Simple extraction and membrane purification process in isolation of steviosides with improved organoleptic activity ()
1. INTRODUCTION
Dietary and health demands are continuing to expand the market for sweeteners in two distinct areas one in specifically for the low calorie/dietetic segment, while the other is as an alternative to sugar and other nutritive sweeteners (i.e. corn syrup, fructose, glucose) [1]. Recently, there is an increasing demand for low calorie natural sweeteners as a substitute for sucrose and other synthetic sweeteners such as saccharine and aspartame. Stevia a perennial plant species commonly called as “sweet herb” is gaining significant importance as a natural sweetner in different parts of the world and is expected to develop into a major source of high potency sweetener for the growing natural food market [2-4]. Steviol glycosides are natural diterpene glycosides extracted from the leaves of Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni. (Family-Asteraceae) possessing a 250 - 300 times higher sweetening property than sucrose, and they also used in treatment of patients suffering from carbohydrate metabolic diseases such as diabetes mellitus, obesity, hypertension and stimulates cell regeneration. Thus the steviol glycosides are also widely used in food, beverage, medicine, wine making cosmetics and other food/chemical industry [5-7]. Despite wide therapeutic application of these sweet glycosides, its uses are limited for human consumption (food and pharmaceutical) due to its after taste bitterness, astringency and grassy taste; associated with the presence of some un-known glycosides and other alkaloid impurities [8]. Thus, the quality and taste of the commercial stevioside product depends on the percentage/proportion of the steviol glycosides in the product.
Traditional separation and isolation process of natural products from plant extracts normally use different techniques but still it remains a mystery in isolation of water soluble natural-compounds. There are abundant published/patented literature in extraction and purification process of steviosides based on solvent, solvent plus a decolorizing agent, selective precipitation by metallic ions, supercritical fluid extraction and purification by adsorption and column chromatography, ion exchange resin, ultra and nano membrane process [9-12]. The recent development of various membrane-based techniques for the purification of valuable natural products covers utilization of microfiltration, ultrafiltration and nanofiltration membrane techniques, either carried out singly or coupled with other separation techniques, in order to achieve purification process of natural products to improve the biological activity [13-16].
The available extraction process require long and complex extraction processes steps, high temperatures and no information about the effects of the extraction methods on the contents of steviosides. The long isolation procedures of steviol glycosides known to produce noxious residues and biter alkaloids harmful to the human health [17,18]. Some of the recent stevioside isolation methodologies are expensive and are energy intensive process in obtaining pure steviol glycosides’ [9-11, 19]. Therefore, a simple, inexpensive and environmental friendly procedure in isolation of highly purified steviol glycosides is present day challenging problem [20-23]. Oxygen free radicals and other reactive oxygen species can cause oxidative injury to living organisms and thus play an important role in many lifestyle related diseases such arthritis, tissue injury, atherosclerosis, cancer and neurodegenerative diseases as well as ageing process [24-26].
Although several synthetic antioxidants, such as butylated hydroxyl anisole (BHA) and butylated hydroxyl toluene (BHT), are commercially available, these synthetic antioxidants are quite unsafe and are toxic to humans [27]. There is a growing interest in natural antioxidants found in plants because of the world wide trend towards the use of natural additives in food and cosmetics. Natural plant-based anti oxidants especially phenolics and flavonoids have gained importance in therapeutic potential and has been exploited commercially either as antioxidant additives or as nutritional supplements [28-30].
Therefore, the present study is on development of simple, inexpensive processes by minimizing unit operations and chemical usage of solvents and subsequently refining the isolation of steviosides by removing the impurities of after taste for additional improvement of taste profile and anti-oxidant potential of steviosides isolated from the aqueous extract of S. rebuadiana leaves.
2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1. Materials
Leaves: Stevia rebaudiana bertoni leaves were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich Chemicals USA S5381-batch #100- F0417. Stevioside 97%: The standard stevioside 97% (HPLC) was purchased from Sigma chemicals USA.
All the chemicals and solvents used in the process were of commercial solvents and were glass distilled. The membrane filtration was carried out using hollow fiber ultrafiltration (HF-UF) membrane of 30,000 molecular weight cut off (MWCO) the length of spiral wound module and hydrophilized polyamide (HPA) nanofiltration (NF) membrane of 250 MWCO were purchased from M/s Permionics Membranes India Ltd., Vadodara, India.
