection occurred in the 2θ = 32.22˚ direction but with a low intensity compared to the 2θ = 35.13˚ direction.
The difference in the planes along which the strongest reflections occur may be due to preparation method. Figure 2(b) indicates increase in intensities and decrease in widths of peaks resulting from annealing. This is indicative of high crystallinity. Thus, annealing improves the crystallinity of CuO thin films deposited using the Aqueous Chemical Growth Method. This is in agreement with the results of F. Bayansal et al. (2011) [13].
Figures 3-11 are the spectral analysis for the absorbance, transmittance, reflectance, absorption coefficient, direct band gap, extinction coefficient, real dielectric constant, imaginary dielectric constant and refractive index of the CuO ACG thin films investigated.
A Unico UV-2102 PC spectrophotometer was used for the spectral analysis.
Absorbance decreases with increasing annealing temperature.
The absorbance of all the samples decrease sharply from a common value of about 1.50 a.u at about 329.41 nm to about 0.81 a.u (XB1), 0.63 a.u (XB2), 0.52 a.u (XB3) and 0.45 a.u (XB4) at 400 nm.
Within the visible range, the absorbance value of some of the samples decrease from about 0.81 a.u to 0.75 a.u (XB1), 0.63 a.u to 0.62 a.u (XB2), 0.59 a.u to 0.52 a.u (XB3). However the absorbance of sample XB4 increases slowly from about 0.45 a.u to about 0.48 a.u within the visible range.
Between 700 nm and 900 nm, the absorbance values of the samples are fairly constant. While the value for samples XB1 and XB2 are about 0.75 a.u and 0.62 a.u within this range, the value for samples XB3 and XB4 are about 0.52 a.u and 0.45 a.u respectively.
Beyond 900 nm, absorbance value of all the samples decreases slowly with increasing wavelength.
Transmittance of the samples increases with increasing annealing temperature.
The transmittance of all the samples rises from a common value of about 3.16% at about 306 nm to peak values of about 35.67% (XB4), 26.32% (XB3), 22.90% Absorbance vs. wavelength
Figure 3. Absorbance vs. wavelength for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
Transmittance vs. wavelength
Figure 4. Transmittance vs. Wavelength for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
Reflectance vs. Wavelength
Figure 5. Reflectance vs. wavelength for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperature.
Absorption Coefficient
Figure 6. Absorption coefficient vs. photon energy for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
Direct band gap
Figure 7. Direct band gap plot for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperature.
Extinction coefficient vs. photon energy
Figure 8. Extinction coefficient vs. photon energy for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
Real dielectric constant vs. photon energy
Figure 9. Real dielectric constant vs. Photon energy for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
Imaginary dielectric constant vs. photon energy
Figure 10. Imaginary dielectric constant vs. photon energy for ACG CuO thin film at different annealing temperatures.
Reflective index vs. photon energy
Figure 11. Refractive index vs. photon energy for ACG CuO thin films at different annealing temperatures.
(XB2) ad 15.53% (XB1) in the infra-red region.
A small decrease in transmittance occurs around 400 nm in all the samples. Between 400 nm and 700 nm, the transmittance of samples XB1, XB2 and XB3 rise from 15.53% to 17.50%, 22.90% to 25.00% and 26.32% to 29.61% respectively while the transmittance of sample XB4 decreases from 35.00% to about 33.29%.
Above 700 nm the transmittance of samples XB1, XB2 and XB3 increases while that of sample XB4 follows a parabolic path.
Reflectance of the samples increases with increasing annealing temperature. The reflectance of the as-prepared sample (XB1) rises from about 0.67% at about 347.06 nm to 4.5% at 400 nm while the reflectance of samples XB2, XB3 and XB4 rise sharply from 3.58%, 5.17% and 7.00% at 329.41 nm, 323.53 nm and 317.65 nm respectively to about 13.50%, 15.75 and 19.50% respectively at 400 nm.
Within the visible region, the reflectance of the XB4 sample decreases slowly to 19.08% while the reflectance of samples XB3, XB2 and XB1 increases to 17.33%, 14.75% and 7.00% respectively in the direction of increasing wavelength.
In the infra-red region, reflectance increases in the direction of increasing wavelength.
Absorption coefficient decreases with increasing annealing temperature. The absorption coefficient of three samples increased from 1.58 × 10−6 (XB1), 1.29 × 10−6 (XB2) and 1.08 × 10−6 (XB3) at about 1.14 eV in the infra-red region to about 1.93 × 10−6 (XB2), 1.58 × 10−6 (XB2) and 1.29 × 10−6 (XB3) at about 3.62 eV in the visible region.
The absorption coefficient of sample XB4 increases in the direction of increasing photon energy in the infra-red region and thereafter decreased slowly until it attained the value of about 1.03 × 10−6 at 3.62 eV.
Between 3.62 eV and 400 eV, the absorption coefficient of the samples rises sharply and attained different peak values which decreases with increasing annealing temperature.
There is an increasing blue shift with increasing annealing temperature. The direct band gap of the as-prepared sample (XB1) is about 3.55, while that of the XB2 and XB3 samples is about 3.80. The XB4 sample has a direct band gap of about 3.85.