2.2. Methods
2.2.1. Analytical Methods
The concentration of steviosides present in the leaf extracts were quantified by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using Waters spherisorb NH2 analytical column (250 mm × 4.6 mm, particle size 5 µM), elution solvent used was acetonitrile: 0.1 mM Na-phosphate buffer pH-5 (85:15) in isocratic mode; with flow rate of 1.0 mL∙min−1, column temperature maintained at 27˚C - 28˚C, and UV detection was adjusted at 210 nm [31,32]. In LC-Mass analysis of steviosides the isocratic solvent system acetonitrile: 0.1 mM sodium-phosphate buffer pH-5 (60:40) with flow rate of 1.0 mL∙min−1 was used.
The structure of the purified stevioside isolated was confirmed by 1H-NMR and LC-MASS spectral studies and compared with standard stevioside obtained from Sigma Chemicals USA.
2.2.2. Isolation and Purification of Steviosides
The leaves (5 Kg) of Stevia rebaudiana were initially air dried at 50˚C and treated with non polar organic solvent to remove color pigments and waxy material present on the surface of stevia leaves. Thus obtained leaves were powdered to 20 - 30 mm mesh size and steviosides were extracted in aqueous solution (1:10) adjusted to pH 3, at 60˚C, with agitation. On incubation for 6 hours the extract was subjected to pressurized hot water extractor (PHWE) operating at optimized conditions of 100 kPa pressure at temperatures of 100˚C - 110˚C for 10 minutes, for extraction of steviosides. Thus, obtained crude extract was cooled and filtered solution was adjusted to pH10 by adding 0.1 N sodium hydroxide and heated to 60˚C for one hour, the precipitate formed was filtered and the stevioside rich solution was neutralized to pH 7 by adding dilute acid (0.1 N HCl). The crude solution rich in stevioside was passed through ultrafiltration (UF) membrane of 30 kDa, molecular weight cut-off (MWCO), operating at a feed pressure of experimental conditions. The concentration of stevioside present in the extracts was determined 200 - 500 kPa, at room temperature. This process removes cell debris and helps in clarification of the leaf extract, in obtaining a clear solution containing sweet steviol glycosides. The UF membrane unit operation results in retaining leaf carotenoid pigments (70% - 80%); quantified through spectrophotometer, as described in AOAC, 2000 [33]. The obtained filtrate was passed through nanofiltration membrane (NF) with a MWCO ranging of 250 Da, operated at a trans membrane pressure of 1500 kPa at a room temperature to concentrate the product stevioside in the retentate by removing 80% - 90% of water through permeate. Thus obtained stevioside rich solution was treated with active animal charcoal (20%) and filtered through ciliate (5%) for to obtain a clear solution enriched with steviosides, this on spray drying gave a white stevioside powder. All the operating conditions carried out by UF/NF membrane process in isolation and purification steviosides from stevia leaves were carried at optimum by HPLC. The structure of steviosides were confirmed by NMR and mass spectral studies (LC-Mass chromatogram) and compared with standard stevioside (Figure 1).
2.2.3. Ultrafiltration and Nanofiltration Procedures
The clarification of the stevia extract (30 L solution) was carried out using ultrafiltration membrane (HF-UF 30 kD membrane) operated in batch mode with complete recycle of reject at a constant feed rate of 17 L/min were 23 L of permeate, which gives high flux without compromising on the quality of the stevioside present in the permeate [16]. The permeate enriched in the steviol-glycosides (20 L) was feed to HPA-250 nanofiltration membrane to collect enrich stevioside in the reject and the obtained water solution in the permeate (14 L) was free from sweet glycosides. The enriched stevioside reject was passed through animal charcoal and cellite to remove colour of the stevia extract and the impurities of bitter taste. Thus obtained enrich concentrated stevia extract was spray dried to obtain powdered stevioside.
The effect of pressure in separation stevioside and life of the membrane used for filtration process was studied as described in our earlier studies [34].
2.2.4. Determination of Stevioside Rejection, Permeate Flux and Percentage Water Recovery
In UF and NF membrane processes the separation performance of the membrane is denoted in terms of %
Figure 1. Structures of steviosides and related sweet glycosides.
rejection of solute which was calculated as given in Sridhar et al., 2000 [34].
(1)
where the Cp is amount of the stevioside in the permeate, Cf is the amount of the stevioside in the feed.
The flux (J) is the volume of the permeate (V) collected per unit membrane area per unit time (t):
(2)
The approximate osmotic pressure Dp (bar) is determined from the following equation:
(3)
where ci is the concentration of TDS (~NaCl) in mol∙dm−3, vi is the number of ions formed when the solute dissociates, R is the universal gas constant (83.133 dm3∙bar∙kmol−1∙k−1) and T is the absolute temperature (301 k).
For clarification of the stevia extract an absorbance analysis was carried out.
. (4)
Percentage (%) steviosides (stevioside or rebaudioside) recovered after the purification process, were calculated.
(5)
where, the subscripts “after” and “before” mean after and before the clarification, respectively. Optical absorbencies measured at 420 or 670 nm correspond to color or turbidity analysis, respectively. The concentration of steviol glycoside recovered after the purification process, were quantified through HPLC.
2.2.5. Sensory Evaluation
The relative sweetness of steviol glycosides was compared in relation to standard sucrose solution. The organoleptic sensory evaluation for steviosides present in stevia extract and FCPS-(final crystallized product of stevia leaf extract) was carried out by comparing with sucrose solution 2% as a reference standard, taking its sweetness value as 100, which give a direct quantitative measure of the subjective intensity of stevioside sweetness [35-38].
2.2.6. Determination of Antioxidant Activity Different Radical Scavenging Activities
Steviol glycosides obtained from stevia leaves promote wide range of physiological activities like cardiovascular, anti cancer, hyperglycemia and also influence in reducing hypertension [38]. Superoxide radical is known to be very harmful to cellular components as a precursor of the more reactive oxygen species, contributing to tissue damage and various diseases [39]. Superoxide scavengers and their capacity to scavenge superoxide may contribute to their anti oxidant activity. A large number of phyto chemicals, phenols, flavonoids are among the most potent and therapeutically useful bioactive molecules, providing health benefits associated with reducing of oxidative injury to living organism [40,41]. The traditional use of leaves of S. rebaudiana as natural antioxidants with consequent health benefits has to be confirmed by battery of antioxidant assays.
To evaluate the antioxidant activity or super oxide radical scavenging activity of the steviol glycosides present in the extract of stevia following assays were studied 1) free radical scavenging capacity assay by DPPH (1,1- Diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl) method; 2) hydroxyl superoxide radical and 3) nitric oxide radical assay were carried out using standard methods [42]. The results obtained were compared with that of known anti-oxidants samples like green tea and ascorbic acid.
Statistical Analysis
The results were analyzed by two-way ANOVA followed by Bonferroni post tests. The results were processed by GraphPad Prism version 5.0. Results were found statistically significant (P < 0.05).
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
This study high lights development of a rapid, improvised and effective methodology in isolation and purification of sweet glycosides, from the leaves of Stevia rebaudiana. The process involves combined use of pressurized hot water extraction, followed by ultra-filtration and nano-filtration to obtain high quality steviosides from the leaves of the stevia. The initial pretreatment of stevia leaves with hexane, results in removing color pigments and waxy plant material and helps in subsequent process of clarification of the extract. The total pigments (carotenoids) extracted were found to be 19 - 22 mg/100g of dry stevia leaves [43]. After preliminary discoloration the powdered stevia leaves were subjected to water extraction in a pressure reactor to obtain stevioside rich extract (CSEA-crude stevia leaf extract after autoclave). It was observed that the rate of extraction of stevia was higher at pH 3 during the process of extraction. Thus obtained extract was subjected to multi stage ultra and nano membrane filtration process to remove suspended particles, high molecular weight impurities and undesirable bitter compounds, without any loss of steviosides/or in the permeate (decline in non-glycoside peaks in HPLC chromatogram) Table 1. Thus indicating reasonably high permeation rates and no significant
Table 1. Comparative performance of UF and NF membranes in concentration and purification of steviosides (7% - 8%) present in Stevia rebaudiana +.
fouling of membranes was observed during the process of filtration. The stevioside enriched permeate was filtered through active animal charcoal and celate to obtain golden yellow color solution containing steviol glycosides which on spray drying gave a pure white product (98%) of steviol-glycosides.
3.1. Effect of Pressure
From the results the increase feed pressure in NF membrane from 200 - 600 psi, the increase flux from 25.2 L to 39.3 lit/m2. Hr was observed, whereas the permeate conductivity reduced from 0.48 to 0.26 mS/cm as shown in Figure 2. The recovery of water was maintained constant at 60% - 80% for all the operating pressures. The increase in pressure would obviously is due to greater driving force for transport of the water molecules leading to a rise in flux. It is well known that by solution diffusion mechanism, the hydrophilic NF membrane allows more and more water molecules to pass through due to preferential sorption of water on the membrane surface [44]. Thus the smaller molecular size (MW = 18) of the water molecules would therefore exhibit higher diffusivity compared to the much larger stevioside molecules; resulting in 100% rejection of stevioside throughout the range of feed pressure studied.