Aiping Chen et al. (2009) [61] estimated the direct band gap of CuO thin films deposited on Si (100) substrates using pulsed laser deposition technique to be 2.12 eV.
By comparison, our values are higher. These relatively high values of direct band gap for CuO thin films are attributable to preparation method. Several researchers have reported that the band gap of CuO can be changed to a wide range depending on the preparation conditions of CuO [62-67].
The high values of direct band gap obtained for ACG CuO thin films make them highly suitable for use as window layer in solar cells.
The Extinction coefficient of the samples decreases with increasing annealing temperature.
The extinction coefficient of the samples decreases parabolically from 133.89 × 10−3 (XB1), 11.89 × 10−3 (XB2), 93.89 × 10−3 (XB3) and 89.44 × 10−3 (XB4) at about 1.15 eV in the infra-red region to about 81.11 × 10−3 (XB1), 82.22 × 10−3 (XB2), 83.33 × 10−3 (XB3) and 84.44 × 10−3 (XB4) at 4.0 eV (XB1), 4.08 eV (XB2), 4.15 eV (XB3) and 4.23 eV (XB4) respectively.
The minimum values of the extinction coefficient of the samples are 57.78 × 10−3 (XB2) and 29.44 × 10−3 (XB1) and they all occurred at about 3.54 eV.
The extinction coefficient values of the samples at 2.0ev are approximately 94.44 × 10−3 (XB1), 72.78 × 10−3 (XB2), 64.44 × 10−3 (XB3) and 59.44 × 10−3 (XB4).
The real dielectric constant of the samples increases with increasing annealing temperature. The real dielectric constant of the samples decreases parabolically from about 4.92 (XB4), 4.73 (XB3), 3.67 (XB2) and 2.65 (XB1) at about 1.16 eV in the infra-red region to about 4.73 (XB4), 4.16 (XB3), 3.35 (XB2) and 1.82 (XB2) respectively at 2.0 eV.
In the visible region, the real dielectric constant of the XB4 sample increased slowly from 4.73 at 2.0 eV in the direction of increasing photon energy to about 4.92 at 4.0 eV. However, the dielectric constant of the other samples decreases from 4.16 (XB3), 3.35 (XB2) and 1.82 (XB1) in the direction of increasing photon energy to about 3.69 (XB3), 2.84 (XB2) and 1.26 (XB1) at about 3.5 eV in the visible region.
Beyond 3.5 eV and in the direction of increasing photon energy, the real dielectric constant of all the samples decreases sharply to 0. This occurs at about 4.13 eV (XB4), 406 eV (XB3 and XB2) and 4.0 eV (XB1).
The imaginary dielectric constant of the samples increases with increasing annealing temperature. The imaginary dielectric constant of the samples decreases parabolically from approximately 39.67 × 10−3 (XB4), 410.00 × 10−3 (XB3), 433.33 × 10−3 (XB2) and 440 × 10−3 (XB1) at about 1.04 eV in the infra-red region to 130.00 × 10−3 at about 4.0 eV (XB4), 3.38 eV (XB3), 3.85 eV (XB2) and 3.77 eV (XB1).
The values of the imaginary dielectric constant of the samples at 2.0 eV are about 243.33 × 10−3 (XB1), 250 (XB4) and 263.33 × 10−3 (XB2 and XB3).
The imaginary dielectric constant for all the samples decreases sharply from about 130.00 × 10−3 to about 15 × 10−3 at 4.0 eV (XB1), 4.08 eV (XB2, XB3 and 4.15 eV (XB4).
Refractive index of the samples increases as annealed temperature increases. All the samples have their peak refractive index at 1.15eV in the infra-red region. The values are 1.63 (XB1), 1.93 (XB2), 2.17 (XB3) and 2.20 (XB4).
The refractive indices for all the samples however followed a parabolic path with increasing photon energy within the infra-red region. A small peak in the refractive index occurred at 2.0 eV for all the samples. The values are 1.33 (XB1), 1.83 (XB2), 2.03 (XB3) and 2.17 (XB4). Except for sample XB4 in which its refractive index increases slowly with increase in photon energy up to 3.54 eV, the refractive index of each of the samples decreases with increase in photon energy from 2.0 eV up to 3.54 eV.
From 3.54 eV, the refractive index of each of the samples decreases sharply to about 0.08 in the direction of increasing photon energy up to 4.0 eV (XB1), 4.08 eV (XB2) and (XB3) and 4.15 eV (XB4).
5. CONCLUSIONS
We have successfully deposited thin films of CuO having average thickness of 720nm on clean glass substrates and have also determined the effect of annealing temperature on their optical and solid state properties.
Our findings indicate that while absorbance and absorption/extinction coefficients of the deposited films decreases with increasing annealing temperature, the transmittance, reflectance, direct band gap, real/imaginary dielectric constants and refractive index of the films increases with increasing annealing temperature. Also, there is an improvement in the crystallinity of deposited films as annealing temperature increases.
The high direct band gap of the as-deposited ACG CuO thin films and those annealed at different temperatures indicate their suitability for use as window layer in solar cells among other opto-electronic applications.