3.2. Membrane Fouling and Its Control
The UF /NF membranes would be especially prone to biological fouling since aqueous stevia solution gathers fungal growth within two days time [45]. For a prolonged life of the filtration membrane it is necessary to wash the membrane thoroughly washed with deionized water followed by 2% (w/v) citric acid solution to remove metal salt precipitates formed due to presence of in organics in the feed solution. Every alternate week, washing with 1% (w/v) solution of tetra sodium EDTA, a chelating agent is necessary to remove organic foul ants and silt and the membrane is finally stored in a 1% (w/v)
Figure 2. Effects of feed pressure on permeate flux and conductivity at constant water recovery by nanofiltration membrane (values expressed were average of three determinations).
sodium metabisulfite solution to prevent biological fouling. The membrane show longer half life, without membrane fouling when compared to other existing methods available The conceptual flow diagram Figure 3 show the process of extraction, isolation and purification steps that produce a high purity steviosides 94% - 98% with recovery yield of sweet steviol glycosides from the stevia leaves in the range of (90% - 95%), as confirmed through HPLC, LC-Mass and NMR analysis Figures 4 and 5.
3.3. Sensory Evolution
It was observed that the steviosides isolated through the multistage membrane filtration has improved sweetening potency and taste profile. This may be due to the removal of glycoside impurities or bitter alkaloids responsible for after taste present in the stevia extracts Table 2 [14].
3.4. Antioxidant Activity Assay
Natural antioxidants that are present in herbs and spices are responsible for inhibiting or preventing the deleterious consequences of oxidative stress. It is well known that the stevia extracts contain flavonoids or phenolic compounds that scavenge the free radicals, promote wide range of physiological activities [46,47]. The free radical scavenger activity for three different samples of stevia leaf extracts (SEHW, CSEA, and FCPS) were compared with the reference sample aqueous extract of green tea leaves (Camellia sinensis Linn.) prepared by infusions of 1 g of green tea brewed for 5 min with 100 mL of boiling water, and with standard ascorbic acid of equal concentration to that of Stevioside samples (5 µg/ml). From the results as shown in Figure 6 the percentage inhibition of DPPH free radical scavenging activity for green tea was 7.3% and for standard ascorbic acid it was 86.5%, where as for the three stevia extracts it was 21.5%; 40.25%; 39.8% respectively. All the three stevia sample extracts have shown increased in vitro antioxidant activity when compared with green tea extract tested; similar results were obtained with other two free radical assay methods.
This study confirms a simple advantageous methodology of extraction and purifications process of steviosides using multistage UF and NF membrane filtration operating with higher flux and flow rates, at room temperature. The UF and NF membranes used show longer half life, without membrane fowling when compared other existing methods available. Thus, the method established show the isolation of high purity steviosides free from impurities of bitterness, with improved taste and anti-oxidant activity, without presence of any impurities and obnoxious residues in an eco-friendly condition.
4. CONCLUSION
Steviosides are major low-calorie diterpene steviol glycosides present in the leaves of Stevia rebaudiana. They are widely used as natural low calorie sweetener for diabetic patients. The long extraction and optimization
Figure 3. Schematic view of ultra filtration/nano filtration experimental mini pilot plant.
Figure 4. ESI-LC mass spectra-pure stevioside.
procedure required in isolation of the steviol glycosides is a present day challenging problem. An object of the study is to develop a rapid and effective methodology of production of natural sweetener steviol glycosides and to overcome the disadvantages associated with extraction processes. The study establishes a continuous isolation of steviosides from the stevia leaves by integrated and simple clarification process using inexpensive membranes in removing color pigments, high molecular impurities and obnoxious residues. An enrichment of the steviosides could be obtained in permeate during clarification by UF process, as the UF membrane was sensitized by a coating of hydrophilic polyvinyl alcohol polymer which may have significant affinity towards retaining steviosides, leading to its preferential separation of impurities with a higher molecular weight. Finally, nano membrane filtration (NF) processes remove lower molecular weight impurities. There were no losses of steviosides in the
Figure 6. Comparative percentage of antioxidant activity of steviosides glycosides with sucrose in human volunteers. *SEHW-stevia leaf extract of hot water similar to that of Green tea extract. *CSEAcrude stevia leaf extract after autoclave. *FCPS-final crystallized product of stevia leaf extract.
Table 2. Comparative sweetness and (bitter) no sweet after taste of steviosides glycosides with sucrose in human volunteers.
permeate during the NF process indicating 100% rejection; confirming the most of the steviol glycosides extracted from stevia leaves was recovered. The process also confirms the improved taste, palatability and antioxidant activity of the isolated steviol glycosides. Thus, this study established simple “green” method of extraction steviosides using multi-stage membrane based purification techniques in a viable, economical (saving time and energy) and eco-friendly conditions.
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors are grateful for the financial support by Department of the Biotechnology, (DBT) New Delhi, Author G R express sincere thanks to DBT for awarding the research fellowship.
NOTES